Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner Of C. Ex., Bangalore-I v. Ecof Industries Pvt. Ltd.

Karnataka High Court
Feb 3, 2011
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal was filed by the Revenue against three assessment orders passed by the Tribunal (reported as 2010 (17) S.T.R 515 (Tri.-Bang.)), which had restored the order of the Assessing Authority that had upheld the assessee's entitlement to CENVAT credit. The assessee is a manufacturer of excisable goods under Chapter 34 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. The assessee's Chennai head office, registered as an Input Service Distributor (ISD), paid service tax on a variety of services (including insurance, telephones, security, travelling, advertising, market research, courier, maintenance, utilities, bank charges, AMC, professional charges) and distributed credit to the manufacturing units, including the Malur unit.

A show cause notice dated 31-12-2007 alleged contravention of Rule 3(1) of the CENVAT Credit Rules and sought demand and recovery of irregularly availed service tax credit of Rs. 3,09,518/- (including cess) under Rule 14 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 read with Section 11A of the Central Excise Act, 1944, with interest and penalty. The assessee relied on Rule 7 permitting ISDs to distribute credit and sought dropping of proceedings. The Assistant Commissioner dropped the proceedings relying on Rule 3(1), Rule 7 and a Board circular. The Revenue appealed to the Commissioner (Appeals), who disagreed, held that the Malur unit had not received the input services and that the credit was not used in or in relation to manufacture at Malur, set aside the original order, confirmed demand and interest, and imposed a penalty of Rs. 1,00,000/- under Rule 15. The assessee appealed to the Tribunal, which restored the original Assistant Commissioner order by relying on Rule 7 and a master circular, and held the restrictions relied upon by the Commissioner (Appeals) were not supported by the rules. The Revenue brought the present appeal challenging the Tribunal's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether service tax credit paid in respect of services obtained by one unit (Cuttack) of a manufacturer can be utilized by another unit (Malur) of the same manufacturer through the mechanism of an Input Service Distributor under the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Revenue) Arguments

  • The service tax was paid in respect of the Cuttack unit but was sought to be availed by the Malur unit; since the tax was not paid in connection with inputs used in manufacture at Malur or for advertising/production at Malur, the Malur unit is not entitled to CENVAT credit.
  • The Commissioner (Appeals) correctly found that the credit was not in accordance with Rule 3(1) and that the Tribunal erred in setting aside the Commissioner (Appeals) order; interference by this Court is warranted.

Respondent's (Assessee) Arguments

  • The definitions of "input service", "input service provider" and the provisions of Rule 3(1) and Rule 7(1) make clear that it is not necessary that the unit which paid the service tax alone must avail the credit; a manufacturer with several units can register as an Input Service Distributor, collect taxes paid across units and distribute credit to its units, subject to the two conditions in Rule 7.
  • Because the assessee complied with the statutory scheme (registration as ISD and distribution under Rule 7), there is no reason to interfere with the Tribunal's order which followed the Rules and the Board's master circular.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis focused on the statutory definitions and the text of the relevant CENVAT Credit Rules:

  1. The Court extracted and relied on the statutory definitions from Rule 2: "input", "input service" and "input service distributor" (Rule 2(k), Rule 2(1) and Rule 2(m)). These definitions show that an input service includes services used by a manufacturer "directly or indirectly, in or in relation to the manufacture of final products", and that an input service distributor is an office of the manufacturer which receives invoices under rule 4A of the Service Tax Rules, 1994 and distributes the credit of service tax to the manufacturer's units.
  2. Rule 3(1) was noted as the provision allowing a manufacturer to take credit.
  3. The Court examined Rule 7, which prescribes the "Manner of distribution of credit by input service distributor" and contains only two stated conditions limiting distribution: (a) credit distributed against an eligible document cannot exceed the service tax paid on that document; and (b) credit attributable to services used in a unit exclusively engaged in manufacture of exempted goods or exclusively providing exempted services shall not be distributed.
  4. The Court also considered the Board's master circular (extracted at para 7 of the Tribunal's order and reproduced in the opinion), which reiterates the two conditions and describes the ISD mechanism, including the requirement for separate registration under Section 69 read with Notification No. 26/2005-S.T.
  5. Applying these textual provisions, the Court concluded that the Rules impose only the two explicit limitations in Rule 7 on distribution by an ISD. The fact that service tax was paid at a particular unit and the benefit was sought by another unit is not, by itself, prohibited by the statutory scheme. The statutory framework expects a manufacturer with multiple units to register as an ISD, accumulate input service tax credits at the head office and distribute them to units subject to Rule 7's conditions.
  6. Because the Tribunal's reasoning relied on Rule 7 and the master circular and found that the two restrictions did not apply to the facts of this case, the Court found the Tribunal's order to be legal and valid and not suffering from any legal infirmity.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

The appeal by the Revenue is dismissed. The direct effect is that the Tribunal's order restoring the Assessing Authority's decision (which allowed the assessee to retain and distribute the CENVAT credit via the Input Service Distributor mechanism) is upheld. The Court held that under the CENVAT Credit Rules and the Board's master circular the only limitations on distribution by an Input Service Distributor are the two conditions stated in Rule 7, and those limitations did not apply to the facts of this case.

The opinion does not discuss any broader precedent being established beyond applying the existing Rules and the master circular; its stated consequence is the dismissal of the Revenue's appeal and the affirmation of the Tribunal's order.

Show all summary ...

N. Kumar, J.:— This appeal is by the Revenue in respect of three different assessment orders passed by the Tribunal [2010 (17) S.T.R 515 (Tri.-Bang.)], which restored the order of the Assessing Authority, who had upheld the exemption in respect of CENVAT credit which was set aside by the 1st Appellate Authority.

2. The assessee is a manufacturer of excisable goods falling under Chapter 34 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. The assessee has availed a service tax credit based on the invoice issued by the Chennai head office, which is registered as ‘Input Service Distributor’ and has paid service tax for services received by them from various service providers like insurance, telephones, security charges, travelling expenses, advertising, market research, courier, xerox maintenance, utility services, bank charges, AMC, professional charges, etc. The head office in turn distributed the service tax to the assessee. The assessee availed and utilized the said credit for payment of Central Excise Duty on their final products. The services in question were received by their head office at Chennai in respect of advertisement and other services, which are meant for the products manufactured by their units located at other places i. e. other than Malur Unit. The services like telephone, security charges, etc., are all received by them at Chennai and not related to Malur Unit. On the ground that the assessee had contravened the provisions of Rule 3(1) of CENVAT Credit Rules (for short hereinafter referred to as the ‘Rules’), a show cause notice came to be issued to the assessee on 31-12-2007 to show cause as to why irregular service tax credit availed of Rs. 3,09,518/- (3,04,887/- duty + Rs. 4,631/- cess) on input services which are not used in or in relation to the manufacture of finished goods or in relation to their manufacturing unit during December, 2006, should not be demanded and recovered from them under Rule 14 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 read with Section 11A of Central Excise Act, 1944 along with interest and penalty. The assessee filed a detailed statement of objections and contended by referring to Rule 7 under which an input service distributor is allowed to distribute CENVAT credit in respect of service tax paid on input service to its manufacturing units or units providing output service. Therefore they sought for dropping of the proceedings. The Assessing Authority taking note of Rule 3(1) and Rule 7 and as well as the circular issued by the Board dropped the proceeding. Aggrieved by the same, the revenue preferred an appeal before the Commissioner of a Central Excise (Appeals-I), Bangalore. The Commissioner found that the credit distributed was pertaining to the advertisement of the product which were manufactured at the respondent's other unit and not in their unit at Malur. The credit availed on other services viz., telephone, security services, insurance etc on which the service tax was paid at Chennai and that services provided were, not in the respondent's unit at Malur. Therefore, he held that the assessee has not received the input service and there is no discussion in the findings as to whether the credit has been utilized in relation to the manufacture of the goods in their Malur unit. The credit so availed pertains to advertisement and other services meant for the products manufactured by their units located at a place other than their Malur unit and the service tax availed on input service were not provided in the assessee's unit at Malur. The assessee has not used the input service in or in relation to the manufacture of the finished goods or in relation to their manufacturing unit. Therefore, the credit availed by the assessee is not in accordance with the provisions of the Rule 3(1) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. Accordingly, the appeal was allowed. The order-in-original passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Central Excise, Bangalore IV Division, Bangalore was set aside and he confirmed the demand and interest and directed for payment of penalty of Rs. 1,00,000/- under Rule 15 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. Aggrieved by the same, the assessee preferred an appeal to the tribunal. The tribunal relying on Rule 7 as well as the master circular issued by the Board held that the combined reading of Rule 7 and the clarificatory circular dated 23-8-2007 clearly shows that there are only two restrictions regarding the distribution of the credit. The said two restrictions have no application to the facts of this case. The restrictions sought to be applied in this case in limiting the distribution of the service credit tax made in respect of the Malur unit on the ground that the services were used in respect of the Cuttack unit finds no mention in the relevant rules and therefore the said restriction cannot be upheld. Accordingly, he allowed the appeal, set aside the order of the appellate authority and restored the order-in-original. Aggrieved by the same, the Revenue is in appeal. The learned Counsel for the Revenue assailing the impugned order contends that admittedly the service tax is paid in respect of the unit at Cuttack and it is sought to be availed by the unit at Malur. As the said tax has not been paid in connection with the input used in manufacture of products at Malur unit or in the advertisement or production at Malur Unit, the assessee is not entitled to the benefit of CENVAT credit under the rules. The lower Appellate Authority has rightly held so which order has been erroneously set-aside by the tribunal and therefore he submits a case for interference is made out.

