Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Sales And Agencies v. The Plantation Corporation Ltd.

Kerala High Court
Mar 1, 1996
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The decree holder in O.S 345/77 filed a revision against an order dated 21-7-1993 in E.A 211/93 in E.P 383/82 related to the suit. The suit originally sought recovery of Rs. 75,645.20 with interest, and was decreed for Rs. 82,354.15. Execution proceedings were initiated to recover the decree amount. The High Court, by judgment dated 2-6-1989 in A.S 396/81, modified the decree to Rs. 55,645.20 with interest at 6% per annum from the suit filing date. The trial court had credited an amount of Rs. 18,305.84 deposited by the respondent on 2-2-1978 towards the decree. During execution, an attachment was ordered, but the judgment-debtor paid Rs. 78,445.70 to the Amin, which was deposited in court on 30-11-1982. The High Court permitted the decree-holder to withdraw this amount subject to furnishing security, but the decree-holder did not withdraw it. Subsequently, the judgment-debtor petitioned for a refund of Rs. 28,089.90, claiming excess deposit beyond the decretal dues. The execution court allowed the refund, which led to the present revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the amount deposited on 30-11-1982 is deemed to be a deposit under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 of Order 21 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C), entitling the decree-holder to interest only up to that date?
  2. Whether the decree-holder is entitled to interest on decretal dues less the amount deposited on 2-2-1978 up to the date of the High Court judgment dated 2-6-1989?
  3. Whether the conditional nature of the deposit on 30-11-1982 affects the entitlement to interest under the provisions of Order 21, Rule 1 of the C.P.C?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The court below erred in restricting interest payment from 30-11-1982, the date of deposit.
  • The amount deposited on 30-11-1982 was conditional and not in terms of Order 21, Rule 1(a) of the C.P.C.
  • The decree-holder is entitled to interest on decretal dues less the amount paid on 2-2-1978 up to the date of the High Court judgment on 2-6-1989.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The petitioner was at liberty to withdraw the amount deposited on 30-11-1982 on that day, deeming it a deposit under Order 21, Rule 1(a) of the C.P.C.
  • The decree-holder is not entitled to claim interest on decretal dues from 30-11-1982.
  • The execution court rightly accepted the judgment-debtor’s account statement which excluded interest from 30-11-1982 and directed refund of the excess amount.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramanathan v. Ramanathan, A.I.R 1968 S.C 1047 Clarification that a conditional deposit by judgment-debtor pending appeal does not amount to satisfaction of decree under Order 21, Rule 1(a) of C.P.C. The court relied on this principle to hold that the conditional deposit on 30-11-1982 was not a deposit under Order 21, Rule 1(a), and thus interest entitlement continued beyond that date.
Ramanathan v. Ramanathan, A.I.R 1960 Madras 207 (Full Bench) Payments under Order 21, Rule 1 must be unconditional; conditional deposits governed by court order are not deemed deposits under the rule. The court noted that this principle was not set aside by the Supreme Court and supported the view that the deposit was conditional and not under Order 21, Rule 1.
Union of India v. Sheela Devi, A.I.R 1963 Punjab 111 Where a condition is imposed by the court on payment to decree-holder, interest runs from date of deposit till actual payment. The court applied this principle to hold that the decree-holder was entitled to interest on the decretal amount from the date of deposit till actual withdrawal due to the conditional nature of the deposit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the nature of the deposit made on 30-11-1982 and whether it qualified as a deposit under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 of Order 21 of the C.P.C. It observed that the deposit was conditional, as the decree-holder was allowed to withdraw the amount only upon furnishing security. The court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Ramanathan v. Ramanathan (A.I.R 1968 S.C 1047) which established that such conditional deposits do not amount to satisfaction of the decree and are not deemed deposits under Order 21, Rule 1(a). The court further noted the Full Bench Madras High Court ruling which held that payments under Order 21, Rule 1 must be unconditional. Additionally, the Punjab High Court's decision in Union of India v. Sheela Devi was cited to support the proposition that interest continues to run on deposits subject to conditions until actual payment. Applying these principles, the court concluded that the decree-holder was entitled to interest at 6% per annum on the decretal dues, less the amount deposited on 2-2-1978, from that date until 2-6-1989, the date of the High Court judgment. The court rejected the petitioner's claim for interest beyond 2-6-1989, reasoning that the decree-holder was free to withdraw the amount after that date but did not do so. Consequently, the execution court's order allowing refund based on the conditional deposit was set aside.

