- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kheralu Nagarik Sahakari Bank Ltd. v. State Of Gujarat
Structured Summary of the Opinion by K.S. Jhaveri, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicant is Kheralu Nagarik Sahakari Bank Ltd. (the bank), which operates a branch at Sola Road, Ahmedabad. Respondent No. 2 was the branch manager. The bank alleged that during respondent No. 2's tenure he caused financial loss by fraudulent transactions: aggregate alleged loss about Rs. 3,50,64,825/-, and in respect of the present complaint misappropriation of about Rs. 25,92,598.30 from Current Account No. 5490.
A First Information Report (FIR) was lodged on 21 October 2003 at Ghatlodia Police Station (C.R. No. 362 of 2003) alleging offences under Sections 406, 420, 114 and 120B IPC, and naming respondent No. 2 as an accused. The FIR alleged that the branch manager misused his position to permit unauthorized withdrawals (honouring cheques/withdrawal slips despite insufficient balances).
Respondent No. 2 applied for anticipatory bail before the sessions court (rejected) and then before the High Court (application withdrawn on 12 May 2004). He was not arrested immediately. The bank filed Special Criminal Application No. 74 of 2005 requesting police to arrest the accused; this Court directed consideration of Sections 82 and 83 Cr.P.C. to declare respondent No. 2 an absconder. After further delay and representations, respondent No. 2 was arrested on 24 August 2005.
Respondent No. 2 sought regular bail before the District and Sessions Court at Ahmedabad (Rural). By order dated 13 September 2005 (the opinion mentions both 13 and 16 September 2005 as the order/dates under challenge), the sessions court granted bail. The bank filed the present criminal miscellaneous application in this High Court seeking quashing of that order and cancellation of bail.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the order dated 16th September 2005 (order of the Sessions Court granting bail to respondent No. 2) should be quashed and the bail granted to respondent No. 2 cancelled.
- Whether the High Court should intervene under its powers (including Section 439(2) and Section 482 contexts cited in the opinion) to recall bail granted by the Sessions Court where the grounds for bail are alleged to be erroneous.
- Whether the applicant bank, a private party (but the aggrieved party), is maintainable to move the High Court for cancellation of bail (i.e., maintainability of the bank's petition to cancel bail).
- Whether the grounds relied upon by the Sessions Court (charge sheet already filed; parity with co-accused granted bail; documents in police custody) were valid and sufficient to justify grant of bail in light of the accused's alleged evasion of arrest and prima facie evidence.
- Whether supervening circumstances exist (or whether the bail was granted illegally or on erroneous grounds) so as to warrant recall/cancellation of bail.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant / Bank (represented by Mr. P. K. Jani)
- The Sessions Judge erred in releasing respondent No. 2 on bail despite his grave involvement in serious financial irregularities.
- The respondent had been absconding for almost two years and only arrested after this Court ordered action; his conduct showed a propensity to evade law and thus bail should not have been granted.
- The respondent was shown as absconding in the charge sheet; he was not arrested till the date of the charge sheet.
- The Sessions Court improperly relied on parity with accused No. 4 (Kamlesh P. Shah); the earlier bail to Kamlesh Shah was on the basis that the password for permitting overdrafts was held by the branch manager (i.e., respondent No. 2), which undermines a parity argument in favour of respondent No. 2.
- Earlier anticipatory bail had been rejected; withdrawal of HC anticipatory bail application and the prior rejections meant there was no change of circumstances to justify regular bail.
- Multiple criminal complaints are pending against respondent No. 2; previous breaches of bail conditions by respondent show unfitness for bail.
- Relied upon apex court and High Court decisions (to be discussed) to support cancellation of bail.
State (represented by Mr. H. L. Jani)
- Supported the bank's contentions; emphasized that irregularities could not have occurred without the branch manager's knowledge and that credible evidence against respondent No. 2 was overlooked by the Sessions Court.
Respondent No. 2 (represented by Mr. P. M. Thakkar)
- Preliminary objection: the application was filed by the bank (private party) and not the State; hence it is not maintainable and should be rejected.
- Substantive defense: prima facie no case against respondent No. 2; withdrawals were by others (accused Nos. 2 and 3) using TOD facilities; respondent No. 2 did not sign the cheques for clearance/payments and accused No. 4 (Kamlesh Shah) had handled certain clearances.
- Audit reports (2000–2003) showed TOD amounts were reported to head office and no objections were raised by the bank management; the TOD facility had extension/consent involving directors (accused No. 2 related to a director), and accused No. 2 had admitted liability in writing to the bank manager without prompting a criminal complaint earlier.
- Allegation that FIR was filed after three years to falsely implicate respondent No. 2 so that bank management could shirk responsibility.
- Parity: accused No. 4 was released on bail by this Court; therefore by parity respondent No. 2 should not be deprived of bail.
- Relied on precedents (Dolat Ram; Subbendu Mishra; M.C. Abraham; Nityanand Rai; Ramcharan; and an earlier High Court decision) to argue that cancellation of bail should not be mechanical and requires supervening circumstances.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court in This Opinion |
|---|---|---|
| Dolat Ram and others v. State of Haryana, 1995 (1) SCC 349 | That bail once granted should not be cancelled mechanically without considering whether supervening circumstances render continued bail unconducive to a fair trial. | Noted as relied upon by respondent's counsel to argue against mechanical cancellation; the Court recorded this reliance but considered other facts and authorities to justify cancellation in the present case. |
| Subbendu Mishra v. Subrat Kumar Mishra, AIR 1999 SC 3026 [2000 SCC (Cri.) 1508] | Distinction between factors relevant for rejecting bail initially and for cancelling bail once granted; cancellation in a mechanical manner is unsustainable. | Recorded as relied upon by respondent; the Court acknowledged the principle but proceeded to assess that supervening circumstances and other factors justified cancellation here. |
| M. C. Abraham v. State of Maharashtra, (2003) 2 SCC 649 | Discretions (including bail decisions) should not be exercised mechanically but cautiously; rejection of anticipatory bail alone is not ground for immediate arrest. | Relied upon by respondent's counsel. The Court noted the principle of caution but found the Sessions Court had erred on material grounds (evasion, prima facie case), supporting cancellation. |
| Nityanand Rai v. State of Bihar, AIR 2005 SC 2239 [2005 (4) SCC 178] | Allegation of past abscondence or mere likelihood of abscondence is not, by itself, sustainable ground for cancellation of bail. | Relied upon by respondent. The Court considered it but concluded that the facts here (long evasion, showing as absconder in charge sheet, risk of tampering, prima facie case) distinguish the present situation. |
| Ramcharan v. State of M.P., (2006) 1 SCC (Cri.) 511 | Different considerations apply for cancellation of bail and for grant of bail; absent supervening circumstances, High Court should not cancel bail merely because the order was passed on misapprehension. | Relied upon by respondent. The Court noted the principle but found supervening circumstances and errors in the Sessions Court's reasoning sufficient to warrant cancellation here. |
| Criminal Misc. Application No. 1662 of 2000 (High Court, order dated 10 July 2000 — unreported) | An instance where application for cancellation of bail was rejected (used by respondent to support non-cancellation approach). | Defence relied upon the earlier unreported decision. The Court observed that this decision did not assist respondent in view of subsequent authorities and the facts of the present case. |
| State v. Jaspal Singh Gill, AIR 1984 SC 1503 [1984 (3) SCC 555] | Before granting bail in non-bailable offences (trial not yet commenced), court must consider nature/seriousness of offence, character of evidence, peculiar circumstances of accused, possibility of absconding, risk of witness tampering, and public interest. | The Court relied on this authority to emphasize that, given respondent's evasion and prima facie case, there was a real possibility of non-appearance and tampering, supporting cancellation. |
| Hahzad Hasan Khan v. Ishtiaq Hasan Khan, AIR 1987 SC 1613 | If an accused named in the FIR is absconding after the incident but surrenders after a short interval, bail granted upon surrender can be set aside (where abscondence present prior to surrender). | The Court compared the present long period of evasion (about 1 year 9 months) with this principle to reinforce the view that extended evasion justified cancellation. |
| State of Maharashtra v. Ramesh Taurani, AIR 1998 SC 586 [1998 (1) SCC 41] | If a prima facie case is made out against the accused, granting bail pending investigation is not proper. | The Court applied this principle, finding a prima facie case against respondent No. 2 and concluding that the Sessions Court should not have granted bail. |
| State through CBI v. Amarmani Tripathi, AIR 2005 SC 3490 [2005 (8) SCC 21] | In appeals against grant of bail, post‑bail conduct and supervening circumstances must be considered; bail granted illegally or improperly can be cancelled even without new facts. | The Court cited this authority to support the proposition that bail improperly granted can be cancelled; applied to conclude cancellation was appropriate here. |
| Jayesh G. Ramani v. State of Gujarat, 2004 (3) GLH 270 | Second anticipatory bail rejected where the accused was not traceable and was found absconding, and did not present himself for interrogation. | Referred to as a comparable instance where abscondence warranted denial of bail; the Court cited it in support of its assessment of the respondent's conduct. |
| R. Rathinam v. State, AIR 2000 SC 1851 (= 2002 (2) SCC 391) | The High Court's power to cancel bail can be invoked by the State or any aggrieved party (including members of the public with concern), and it is improper to refuse such petitions as not maintainable. | Relied upon to reject respondent's preliminary objection that the bank could not maintain the application; the Court accepted that an aggrieved private party may move the High Court to cancel bail. |
| Delhi Administration v. Sanjay Gandhi, AIR 1978 SC 961 [1978 (2) SCC 411] | The relevant test for cancellation: whether the material would lead to a conclusion of a strong prima facie case that, if at large, the accused would tamper with prosecution witnesses and impede justice. | Applied as a test: the Court found prima facie evidence and a risk of witness tampering plus evasion, and thus concluded cancellation was appropriate. |
| Puran v. Rambilas, AIR 2001 SC 2023 [2001 (3) SCC 685] | High Court should give cogent reasons when cancelling bail; cancellation should not be a mere mechanical exercise and the HC may briefly indicate the evidence and grounds for cancellation. | Cited by the Court to show that reasons must be given; the Court set out factual and legal reasons for cancellation in the opinion consistent with this requirement. |
| Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Admn), AIR 1978 SC 179 | Distinction between setting aside an unjustified order and canceling bail on new facts; explains procedures/approaches available to State or HC to challenge a sessions court bail order. | Referred to support the proposition that High Court can intervene where there are no new circumstances and the Sessions Court erred; used to frame the High Court's power to quash erroneous bail orders. |
| State v. Mohmadhusain A. Meman, 1997 (1) GLR 74 | High Court can interfere with an order granting bail if it disregards Supreme Court principles. | Mentioned to indicate that prior High Court reasoning relied upon by respondent would not assist because the High Court has power to interfere when SC principles are disregarded. |
| State v. Lalji Popat, 1988 (2) GLR 1073 | Applying Supreme Court tests, High Court has jurisdiction under Section 439(2) or Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash or set aside arbitrary or illegal orders passed by subordinate courts. | Cited to support the High Court's jurisdiction to quash the Sessions Court bail order when it is arbitrary or ignores relevant factors. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court undertook a step-by-step analysis of facts, the Sessions Court's reasons, and applicable legal principles as follows:
- Factual findings: The Court reiterated that (a) FIR was lodged on 21 October 2003; (b) the charge sheet was filed on 23 August 2004; (c) respondent No. 2 was shown as absconding in the charge sheet and was not arrested until 24 August 2005; and (d) alleged misappropriation in the present complaint amounted to Rs. 25,92,498.30 while total misappropriation alleged was Rs. 3,50,64,825/-, involving public money.
