- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Parameswaran Kartha And Others v. Asst. Registrar And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The opinion arises from multiple original petitions challenging communications/orders of the Assistant Registrar (and related respondents) concerning reclassification of co-operative societies and consequent staff-related consequences under the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1969 and the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules, 1969.
- O.P. No. 985 of 1992: The petitioner is a Senior Clerk in a credit society (second respondent). The managing committee passed resolution Ext. P1 on 30-5-1991 to upgrade the society from Class IV to Class III (as per Appendix III) and to pay salaries accordingly. The Assistant Registrar (first respondent) replied by communication Ext. P2 dated 7-11-1991, stating that as per extant government orders no reclassification was permissible and it was not proper to pay employees the salaries admissible for Class III. The petitioner challenged Ext. P2 by filing the original petition.
- O.P. No. 1436 of 1992: Filed by a Co-operative Bank which, by its working capital and outstandings, qualified for Class II but had been included only in Class III. The managing committee passed resolution Ext. P3 on 25-2-1991 seeking upgradation to Class II. The Assistant Registrar (second respondent) by proceedings dated 1-11-1991 directed cancellation of the reclassification, cancellation of promotions and recovery of excess amounts paid, contending that such steps without the Joint Registrar's approval were irregular. The petitioner challenged that order.
- O.P. No. 3154 of 1992: Filed by an employee of another society where the managing committee's resolution to upgrade to Class III was rejected by order Ext. P1 on grounds that the additional establishment expenditure (Rs. 22,086.30) would be detrimental to shareholders and because the Government was in the process of changing norms for classification. The petitioner challenged Ext. P1.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a society's decision to re-classify itself into a higher class (as per Appendix III to the Rules) requires prior approval of the Registrar or the Government.
- Whether an increase in staff strength consequent on such reclassification requires the prior approval of the Registrar (in light of Rule 188 and Note 2 to Appendix III).
- Whether payment of higher scales of pay to existing staff on upgradation requires prior approval of the Registrar.
- What limitations (if any) constrain the Registrar's discretion to refuse approval for an increase in staff strength — i.e., whether refusal can be arbitrary or can be based only on prescribed criteria (such as the conditions in column 3 of Appendix III).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Contentions
- Reliance on section 80 read with Rules 182 and 188 and Annexure (Appendix) III to the Rules: petitioners contend that it is within the prerogative of the society to place itself in the proper classification and to appoint and pay staff appropriate for that classification.
- Specifically, petitioners assert that no prior approval of the Registrar is required for effecting a change in classification and for paying employees the scale of pay applicable to the higher class.
Respondents' / Government Pleader's Contentions
- Respondents (via counter affidavit) accept that the managing committee may decide classification but contend that reclassification can be brought into effect only with the prior approval of the Registrar.
- It is submitted that norms for classification have been laid down by circulars of the Registrar and that reclassification implicates revision of pay and increase in staff; therefore the Registrar must be satisfied that norms are met before giving approval to safeguard the society's working.
- The Government Pleader submitted that while a society may re-classify itself, payment of enhanced salary or appointment of additional staff should be subject to prior approval of the Registrar.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sherthallai Urban Co. Op. Bank Ltd. v. State Of Kerala, 1984 KLJ 409 | Considered the validity of a prohibition imposed by the Registrar on appointments without his prior sanction while recognising upgradation of a society. | The court held that the Sherthallai decision does not affect the present question because the effect of Note 2 to Appendix III was not under consideration in that case; Sherthallai concerned a prohibition on appointments without prior sanction and was held to be unauthorised for the facts then before the Court. |
| O.P. No. 10078 of 1985 | Interpreted limits on the Registrar's power to refuse approval for staff-strength increase (treats the conditions in Appendix III as the relevant considerations). | The court relies on this decision as supporting the proposition that the Registrar cannot refuse approval for increased staff-strength on irrelevant grounds and must confine consideration to prescribed criteria (e.g., working capital, loan outstandings). |
| O.P. No. 5321 of 1990 | Same line of authority regarding the Registrar's permissible grounds for refusing approval. | The court invokes this decision to corroborate that the Registrar's refusal must be confined to whether the society meets the conditions specified in Appendix III and not on other considerations. |
| O.P. No. 8628 of 1990 | Same principle limiting Registrar's discretion in staff-strength approval. | Used by the court to support the view that the Registrar cannot, for example, rely on the society working at a loss as a ground for declining approval for increased staff-strength. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis follows the statutory scheme and the Rules as they interact with Appendix III:
- Statutory allocation of powers: Sub-section (1) of section 80 vests the primary right to classify societies in the Government; Rule 182 contemplates periodic revision (once in three years) and the Government, in consultation with the Registrar and State Co-operative Union, prescribes staff and scales under sub-section (2) and (3) of section 80 and Rules 183–201.