Holding and Implications

The revision is allowed and the impugned order dated 21-7-1993 is set aside.

Parties are directed to submit fresh statements of account before the execution court, which shall pass appropriate orders after scrutiny. The direct effect is that the decree-holder is entitled to interest on the decretal dues (less the amount deposited on 2-2-1978) from 2-2-1978 until 2-6-1989, considering the conditional nature of the deposit on 30-11-1982. No new legal precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles regarding conditional deposits under Order 21, Rule 1 of the C.P.C.

Show all summary ...

1. The decree holder in O.S 345/77 on the file of the Addl. Sub Court, Kottayam, hats preferred this revision against the order dated 21-7-1993 in E.A 211/93 in E.P 383/82 arising out of the said suit. By the impugned order, the learned Sub Judge allowed the petition of the judgment-debtor to get refund of an excess amount of Rs. 28,089.90 which was said to have been deposited in excess of the decretal debt due to the petitioner - decree holder.

2. The petitioner filed the suit for recovery of an amount of Rs. 75,645,20 with interest from the date of the suit. The suit was decreed for a sum of Rs. 82,354,15. The decree holder levied execution to execute the decree. While the execution proceeding was pending, the High Court by judgment dated 2-6-1989 in A.S 396/81 modified the decree and allowed the petitioner-decree holderto recover only an amount of Rs. 55,645.20 with interest at 6% per annum from the date of filing the suit (29-7-1977). The trial court, while granting the decree had directed that the amount of Rs. 18,305.84 deposited by the respondent herein on 2-2-1978 will be credited in the decree as having been paid on 2-2-1978. In pursuance of that order, an amount of Rs. 77,594.01 was claimed in the execution prooceeding. In that execution proceeding an order for attachment of movables belonging to the respondent judgment-debter was passed. When the Amin went to effect attachment, the judgment-debtor paid an amount of Rs. 78,445.70 to the Amin, who deposited the same in court on 30-11-1982. Thereafter, the High Court allowed the petitioner - decree holder towithdraw the amount on the condition of furnishing security to the satisfaction of the execution court. The petitioner did not draw that amount in view of the conditional order of the appellate court. The appeal was finally disposed of on 2-6-1989.

3. The judgment-debtor respondent filed a petition before the execution court stating that he is entitled to get refund of an amount of Rs. 28,089.90, since the deposits made by him on 2-2-1978 and 30-11-1982 are in excess of the decretal dues. The petitioner decree-holder contended that the decretal amount and interest thereon would be Rs. 1,08,020/- The judgment-debter has deposited only an amount of Rs. 96,761.54. In the statement filed by the judgment-debtor respondent deduction of the first deposit of Rs. 18,305.84 was made from the total amount due as on 2-2-1978. He stated that he made the deduction from the total amount of the principal, interest, execution expenses and advocate fee as on 2-6-1989.

4. The execution court held that if the deposit made on 2-2-1978 is deducted from the total amount due on that date, the statement of account filed by the judgment debtor is correct. The total amount due to the decree-holder as on 30-11-1982 on which date the judgment-debtor made the second deposit of Rs. 78,455.70 was completely satisfied and as such there is an excess amount of Rs. 28,089.09. With the above finding, the execution court directed for refund of the amount.

5. It is contended by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the court below erred in restricting the payment of interest from 30-11-1982 when the said amount was deposited. Since the petitioner was not allowed to withdraw the amount unconditionally, it was not deposited in terms of Order 21, rule 1(a) of the Code of Civil Procedure, for short, the C.P.C Hence the decree-holder is entitled to get interest on the decretal dues less the amount paid on 2-2-1978 upto the date of judgment in A.S 396/81.

6. Learned counsel for the respondent contends that the petitioner was at liberty to withdraw the amount deposited on 30-11-1982 on that day, as it was deemed to have been done under Order 21, rule 1(a) of the C.P.C He is nto entitled the claim interest on the decretal dues from 30-11-1982. Hence it is contended that the execution court is justified in accepting the statement of account filed by the respondent-judgment debtor in which no interest was calculated with effect from 30-11-1982 and directing the refund of the excess amount.

