Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Stalin v. State Of Kerala

Kerala High Court
Nov 18, 2005
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by A.K. Basheer, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The core dispute concerns whether the Kerala Public Service Commission (the Commission) was justified in refusing to advise candidates included in the rank lists for the post of Pharmacist (Homoeopathy) on the ground that an amended set of Special Rules (SRO No. 397/1999, effective 12 April 1999) introduced a new essential qualification — a certificate in the Nurse-Cum-Pharmacist (N.C.P.) training course — after the Commission had issued a common notification (Ext. P1) on 27 October 1998 and while the selection process was in progress.

Ext. P1 prescribed qualifications as then prevailing (pass in SSLC and three years experience dispensing homoeopathic medicine). The selection process under Ext. P1 was completed and district-wise rank lists were published between April 2002 and January 2003; the petitioners were included in those rank lists. After framing of the Special Rules on 12 April 1999, the Commission filled only those vacancies that had arisen prior to the framing of the Special Rules and treated candidates without the N.C.P. certificate as ineligible for advice and appointment. The petitioners challenged this refusal by filing writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution; one such writ petition (W.P. No. 15076/2005) was dismissed by a learned single Judge, and the present writ appeal and connected petitions raised the identical question.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Special Rules framed by the Government on 12 April 1999, introducing the N.C.P. certificate as an essential qualification for appointment as Pharmacist (Homoeopathy), operate retrospectively to defeat the rights of candidates included in rank lists prepared pursuant to the Commission's notification dated 27 October 1998.
  2. Whether the Commission was required to advise candidates included in the extant rank lists for any vacancies that existed or were reported before the expiry of those rank lists, notwithstanding the subsequent Special Rules.

Arguments of the Parties

Commission's Arguments

  • The Commission relied on Rules 10 and 13 of the General Rules, contending that the incumbent of a post must have such educational and other qualifications as specified in the Special Rules applicable to the service; therefore, candidates lacking the N.C.P. certificate prescribed by the Special Rules could not be considered eligible for advice or appointment.
  • The Commission also stated that the decision to advise only those who possessed the qualifications under the Special Rules was taken after detailed deliberations.

Respondent No. 2 (Director of Homoeopathy) — Admissions in Counter Affidavit

  • Admitted that several vacancies were available when the rank lists were published and that such vacancies were reported to the Commission (Exts. R2(a) to R2(f)).
  • Admitted that the Nurse-Cum-Pharmacist (N.C.P.) training course is not a regular ongoing training programme and is conducted only as and when trained hands are required for recruitment.
  • Admitted that departmental temporary promotions (of Attenders/Dispensers/Nursing Assistants) were made as provisional measures in view of the dearth of N.C.P.-trained hands and were subject to reversion when regular hands join duty.

Petitioners'/Appellants' Position (as reflected in the petition and the issues raised)

  • The petitioners challenged the Commission's refusal to advise them, asserting entitlement to be considered for appointment based on the qualifications prescribed in Ext. P1 notification issued on 27 October 1998 and on the principle that a rule or statutory amendment introduced during a selection process should not affect candidates' accrued rights.
  • They relied on higher court authority (Supreme Court decisions) on the prospective operation of statutory rules and the protection of rights of candidates who had applied before amendment of qualification rules.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P. Mahendran v. State of Karnataka, (1990) 1 SCC 411 Every statute or statutory rule is prospective unless expressly or by necessary implication made retrospective; amendment brought into force during the course of selection will not affect rights of candidates qualified on the date of application; rules should be construed as prospective in absence of express retrospective language. The court relied on this authoritative pronouncement to hold that the Special Rules framed on 12 April 1999 do not affect petitioners' accrued rights arising from Ext. P1 notification and selection process already in progress.
A.A. Calton v. Director of Education, (1983) 3 SCC 33 Referenced by the Supreme Court in Mahendran for principles relating to prospective operation of statutes/rules (as part of supporting jurisprudence). Used as part of the chain of authority reinforcing the principle that statutory/rule changes during selection processes do not operate retrospectively absent clear intent; cited in support of the Mahendran principle applied by this Court.
Katti v. Karnataka Public Service Commission, (1990) 3 SCC 157 Affirmed the Mahendran principle relating to prospective operation of statutory/rule changes affecting selection criteria. The court noted this decision as following the Mahendran dictum and treated it as part of binding Supreme Court authority supporting prospective operation of the Special Rules at issue.
Secretary, A.P. Public Service Commission v. B. Swapna, (2005) 4 SCC 154 Once a process of selection starts, the prescribed selection criteria cannot be changed; rules regarding qualification if amended during continuance of selection do not affect existing rights; principle based on fair play. The court quoted and applied this recent Supreme Court precedent directly to hold that the Special Rules could not be applied retrospectively to defeat petitioners' rights; it reinforced the conclusion that selection criteria applicable when the process began must govern.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by reference to the chronology and the legal principles established by the Supreme Court:

  1. Chronology and facts: Ext. P1 notification was issued on 27 October 1998 specifying qualifications in terms of an earlier G.O. (G.O.(Ms.)161/84.HG dated 21.6.1984). The Government framed Special Rules for the Kerala Homoeopathy Subordinate Service (SRO No. 397/1999) on 12 April 1999 introducing the N.C.P. certificate as an essential qualification. The selection process pursuant to Ext. P1 had been in progress; district-wise rank lists were published between April 2002 and January 2003 and the petitioners were included in those lists.
  2. Legal proposition from authority: The court identified binding Supreme Court authority (Mahendran and subsequently Katti and Swapna) establishing that statutes or statutory rules are ordinarily prospective, and that amendments to prescribed selection criteria made during an ongoing selection process do not affect the rights of candidates who were qualified at the time of application unless the amendment expressly or by necessary implication provides for retrospective effect.
  3. Application to present facts: Because the Special Rules do not contain any clause indicating retrospective operation, they must be understood to operate prospectively only. Therefore, Rules 10 and 13 of the General Rules, which generally require incumbents to possess qualifications as specified in Special Rules, must be read subject to the settled Supreme Court law protecting rights accrued when a selection process has commenced.
  4. Auxiliary executive order (Ext. P4): The court relied on a Government order, G.O. Ms. 233/85.GAT dated 27 June 1985 (Ext. P4), in which the Government clarified that changes in qualifications or method of appointment introduced after the issue of a notification will be given effect to in future selections only. The court held Ext. P4 binding on the Commission and emphasized that Rule 10 itself contemplates that qualifications may be specified in executive orders where special rules are not issued; since no special rules were in force when Ext. P1 was issued in 1998, the qualifications in Ext. P1 governed.
  5. Relief flowing from analysis: Because vacancies existed and were reported at the time the rank lists were prepared (and before expiry of those rank lists), and because the Special Rules could not be applied retrospectively to displace rights accruing under Ext. P1, the Commission was bound to advise candidates from those rank lists for vacancies that existed during the currency of those lists. The court further noted that temporary promotions made by the Department were provisional and without prejudice to the petitioners' rights, and therefore the petitioners could be accommodated without disturbing appointments made under the new rank lists.
  6. Conclusion of analysis: The single Judge's dismissal of W.P. No. 15076/2005 was set aside, and the court ordered that appropriate orders be issued to advise and appoint the petitioners to vacancies reported before expiry of the respective rank lists, within one month of receipt of the judgment.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Writ Appeal and the connected Writ Petitions are allowed. The judgment of the learned single Judge in W.P. No. 15076/2005 is set aside. The respondents are directed to issue appropriate orders advising and appointing the appellants/petitioners to the vacant posts which were reported before the expiry of the respective rank lists, expeditiously and in any event within one month from receipt of a copy of the judgment.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The immediate consequence is that petitioners included in the rank lists prepared under Ext. P1 who satisfy other conditions are entitled to be advised for appointment against vacancies that existed or were reported before the expiry of those rank lists, despite the later-introduced Special Rules requiring an N.C.P. certificate.
  • On temporary promotions and new rank lists: Appointments already made pursuant to fresh rank lists (published after selections conducted under the Special Rules) need not be disturbed; the court directed accommodation of successful petitioners because the Department's provisional temporary promotions were made without prejudice to the petitioners' rights.
  • Precedential impact: The court applied and followed existing Supreme Court authority (Mahendran, Katti, Swapna) and an existing Government executive clarification (Ext. P4). The decision enforces those authorities in the present factual matrix rather than announcing a new principle; the judgment derives directly from and applies established jurisprudence that rule changes during an ongoing selection are prospective unless expressly made retrospective.

