Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Anil Rai v. Central Bureau Of Investigation

Delhi High Court
Sep 8, 2008
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The present legal opinion concerns three petitions filed by the same parties, all seeking modification of earlier court orders dated November 14 and November 30, 2005, in cases titled CBI Vs. J.R. Gupta and others. Specifically, the petitions request waiver of the condition requiring the petitioner to obtain prior court permission for foreign travel during the pendency of serious economic offence trials. The petitioner, who provides educational services and advises an institute, has been permitted to travel abroad six times previously and seeks relief from the procedural requirement of court permission for each trip due to frequent and sometimes short-notice travels. The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) opposes the waiver citing concerns about monitoring and the risk of the petitioner absconding.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the condition of obtaining prior court permission for foreign travel imposed on the petitioner in the context of serious economic offence trials can be waived or modified.
  2. What alternative safeguards can be imposed to balance the petitioner’s right to travel abroad and the State’s interest in ensuring the petitioner’s presence during trial.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner provides educational services and advises an institute, necessitating frequent foreign travel.
  • The petitioner has complied with previous travel permissions, returning timely on six occasions.
  • Obtaining prior court permission for each trip causes inconvenience, delay, and expense, especially when travel is at short notice.

CBI's Arguments

  • The petitioner faces trial for serious economic offences involving large sums of money.
  • Frequent foreign travel without court permission impedes monitoring and increases the risk of absconding.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Avnish Bajaj Vs. State (NCT of Delhi) (Criminal Misc. NO.9696/2005 in Bail Application no.2284/04) Waiver of condition requiring permission to travel abroad imposed on accused on bail. The court relied on this precedent to recognize that the condition aims to secure accused’s presence and that where the accused has complied previously, unnecessary delays can be avoided by waiving the permission requirement.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court observed that the primary objective of imposing the condition of prior permission for foreign travel is to ensure the accused’s presence during trial. Since the petitioner has already traveled abroad six times with permission and returned timely, there is no evidence of misuse. The court considered the petitioner’s professional obligations requiring frequent and sometimes urgent travel, and the inconvenience caused by obtaining prior permission each time. Balancing the petitioner’s rights and the State’s interest, the court modified the condition by substituting the requirement of prior permission with a detailed notification system to the trial court. This includes informing the court a week in advance with itinerary details, contact information, and a written confirmation upon return. Additionally, the petitioner must not travel during trial hearing dates and must furnish an affidavit undertaking these conditions. To address the CBI’s apprehensions, the petitioner is required to furnish an enhanced surety bond of one crore rupees, maintainable throughout the trial, with liberty granted to the respondent to seek revocation of this order if the petitioner fails to comply.

Holding and Implications

The petitions are allowed and the condition requiring the petitioner to obtain prior court permission for foreign travel is modified to a system of prior intimation and undertaking as detailed by the court. The petitioner must also furnish an enhanced surety bond of one crore rupees before traveling abroad. The court’s order balances the petitioner’s need for travel convenience with the State’s interest in securing the petitioner’s presence at trial.

The direct effect is that the petitioner is relieved from the procedural burden of seeking permission for every foreign trip, subject to strict disclosure and undertaking conditions. No new precedent beyond the application of existing principles is established.

Show all summary ...

Sunil Gaur, J.:-

1. The parties in all the above titled three petitions is common. With the consent of both sides, these three petitions are being disposed of by this common order.

2. In the first petition no.2801/2008, modification of order dated 14th November, 2005 seeking waiver of the condition of obtaining permission to travel abroad, in case RC SIG 2001 E 0007 titled CBI Vs. J.R. Gupta and others, is sought. In the second petition no.2802/2008, modification of order dated 14th November, 2005 seeking waiver of the condition of obtaining permission to travel abroad, in case RC SIG 2001 E 0006 titled CBI Vs. J.R. Gupta and others, is sought. In the third petition, modification of order dated 30th November, 2005 of the learned Addl. Sessions judge passed in RC SIG 0005 titled CBI Vs. J.R.Gupta and others, is sought to the extent of petitioner being required to seek the permission of the court for foreign travel.

3. Both the sides have been heard in these three petitions and response to these three petitions have been perused.

4. The common stand taken by learned counsels for the petitioner in these three petitions is that the petitioner is providing educational service to the society and is an advisor to the Institute for Integrated Learning in Management and for that purpose, he has to travel abroad quite frequently. It is pointed out that petitioner has been permitted to travel abroad on six occasions and has always returned back to India in time. The reason for seeking the waiver of taking permission of the court to travel abroad every time is that at many times, the petitioner has to travel at short notice and it is not possible to take the permission of the court and the petitioner has to reschedule his visit, causing much inconvenience and unnecessary delay and expense.

5. The opposition to this petition by the CBI is on the ground that the petitioner is facing trial for very serious economic offences involving crores of rupees and there is no monitoring of the frequent visits of the petitioner abroad, and there is every likelihood of petitioner fleeing away from the process of law.

6. Order dated 22nd July, 2005 passed by another bench of this court in Criminal Misc. NO.9696/2005 in Bail Application no.2284/04 titled Avnish Bajaj Vs. State (NCT of Delhi) relied upon by the petitioner has been perused. In the aforesaid order, the condition imposed of taking permission to travel abroad has been waived. Object of putting such condition is to secure the presence of the accused admitted to bail. The gravity of the offence has been already considered by the court while granting bail. Unnecessary inconvenience and the delay in obtaining a formal permission to travel abroad can be easily avoided in a case like present one where petitioner has already travelled abroad about six times and has not misused the permission granted to him.

7. In view of the aforesaid, the present petitions are allowed and the condition imposed in impugned orders in these three petitions, of petitioner “not leaving India without permission of the court” is substituted with the modified direction of petitioner informing the trial court, a week in advance, of his visit abroad and the petitioner shall furnish the complete itinerary i.e. stating the country/countries which is/are to be visited by him and the period of his visit and the address/addresses where he would be staying and his contact number. Petitioner would be also obliged to indicate the Airport from where he would be boarding and de-boarding. Not only this, the petitioner shall also inform the trial court in writing about his return to India within a week thereof. Petitioner is directed to furnish aforesaid undertaking on affidavit to the trial court and also state on affidavit that he would not undertake a foreign visit on the effective dates of hearing in the trial court i.e. when the evidence in this case is being recorded.

8. In view of the aforesaid relief being granted to the petitioner, learned Counsels for the petitioner do not and cannot have any possible objection to the enhancement of the surety bond amount to Rupees one crore. Meaning thereby, a bond of Rupees one crore would be furnished by the petitioner to be trial court within three weeks from today and in any case, before the petitioner proceeds on a visit abroad and the said bond would be kept alive during the trial of this case. This will take care of the apprehension of the CBI expressed in this matter. Liberty is granted to the respondent to get this order revoked in the event of petitioner failing to comply with this order at any point of time during the trial.

9. These three petitions stand disposed in the aforesaid terms.