3. Per contra, the learned Counsel for the assessee submits that the definition of input service and input service provider read with Rule 3(1) and Rule 7(1) of the Rules makes it very clear that it is not the requirement of law, that the unit, which has paid the tax alone, is entitled to the benefit of the credit under the scheme. If a manufacturer has several units and has paid. input tax, he is expected to register himself as a input service distributor, collect all these taxes paid and thereafter distribute the same to its various units except to two conditions which are mentioned in Rule 7. Therefore, he submits that there is no reason for interfering with the order passed by the tribunal, which is strictly in accordance with law.

4. In the light of the aforesaid facts and rival contentions, the question that arises for consideration is that when service tax is paid in respect of services obtained by a unit at Cuttack whether such a credit of the said service tax paid cannot be utilized by a unit at Malur belonging to the same manufacturer, namely the assessee.

5. As we are concerned only about input service, it is sufficient to extract the definition of input, input service and input service distributor, which are defined at Rule 2(k)-‘Input’, Rule 2(1)-‘Input service’ and Rule 2(m)-‘Input service provider’ as under:—

“Rule 2(k) “input” means —

(i) all goods, except light diesel oil, high speed diesel oil and motor spirit, commonly known as petrol, used in or in relation to the manufacture of final products whether directly or indirectly and whether contained in the final product or not and includes lubricating oils, greases, cutting oils, coolants, accessories of the final products cleared along with the final product, goods used as paint, or as packing material, or as fuel, or for generation of electricity or steam used in or in relation to manufacture of final products or for any other purpose, within the factory of production;

(ii) all goods, except light diesel oil, high speed diesel oil, motor spirit, commonly known as petrol and motor vehicles, used for providing any output service;