-
Evaluation of the Sessions Court's grounds: The Sessions Court relied primarily on (i) that a charge sheet had been filed; (ii) parity with accused No. 4 (Kamlesh P. Shah) who had earlier been granted bail; and (iii) the fact that documents were in police custody and the investigation was over for those arrested. The High Court found each of these grounds erroneous or misapplied:
- The charge sheet had been filed before respondent's arrest and showed him as absconding — therefore filing of charge sheet did not negate the fact that respondent had evaded investigation or arrest.
- Parity was misplaced: Kamlesh Shah's bail had been allowed by this Court on the basis that the "password" for permitting overdrafts was with the branch manager (i.e., respondent No. 2), which actually implicated respondent No. 2 rather than justifying parity in favour of respondent No. 2.
- Although investigation was complete as to arrested accused, investigation vis-à-vis respondent No. 2 was incomplete because he had been avoiding the process of law.
- Earlier rejections of anticipatory bail by sessions court and withdrawal of HC anticipatory application were material and not counterbalanced by any change of circumstances to justify regular bail.
- Assessment of respondent's conduct and prima facie case: The Court accepted that there was prima facie evidence implicating respondent No. 2 (statements indicating he had the password and allowed withdrawals despite insufficient balances; corroboration by employees). The respondent had evaded arrest from 21.10.2003 until 24.8.2005, which the Court considered significant in assessing likelihood of non‑appearance and risk of witness tampering.
- Precedent analysis and legal framework: The Court reviewed numerous Supreme Court and High Court precedents. It applied settled tests (e.g., Jaspal Singh Gill; Delhi Administration v. Sanjay Gandhi) requiring consideration of seriousness, character of evidence, risk of abscondence, and witness tampering before granting bail in non-bailable offences where trial has not commenced. The Court also relied on authorities (e.g., Ramesh Taurani; Amarmani Tripathi) to conclude that where a prima facie case exists and bail was granted improperly, cancellation is justified; and R. Rathinam to rule the bank's petition maintainable.
- Policy/contextual consideration: The Court noted recent widespread scams in cooperative banks, their severe public consequences, and the special responsibility of directors/managers as custodians of public money — all of which counsel against a liberal approach to bail in such serious financial irregularity cases.
- Conclusion of analysis: On the record the Sessions Court's exercise of discretion in granting bail was found to be unjust and erroneous because it relied on grounds not substantiated by the record, and because supervening circumstances (extended evasion, prima facie case, risk of tampering, public interest) warranted recalling the bail order.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The High Court allowed the criminal miscellaneous application. The order dated 16th September 2005 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court No. 2, Ahmedabad (Rural) in Criminal Misc. Application No. 715 of 2005 is quashed and set aside, and the bail granted to respondent No. 2 is hereby cancelled.
Direct consequences and directions:
- The respondent No. 2 is ordered to surrender before the authorities on or before 4th May 2005 (as stated in the operative paragraph of the opinion).
- Rule is made absolute accordingly (i.e., the High Court's rule nisi is made absolute by quashing the sessions court order and cancelling bail).
Implications beyond the parties: The Court applied and reiterated settled principles from Supreme Court and High Court authorities about (a) the careful exercise of discretion in bail matters, (b) the relevance of prima facie evidence, evasion and risk of tampering, and (c) the High Court's jurisdiction to quash orders of subordinate courts when bail is granted on erroneous or arbitrary grounds. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle but applies established authorities to the facts before it.
Notes on Sources and Limitations
This summary is strictly confined to statements, facts, citations and reasoning contained in the provided opinion. No information beyond the text of the opinion has been added or inferred.
K.S.Jhaveri, J.:-
(1) By way of this criminal misc. Application, the applicant - the original complainant the kheralu nagarik sahakari bank limited (hereinafter referred to as the bank or the applicant) , has prayed for quashing the order dated 16th september 2005, passed by the additional sessions judge and presiding officer, fast track court no. 2, ahmedabad (rural) in criminal misc. Application no. 715 of 2005 and to cancel the bail granted to the accused, the respondent no. 2 herein (hereinafter referred to as respondent no. 2 or branch manager).
