- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Xiaomi Technology And Ors. v. Telefonaktiebolaget Lm Ericsson Publ And Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
The first respondent (plaintiff) filed a suit alleging patent infringement against the appellants (defendants No. 1 and 2) and the second respondent (defendant No. 3). The suit is based on eight patents held by the plaintiff, alleging that the appellants infringe these patents through their use of certain chipsets. A sweeping ex-parte ad-interim injunction was granted against the appellants on December 8, 2014, which significantly impacted their business operations. The appellants challenged this injunction, alleging suppression of material facts, particularly regarding the source and licensing status of the chipsets they use, which are sourced from Qualcomm Incorporated. Qualcomm communicated that it holds a license from the patentee Ericsson for the relevant technology, suggesting that the appellants' use of Qualcomm chipsets does not infringe Ericsson’s 3G related patents. The court heard the appeal and decided to pass a pro tem interim order, pending the learned Single Judge’s decision on the appellants’ application for vacation of the ad-interim injunction.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellants suppressed material facts regarding the licensing status of the chipsets sourced from Qualcomm in the context of the patent infringement suit.
- Whether the appellants’ import and sale of devices containing Qualcomm chipsets infringe the patents held by the first respondent.
- The scope and appropriateness of granting a pro tem order permitting the appellants to continue certain business activities pending final determination of the suit.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The appellants contend that the chipsets they use are sourced from Qualcomm, which holds a license from Ericsson (the patentee) to use the patented technology.
- They rely on email communications with Qualcomm indicating that Qualcomm’s license covers the relevant patents asserted by Ericsson, particularly for 3G technology.
- The appellants argue that this licensing status was not disclosed earlier and that the injunction was granted without considering this material fact, amounting to suppression.
Respondent No. 1's Arguments
- The first respondent disputes the appellants' characterization of the licensing agreement between Ericsson and Qualcomm, asserting that Qualcomm’s written confirmation to Xiaomi misrepresents the facts.
- Ericsson’s communication demands immediate withdrawal of Qualcomm’s statement and threatens to consider legal options, indicating a dispute over the scope of the license and infringement.
- The respondent maintains that the injunction was justified based on their claim of patent infringement and that the appellants’ arguments regarding licensing do not negate the infringement allegations.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court restricted its analysis to the limited issue of whether the appellants’ use of Qualcomm chipsets was covered by Qualcomm’s license from Ericsson, without delving into the broader patent infringement claims or the technical analysis of the patents. It recognized that the dispute over suppression of material facts concerned the interpretation of the license agreement between Ericsson and Qualcomm, and the agreement under which the appellants source the chipsets. The court emphasized that the pro tem order was distinct from an ad-interim order and was intended as a temporary measure to balance the appellants’ right to conduct business against the potential financial harm to the first respondent if infringement were ultimately established. The court conditioned the pro tem relief on the appellants depositing Rs. 100 per device imported, disclosing import details, and filing affidavits, thereby preserving the first respondent’s interests while allowing the appellants to continue business operations pending final adjudication.
Holding and Implications
DISPOSED OF
The appeal was disposed of by granting a pro tem order permitting the appellants to import and sell devices containing Qualcomm chipsets subject to specified conditions, including monetary deposits and disclosure requirements. The impugned ex-parte ad-interim injunction order was superseded to this extent. The court directed the learned Single Judge to consider the appellants’ application under Order 39 Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure regarding alleged suppression of facts. No final determination on the merits of patent infringement or royalty quantification was made. The decision allows the appellants to continue business operations temporarily while safeguarding the first respondent’s potential financial interests through deposits. No new precedent was established by this order.
Caveat 1112/2014
Respondent No. 1 - the caveator appears through counsel as above and hence the caveat is discharged.
CM No. 20650/2014, CM No. 20652/2014, CM No. 20651/2014 and CM No. 20649/2014
Allowed subject to just exceptions.
FAO(OS) 522/2014
1. The first respondent is the plaintiff in the suit. The appellants are defendants No. 1 and 2. The second respondent is defendant No. 3 in the suit.
2. Parties agree that respondent No. 2 would be a proforma party and thus the appeal would be heard for disposal without issuing notice to respondent No. 2.
3. Counsel for respondent No. 1 waives notice.
4. We have heard learned counsel for the parties. We make it clear that the arguments have been restricted to enable the Court to receive such facts which may be relevant for the purposes of passing a pro tern interim order (as distinct from an ad-interim order which has to be passed after hearing the parties on merits in view of the respective pleadings and keeping in view the principles relating to the grant of an interim injunction). The reason for the pro tern order being passing is the sweeping ex-parte ad-interim injunction order passed by the learned single Judge against the appellants on December 8, 2014 which has throttled the business of the appellants. Needless to state it is for the learned Single Judge to first decide the controversy between the parties keeping in view the pleadings concerning plaintiffs claim for grant of an injunction pending determination of the issues in the suit.
5. The bedrock stone of the suit filed by the first respondent, is patent(s) No. IN2033034, IN203036, IN234157, IN203686, IN213723, IN229632, IN240471 and IN241747. The plaintiff alleges that the appellants are infringing the patent(s). The averments concerning alleged infringement analysis are to be found in paragraph 29 onwards till paragraph 36 of the plaint.
6. The grievance in the appeal is one of suppression of material facts. As per the appellants the chip containing the technology of the patentee i.e. the plaintiff is being sourced by the appellants from a company called ‘Qualcomm Incorporated’. The appellants rely upon a communication sent by e-mail to said company querying whether the said company has a right to, in turn permit the appellants, from using the chip manufactured by the said company as a licensee of the plaintiff. The-mail dated December 14, 2014 has been placed before us at page 191 and 192 of the appeal paper book. The response thereto is at page 193 of the appeal paper book. The reply of Qualcomm, at page 193 would evince that as per Qualcomm it has a licence under an agreement with the patentee : Ericsson to use its technology for which it has a patent. As per Qualcomm, the 3G standards are CDMA standards or applications under the agreement and accordingly, any implementation of 3G technology by Xiaomi in devices which implement a Qualcomm chipset is a licensed implementation and does not infringe at least Ericsson’s 3G related patents.
7. The respondent No. 1 would rely upon an e-mail dated December 16, 2014 received by it from Qualcomm informing as under:
“As you may be aware of Ericsson has taken legal action in India against a company called Xiaomi Technology Co., Ltd (“Xiaomi”). The suit involves products of Xiaomi incorporating both chipsets of Qualcomm as well as chipsets of third parties (Mediatek). 8 patents have been asserted against Xiaomi relating to e.g. EDGE, AMR for GSM, AMR for WCDMA, WCDMA etc.
I has come to our knowledge that a legal representative of Qualcomm has confirmed in writing to Xiaomi that the Agreement “covers the 8 patents asserted by Ericsson in the suit against Xiaomi”. See e-mail confirmation by John Scott of December 14th. Apart from considering the confidentiality obligations of Qualcomm in respect of the terms and conditions, the statement made is incorrect and misrepresenting the facts of the agreement in between our companies and could potentially harm Ericsson irreparably.
"Please, by immediate return e-mail, withdraw the statement made. Absent such withdrawal, Ericsson will be forced to consider its relevant options under the Agreement, as well as any other legal rights it may have as a consequence."
8. The narrative of the above noted facts would evince that the dispute between the parties concerning the issue of suppression would not warrant any analysis of the infringement data relied upon in the plaint. The limited area of this dispute would be : Whether the use of the chipset sourced by the appellants from Qualcomm would be in terms of the license agreement which Qualcomm has from the patentee i.e. Ericsson. This issue would simply relate to interpreting the agreement between Ericsson and Qualcomm and perhaps the agreement under which the appellants is sourcing the chipsets from Qualcomm.
9. At this stage a word of caution with respect to the intent and purport of the present order needs to be penned.
10. Since we have indicated to the parties that we would be working out a pro tern measure and simultaneously requesting the learned single Judge to decide appellants’ application for vacation of the ex-parte ad-interim injunction, concerning suppression of material facts, any other issue relating to the right of the patentee, which would require a prima facie view to be taken with respect to the data analysis of the technology used by the appellants vis-a-vis the technology in which patent rights are claimed by the respondent, would have to wait hearing at a later stage for the purpose of deciding the application seeking an interim measure.
"11. Thus, our present order would be restricted only to such devices which the appellants import as are fitted with the chipset manufactured by Qualcomm and no other chipset. To said extent i.e. on the terms of the present order as hereinafter recorded, the impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge would be superseded."
12. We are passing the pro tem order keeping in view the fact that treating the averments in the plaint to be true, the adverse effect upon the first respondent would be the finances which would otherwise flow to the coffers of the first respondent if ultimately it is found that the appellants is infringing the patent of the first respondent. The measure of the infringement would be the amount which the appellants would then have to pay to the first respondent as per policy of the first respondent while granting licenses. It is trite that the measure of damages for infringement of a patent would be the revenue loss to the patentee which it would have got by way of royalty while granting the license.
13. Striking a balance between the right of the appellants, which even as per the plaint, is concededly in business in India since July, 2014, we dispose of the appeal directing that as a pro tem measure the appellants would be permitted to import and sell the devices containing chipsets sold to it by Qualcomm upon the following terms:
(1) The pro tem measure would be restricted to import and sale of devices in which Qualcomm chipsets are used.
(2) By January 5, 2015, ?100 per device imported would be deposited in the name of the Registrar General of this Court by the appellants, which would be kept in a fixed deposit by the Registrar General; term of the deposit being three months.
(3) Affidavit would be filed by January 5, 2015 disclosing the import of devices in India containing chipset of Qualcomm pursuant to the present order.
(4) Particulars of invoices of purchase of chipsets from Qualcomm shall be disclosed in the affidavit.
(5) Imports made in the month of January, 2015 would likewise be disclosed by way of an affidavit and Rs. 100/- per device deposited in the name of the Registrar General of this Court by February 03, 2015.
14. Upon the appellants filing an application before the learned single Judge under Order 39 Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the learned Single Judge would at the first instance consider arguments concerning suppression of relevant facts as alleged by the appellants against the first respondent, and should the appellants raise other issues, the decision thereon for purposes of an interim order would be severed. The application shall be filed by December 20, 2014 and the reply thereto shall be filed by January 03, 2015. The rejoinder would be filed before the next date of hearing before the learned Single Judge which is February 05, 2015, on which date the application shall be listed before Court and the date fixed before the learned Joint Registrar shall be cancelled.
15. Nothing said by us in appeal, in relation to the facts or Rs. 100/-required to be deposited per sale of device imported would not be treated as an expression of merits of the claims of the parties or the quantification of the royalty by the Division Bench. Such facts which we have noted above are necessary to form the backdrop for the pro tern measure we have directed.
16. The appeal is disposed of in terms above without any order as to costs. Dasti under signature of the Court Master to counsel for the parties.
CM No. 20720/2014 (stay)
Since the appeal has been disposed of by passing a pro tern order, the instant application which seeks stay of the operation of the impugned order is disposed of as infructuous.
_______________
Alert