Order for compliance: The respondents shall issue orders for advice and appointment in respect of the relevant vacancies within one month from date of receipt of this judgment.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

A.K Basheer, J.:— The short but important question that arises for consideration in this bunch of cases is whether the Kerala Public Service Commission is justified in refusing to advise candidates like the petitioners included in the rank list of Pharmacist (Homoeopathy) on the ground that they did not possess requisite qualification in terms of the amended special rules framed by the Government after commencement of the selection process. In other words, the question is: Are the amended rules regarding qualification, atleast vis-a-vis the appellant and petitioners, prospective or retrospective in their operation?

2. A brief reference to the essential facts is necessary to answer the above question. We will be referring to the relevant dates and documents available in Writ Petition No. 18087/2005. The Kerala Public Service Commission (for short, the Commission) issued Ext. P1 notification in the Kerala Gazette on October 27, 1998 inviting applications for appointment, to the post, of Pharmacist (Homoeopathy) in the Department of Homoeopathy. The common notification was issued for filling up the several vacancies in 8 districts in the State. The qualifications prescribed were:

(1) A pass in SSLC examination or equivalent.

(2) Experience in dispensing homoeopathic medicine for not less than 3 years in Government Homoeopathic Hospital/Dispensary or in a dispensary run by a registered A Class Homoeopathic Medical Practitioner.

3. The above qualifications were in terms of those prescribed in G.O(Ms)161/84.HG dated 21.6.1984 It is not in dispute that the selection process was completed and separate districtwise rank lists were published on various dates between April 2002 and January 2003. Admittedly the petitioners were included in the rank lists of their respective districts.

4. On April 12, 1999, the Government of Kerala framed Special Rules for the Kerala Homoeopathy Subordinate Service vide SRO. No. 397/1999. Qualifications for the post of Pharmacists (Homoeopathy) ware prescribed in the Special Rules as hereunder:

Pharmacist (Homoeopathy) (1) By direct recruitment (1)Pass in SSLC or equivalent qualification. (2) A certificate obtained after successful training in Nurse-Cum-Pharmacist training course (Homoeopathy) conducted by the Govt, of Kerala or its equivalent.

5. It can be seen that a certificate in Nurse-cum-Pharmacist Training Course (Homoeopathy) Conducted by the Government of Kerala or its equivalent became an essential qualification for the post of Pharmacists (Homoeopathy). A true photo copy of the notification has been produced as Ext.R2(f).

6. The admitted position is that the Special Rules were framed by the Government when the selection process pursuant to Ext. P1 notification issued by the Commission was in progress. The petitioners had not undergone training in Nurse-Cum-Pharmacist Training Course conducted by the Government of Kerala and therefore they would not be eligible for appointment, if the Special Rules are made applicable for selection and appointment.

7. After publication of the rank list, the Commission filled up only those vacancies which had arisen prior to the framing of the Special Rules which came into force with effect from April 12, 1999. The Commission took the view that the petitioners and other similarly placed candidates in the rank lists who did not possess a certificate in Nurse-Cum-Pharmacist Training Course (Homoeopathy) as prescribed under the Special Rules were not eligible or entitled to be advised for appointment. It is in the above circumstances that the petitioners whose names have been included in the rank lists of various districts have come up before this Court under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India.