- Rule 188 and Appendix III: Rule 188 requires every society to adopt the staff pattern indicated in Appendix III according to its type and class. Appendix III prescribes staff pattern and scales of pay. Two provisos to Rule 188 allow (a) committee members to work honorary if the society cannot afford the prescribed staff due to financial incapacity, and (b) where a society needs a different staff pattern or special scale of pay, such changes may be made with the prior approval of the Registrar (in special circumstances).
- Note 2 to Appendix III: The Note states that any increase in existing staff strength shall be made only with the approval of the Registrar. The court reads Note 2 in the context of Rule 188 and Appendix III and concludes that, although Rule 188 mandates adoption of the Appendix's staff pattern, the Note imposes a specific prior-approval requirement only for increases in staff strength (i.e., appointment of additional staff).
- Purpose of Note 2: The court identifies a protective purpose — to enable the Registrar to check arbitrary upgradation by societies that might appoint staff on the basis of an invalid upgradation, thereby creating problems if the upgradation is later held unjustified.
- Distinguishing Sherthallai: The court notes that the Sherthallai decision dealt with a prohibition on appointments without prior sanction while recognising upgradation and held that prohibition unauthorised; however, Sherthallai did not consider the effect of Note 2 and therefore is not directly applicable to the present question.
- Conclusions drawn: The court determines that (a) the broad right to classify societies and prescribe staff/scales is the Government's, but once the statutory/classification criteria in Appendix III are met, it is for the society to decide the precise class in which it falls (no prior approval required for reclassification by the society itself); (b) increase in staff strength consequent upon upgradation requires prior approval of the Registrar under Note 2; (c) the Registrar's power to refuse approval is constrained — he may consider only whether the society satisfies the objective criteria in Appendix III (working capital, loan outstandings, investments, turnover), and cannot refuse approval arbitrarily or on irrelevant grounds (for example, the society working at a loss is not a permissible ground to refuse).
- Payment of salaries: The court holds that Note 2's embargo applies only to increase of staff strength and does not prevent payment of higher scales to existing staff upon upgradation — Rule 189 prescribes scales and therefore existing staff must be paid salaries applicable to the upgraded class.
- Relief and directions: The impugned orders refusing or cancelling reclassification/related payments are unsustainable and are quashed. The respondents are directed to decide applications for increase in staff-strength only on the limited question whether the reclassification is justified by the stipulations in column 3 of Appendix III, and to pass orders within two months.
Holding and Implications
Core Rulings:
- The original petitions are allowed; the impugned orders are quashed.
- Re-classification of a society does not require the prior approval of the Registrar or the Government.
- Increase in the existing staff-strength consequent on upgradation requires the prior approval of the Registrar.
- On upgradation, existing staff must be paid the scales of pay applicable to the higher class.
Implications and direct consequences:
- The Registrar may not refuse approval for increase in staff-strength arbitrarily or on irrelevant grounds; his consideration must be confined to whether the society satisfies the objective conditions specified in column 3 of Appendix III (working capital, loan outstandings, investments, turnover/business turnover).
- The respondents are directed to pass orders concerning increase in staff-strength of the concerned societies within two months from receipt of a copy of the judgment, addressing only the relevant question whether reclassification is justified under Appendix III.
- Existing employees of societies that validly upgrade are entitled to be paid on the higher scales appropriate to the upgraded class even before any appointment of additional staff is approved.
- The petitions were allowed with no order as to costs ("No costs").
This summary is confined to the matters expressly addressed in the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond that text.
