- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dr. V.K Agrawal v. University Of Delhi & Ors.
Summary of Opinion (Bench: Markandeya Katju, C.J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal challenges a judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 20.7.2005. The Court heard counsel and perused the record.
The essential facts, as recited in the opinion, are as follows (the fuller facts appear in the Single Judge's judgment):
- The appellant joined Moti Lal Nehru College as a Lecturer in Physics in 1969. The college is a constituent college recognised by the Executive Council of Delhi University under the Act No. VIII of 1922 (as amended).
- The appellant retired on 15.7.2004 upon attaining the age of superannuation (62 years).
- The appellant submitted an application for re-employment on 18.11.2003, along with his bio-data, under Ordinance XII and the revised Executive Council Guidelines.
- Ordinance XII Rule 3-A(2) (quoted in the opinion) authorises a Governing Body to re-employ a distinguished teacher after age 62 for a period not exceeding three years, but only with the approval of the Vice-Chancellor and not beyond age 65, if the Governing Body is satisfied re-employment is in the college's interest.
- The appellant's case was recommended by the Principal (letter dated 24.11.2003) and by the Governing Body (resolution referenced as 3.12.2003 and a resolution text dated 12.12.2003 is reproduced in the opinion).
- The Vice-Chancellor did not approve the Governing Body's recommendation; the Vice-Chancellor referred the matter to an advisory committee constituted under Executive Council resolutions, and that committee did not recommend re-employment. The University communicated its inability to approve the recommendation to the college by letter dated 29.7.2004, and the college informed the appellant.
- The appellant challenged the Vice-Chancellor's decision by writ petition, alleging improper bypassing of norms and unfair consideration; the appeal before this Court followed the Single Judge's judgment dated 20.7.2005.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Vice-Chancellor was obliged to approve a Governing Body's recommendation for re-employment where the Governing Body had recommended re-employment under Ordinance XII Rule 3-A(2).
- Whether the Vice-Chancellor could dispose of such a recommendation on the basis of the advice of an advisory committee of experts (i.e., whether the Vice-Chancellor's referral to such a committee and acceptance of its recommendation amounted to improper delegation or denial of fair consideration).
- Whether reasons were required to be recorded by the selection/advisory body (or by the Vice-Chancellor) when rejecting an application for re-employment.
- Whether the Court should interfere with the decision of expert academic/advisory bodies in the absence of mala fides or statutory violation.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant (in para 28 of the writ petition) contended that only the formal assent of the Vice-Chancellor was required for re-employment and that it was essentially the Governing Body which should decide the matter.
- It was alleged that the Vice-Chancellor bypassed norms of objective, judicious and fair consideration by rejecting the Governing Body's recommendation on the advice of an advisory committee.
- Learned counsel for the appellant argued that while reasons must be recorded when granting re-employment, no reasons were required when rejecting re-employment; counsel submitted that this asymmetry is arbitrary.
- Learned counsel also argued that the Vice-Chancellor should have applied his own mind to the matter instead of referring it to an advisory committee.
- Counsel asserted that the appellant was a person of great distinction and therefore should have been re-employed.
Respondents' Arguments
- The college (counter-affidavit) stated that a teacher can be re-employed only with the approval of the Vice-Chancellor and that the University had framed guidelines for considering re-employment cases (Executive Council resolution No. 22 dated 11.4.1981, revised by resolution No. 159 dated 22.1.1991, as stated in the affidavit).
- The college informed that, after receiving the Governing Body's recommendation, the University communicated by letter dated 29.7.2004 that it was not possible to approve the recommendation for the appellant.
- Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 stated that the appellant had no vested right to re-employment and that the conditions for re-employment included being a "distinguished teacher" and that the teacher's service was required in the interest of the college.
- The Vice-Chancellor referred the matter to an advisory committee (per Executive Council resolutions) consisting of experts who examined bio-data, teaching experience, academic excellence, research publications and related aspects; that committee did not recommend re-employment.