8. A learned single Judge before whom one of the identical Writ Petitions (W.P No. 15076/2005) came up earlier held that in view of the introduction of the Special Rules, the petitioner in that Writ Petition who did not admittedly possess the requisite qualification was not entitled to be advised for appointment. Thus the learned single Judge accepted the contention of the Commission that only those among the candidates who had the requisite qualification as prescribed under the Special Rules were entitled to be advised and accordingly dismissed the writ petition. The learned single Judge had in fact followed a similar view taken by another learned single Judge in another writ petition. W.A No. 1030/2005 is filed against the judgment of the learned single Judge in W.P No. 15076/2005. The remaining Writ Petitions have been posted along with the Writ Appeal since identical question has arisen in this bunch of cases.

9. It is contended on behalf of the Commission that Rr. 10 and 13 of the General Rules are unambiguous that the incumbent of a post shall have such educational and other qualifications as specified in the special rules applicable to the service in which the post is included or specified. Therefore, the petitioners who do not have the requisite qualifications as specified in the special rules for the Kerala Homoeopathy Subordinate Service Rules, cannot be heard to say that they are entitled to be advised for the said post. It is also contended that the decision to advise only those who had the requisite qualifications under the special rules, was taken after detailed deliberations in the matter.

10. In the counter affidavit filed on behalf of respondent No. 2, the Director of Homoeopathy, it is admitted that several vacancies were available when the rank lists of various districts were published. It is also admitted that the existing vacancies of Pharmacists were reported to the Commission. Since the Commission had not advised candidates to fill up the vacant posts, temporary promotions were made against those vacancies subject to the condition that those departmental hands will be reverted back as and when regular hands join duty. Exts. R2(a) to (f) will show that several such vacancies were reported by the department to the Commission. More significantly, respondent No. 2 has admitted that Nurse-cum-Pharmacist Training course (N.C.P) is not a regular ongoing training programme. The said training programme is conducted as and when trained hands are required for recruitment. It is also conceded that the department had accorded sanction to promote Attenders/Dispensers/Nursing Assistants in the department as Pharmacists in view of the dearth of N.C.P trained hands.

11. We have heard learned counsel for the parties at length. The learned counsel have taken us through a long number of decisions as well as some authoritative textbooks on Interpretation of Statutes and Administrative Law. But in our view, the issue involved in these case is settled in favour of the petitioners in view of the authoritative pronouncements of their Lordships of the Supreme Court, to which we will refer shortly. Therefore, we do not deem it necessary to deal with the entire case law and also principles of statutory interpretation.

12. In P. Mahendran v. State of Karnataka, (1990) 1 SCC 411) a 3 Judge Bench of the Honourable Supreme Court held that every statute or statutory rule being prospective, the amendment, if any, brought into force during the course of the selection process would not in any way affect the rights of the candidates who were otherwise qualified as on the date of making the application for selection. Their Lordships further held thus:

“It is well settled rule of construction that every statute or statutory rale is prospective unless it is expressly or by necessary implication made to have retrospective effect. Unless there are words in the statute or in the Rules showing the intention to affect existing rights the rule must be held to be prospective. If a rule is expressed in language which is fairly capable of either interpretation it ought to be construed as prospective only. In the absence of any express provision or necessary intendment the rule cannot be given retrospective effect except in matter of procedure….”

13. In the above decision their Lordships had also referred to the observations made by the Court in A.A Calton v. Director of Education, (1983) 3 SCC 33 and several other decisions on the point. Later the Apex Court had followed the dictum laid down in Mahendran's case (supra) in Katti v. Karnataka Public Service Commission. ((1990) 3 SCC 157) and in Secretary, A.P Public Service Commission v. B. Swapna. ((2005) 4 SCC 154.

14. In Swapna's case (supra), their Lordships held thus:

“Once a process of selection starts, the prescribed selection criteria cannot be changed. The logic behind the same is based on fair play. A person who did not apply because a certain criterion e.g minimum percentage of marks, can make a legitimate grievance, in case the same is lowered, that he could have applied because he possessed the said percentage. Rules regarding qualification for appointment if amended during continuance of the process of selection do not affect the same. That is because every statute or statutory rule is prospective unless it is expressly or by necessary implication made to have retrospective effect. Unless there are words in the statute or in the rules showing the intention to affect existing rights the rule must be held to be prospective. If the rule is expressed in a language which is fairly capable of either interpretation it ought to be considered as prospective only”

15. In view of the decisions of the Apex Court cited supra, there cannot be any doubt as regards the answer to the question whether the Special Rules framed by the Government with effect from April 12, 1999 would have any impact on the rights accrued to the petitioners as on the date of the notification issued by the Commission. Since the Special Rules do not contain any clause indicating retrospectivity of the qualifications prescribed in those Special Rules, it will have only prospective operation. Rr. 10 and 13 of the General Rules have to be understood subject to the law laid down as above. Therefore the Commission has to necessarily make appointments in terms of the qualifications prescribed in Ext. P1 notification.