1. The petitioner in O.P No. 985 of 1992 is a Senior Clerk in the second respondent Society, which is a credit society registered under the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1969 (the Act). The society had been classified in class IV of Appendix III to the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules, 1969 (The Rules) though the increase in its working capital and outstandings justified a higher classification. The managing committee of the society passed resolution Ext. P1 on 30-5-1991, resolving to upgrade the society to class III and to pay salary accordingly to the members of its staff. This was duly intimated to the first respondent, Assistant Registrar. But he informed the society by his communication Ext. P2 dated 7-11-1991 that as per the extant orders of the Government, no reclassification of any society was permissible, and that it was not proper to pay the employees, the salary admissible for a society included in class III. The petitioner who is an employee of the society and who is affected by Ext. P2 has challenged it by filing the original petition. O.P No. 1436 of 1992 is by a Co-operative Bank. Its working capital and the outstandings entitled it to be included in Class II of Appendix III. But it had been included only in Class III. The managing committee passed resolution Ext. P3 on 25-2-1991 to upgrade the classification to Class II. However, the second respondent, the Assistant Registrar of Co-operative Societies informed the petitioner by his proceedings dated 1-11-1991 that the reclassification, and the payment of enhanced salary and grant of promotions to the employees consequent thereon without the approval of the Joint Registrar were irregular. Accordingly he directed the petitioner to cancel the reclassification, and the promotions, and to take steps to recover the excess amounts paid to the employees. Petitioner challenges this order which has been extracted in paragraph 3 of the original petition. (Ext. P4 produced as a copy of this order is really some other communication, which has nothing to do with this case).
2. A counter affidavit has been filed on behalf of the respondents, in which, while admitting that it is for the managing committee of the society to decide on the classification, it is contended that the re-classification can be brought into effect only with the prior approval of the Registrar. That was why the communication dated 1-11-1991 was issued. Norms for classification have been laid down by various circulars of the Registrar. Since the reclassification involves revision of pay and increase in the number of staff, the Registrar has to be satisfied about the achievement of the norms by the society before giving approval for the reclassification. It is his duty to see that the reclassification does not affect the working of the society adversely.
3. O.P No. 3154 of 1992 is filed by an employee of the second respondent Co-operative Society in similar circumstances as in O.P No. 985 of 1992. Here again the resolution pissed by the managing committee to upgrade the society to class III was rejected by the order Ext. P1 on various grounds. It was pointed out that the additional expenditure on establishment consequent on the reclassification will be Rs. 22,086-30, which is detrimental to the share-holders. Government was taking steps to change the norms prescribed for classification and they were yet to be finalised. The reclassification sought could not be granted for these reasons. Petitioner challenges Ext. P1.
4. In all the cases, the contention of the petitioners is that as per section 80 read with rules 182 and 188, and Annexure III to the Rules, it is the prerogative of the society to place it in the proper classification, and to appoint and pay the staff appropriately for that classification. The contention is that no prior approval of the Registrar is required for effecting such a change.
5. Government Pleader on the other hand, submits that though the re-classification may be done by the society, payment of enhanced salary or the appointment of additional staff can be had only with the prior approval of the Registrar.