- The respondents denied any mala fides and emphasised that other re-employment cases were decided on their own merits by the advisory committee, which is not directly relevant to the appellant's case.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Reserve Bank of India v. CL Toora, (2004) 4 SCC 657 | The High Court should not set aside a selection made by a high-power selection board. | The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that it should not substitute its view for that of expert selection/advisory bodies. |
| National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences v. Dr. K. Kalyana Raman, 1992 Supp (2) SCC 481 | Court ordinarily should not interfere with decisions of selection committees consisting of experts. | Cited to reinforce the principle of deference to expert selection committees; the Court stated it cannot sit in appeal over the advisory committee's decision. |
| Rajendra Prasad Mathur v. Karnataka University, 1986 Supp SCC 740 : AIR 1986 SC 1448 | Courts should be reluctant to interfere in academic/educational matters. | Invoked to support non-interference in academic decisions; the opinion states the Court must ordinarily defer to academic authorities. |
| J.P. Kulshreshtra v. Allahabad University, (1980) 3 SCC 418 : AIR 1980 SC 2141 | Non-interference with academic decisions and selections by expert bodies. | Used as part of a line of authority showing reluctance to interfere in academic selections. |
| State of Mysore v. Govinda Rao, AIR 1965 SC 491 | Recognised principle of deference to academic authorities (as part of established jurisprudence). | Cited among other authorities to show consistent Supreme Court view against judicial interference in academic selection matters. |
| The Chancellor v. Dr. Bijayananda Kar, (1994) 1 SCC 169 | Decisions of academic authorities should not ordinarily be interfered with; eligibility and requisite qualifications are matters for academic bodies and selection committees. | The Court quoted the passage to show that the Chancellor may refer eligibility issues to experts and that courts should not lightly upset such decisions. |
| Secretary (Health), Deptt. Of Health v. Dr. Anita Puri, JT 1996 (8) SC 130 | Court should not ordinarily interfere with selection and evaluation by expert bodies unless allegations of mala fides are made out. | The Court relied on this principle to conclude it should not interfere with the advisory committee's evaluation in the absence of proven mala fides. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeded along the following lines, closely following the reasoning expressed in the opinion:
- The Court observed that it is not its role to determine whether a teacher qualifies as a "distinguished teacher" for purposes of re-employment under Ordinance XII; such determinations require subject-matter expertise which the Court does not possess.
- The advisory committee that reviewed the appellant's application consisted of experts in the subject. That committee examined the appellant's bio-data and various academic factors (teaching experience, academic excellence, research publications, research work, etc.) and did not recommend re-employment.
- The Vice-Chancellor accepted the advisory committee's recommendation and conveyed non-approval to the college; the Court found no basis to substitute its judgment for that of the advisory committee or the Vice-Chancellor in the absence of statutory violation or proven mala fides.
- On the specific contention that reasons were required when rejecting re-employment, the Court relied on Supreme Court authorities to hold that selection committees need not give reasons for rejection unless statute so requires; therefore the appellant's contention of arbitrariness on this ground was rejected.
- The Court rejected the argument that the Vice-Chancellor was obliged to apply his own mind rather than refer the matter to the advisory committee, reasoning that the Vice-Chancellor cannot be an expert in every subject and is entitled to take the opinion of experts, especially where Executive Council guidelines envisage such consultation.
- The Court emphasized the established principle that academic and educational decisions made by expert bodies should not ordinarily be interfered with by the judiciary unless there is a statutory breach or shocking arbitrariness or mala fides—none of which were found on the facts of this case.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED.
Holding (core ruling): The appeal was dismissed and the decision of the Vice-Chancellor (not to approve the Governing Body's recommendation for the appellant's re-employment, following the advisory committee's negative recommendation) was upheld.
Implications:
- The direct consequence for the parties is that the appellant's application for re-employment was not allowed to stand; the administrative decision declining approval remains in force.
- The Court applied and reiterated existing Supreme Court principles of judicial deference to expert academic/selection bodies and emphasised that courts should not ordinarily interfere with such decisions in the absence of statutory violation or demonstrated mala fides.
