Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Grammy Communications Pvt. Ltd. v. Emaar Mgf Land Ltd.

Delhi High Court
Aug 13, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This application (I.A. No. 4692/2013) was filed by the plaintiff under Order 12 Rule 6, CPC, seeking a decree for the principal amount of Rs. 25,81,517/- plus costs. The factual matrix in the opinion is as follows: the plaintiff applied for allotment of commercial space in the defendant's project "The Palm Square" at Sector 66, Gurgaon. The plaintiff made deposits on 22.10.2007 and 25.4.2008, aggregating Rs. 25,81,517/-. The project did not commence and on 3.9.2008 the plaintiff sought a refund (Ex. P-6). By letter dated 15.9.2008 (Ex. P-8) the defendant disputed the project status but gave the plaintiff an option to seek refund through a named contact. The plaintiff alleges repeated approaches for refund were unsuccessful, issued a legal notice dated 1.9.2010, and thereafter filed the suit.

Procedurally, the application seeks judgment on admission under Order 12 Rule 6, CPC. The court considered documentary material placed by both parties (including Ex. D-1, Schedule I, Ex. D-2, Ex. D-6, Ex. D-18 and several plaintiff exhibits) and heard counsel before passing the order. The matter is part of CS(OS) 2635/2010 and directions were given for further filing and listing for framing of issues.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree on admission under Order 12 Rule 6, CPC, for the amount claimed (Rs. 25,81,517/-).
  2. Whether the defence set up by the defendant discloses a triable defence or is a "moonshine" (frivolous) defence that may be summarily rejected.
  3. Whether, assuming breach by the plaintiff, the defendant was entitled to forfeit the entire sums paid by the plaintiff or only the earnest money (10% of sale price), as per the documents.
  4. Whether the defendant can retain amounts beyond the earnest money or deposit amounts in court so as to prevent release to the plaintiff during the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The parties did not enter into any binding contract, and accordingly the plaintiff seeks refund of amounts paid.
  • The plaintiff relies on defendant's later communication (Ex. P-12 dated 31.5.2012) acknowledging payment of Rs. 25,81,517/-, which includes an earnest money sum of Rs. 10,32,607/-.
  • The plaintiff sought full refund and initiated suit after the defendant failed to refund despite requests and a legal notice dated 1.9.2010.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant relies on a series of documents: Ex. D-1 (Advance Registration Application Form dated 30.1.2008) together with Schedule I containing Broad Terms and Conditions; Ex. D-2 (letter of allotment dated 7.2.2008); Ex. D-6 (acknowledgement of payment dated 24.4.2008); Ex. D-18 (cancellation letter dated 18.1.2011); and a final notice dated 1.11.2010 demanding outstanding amounts.
  • The defendant contends the plaintiff failed to make further payments called for under the allotment/buyer's agreement and relies on clauses in its forms that purport to permit forfeiture of amounts paid if the buyer fails to execute the buyer's agreement.
  • The defendant offered to deposit Rs. 15,48,910/- in court while retaining 10% HMD/earnest money of Rs. 10,32,607/- from the total amount of Rs. 25,81,517/-.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mahendra Verma v. Suresh T Kailachand, 2010 (4) AD (Del) 765 Considered in the context of applications under Order 12 Rule 6 to determine whether a sum was refundable or constituted earnest money and whether summary relief was appropriate. The court noted the defendant relied on this decision but held it did not advance the defendant's case because the facts of Mahendra Verma were materially different (there the deposit was said to be earnest money under an oral agreement).
P.P.A. Impex Pvt. Ltd. v. Mangal Sin Mittal, 166 (2010) DLT 84 Explains approach under Order 12 Rule 6 as akin to Supreme Court approach under Order 37 for granting Leave to Defend: a "moonshine" defence may be summarily dismissed. The Division Bench's observation (quoted in the opinion) was applied as persuasive guidance that moonshine defences should not be permitted to proceed to trial. The court used that reasoning to test the defendant's documentary defence.
Mechelec Engineers & Manufacturers v. Basic Equipment Corporation, Manu/SC/0043/1976 : (1976) 4 SCC 687 Supreme Court authority on Order 37 summary-suit leave to defend: if a defence is moonshine it should be summarily disallowed. The court treated the reasoning in Mechelec as the underlying authority for the "moonshine" test and applied the same approach by analogy when assessing whether the defendant's written terms disclosed a real triable defence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the defence pleaded and the documents relied upon by the defendant in light of the scope of Order 12 Rule 6, CPC: the court must determine whether the defendant has admitted liability in its pleadings/documents or whether the defence is "moonshine" such that it discloses no triable issue.