(2) Before considering the merits of the matter, it would be necessary to set out the short facts of the case which are as under:
1]. The applicant bank is a cooperative bank having its one of the branches at sola road area of ahmedabad. The respondent no. 2 herein was the branch manager of the applicant bank. As per the applicant, during the tenure of the respondent no. 2 as branch manager, he has caused financial loss to the applicant bank to the extent of rs. 3,50,64,825/ - by way of fraudulent transactions. As regards the present complaint is concerned, the amount of misappropriation is about rs. 25,92,598. 30 from one current account no. 5490.
2]. In connection with the said alleged irregularities a first information report was lodged 21. 10. 2003 at ghatlodia police station, which came to be registered as c. R. No. 362 of 2003 for the alleged commission of offences punishable under sections 406, 420, 114 and 120b of indian penal code. In the said fir the respondent no. 2 was shown as accused no. L. According to the fir, the modus operand! adopted by the respondent no. 2 was that though a particular account holder does not have sufficient balance in his account and no cash credit limit or loan facility is granted, the respondent no. 2, who was holding the post of branch manager at the relevant time, by misusing his position, allowed the cheques to be honoured and withdrawal slips drawn by such account holder for payment and therefore permitted unauthorized withdrawal causing loss to the bank.
3]. The fir came to be lodged on 21st october 2003. The respondent no. 2 thereafter filed an application for anticipatory bail before the sessions court which came to be rejected. Subsequently the respondent no. 2 approached this court praying for anticipatory bail which came to be withdrawn on 12. 5. 2004. In spite of this, the respondent no. 2 was not arrested.
(3) The applicant bank therefore filed special criminal application no. 74 of 2005 before this court for a direction to the concerned police officer to take steps for arresting the accused. The said petition came to be disposed of by directing the authorities to take steps for the purpose of taking action under sections 82 and 83 of cr. P. C for declaring the respondent no. 2 as accused absconding. However, it appears that even thereafter no arrest was made for quite some time.
1]. The applicant made representation on 1. 8. 2005 to various authorities including the chief minister, home secretary, director general of police, etc. On 24th august 2005 the respondent no. 2 came to be arrested. The respondent no. 2 filed an application for regular bail before the district and sessions court at ahmedabad (rural). The sessions court passed order dated 19. 9. 2005 granting bail to the respondent no. 2. The applicant bank has therefore filed the present application praying to cancel the said order of bail.
(4) Heard mr. P. K. Jani for the applicant, mr. H. L. Jani for the respondent no. L state and mr. P. M. Thakkar, senior advocate, with mr. D. M. Thakkar and mr. V. K. Joshi for the respondent no. 2.
1]. Mr. P. K. Jani submitted that the sessions judge has committed an error in releasing the respondent no. 2 on bail without considering his grave involvement in serious financial irregularities.
2]. He submitted that from the record it is evident that the respondent no. 2 was absconding for quite some time and it is only after an order was passed by this court that the respondent no. 2 came to be arrested after a period of almost two years. He therefore submitted that looking to the conduct of the respondent no. 2 the sessions judge ought not to have enlarged the respondent no. 2 on bail.
3]. Mr. Jani submitted that till the date of charge sheet the respondent no. 2 was not arrested and the respondent no. 2 was shown to be absconding in the charge sheet.
4]. He has further submitted that the sessions judge has erroneously considered parity in respect of accused no. 4 kamlesh p. Shah inasmuch as this court, while granting bail to the said accused no. 2 found that the "password" for permitting the overdrafts in excess of the balance of an accountholder was with the branch manager i. E. The present respondent no. 2.
5]. Mr. Jani submitted that the sessions court had earlier rejected the anticipatory bail. Thereafter the anticipatory bail application filed by the respondent no. 2 before this court which was withdrawn and thereafter he was arrested. He, therefore, submitted that under these circumstances the sessions court ought not to have granted bail to him.
6]. He submitted that looking to the serious financial irregularity and the conduct of the respondent no. 2 the sessions judge should not have granted bail to the respondent no. 2.
7]. Mr. Jani submitted that many criminal complaints are pending against the present respondent and therefore, it would not be advisable to release the respondent no. 2 on bail.
8]. It is contended that in a similar case the respondent no. 2 was granted bail by the sessions court on certain conditions. However, he committed breach of the conditions as a result of which the respondent was re - arrested.
9]. Mr. Jani has also relied upon certain decisions of the apex court and this court, which will be discussed hereinafter.
(5) Mr. H. L. Jani appearing for the state has supported the contentions raised on behalf of the applicant bank. He submitted that the respondent no. 2 being the branch manager of the bank, without his knowledge the alleged irregularities could not have taken place. He submitted that admittedly the cash is withdrawn by the respondent no. 2 in the name of original accused no. 2 who is the peon of the bank. According to him, there is credible evidence against the respondent no. 2 which was overlooked by the sessions court and therefore the bail granted to the respondent no. 2 deserves to be cancelled.
(6) Mr. P. M. Thakkar, learned senior counsel, appearing for the accused - respondent no. 2 raised a preliminary objection to the effect that this application is not filed by the state, but by the applicant bank and therefore it deserves to be rejected.
1]. Mr. Thakkar submitted that prima facie no case is made out against the respondent no. 2. According to him, the temporary over draft (tod) facility was availed of by the original accused nos. 2 and 3 on different dates by drawing cheques in favour of different parties and some cheques drawn in favour of self of different amounts.