6. Sub-section (1) of section 80 of the Act provides that the government shall classify the societies in the State according to their type and financial position. Government has accordingly classified the societies in the State with reference to their type and financial position as mentioned in Appendix III to the Rules. This is as per Rule 182 which reserves a power in the Government of their own motion or other to revise the classification once in every three years, after consultation with the Registrar. It is this revision that is stated to be in the offing and which is put forward as a ground for refusing to recognise the reclassification in O.P No. 3154 of 1992. Under sub-section (2), Government shall, consultation with the State Co-operative Union, fix or after the number and designation of the officers and servants of the different classes of societies specified in sub-section (1). Sub-section (3) of section 80 empowers the Government to make rules regulating the qualifications, remuneration, allowances and other conditions of service of officers and servant of the different classes, of societies in the state, Rules 183 to 201 deal with these matters of which Rule 188 deals with staff pattern and role 189 with remuneration and allowances. Rule 188 requires every society to adopt the staff pattern indicated in Appendix III according to the type and class to which it belongs. There are two provisos to this rule. The first proviso lays down that where any society cannot adopt the staff pattern prescribed in the Appendix because of its financial position, the members of the committee of the society may work in an honorary capacity in lieu of appointing any paid employee. The second proviso prescribes that where any society is in need of any change in the staff pattern, including the special scale of pay under special circumstances, the same may be made by the society with the prior approval of the Registrar. This proviso is intended to cover cases where having regard to the peculiar nature of the work to be undertaken by a particular society, which may require any peculiar staff pattern with some special/higher scale of pay, the Registrar may approve such staff pattern or such scale of pay. This is an exception to be resorted to in special circumstances. Rule 189 lays down that the scale of pay of different categories of posts shall be as shown in Appendix III. I must also refer to Note 2 to Appendix III which lays down that any increase in the existing staff strength shall be made only with the approval of the Registrar. Thus Government has prescribed in Appendix III the staff pattern of the different societies in the State as also the emoluments payable to the employees of each class of societies. It will be seen therefrom that societies have been classified with reference to their working capital, loan outstandings, investments, or turnover/sales turnover/business turnover. After the basic classification on the basis of its type is arrived at, a society is sub-classified with reference to these factors with societies having larger working capitals/loan outstandings/investments/turnover being permitted to employ larger number of staff with higher emoluments. In other words, as the work of the society expands and its business increases, the Appendix provides for employment of larger and perhaps better equipped staff with higher emoluments for coping up with the work.
7. The primary right to classify the societies in the State into different categories, as also the right to prescribe the staff pattern and scales of pay of the employees is that of the Government. It is so laid down in the first three sub-sections of section 80. But when once the broad classification specified in section 80 has been made, it is for the particular society to decide as to the class in which it will fall. Neither the Government nor the Registrar come into the picture of classifying individual societies into any particular class specified in Appendix III. No such power is vested in them. The society falls under a particular classification once it satisfies the conditions mentioned in column 3 of Appendix III. It is for the society to decide the category in which it falls with reference to those conditions. Neither the Act nor the Rules provide for any prior approval of the Registrar or the Government before the society is classified in a particular slot. Any decision of the society that it fells in a particular class will not doubt, be open to recission by a the Registrar in exercise of his powers under Rule 176, if he is not satisfied that the working capital/outstandings/investments/turnover, as the case may be, of the society are such as to bring it within a particular class. It will always be open to him to examine whether the society in question does satisfy the conditions prescribed in Appendix III regarding its working capital, loan outstandings and the like, which as mentioned earlier, and as mentioned in my judgment in O.P No. 10078 of 1985, are the only matters made relevant in the matter of classification of a society. The resolutions passed by the societies involved in these cases that they fall in particular classes cannot therefore be branded as illegal or otherwise liable to be cancelled. I must mention here that the respondents have no case that based on their working capital, loan outstandings or the like, the societies concerned will not fall within the classes into which they wanted to be placed by the resolutions in question.
8. The next question for consideration is whether the increase in the staff strength or the payment of higher scales of pay as envisaged in Appendix III require prior approval of the Registrar. Rule 188 requires every society to adopt the staff pattern indicated in Appendix III. This is liable to be departed from only in the circumstances mentioned in the two provisos, one in the case of societies passing through a financial crisis, and the other, in respect of societies which require a different staff pattern having regard to the peculiar nature of their functions. A society is therefore bound to adopt the staff pattern prescribed in Appendix III in the normal course, rule 188 being mandatory.
9. The contention of the respondents is that having regard to Note 2 to Appendix III an increase in the staff strength requires the prior approval of the Registrar. There is no dispute that this note is to Appendix III as a whole and not merely to serial No. 8 therein. The Note has, got to be read in the light of Rule 188. This rule requires the society to adopt the staff pattern indicated in Appendix III. It does not lay down that the approval of the Registrar is required for the purpose of employing the requisite additional staff as laid down in Appendix III. This is relied on, in the forefront of the contentions raised by the petitioner. But Appendix III itself is subject to the Note that any increase in the existing staff strength has to be with the approval of the Registrar. Therefore, and even though rule 188 does not in terms lay down that the approval of the Registrar is requited, still and having regard to the terms of Note 2, the position is that when a society it upgraded and goes into a higher classification, the additional staff permitted consequent on the up gradation can be appointed only after obtaining the approval of the Registrar. This is the effect of Note 2 to Appendix III.