The court made the following analytical steps:

  1. Identified that the central factual dispute — whether the plaintiff defaulted on instalment payments called by the defendant — is a triable issue and therefore the plaintiff could not, at this interlocutory stage, recover the entire principal amount claimed.
  2. Examined Ex. D-1 (the application form) and Schedule I (the defendant's printed Broad Terms and Conditions), noting both documents are authored by the defendant and placed on record by it.
  3. Detected a contradiction within those defendant-authored documents: one clause purported to permit forfeiture of "all the sums/monies" paid if the applicant failed to sign the buyer's agreement, whereas Clause 14 expressly treated 10% of the sale price as earnest money to ensure due fulfilment.
  4. Applied the doctrine of contra proferentem (because the defendant drafted the terms), reading the ambiguous and contradictory terms strictly against the defendant.
  5. Concluded that the defendant's attempt to justify forfeiture of the entire amount (beyond the 10% earnest money) was frivolous/moonshine and therefore could not stand as a defence sufficient to prevent summary relief on that portion of the claim.
  6. Noted Ex. D-2 (letter of allotment) sets the sale price at Rs. 1,03,26,069/-, making 10% equal to Rs. 10,32,607/-, a figure acknowledged in Ex. D-18 as earnest money.
  7. Rejected the defendant's submission that it should be permitted to deposit amounts in court and prevent release to the plaintiff during the suit; the court held the defendant was not entitled to retain any amount beyond the earnest money sum.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court granted partial relief to the plaintiff and decreed the suit in part. Specifically, the court awarded the plaintiff a partial decree in the amount of Rs. 15,48,910/-.

The court held that, even if the plaintiff had breached the allotment terms, the defendant could only forfeit the earnest money of Rs. 10,32,607/- (10% of the sale price) and not the entire amount deposited. The defendant was not entitled to retain any amount beyond that or to withhold the balance by depositing it in court during the pendency of the suit.

Implications and consequential directions:

  • The question of interest on the awarded sum (whether payable, rate and period) was left open for determination after trial.
  • The application is disposed of and the suit was partially decreed for Rs. 15,48,910/-. Further documents were directed to be filed within two weeks and the matter listed for framing of issues on 24.10.2013 (CS(OS) 2635/2010).
  • The court also referred the case to the Competition Commission: the Registry was directed to forward the parties' correspondence and documents to the Director General of the Competition Commission for appropriate action under the Competition Act, 2002, to examine whether the documents and the defendant's conduct fall foul of that Act.
  • No broader legal precedent was created by the order; the court applied existing principles (including contra proferentem and the "moonshine" test) to the facts and confined its ruling to the parties' rights and the partial decree awarded.
Show all summary ...

I.A. No. 4692/2013

1. This application has been filed by the plaintiff under Order 12 Rule 6, CPC to claim a decree for the principal amount of Rs. 25,81,517/- apart from costs.

2. The dispute between the parties arises on account of the plaintiff having applied for allotment of commercial space in a construction project of the defendant by the name The Palm Square' at Sector 66, Gurgaon, Haryana. The case of the plaintiff is that the plaintiff had made some deposits as early as on 22.10.2007 and 25.4.2008' in all aggregating to Rs.25,81,517/-. However, the project did not commence. Consequently, vide Ex. P-6 dated 3.9.2008, the plaintiff sought refund of the amount, vide Ex P-8 dated 15.9.2008, the defendant while disputing the claim of the plaintiff regarding status of the project, gave an option to the plaintiff to seek refund and, for that purpose, to contact one Mr. Amar Basra. The claim of the plaintiff is that despite repeated approaches, the amount was not refunded and the plaintiff issued legal notice dated 1.9.2010 to the defendant. Thereafter the present suit cause to be filed.

