- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State v. Kodakkat Pocker & Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal arises from orders of the Forest Tribunal, Palghat, in Original Applications (O.A) Nos. 889, 896, and 1102 of 1974, concerning lands claimed as private property but challenged as forest land. The applicants, comprising two brothers and the wife of one brother, claimed ownership of contiguous lands purchased by their mother under kanom rights. They asserted that the lands were cashew plantations with some fugitive cultivation. The respondents contended that the lands formed part of Anangan Mala, an extensive forest area under the M.P. P.F. Act, and maintained that natural forest growth existed with no cultivation.
The Forest Tribunal initially dismissed the applications, holding the applicants were not entitled to exemption under Sections 3(2) or 3(3) of Act 26 of 1971. On appeal, this Court set aside the Tribunal's order and remanded the case for fresh disposal with directions to allow fresh evidence. Upon remand, the Tribunal allowed the applications, holding the properties to be cashew plantations.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the lands in dispute are private cashew plantations exempt from forest classification under Act 26 of 1971.
- Whether the commissioner's report correctly identified the properties and the extent to which the Court can rely on or reject such a report under the provisions of the Civil Procedure Code (C.P.C.), specifically Order 26 Rule 9 and Rule 10(3).
Arguments of the Parties
Government Pleader's Arguments
- The commissioner did not properly identify the properties inspected, relying only on boundary descriptions provided by the applicants.
- The report was flawed and unrelated to the actual state of the disputed lands.
- At the time of inspection, no respondent representatives were present, undermining the report’s reliability.
- The petition averments were insufficient to prove the lands were cashew plantations.
- The commissioner’s failure to observe coconut trees, which the applicants claimed were present, indicated the report pertained to a different property.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Order 26 Rule 9 C.P.C | Empowers the Court to issue commissions for local inspection to gather evidence best obtained from the spot. | The Court explained the purpose of deputing a commissioner to collect evidence to clarify doubtful points on record. |
| Order 26 Rule 10(3) C.P.C | Allows the Court to make further enquiry if dissatisfied with the commissioner's proceedings, including calling for a fresh report. | The Court held that it can set aside a commission report found to be unacceptable and order another inspection to ascertain the truth. |
| Sub-Rule (3) of Order 26 Rule 10 C.P.C | Permits both trial and appellate courts to reject a commission report if it does not reflect the true state of affairs, regardless of objections filed by parties. | The Court asserted its competence to exercise this power to ensure a correct decision by ordering a fresh commission report. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court scrutinized the commissioner's report and found it deficient in properly identifying the properties in dispute. The report inconsistently described the presence and extent of cashew and coconut plantations compared to the applicants’ claims, suggesting the commissioner inspected different lands. The Court emphasized the purpose of issuing a commission under Order 26 Rule 9 C.P.C. as gathering reliable, on-spot evidence to resolve disputes. It further noted that under Order 26 Rule 10(3) C.P.C., the Court retains the authority to reject a commission report if it is found to be unreliable or inconsistent with the facts, and to order a fresh inquiry. The Court concluded that the commission report in question was casual and unacceptable, justifying its setting aside and remand for a fresh commission with clear directions to properly identify the properties using survey plans and documents.
Holding and Implications
The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the Forest Tribunal’s order and the commission report, and remanded the case for fresh disposal. The Tribunal was directed to appoint another commissioner to conduct a proper inspection and submit a fresh report based on accurate identification of the lands. After receiving the fresh report, the Tribunal must decide the Original Applications in accordance with law. There was no order as to costs.
The decision directly affects the parties by requiring a re-examination of the factual basis of the dispute through a properly conducted commission. No new legal precedent was established beyond clarifying the Court’s power under the relevant C.P.C. provisions to reject and order fresh commission reports when the original is found unreliable.
Pareed Pillay, J.:— The appeal is filed against the order of the Forest Tribunal, Palghat in O.A Nos. 889 and 1102 of 1974. The applications were allowed by the Forest Tribunal holding that the entire extent shown in the respective Original Applications are not private forest but cashew plantation coming within the exclusion under Act 26 of 1971.
2. The parties will be referred to in this judgment by their ranking before the Tribunal.
3. The applicants in O.A Nos. 889 of 1974 and 896 of 1974 are brothers. The applicant in O.A 1102 of 1974 is the wife of the applicant in O.A 889 of 1974. The lands comprised in the Original Applications lie contiguous. The extent of the lands in the Original Applications are 10 acres, 14.40 acres and 8 acres respectively. The entire extent of the land was purchased by the mother of the applicants in O.A Nos. 889 and 896 of 1974 on kanom rights. Their case is that after they obtained rights over the properties they planted cashew trees in almost the entire extent of the property and in small portions they have raised fugitive cultivation. Respondents filed counter statement contending that the lands in dispute form part of Anangan Mala which is an extensive forest area governed by the M.P P.F Act, that there is natural forest growth in the properties and that no cultivation was effected in it.