10. There is apparently a purpose behind this Note. It cannot be disputed that the Registrar has the right to supervise the activities of the society and to rescind any resolution passed by it under Rule 176. Cases may be postulated where a society resolves to upgrade itself, perhaps with ulterior motives, without the requisite conditions existing for the upgradation. If on such resolution, further staff is appointed, consequent on the increased staff strength admissible for a higher class, and it turns out later that the upgradation was invalid and was not justified, the newly employed staff will pose problems to the society as also to themselves. It is apparently to safeguard against any such wayward action by the societies with unjustified resolutions for upgradation, and with a view to provide an opportunity even at the threshold to ascertain whether the society was arbitrarily or illegally upgraded, that Note 2 provides for prior approval of the Registrar before increasing the staff strength.
11. The decision in Sherthallai Urban Co. Op. Bank Ltd. v. State Of Kerala, 1984 KLJ 409 which was referred to in the course of the arguments does not affect the question under consideration. In that case, the issue considered was the validity of the prohibition imposed by the Registrar, on appointments, without bis prior sanction, while recognising the upgradation of a society. This Court held the prohibition to be unauthorised. The questions arising before me are different. In fact, the effect of Note 2 was not under consideration in the Sherthallai case. That decision has therefore no relevance here.
12. The result of the discussion therefore is that while the upgradation of a society does not require the approval of the Registrar, increase in the staff stregth consequent thereon doss require his approval, and any additional staff ran be appointed only after such approval of the Registrar is obtained.
13. But this does not mean that the Registrar can refuse approval to increase the staff strength arbitrarily or unreasonably or any ground whatsoever. If the decision of the society to upgrade itself is regular and valid, the Registrar will not be entitled to refuse approval for increase in the staff strength, taking shelter under Note 2 to Appendix III. The only questions which will open to him for consideration will be whether the conditions specified in column 2 of Appendix III regarding working capital, loan outstandings etc., appropriate to the society in question are satisfied. If these conditions are satisfied, it is incumbent on a Registrar to accord approval for the increase in the staff strength. He cannot take other factors into account to refuse such approval. This is the effect of the decisions in O.P No. 10078 of 1985, O.P No. 5321 of 1990 and O.P No. 8628 of 1990. He cannot, for example, rely on the fact that the society is working at a loss as a ground for declining approval.
14. The embargo under Note 2 applies only to the increase in the staff strength; it does not apply to the payment of salary due to the employees appropriate to the upgraded category. The Note provides for approval only for increase in the staff strength, but not otherwise. Therefore, and on the upgradation of the society, the existing staff will have to be paid at the higher scales applicable to the higher classification. This is the effect of Rule 189 which prescribes the scale of pay for different categories of posts, as shown in Appendix III.
15. I shall summarise my conclusions as under:—
(a) The re-classification of a society does not require the approval of the Registrar or Government.
(b) But increase in the existing strength of the staff does require the approval of the Registrar and appointment of additional staff appropriate for the upgraded class can be made after such approval for the increase is obtained.
(c) On upgradation, the existing staff has to be paid at the scales of pay applicable to the higher class.
16. The reason stated in O.P No. 3154 of 1992 that Government was proposing to change the classification fixed as early as on 1-7-1974 is not a relevant one. Government is enabled by Rule 182 to effect such a change once in three years. But that is not a justification to refuse approval of the change in classification. The orders impugned in these cases are therefore unsustainable. They are quashed. The appropriate respondent is directed to pass orders on the question of increase in the staff-strength in the light of the observations contained herein above after adverting to the only relevant question whether the reclassification is justified on the basis of the stipulations contained in column 3 of Appendix III to the Rules. No other question will be open for consideration. Since the work of the societies has increased tremendously over the years, without any corresponding change in the staff strength, the concerned respondents are directed to pass orders regarding the staff strength of concerned societies within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
17. The original petitions are allowed as above. No costs.
Alert