3. The submission of learned Counsel for the plaintiff is that the parties did not enter into any binding contract. Reliance is also placed on a subsequent communication issued by the defendant being Ex. P-12 dated 31.5.2012 which, inter alia, records that total amount of Rs. 25,81,517/- has been paid by the plaintiff, which includes earnest money of Rs. 10,32,607'/-.

4. On the other hand, the defendant has sought to place reliance on several documents filed by it. Ex. D-l is an application made by the plaintiff on 30.1.2008 for allotment of the commercial area. Along with Ex. D-1 which is the 'Advance Registration Application Form for Expression', the Schedule I contains the 'Broad Terms and Conditions for Registration of a Commercial Unit in 'Palm Square".

Whereas the last clause of Ex. D-1, inter alia, states that if the applicant i.e. the plaintiff fails to execute and deliver to the defendant the signed buyers agreement the plaintiffs application shall be treated as cancelled and 'all the sums/monies paid/deposited by me/us with Emaar MGF shall stand forfeited without any notice/reminder', the Broad Terms and Conditions — in Clause 14, states that 'the applicant(s) agrees that out of the amount(s) paid/payable by him/her/them/it towards the sale price, the Company shall treat 10% of the sale price as earnest money to ensure due fulfilment, by the Applicant(s) of all the terms and conditions as contained herein and in the Buyer's Agreement'.

5. The further case of the defendant is that the defendant had made allotment of Unit No. 1108 of 11th floor (Commercial Section) of the Palm Square to the plaintiff on 7.2.2008 vide Ex. D-2. In pursuance of the said agreement, the plaintiff, after a few reminders, had also made further payment of Rs. 8,54,189/- which was acknowledged by the defendant vide Ex. D-6 dated 24.4.2008. The case of the defendant is that the plaintiff has, thereafter, failed to make further payment.

6. The submission of learned Senior Counsel for the defendant is that the defendant is willing to deposit in this the Court the amount of Rs. 15,48,910/- i.e. after retaining 10% HMD of Rs. 10,32,607/- from total amount of Rs. 25,81,5177-deposited by the plaintiff. The defendant has also placed reliance on the final notice dated 1.11.2010 requiring the plaintiff to make the deposit of the outstanding amounts of Rs. 67,11,942/- and the cancellation letter dated 18.1.2011 Ex. D-18, whereby the defendant sought to forfeit the amount of Rs. 25,00,2167- from out of the amount of Rs. 25,81,517/-.

7. Having heard learned Counsel for the parties, I am of the view that the plaintiff is entitled to partial relief in the present application. For the purpose of Order 12 Rule 6, CPC, what is relevant is the defence set up by the defendant. It has to be examined whether the defendant had made an admission of liability in the written statement or the documents relied upon by it, and also whether the defence set up by the defendant is moonshine or not. This is so, because, if the defence is found to be moonshine, the Court shall be justified in passing a decree on admission on the ground that the defendant has not disclosed a triable defence. In this regard, I may refer to the judgment relied upon by the defendant in Mahendra Verma v. Suresh T Kailachand, 2010 (4) AD (Del) 765. The Division Bench placed reliance on an earlier Division Bench judgment in P.P.A. Impex Pvt. Ltd. v. Mangal Sin Mittal, 166 (2010) DLT 84, wherein the Division Bench had observed as follows:

"It appears to us that the approach to the taken under Order 12 Rule 6 is akin to what has been enunciated by the Supreme Court in Mechelec Engineers & Manufacturers v. Basic Equipment Corporation., Manu/SC/0043/1976 : (1976) 4 SCC 687 in the context of Order 37 of the CPC with regard to granting Leave to Defend a summary suit. This is that if a defence amounting to moonshine has been presented, it should be summarily dismissed by not granting Leave to Defend and by decreeing the suit forthwith. The Courts are already groaning under the weight of bludgeoning and exponentially increasing litigation. The weight will unvaryingly increase if moonshine defences are needlessly permitted to go to Trial."