2]. He submitted that all the withdrawals by self drawn cheques were passed and cleared by accused no. 4 kamlesh shah for payments to accused nos. 2 and 3 and the respondent no. 2 has not signed any such cheques for clearance and payment to accused nos. 2 and 3.
3]. Mr. Thakkar submitted that the audit of accounts of the bank was made every year between 2000 and 2003 and in all audit reports the amounts of tod in favour of accused nos. 2 and 3 were shown to the head office bank management. According to him no objections were raised by the bank management and since accused no. 2 is brother - in - law of the then director shri nandlal babulal bhavsar, with the consent and knowledge of the board of directors, the tod facility was extended and continued from time to time between 2002 and 2003. According to him, the accused no. 2 admitted in writing executed on stamp paper submitted before the bank manager, about his liability of the tod amounts mentioned in the fir and the bank manager did not file any complaint.
4]. Mr. Thakkar further submitted that the fir has been filed after three years by the bank management by falsely implicating the respondent no. 2 to shirk from their responsibility in favouring and protecting the accused no. 2.
5]. According to mr. Thakkar, the accused no. 4 kamlesh p. Shah was released on bail by this hon'ble court and therefore even on parity the present application may not be entertained.
6]. Mr. Thakkar submitted that while considering the case for cancellation of bail, the court has to consider whether the grounds which are considered by the sessions court are valid or not. He submitted that this court is required to consider that this is not a crime where the applicant is involved and that the original accused nos. 2 and 3 are relatives of the director of the applicant bank and the respondent no. 2 being an employee of the applicant bank, he was required to follow the instructions of the director. He, therefore, submitted that this is not a fit case where this court should interfere in the matter of cancellation of bail.
(7) Mr. Thakkar, in support of his submissions, relied upon a decision in the case of dolat ram and others v/s. State of haryana, reported in 1995 (1) scc 349 (= 1995 scc (cri) 237: 1994 (9) scale 1119: 1995 (1) jt 127) wherein it is held that bail once granted should not be cancelled in a mechanical manner without considering whether any supervening circumstances have rendered it no longer conducive to a fair trial to allow the accused to retain his freedom by enjoying the concession of bail during the trial.
1]. He relied upon a decision in the case of subbendu mishra v/s. Subrat kumar mishra, reported in air 1999 sc 3026 [2000 scc (cri.) 1508]. In the said case the apex court held that high court overlooked distinction of factors relevant for rejecting bail at initial stage and canceling bail once granted and therefore cancellation of bail done in mechanical manner is not sustainable.
2]. Mr. Thakkar has next relied upon decision in the case of m. C. Abraham v/s. State op maharashtra, reportedj (2003) 2 scc 649 (2003 (1) supreme 126: 2002 (10) jt 482: 2002 (9) scale 769: 2003 scc (cri.) 628) wherein it is held that discretions should not be exercised mechanically, but should be exercised cautiously and with circumspection having regard to the nature of the offence alleged and the type of person accused of having committed a cognizable offence. It was further held in the said decision that merely because rejection of anticipatory bail applications would not be a ground for directing immediate arrest of accused.
3]. Mr. Thakkar, has relied upon a decision in the case of nityanand rai vi s. State of bihar and another, reported in air 2005 sc 2239 [= (2005) 4 scc 178: 2005 cr. L. J. 2187: 2005 scc (cri.) 1159:], wherein it is held that allegation as to abscondence of the accused in the past or the likelihood of the same in future is not sustainable for cancellation of bail.
4]. He has next relied upon a decision in the case of ramcharan v/s. State of m. P. Reported in (2006) 1 scc (cri.) 511, wherein it is held that different considerations have to be weighed while dealing with applications for cancellation or bail and for grant of bail respectively and that in absence of any supervening circumstances which might warrant recalling of the order which granted bail, suo motu cancellation of bail by the high court merely on the ground that the bail order was passed on some misapprehension of factual position is not sustainable.
5]. He has also relied upon a decision of this court passed in criminal misc. Application no. 1662 of 2000 dated 10 july. 2000 whereby the said application for cancellation of bail has been rejected.
(8) At this stage it would be relevant to note the grounds weighed with the sessions judge for granting bail to the respondent no. 2. One of the grounds was that the original accused no. 4 namely kamlesh shah was granted bail by this court by order dated 13th august 2004 passed in criminal misc. Application no. 6534/2004.
1]. The other ground was that the charge sheet was filed and that there was no question of further investigation. 2]. The sessions judge has also considered the fact that earlier no bail application was preferred by the respondent no. 2 and that all the documents were in the custody of the police.
(9) It is a well settled law that the court before granting bail in cases involving non - bailable offences, particularly where the trial has not yet commenced should take into consideration various matters such as the nature and seriousness of the offence, the character of the evidence, circumstances which are peculiar to the accused, a reasonable possibility of the presence of the accused not being secured at the trial, reasonable apprehension of witnesses being tampered with, the larger interests of the public or the state and similar other consideration. It is also a settled law that if a prima facie case is made out against the accused, order granting bail to him pending investigation is not proper. Hence it is required to be seen whether the sessions court has exercised the discretion properly or not and whether sufficient grounds are available for cancellation of bail or not.