Rule 2(1) “input service” means any service

(i) used by a provider of taxable service for providing an output service, or

(ii) used by the manufacturer, whether directly or indirectly, in or in relation to the manufacture of final products and clearance of final products from the place of removal, and includes services used in relation to setting up, modernization, renovation or repairs of a factory, premises of provider of output service or an office relating to such factory or premises, advertisement or sales promotion, market research storage upto the place of removal procurement of inputs, activities relating to business, such as accounting, auditing, financing, recruitment and quality control, coaching and training, computer networking, credit rating, share registry, and security, inward transportation of inputs or capital goods and outward transportation upto the place of removal;

2(m) “input service distributor” means as office of the manufacturer or producer of final products or provider of output service, which receives invoices issued under rule 4A of the Service Tax Rules, 1994 towards purchases of input services and issues invoice, bill or, as the case may be, challan for the purposes of distributing the credit of service tax paid on the said services to such manufacturer or producer or provider, as the case may be;”

6. Rule 3(1) has been defined as under

“A manufacturer or producer of final products or a provider of taxable service shall be allowed. to take credit”.

7. It is in this context, the definition of input service distributor makes it clear that a manufacturer or a producer of a final product or a provider of output service may have more than one unit and may be distributed in various parts of the country. It is in this background the definition of service distributor is defined as office of the manufacturer or producer of a final product or provider of output service which receives invoices issued under rule 4A of the Service Tax Rules, 1994 towards purchases of input services and issues invoice, bill or, as the case may be, challan for the purposes of distributing the credit of service tax paid on the said services to such manufacturer or producer or provider, as the case may be. Therefore, the law mandates that the manufacturer who wants to avail the benefit of this service tax if he has more than one unit he should also get registered himself as a service provider and then, he would be able to collect all the input service tax paid in all its units and accumulate them at its head office and distribute the said credit to its various units. at the time of distribution, the manner of distribution is provided in Rule 7 which reads as under

“Rule 7. Manner of distribution of credit by input service distributor. — The input service distributor may distribute the CENVAT credit in respect of the service tax paid on the input service to its manufacturing units or units providing output service, subject to the following conditions, namely

(a) the credit distributed against a document referred to in rule 9 does not exceed the amount of service tax paid thereon, or

(b) credit of service tax attributable to service use in a unit exclusively engaged in manufacture of exempted goods or providing of exempted services shall not be distributed.”

8. Therefore, only two limitations are put for the distribution of credit by an input service distributor. Firstly, it cannot exceed the amount of service tax paid and secondly, the credit of service tax attributable to service used shall not be distributed in a unit exclusively engaged in the manufacture of exempted goods or providing of exempted services. In fact, the Board has issued a circular clarifying in this regard, which is extracted by the tribunal at para 7 which reads as under

“Para 7. Para 2.3 of the Master Circular referred to by the Id. Advocate reads as under

“2.3 An ‘Input service distributor’ is an office or establishment of a manufacturer of excisable goods or provider of taxable service. It receives tax paid invoices/bills of input services procured (on which Cenvat credits can be taken) and distributes such credits to its units providing taxable services or manufacturing excisable goods. The distribution of credit is subject to the conditions that-(a) the credit distributed against an eligible document shall not exceed the amount of service tax paid thereon, and (b) credit of service tax attributable to services used in a unit either exclusively manufacturing exempted goods or exclusively providing exempted services shall not be distributed. An input service distributor is required (under Section 69 of the Act, read with Notification No. 26/2005-S.T.) to take a separate registration.”

9. Therefore, these are the only two limitations, which are imposed in Rule 7 preventing the manufacturer from utilizing the CENVAT credit, otherwise, he is entitled to the said credit. Merely because the input service tax is paid at a particular unit and the benefit is sought to be availed at another unit, the same is not prohibited under law. It is in this context, the manufacturer is expected to register himself as a input service distributor and thereafter, he is entitled to distribution of credit of such input in the manner prescribed under law. Therefore, the order passed by the tribunal is legal and valid and does not suffer from any legal infirmity and does not call for any interference and therefore it is dismissed.