8. The issue, whether the plaintiff was in default of the terms of the allotment — by not making payment of the instalments called upon by the defendant, is a triable issue. Therefore, the plaintiff cannot succeed at this stage in claiming the entire principal amount. However, Ex. D-1 is the application made by the plaintiff on 30.1.2008 on the prescribed proforma of the defendant — seeking allotment of commercial space. The broad terms and conditions contained in Schedule I to this application are also in a printed format of the defendant. It is the defendant which has placed this document on record and relies on it. The said document, as noticed hereinabove, at one stage authorises the defendant to forfeit all the sums/monies paid/deposited by the applicant i.e. the plaintiff in the eventuality of the applicant not signing the buyers agreement within thirty days of dispatch by the defendant. At another place, i.e. Clause 14 of Schedule I, it is clearly stated that the defendant company shall treat 10% of the sale price as earnest money to ensure fulfilment by the applicant of the terms and conditions 'contained herein and in the buyers agreement'. Apparently, there is a contradiction in the two terms. Since the defendant is the author of the said documents (Ex. D-1 and Schedule I), the said document has to be strictly read against the defendants by application of the doctrine of contra proferentem. Consequently, the defence of the defendant' insofar as the defendant seeks to justify forfeiture of the entire amount deposited by the plaintiff, and not just the earnest money deposit, appears to be frivolous, moonshine and untenable. Mahendra Verma (supra) does not advance the defendants case, because the facts of that case were materially different. In that case the plaintiff had preferred the application under Order 12 Rule 6, CPC in respect of the deposit admittedly made by the defendant, which the defendant had claimed, was an earnest money deposit in pursuance of an oral agreement. In the present case, the documents/terms and conditions relied upon by the defendant are in writing; the writing is also of the defendant, and; the amount claimed by the defendant as paid towards earnest money, in any case, is not being directed to be refunded at this stage.

9. The total sale price of the property in question is contained in the letter of allotment Ex. D-2 i.e. Rs.1,03,26,069/-. 10% of the said amount could, at best, be the EMD, which comes to Rs. 10,32,607/-. Pertinently, Ex. D-18 also acknowledges this position by disclosing that the earnest money is Rs.10,32,607/-. Assuming that the breach of the agreement is on the part of the plaintiff, all that the defendant was entitled to forfeit was the earnest money of Rs.10,32,607/- and nothing beyond that.

10. I see no justification in the defendants submission that the defendant should be permitted to deposit the said amount in this Court, and the said amount should not be released to the plaintiff during the pendency of the suit. Clearly, the defendant is not entitled to retain any amount beyond Rs.10,32,607/-, even if one were to accept the defence of the defendant that the plaintiff was in breach of the allotment terms and buyers agreement.

11. Accordingly, the plaintiff is entitled to a partial decree for the amount of Rs. 15,48,910/-. The suit is accordingly partially decreed for the said amount. The issue, whether the plaintiff is entitled to interest on the said amount, and if so, at what rate and for what period would require consideration after trial and the same is left open.

12. Application stands disposed of.

CS(OS) 2635/2010

Further documents, if any, be filed within two weeks. List for framing of issues on 24.10.2013.

Having gone through the terms and conditions contained in the application form and letter of allotment issued by the defendant, in my view, this is a fit case which calls for investigation by the Competition Commission to examine whether the said documents and the conduct of the defendant fall foul of the Competition Act, 2002. The Registry is directed to send copies of the entire correspondence exchanged between the parties, which is contained in the documents filed by the parties to the Director General of the Competition Commission, who shall take appropriate action in terms of the Act and in accordance with law.

Application disposed of.

_____________