1]. The respondent no. 2 is charged with committing fraud and misappropriation of funds in respect of the present complaint is to the extent of rs. 25,92,498. 30 (rupees twentyfive lacs ninetytwo thousand four hundred ninety - eight and thirty paise only). However, the total misappropriation is to the extent of rs. 3,50. ,64,825/ - (rupees three crores fifty lacs sixty - four thousand eight hundred twenty five only) , and the amount is public money. The fir was lodged on 21st october 2003. The respondent no. 2 has filed anticipatory bail application on 12th may 2004, which was rejected by the sessions court. On 21st july 2004 he filed anticipatory bail application before the high court which came to be withdrawn. However, till march 2005 the respondent no. 2 was not arrested in connection with the fir even though he was the accused no. 1 in the complaint.
2]. The applicant bank therefore filed special criminal application no. 74 of 2005 before this court praying to direct the concerned officer to initiate steps for arresting the respondent no. 2 along with other accused and to initiate proceedings in accordance with law. In the said petition on 16th march 2005 this court passed an order directing that the investigating agency shall start appropriate steps for the purpose of taking action under sections 82 and 83 for declaring the respondent no. 2 as accused absconding.
3]. It appears that even then the arrest was not made. Thereupon representation was made to chief minister, home secretary, director general of police and others on 1st august 2005. Thereafter on 24th august 2005 the respondent no. 2 came to be arrested. Within a period of one week i. E. On 1st september 2005 he moved an application for regular bail before the sessions court and by order dated 13th september 2005 he was enlarged on bail. It is therefore required to be noted that the offence was registered in the year 2003 and the respondent no. 2 was arrested only in august 2005 i. E. After a period of almost two years. From the aforesaid facts it is apparent that the respondent no. 2 was avoiding the process of law and the arrest.
(10) In light of the above facts the grounds weighed with the sessions court are required to be analysed. The sessions court held that the charge sheet has already been filed and therefore it is a ground for grant of bail. However, it appears that the sessions court lost sight of the fact that the charge sheet was submitted on 23rd august 2004 i. E. Even before the arrest of the respondent no. 2. Further, the respondent no. 2 was shown as absconding. I am therefore of the view that the sessions court fell into an error in taking such a ground for releasing the respondent no. 2 on bail.
1]. The second ground for grant of bail was that the original accused no. 4 kamlesh p. Shah had been granted regular bail and therefore the respondent no. 2 is also required to be released oh bail. In this connection it is required to be noted that the said kamlesh p. Shah had preferred criminal misc. Application no. 6534 of 2004 before this court and the order dated 13th august 2004 in the said application is available for perusal of this court. In the said order this court observed as under: "2 (ii) the statement of witness - bhavanbhai parbat patel dated 2nd june 2004 reveals that only the branch manager had the pass word for permitting the overdrafts in excess of the balance in the account. The cheques collected indicate that the endorsement is of signature verified and pay cash". Thus, the order passed by this court clearly indicates that the said original accused kamlesh p. Shah was released on bail because this court had found that "password" for permitting the over - drafts in excess of the balance of an account holder was with the branch manager i. E. The present respondent no. 2. Thus, in fact it is on the ground that the respondent no. 2 is responsible for such irregularity, the said kamlesh p. Shah has been released on bail. Therefore, the sessions court has committed an error in granting bail on the alleged ground of parity which is not emerging from the record.
2]. Another observation made by the sessions court is that the investigation is already over. From the papers it is found that the investigation with respect to those accused who were arrested was over and the charge sheet was also filed on 23rd august 2004 with respect to those accused, showing the present respondent no. 2 accused as absconding. In fact the respondent no. 2 was not available for investigation at all. Therefore, while granting bail the said fact has been erroneously considered in favour of the respondent no. 2.
3]. It is required to be noted that the respondent no. 2 had preferred anticipatory bail application before the sessions court which was rejected. Thereafter the respondent no. 2 approached this court praying for anticipatory bail which was withdrawn. Thereafter, after arrest of the respondent no. 2. , he moved an application for regular bail before the sessions court. The sessions court, without considering the fact that earlier applications for anticipatory bail were not granted, by sessions court and high court, allowed the application and granted bail. When the anticipatory bail was not granted earlier, there was no change in the circumstance* to grant regular bail.
4]. Another aspect of the matter is that the charge sheet was submitted on 23rd august 2004 before the arrest of the respondent no. 2. There are consistent statements on record that the respondent no. 2 was having the password and was allowing withdrawal on his own volition without there being sufficient balance in the account. Thus, there is prima facie evidence that the respondent no. 2 is connected with the alleged offence.
5]. It was further pointed out that the respondent was arrested in respect of another case being m. Case no. 9 of 2002 and he was granted regular bail by the sessions court on certain conditions. However, the respondent no. 2 has committed breach of the conditions, as a result of which warrant for his arrest was issued and he was rearrested.
6]. The summary of the aforesaid discussion is that, the accused was in a controlling position i. E. Branch manager of the bank; he was the only person knowing the password: he allowed many account holders to withdraw amounts even though there was no sufficient amount in their accounts; the act of the respondent no. 2 has been corroborated by the statement of the employees; the respondent no. 2 tried to evade arrest from the date of filing fir i. E. 21. 10. 2003 till 24. 8. 2005: he was arrested only when the proceedings for declaring him to be an absconder were initiated and that because of his alleged act the bank has suffered a huge loss. It is required to be noted that the respondent no. 2 is custodian and/or trustee of the bank and therefore, he should have acted to safeguard the interest of the bank. On perusal of the record it is clear that the contention that the withdrawal is by the relatives of the director is only an excuse. From the above facts, it is evident that the grounds stated for releasing the applicant were not sustainable at all.
(11) In the case of state v/s. Jaspal singh gill, reported in air 1984 sc 1503: 1984 (3) scc 555: 1984 (3) scr 993: 1984cr. Lj 1211 : 1984 scc (cri.) 444: 1984 (1) scale 990], the apex court held that the court before granting bail in case involving non - bailable offences particularly where the trial has not yet commenced should take into consideration various matters such as the nature of seriousness of the offence, the character of the evidence, circumstances which are peculiar to the accused, a reasonable possibility of the presence of the accused not being secured at the trial, reasonable apprehension of witnesses being tampered with, the larger interests of the public of the state and similar other consideration. Considering the facts narrated hereinabove, especially in view of the fact that the respondent no. 2 was evading the arrest, it cannot be ruled out that there is a possibility of the respondent not being secured at the trial and his tampering with the witnesses.
1]. In th cm of hahzad hasan khan v/s. Ishtiaq hasan khan and, another, reported in air 1987 sc 1613 [= 1987 (2) sco 684 : 1987 (3) scr 34 : 1987 (2) glh 183 : 1987 (2) jt 323 1987 scc (cri.) 415 1987 cr. Lj. 1872: 1987 (1) scale 1249], the apex court held that if the accused named in fir is absconding after the incident, but surrendering after a month, order granting bail was liable to be set aside. In the present case, it is apparent that the applicant was evading his arrest for more than 1 year nine months and it is only on order of this court for initiating proceedings for declaring him as an absconder, he was arrested.
2]. In the case of state of maharashtra v/s. Ramesh taurani, reported in air 1998 sc 586 (1998 (1) scc 41: 1998 cri. L. J. 855: 1997 (9) jt 304:1997 (7) scale 168: 1998 scc (cri.) 257], the apex court held that if there is a prima facie case made out against the accused, order granting bail to him pending investigation is not proper. On the facts of the present case, there is certainly a prima facie case against the respondent no. 2 and therefore, considering the gravity of the offence the sessions court ought not to have granted bail to him.
3]. In the case of state through cbi v/s. Amarmani tripathi, reported in air 2005 sc 3490 [= 2005 (8) scc 21: 2005 sco (cri.) 1960: 2005 cri. Lj 4149] the apex court held that while considering and deciding appeals against grant of bail, where the accused has been at large for a considerable time, the post - bail conduct and supervening circumstances will also have to be taken note of. If bail has been granted illegally or improperly and if the discretion is exercised erroneously, the bail granted is liable to be cancelled even if there is absence of supervening circumstances.
4]. In the case of jayesh g. Ramani v/s. State of gujarat, reported in 2004 (3) glh 270, the second anticipatory bail application has been rejected on the ground that the accused was not traceable and was found absconding and even during the course of hearing of the application the accused has not presented himself for interrogation by the police.
(12) The preliminary contention raised by the learned counsel for the applicant is devoid of any merits in view of the observation of the apex court in the case of r. Rathinam v/s. State, reported in air 2000 sc 1851 (=2002 (2) scc 391: 2000 scc (cri.) 958: 2000 (1) crime 211: 2000 (1) jt 604: 2000 (1) scale 458: 2000 (1) supreme 431) para 8 of the said decision reads as under:
8. It is not disputed before us that the power so vested in the high court can be invoked either by the state or by any aggrieved party. Nor is it disputed that the said power can be exercised suo motu by the high court. If so, any members of the public, whether he belongs to any particular profession or otherwise, who has a concern in the matter can move the high court to remind it of the need to invoke the said power suo motu. There is no barrier either in section 439 the code or in any other law which inhibits a person from moving the high court to have such powers exercised suo motu. If the high court considers that there is no need to cancel the bail for the reasons stated in such petition, after making such considerations it is open for the high court to dismiss the petition. If that is the position, it is also open to the high court to cancel the bail if the high court feels that the reasons stated in the petition are sufficient enough for doing so. It is, therefore, improper to refuse to look into the matter on the premise that such a petition is not maintainable in law.
In view of the above decision, the preliminary contention raised by the learned advocate for the respondent no. 2 cannot be accepted.
1]. In the case of delhi administration v/s. Sanjay gandhi, reported in air 1978 sc 961 [1978 (2) scc 411: 1978 cri. Lj 952: 1978 scc (cr.) 223: 1978 (3) scr 9501. In. Para 25 it is held as under: "25. The power to cancel bail was exercised by the bombay high court in madhukar purshottam mondkar v/s. Talab haji hussain, 60 bom lr 465: (air 1958 bom 406) where the accused was charged with a bailable offence. The test adopted by that court was whether the material placed before the court was "such as to lead to the conclusion that there is a strong prima facie case that if the accused were to be allowed to be at large he would tamper with the prosecution witnesses and impede the course of justice". An appeal preferred by the accused against the judgement of the bombay high court was dismissed by this court. In gurcharan singh v/s. State (delhi administration) , 1978 cri lj 129 at p. 137 : (air 1978 sc 179 at p. 187) while confirming the order of the high court cancelling the bail of the accused, this court observed that the only question which the court had to consider at that stage was whether "there was prima facie case made out, as alleged, on the statements of the witnesses and on other materials", that "there was a likelihood of the appellants tempering with the prosecution witnesses". It is by the application of this test that we have come to the conclusion that the respondent's bail ought to be cancelled. " in the present case a prima facie case has been made out against the respondent no. 2. Other complaints are pending investigation. The grounds on which the sessions court relied upon are erroneous. The respondent no. 2 was evading his arrest. Therefore this is a fit case to cancel the bail granted to the respondent no. 2.
2]. In the case of puran v/s. Rambilas, reported in air 2001 sc 2023 [=2001 (6) sco 338: 2001 (5) jt 226: 2001 (3) scale 695: 2001 (3) supreme 685:2001 scc (cri.) 1124: 2001 (3) scr 432] in paragraphs 8 and 10 the apex court held as under:
"8. Mr. Lalit next submitted that the high court has itself not given reasons but has mechanically set aside the order of the bail. We see no substance in this submission. The high court has correctly not gone into the merits or demerits of the matter. The high court has noted that evidence prima facie indicated demand of dowry. The high court has briefly indicated the evidence on record and what was found at the scene of the offence. The high court has indicated that evidence prima facie indicated that a demand for rs. 1 lac was made just a month prior to the incident in question. The high court has stated that the material on record suggested that the offences under sections 498 - a and 304 - a were prima facie disclosed. The high court has concluded that the material on record, the nature of injuries, demand for rs. L lac and the other circumstances were such that this was not a fit case granting bail. Thus, the high court has given every cogent reasons why bail should not have been granted and why this unjustified erroneous order granting bail should be cancelled."
10. Further, it is to be kept in mind that the concept of setting aside the unjustified, illegal or perverse order is totally different from the concept of cancelling the bail on the ground that accused has misconducted himself or because of some new facts requiring such cancellation. This position is made clear by this court in gurucharan singh v/s. State (delhi admn) , reported in air 1978 sc 179: (1978 cri lj 129). In that case the court observed as under (para 16) :
"if, however, a court of sessions had admitted an accused person to bail, the state has two options. It may move the sessions judge if certain new circumstances have arise which were not earlier known to the state and necessarily, therefore, to that court. The state may as well approach the high court being the superior court under s. 439 (2) to commit the accused to custody. When, however, the state is aggrieved by the order of the sessions judge granting bail and there are no new circumstances that have cropped up except those already existed, it is futile for the state to move the sessions judge again and it is competent in law to move the high court for cancellation of the bail. This position follows from the subordinate position of the court of session vis - a - vis the high court."
3]. In the case of state v/s. Lalji popat, reported in 1988 (2) glr 1073 [1988 (2) glh 114], in para 22 it is held as under:
"22. Applying the aforesaid tests laid down by the supreme court, it cannot be said that if the sessions court grants the bail application erroneously or illegally or arbitrarily without considering the relevant factors, then this court is helpless and cannot quash and st aside the order passed by the sessions court. This court under sec. 439 (2) or under sec. 482 of the criminal procedure code has jurisdiction to quash and set aside any arbitrary or illegal order passed by the subordinate court."
It is, therefore, clear that when a bail is granted on erroneous ground without considering the relevant factors, this court has ample power to cancel the bail.
4]. Mr. Thakkar had relied upon an unreported decision dated 10. 7. 2000 passed by this court in criminal misc. Application no. 1664 of 2000. In this connection it is required to be noted that in the case of state v/s. Mohmadhusain a. Meman. Reported in 1997 (1) glr 74 wherein it is held that the high court can interfere with the order granting bail if it is granted disregarding principles laid down by the supreme court. Therefore, the aforesaid judgement would be of no assistance to the respondent no. 2.
5]. In view of the aforesaid discussion, i am of the view that the sessions court has committed an error in granting bail to the respondent no. 2, which requires to be cancelled.
(13) Before concluding it is required to be noted that the court should not ignore the fact that in recent past there were large scale scam in cooperative banks as a result of which many cooperative banks have been closed down putting small investors into serious financial hardships. Such scams took place only with the connivance of the directors and/or managers of the respective banks, who are trustee/custodian of the bank. Such scams have seriously affected the economic condition of cooperative banks and also the general public at large. Therefore in these times it would not be advisable to take a liberal view in such serious financial irregularities affecting the general public. The role of director and manager (persons in management) is important in view of the fact that they are empowered with the power and duty in respect of public money and dereliction of their duty will seriously affect the life and business of general public.
(14) In view of the foregoing discussions it is evident that the very foundation of granting bail to the respondent no. 2 is on erroneous ground and consideration which are not emerging from the record. After a detailed consideration i am of the view that the grounds which are considered by the sessions court are not valid grounds for grant of bail. The respondent no. 2 has evaded arrest till this court passed an order for declaring him as an absconder. The amount, which is public money, involved is a huge sum. The charge sheet has been filed before the arrest of the respondent no. 2 and he was shown to be absconding and it cannot be said that the investigation qua the respondent no. 2 is over. On perusal of the record, i am of the view that there is presence of supervening circumstances which warrant recalling of the order which granted bail. The discretion exercised by the sessions court is not just and proper and the present application requires to be allowed.
(15) In the result this application is allowed. The order dated 16th september 2005 passed by the additional sessions judge and presiding officer, fast track court no. 2, ahmedabad (rural) in criminal misc. Application no. 715 of 2005 is quashed and set aside and the bail granted to respondent no. 2 is hereby cancelled. The respondent no. 2 shall surrender before the authorities on or before 4th may 2005. Rule is made absolute accordingly.
Alert