16. There is yet another aspect of the matter. The Government had issued. G.O Ms. 233/85.GAT on June 27, 1985, a copy of which is on record as Ext. P4. In the said order, the Government had clarified that the changes in qualifications, method of appointment, age or other conditions of recruitment introduced after the issue of a notification for selection to the post by the Public Service Commission will be given effect to in future selections only. In our view, the contention raised by the respondents basing on Rules 10 and 13 of the general rules cannot be accepted since we have already held that the special rules do not indicate that they will have any retrospective operation. Undoubtedly, Rules 10 and 13 will prevail as far as the educational and other qualifications required for a post as specified in the special rules are concerned under normal circumstances. But in a case where the special rules were either newly introduced or amended after the selection process had been set in motion, the scenario will change. The candidates who applied for the post on the basis of the then prevailing rules or regulations, cannot be denied the opportunity to be considered for selection if the subsequent amendment prescribes a different qualification. In any view of the matter, we have no hesitation to hold that Ext. P4 order issued by the Government is binding on the Commission and the clarification mentioned therein regarding qualifications, method of appointment etc. have to be followed scrupulously. Further, a perusal of R. 10 will also show that Ext. P4 order issued by the Government in June 1985 cannot be ignored or overlooked by the Commission. Rule 10 stipulates that the educational or other qualifications, if any, required for a post shall be as specified in special rales or in any executive order of the Government in cases where special rules had not been issued for the post/service, (emphasis supplied). The admitted position is that no special rules were in vogue in the year 1998 when Ext. P1 notification was issued. Requisite qualification for the post were specified in Ext. P1 notification in terms of the then prevailing rules or norms. Therefore, the respondents cannot be heard to say that the rules regarding the qualification which were subsequently introduced in the special rules, will prevail.

17. As noticed earlier, the respondents have admitted that vacancies were available in various districts when the rank lists were published by the Commission. Only a handful of vacancies were filled up by the Commission since the remaining vacancies had arisen after the introduction of the special rules. Since we have already held that the Commission is bound to advise candidates from the rank lists to all the vacant posts which were available at the time of publication of the notification and the rank lists and thereafter, it necessarily follows that the petitioners are entitled to get appointment as claimed by them, if they had been included in the rank list and if they satisfy other conditions. Needless, to mention that advice need be given only in respect of those vacancies which were reported before the expiry of the rank list of the respective districts, notwithstanding the fact that the appellant and petitioners did not possess N.C.P certificate as prescribed under the special rules.

18. It has been brought to our notice that the Commission has published fresh rank lists after conducting selection in terms of the Special Rules. However, since we have already held that those vacancies which existed during the currency of the rank lists prepared pursuant to Ext. P1 notification are liable to be filled up for these rank lists and that the appellant and the petitioners in these cases are entitled to be advised if they are otherwise eligible, it necessarily follows that these candidates have to be advised and appointed without disturbing the appointments if any made in terms of the new rank lists. Since the respondents have conceded that the temporary promotions made from the category of Attenders, Dispensers etc. were only provisional and without prejudice to the rights of the appellant and petitioners, we do not find any difficulty in accommodating the appellant and petitioner, if they are entitled to be advised and appointed. In that view of the matter, the judgment of the learned single Judge in Writ Petition No. 15076/2005 is set aside. The respondents shall issue appropriate orders for advice and appointment of the appellant and petitioners to the vacant posts which were reported before the expiry of the respective rank lists expeditiously, at any rate within one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.

19. The Writ Appeal and the Writ Petitions are allowed in the above terms.