- The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal precedent beyond applying and relying upon established Supreme Court authorities; no broader novel principles were announced in this opinion.
Appeal dismissed.
Markandeya Katju, C.J— This appeal is directed against a judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 20.7.2005 Heard Counsel for the parties and perused the record.
2. The facts in detail have been set out in the judgment of the learned Single Judge and hence we are not repeating the same except where necessary.
3. The facts lie in a short compass. The appellant joined the service of Moti Lal Nehru College as a Lecturer in Physics in 1969. The aforesaid college is a constituent college recognised as such by the Executive Council of Delhi University in accordance with the provisions of the Act No. VIII of 1922 as amended.
4. The appellant retired on 15.7.2004 on attaining the age of superannuation of 62 years. However, the appellant submitted an application on 18.11.2003 to his college for reemployment along with his bio-data under Ordinance XII and the revised Executive Council Guidelines.
5. Ordinance XII Rule 3-A(2) of the University Ordinance provides:
“The Governing Body of a College or an institution may, with the approval of Vice-Chancellor, re-employ any distinguished teacher after he has attained the age of 62 years for a period not exceeding 3 years on the whole but not beyond his completing the age of 65 years, if the Governing Body is satisfied that such re-employment is in the interest of the College or Institution.”
6. On receiving the application the Principal of the college recommended the appellant's case for re-employment vide his letter dated 24.11.2003 and submitted it to the Governing Body of the college, which in turn took a decision on 3.12.2003 to recommend his case for re-employment to the Vice-Chancellor.
7. The relevant part of the resolution of the Governing Body dated 12.12.2003 states:
“After due deliberation, the Committee resolved to recommend the case of re-employment to the University of Delhi in respect of Dr. V.K Agarwal.”
8. It is alleged in para 28 of the writ petition that only formal assent of of the Vice-Chancellor is required for the re-employment and it is really the Governing Body of the college which has to take a decision on the matter. However, bypassing all norms of an objective, judicious and fair consideration for grant of approval for re-employment of the appellant, the Vice-Chancellor of the University rejected the recommendation of the Governing Body on the advice of an advisory committee appointed by him. Aggrieved the appellant filed a writ petition in this Court.
9. A counter affidavit was filed by the college and we have perused the same. In para 9 it is stated that a teacher can be re-employed only if the Vice-Chancellor approves his appointment. The University has framed guidelines for taking up the case of teachers applying for reemployment and these guidelines were laid down by the Executive Council vide resolution No. 22 dated 11.4.1981, which were revised by the Executive Council's resolution No. 159 dated 22.1.1991 The Governing Body of the college made a recommendation on the appellant's representation and sent it to the Vice-Chancellor. However, a communication was received from the University vide letter dated 29.7.2004 whereby the college was informed that it is not possible to approve the recommendation of the Governing Body for grant of re-employment to Dr. V.K Agarwal. On receiving this letter of the University the college informed the appellant accordingly.
10. A counter affidavit was also filed by respondent Nos. 1 and 2. In para 1 of the same it is stated that the appellant has no vested right to be reemployed. The conditions for re-employment are that the teacher should be a distinguished teacher and that the service of such teachers are required in the interest of the college.
11. On receiving the recommendation of the Governing Council for reemploying the appellant the Vice-Chairman sent it to an advisory committee as per Executive Council Resolution 22 dated 11.4.1981 and Executive Council Resolution 151 dated 22.1.1991 The advisory committee consists of experts in the subject who after examining and scrutinizing the various aspects e.g bio-data, teaching experience, academic excellence, research publications, research work, etc. did not recommend the appellant's case for reemployment. The decision of the Delhi University was conveyed to the college by letter dated 29.7.2004, copy of which is annexed as Annexure R-1 to the counter affidavit.
12. In para 18 of the counter affidavit it is denied that there were any mala fides in the matter. The case of the appellant was considered by the advisory committee and he was not found fit for re-employment.