4. The Forest Tribunal by common order dated 19-8-1977 held that the applicants are not entitled to exemption either under S. 3(2) or S. 3(3) of Act 26 of 1971 and dismissed the applications. Applicants filed M.F.A Nos. 172, 173 and 174 of 1977. On 23-7-1979 this court set aside the order of the Tribunal and remanded the case for fresh disposal. There was a direction to afford opportunity to adduce fresh evidence. After remand the present Tribunal allowed the Original Applications holding that the properties in the O. As. are cashew plantations.
5. The Tribunal relied on the commission report for its finding that the properties are cashew plantations. Government Pleader submitted that the commissioner has not properly identified the property and therefore on that score alone no reliance can be placed on his report. Government Pleader also submitted that at the time when the commissioner visited the property nobody was present on the side of the respondents, and the commissioner identified the properties only with the help of its boundaries as scheduled in the Original Applications and as pointed out by the applicants. It is pointed out that the commissioner has not properly identified the properties and this has resulted in a thoroughly wrong report which has nothing to do with the real state of affairs. To substantiate the above contention Government Pleader referred to the averments in the petitions. The averments in the petitions are not sufficient to show that the properties are cashew plantations. Hence it is evident that the properties inspected by the commissioner are not she properties scheduled in the Original Applications.
6. Commissioner stated in the report that the property in O.A 839 of. 1974 is a cashew plantation. He stated that he saw in the property yielding cashew trees, which are 15 to 20 years of age. In O.A 889 of 1974 the applicant has stated that cashew trees are planted only in a portion of the property. But the commissioner has stated that the property is a cashew plantation. In O.A 896 of 1974 the commissioner stated that the property is a cashew plantation except in some rocky portion where no plantation is possible. ln the O.A what the applicant has stated is that a portion of the property is cashew plantation and the rest used for agricultural purposes. In the property scheduled in O.A 1102 of 1974 the commissioner did not see any coconut trees though it is the specific case of the applicant that it is planted with coconut trees and cashew trees. The commissioner has not mentioned the number of cashew trees in the properties and merely stated in the report that they are plantations. This would show that he prepared the report in a casual manner. The very fact that the commissioner did not see any coconut trees in the property lends considerable strength to the respondents’ contention that the commissioner visited some other property. Order 26 Rule 9 C.P.C enables the Court to issue commission for local inspection whenever it finds that it is necessary for deciding any matter in dispute. The object of deputing a commissioner for local inspect-on is to gather evidence which from its peculiar nature can best be had from the spot itself. The evidence collected and reported by the commissioner will enable the Court to properly and correctly analyse it. Commission report will be helpful to clarify or explain any point which is left doubtful in evidence on record. Order 26 Rule 10(3) C.P.C enables the Court, if for any reason it is dissatisfied with the proceedings of the ceromissicner, to make further enquiry as it shall think fit. Under the sub-rule it is always open to the Court to analyse the commission report and to call for fresh report if it is found that the report and truth are poles apart. The Court has necessarily to consider the correctness or falsity of the commission report on the basis of materials and data available before it. Merely because one of the parties did not file objection to the commission report it cannot be said that the court is powerless to deal with it in a case coming under Sub-Rule (3). Not only the trial Court, but also the appellate Court can exercise this power. In a case where the Court finds that the commission report is totally unacceptable as it is not in accordance with true state of affairs, it can always attempt to get at the truth by deputing another commissioner and its power to act under sub-rule (3) cannot be minimised or overlooked on the ground that the contesting party has not filed any objection to it. It is always the endeavour of the court to arrive at the correct decision in a given case and whenever it is found that the commission report is unacceptable for any valid reason it can legitimately exercise its power under Sub-Rule (3). It is very well within the competence of the appellate Court also to exercise in appropriate cases power under Order 26 Rule 10(3) to set aside the commission report and call for fresh report by deputing another commissioner.
7. As the evidence on record discloses that the commissioner has not correctly identified the properties in question, we hereby set aside Ext. C-I commission report and the order of the Tribunal and the case is remanded with a direction to depute another commissioner to identify the property with the survey plan and documents for submitting a fresh report before the Tribunal. After obtaining the report the” Tribunal shall dispose of the Original Applications afresh in accordance with law.
8. The order of the Tribunal in O. As. 899, 896 and 1102 of 1974 is hereby set aside and the case is remanded as aforesaid. The appeal stands allowed. There is no order as to costs.
9. Allowed.
Alert