7. The only question for consideration is whether the amount that was deposited in the court on 30-11-1982 is deemed to be a deposit under Order 21 rule 1(a) of C.P.C Clause (a) of sub-rule (I) of rule 1 of Order 21 C.P.C lays down that all money, payable under a decree shall be paid by deposit into the court whose duty it is to execute the decree, or sent to that court by postal money order or through a bank. Sub-rule (2) lays down that where any payment is made under clause (a) or clause (c) of sub-rule (1), the judgment-debtor shall give notice thereof to the decree-holder either through the court or directly to him by registered post, acknowledgment due. Sub-rule (4) contemplates that on any amount paid under clause (a) or clause (c) of sub-rule (1), interest, if any, shall cease to run from the date of service of the notice referred to in Sub-rule (2). The question as to whether the order of the appellate court directing payment to the decree-holder subject to his complying a condition can be said to be a deposit under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of ruled) of Order 21 C.P.C came up for consideration before the Supreme Court in Ramanathan v. Ramanathan (A.I.R 1968 S.C 1047). It has been laid down therein as follows:—

“The fact of a judgment debtor's depositing a sum in Court to purchase peace by way of stay of execution of the decree on terms that the decree holder can draw it out on furnishing security, does not pass title to the money to the decree-holder. He can if he likes take the money but in terms of the order, but so long as he does not do it, there is nothing to prevent the judgment-debtor from taking it out by furnishing other security, say, of immovable property, if the court allows him to do so and his losing the appeal putting the decretal amount in court in terms of Order 21, Rule 1, Civil P.C in satisfaction of the decree. The real effect of deposit of money in Court is to put the money beyond the reach of the parties pending the disposal of the appeal. The decree-holder can only take it out on furnishing security which means that the payment is not in satisfaction of the decree and security could be proceeded against by the judgment-debter in case of his success in the appeal. Pending the determination of the same, it is beyond the reach of the judgment-debtor. Such a deposit would not amount to discharge of decree.”

8. Earlier, a Full Bench of the Madras High Court in Ramanathan v. Ramanathan (A.I.R 1960 Madras 207) laid down the same proposition of law as follows:—

“The payments under O. 21, R. 1 are payments which should be unconditional in their nature. Where money is deposited under an order of court, the terms of the deposit would be governed by the order. When the money was deposited in pursuance of an order which placed a restriction on the decree-holder drawing the money that could not be held to be a deposit under O. 21, R. 1 but one under the order of Court.”

9. Of course, on some other grounds, the Madras decision was overruled by the Supreme Court later in A.I.R 1968 S.C 1047. But, that part of the observation of the Madras High Court was not set aside. Similarly in Union of India v. Sheela Devi (A.I.R 1963 Punjab 111), the High Court of Punjab held as follows:

“The Union of India filed an appeal against the decision of the arbitrator awarding compensation with interest to the land owner whose land was acquired. Pending the appeal the appellant made an application for the stay of the execution proceedings filed by the respondent-owner. On this application the appellate court passed an order that the decretal amount will only be paid to the decree holder on her furnishing security to the satisfaction of theexecuting court for restitution. The appellant deposited the decretal amount in the treasury, but the same was paid to the decree-holder one month after the said deposit when she furnished the required security. On the decree-holder claiming interest, the question was whether the decree-holder was entitled to the interest for the period of one month from the date of the deposit of the decretal amount in the treasury till its actual withdrawal by her on furnishing security.

Held that as the condition was imposed by the Court on the application of the appellant the decree-holder was entitled to interest from the date of deposit to the date of actual payment.”

10. The decree-holder in this case was not at liberty to withdraw the amount deposited on 30-11-1982 inasmuch as it was a conditional order passed by the court. As has been held by the Supreme Court, since he was not entitled to withdraw that amount in satisfaction of the decree, the said deposit is not deemed to be one made under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of rule 1 of Order 21 of the C.P.C Hence the provisions of Sub-rule (4) shall not apply insofar as that deposit is concerned. In this view of the matter, I am of the opinion that the decree-holder is entitled to get interest at the rate of 6% per annum on the balance amount of the decretal dues from 2-2-1978 till 2-6-1989.

11. The centention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner is entitled to get interest at that rate on the said amount even after 2-6-1989 upto the date of filing the revision petition, in my opinion, does not appear to be sound. The decree-holder petitioner was free to withdraw the amount at any time after 2-6-1989. It is true that the judgment-debtor filed a petition about one year thereafter for disbursement of the excess amount said to have been deposited by him. But, that cannot be a ground to say that the decree-holder was prevented from withdrawing the amount after 2-6-1989 and before the judgment-debtor filed the petition.

12. For the reasons stated above, the revision is allowed. The impugned order is set aside. Parties are directed to submit fresh statements of account before the execution court in the light of the observation made above, and the execution court shall pass appropriate orders on a scrutiny of the statements of account to be furnished by the parties.