13. As regards the appellant's allegations that other retired teachers have been re-employed it is stated in para 32 that the advisory committee has dealt with other cases on their own merit which has no relevance with this case.
14. On the facts of the case we find no merit in this appeal. It is not for this Court to say whether a teacher is a distinguished teacher or not. This Court does not consist of experts in the subject concerned, and the Court must ordinarily defer to the opinion of the experts. The advisory committee consists of experts, who considered the case of the appellant and did not recommend grant of reemployment to him. We cannot sit in appeal over the decision of the advisory committee, which was accepted by the Vice-Chancellor.
15. In Reserve Bank of India v. CL Toora, (2004) 4 SCC 657 the Supreme Court held that the High Court should not set aside the selection held by a high power selection board. This is the view which has consistently been followed by the Supreme Court. This Court cannot ordinarily interfere with the decision of selection committees consisting of experts vide National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences v. Dr. K. Kalyana Raman, 1992 Supp (2) SCC 481. The advisory committee appointed by the Vice-Chancellor consists of experts, and we cannot sit in appeal over its decisions.
16. Learned Counsel for the appellant submitted that while reasons have to be recorded in granting re-employment no reasons are required in rejecting the prayer for re-employment. He submitted that this is arbitrary. We cannot agree with this contention in view of the aforesaid decision of the Supreme Court where it has been held that no reasons need be given by the selection committee unless required by the statute.
17. Learned Counsel for the appellant submitted that the Vice-Chancellor had to apply his mind himself instead of referring the matter to the advisory committee. We do not agree. The Vice-Chancellor, though no doubt a man of great academic distinction, cannot possibly be an expert in every subject. Hence he can certainly take the opinion of an advisory committee consisting of experts, particularly when guidelines have been framed for this purpose by the Executive Council.
18. Learned Counsel for the appellant submitted that the appellant is a person of great distinction. As already stated above it is not for this Court to decide whether a person is of distinction or not as that is a matter for experts to decide. This Court cannot interfere with such a decision of experts unless there is a violation of some statute or there is some shocking arbitrariness, which is not so in this case. It is well settled that in academic/educational matters Courts should be reluctant to interfere vide Rajendra Prasad Mathur v. Karnataka University, 1986 Supp SCC 740 : AIR 1986 SC 1448, J.P Kulshreshtra v. Allahabad University, (1980) 3 SCC 418 : AIR 1980 SC 2141, State of Mysore v. Govinda Rao, AIR 1965 SC 491, etc.
19. In The Chancellor v. Dr. Bijayananda Kar, (1994) 1 SCC 169 the Supreme Court observed:
“This Court has repeatedly held that the decisions of the academic authorities should not ordinarily be interfered with by the Courts. Whether a candidate fulfills the requisite qualifications or not is a matter which should be entirely left to be decided by the academic bodies and the concerned selection committees which invariably consist of experts on the subjects relevant to the selection. In the present case Dr. Kar in his representation before the Chancellor specifically raised the issue that Dr. Mohapatra did not possess the specialization in the ‘Philosophical Analysis of Values’ as one of the qualifications. The representation was rejected by the Chancellor. We have no doubt that the Chancellor must have looked into the question of eligibility of Dr. Mohapatra and got the same examined from the experts before rejecting the representation of Dr. Kar.”
20. In Secy. (Health), Deptt. Of Health v. Dr. Anita Puri, JT 1996 (8) SC 130 the Supreme Court held that the Court should not ordinarily interfere with the selection and evaluation by expert bodies unless allegations of mala fides are made out. In that decision the Supreme Court observed:
“It would be prudent and safe for the Courts to leave the decisions on such matters to the experts who are more familiar with the problems they face than the Courts. If the expert body considers suitability of a candidate for a specified post after giving due consideration to all the relevant factors, then the Court should not ordinarily interfere with such selection and evaluation.”
21. For the reasons given above, there is no force in the appeal and it is dismissed.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert