Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Bank Of India,... v. Jayanthi 2. Aarthi L...

Madras High Court
Feb 23, 2011
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal arises from an order dated 7th June, 2010, passed by a learned Single Judge in W.P No. 25277 of 2009, wherein a writ petition filed by the respondents was allowed. The petitioners sought a mandamus directing the appellant bank to return title deeds deposited as security by the late husband of the 1st respondent against a loan. The deceased, Late N.P.S Mahendran, had taken loans from the appellant bank for two tea plantation businesses and deposited title deeds as collateral. After his death, the respondents became liable for the outstanding loan amount. The 1st respondent, widow of the deceased, cleared all dues and obtained a 'No Due' certificate from the bank. Despite repeated requests, the bank refused to return the title deeds, citing outstanding dues of another loan account related to M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation, for which the deceased was a guarantor.

One guarantor had obtained an order from the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT) directing the bank to return the documents, but the bank successfully appealed this order at the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal (DRAT), which held the petition to be not maintainable before the DRT. Consequently, the respondents filed the writ petition seeking return of the documents, which was allowed by the Single Judge, leading to this appeal by the bank.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the liability of a guarantor stands extinguished on the guarantor’s death or continues to be enforceable against the guarantor’s estate and heirs.
  2. Whether the appellant bank is entitled to retain the title deeds deposited as security for a specific loan transaction as a general lien under Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, to recover dues from a different loan account where the deceased was a guarantor but not a borrower.
  3. Whether the bank’s retention of title deeds after full repayment of the loan secured by those deeds is justified under the principle of general lien.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The learned Single Judge erred in holding that the guarantor’s liability extinguished on death; the liability continues against the estate and legal heirs.
  • The title deeds were deposited as mortgage security, and the bank is entitled to retain them under Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act as a general lien for recovery of dues from any account, including those where the deceased was a guarantor.
  • The bank, as a public financial institution, has an obligation to recover dues from defaulting borrowers and guarantors’ estates.
  • Relied on Supreme Court decisions including Industrial Investment Bank Of India Limited v. Biswanath Jhunjhunwala and Syndicate Bank v. Vijay Kumar, supporting the right to retain securities under general lien.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The title deeds were deposited only to secure loans taken by the deceased for two specific plantation firms; the loans were fully repaid.
  • The bank has no authority to retain title deeds on the ground of general lien for dues related to a different loan account (M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation) where the deceased was not a borrower or partner.
  • Even if the deceased was a guarantor for the other loan, the equitable mortgage was not created for that loan, so the bank cannot retain the deeds on that basis.
  • The Single Judge correctly ordered the return of the documents after full repayment of the secured loans.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Industrial Investment Bank Of India Limited v. Biswanath Jhunjhunwala, 2009 (9) SCC 478 Liability of guarantor continues against estate and heirs; guarantor’s liability is not extinguished on death. Supported the view that guarantor’s liability survives death and can be enforced against the estate.
Syndicate Bank v. Vijay Kumar, 1992 (2) SCC 331 : AIR 1992 SC 1066 Bankers’ right to general lien on goods bailed to them for recovery of dues across accounts. Examined the principle of general lien but distinguished the facts where the security was for a specific loan with express contract.
State Bank of India Kothagiri Branch v. Chokkalingam, 2008 (1) MLJ 1009 Supports bankers’ statutory right to general lien under Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act. Referenced in support of the bank’s lien rights but the court found the facts did not support general lien here.
George Henry Chambers v. Patrick Davidson, L.R 1PC 296 Express contract excludes general lien; lien arises by implication of law and is excluded by express agreement. Held that the specific mortgage contract excluded the bank’s claim to general lien on the title deeds.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first addressed the question of guarantor liability on death, rejecting the Single Judge’s conclusion that the guarantor’s liability extinguished upon death. Citing Section 131 of the Indian Contract Act and relevant precedent, the Court held that the guarantor’s liability continues against the estate and legal heirs for liabilities existing at the time of death.

Next, the Court examined the bank’s claim to a general lien under Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act. It emphasized that the title deeds were deposited as security for specific loans taken by the deceased for two plantation companies, and that the contract was self-contained and binding as a “contract to the contrary.” The bank failed to show any contract authorizing it to retain the deeds as security for other loans, including those where the deceased was only a guarantor.

The Court noted authoritative commentary from Chitty on Contracts and the principle that a general lien is excluded by an express contract limiting the security to a specific transaction. It also criticized the bank’s conduct for not informing the respondents about retaining the documents as a lien until after litigation commenced.

Accordingly, the Court held that the bank’s retention of the title deeds on the ground of general lien was not justified because the deeds were mortgaged for a specific loan which was fully discharged, and there was no general balance account liability of the deceased borrower to justify lien under Section 171.

Holding and Implications

The Court disposed of the appeal by directing the appellant bank to return the title deeds to the respondents within two weeks from the date of the order.

The direct effect is that the bank must release the specific securities once the secured loan is fully repaid, notwithstanding other dues of the deceased as guarantor in unrelated accounts. The Court clarified the limits of general lien under Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act and reaffirmed that guarantor liability survives death but cannot be enforced by retaining securities mortgaged exclusively for other loans. No new precedent was set beyond the application of established principles to the facts.

Show all summary ...

Prayer: Writ Appeal filed against the order dated 7th June, 2010, passed by learned Single Judge in W.P No. 25277 of 2009.

JUDGMENT

1. This Appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 7th June, 2010, passed in W.P No. 25277/2010, whereby learned Single Judge allowed the Writ Petition filed by the Respondents/Writ Petitioners and a Mandamus was issued directing the Appellant-Bank to return the title deeds to the Writ Petitioners, which was deposited by the late husband of the 1st Respondent by way of security as against the loan availed by him.

2. The facts of the case lie in a narrow compass.

One Late N.P.S Mahendran, husband of the 1st Respondent and father of Respondents 2 and 3 was running two establishments under the name of M/s. Aarthi Bala Tea Plantations and M/s. Sanjay Bala Tea Plantations. The deceased availed loan from the Appellant-Bank and deposited the Title Deeds by way of collateral security and also executed various documents in order to secure due payment of loan. After the death of the said N.P.S Mahendran, the Respondents/Writ Petitioners became liable to pay Rs. 1,14,86,428.32, which was outstanding in several loan accounts. The 1st Respondent, widow, liquidated the entire outstanding dues lying in the account and the Bank, after acknowledging the same, issued ‘No Due’ Certificate in her favour. The Respondents, then, requested the Appellant Bank to return the Title Deeds relating to the properties, which were deposited with the Bank by Late N.P.S Mahendran. Firstly, the Appellant Bank informed the Respondents that after necessary approval from the controlling office, the documents will be returned, but in spite of repeated requests, the documents have not been returned. It appears that one of the Guarantors filed an Application before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, Chennai, seeking for return of documents, which was allowed by the Tribunal by order dated 31st Oct., 2007 directing the Bank to return the documents. Aggrieved by the said order, the Appellant-Bank preferred an Appeal before the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal, Chennai, and the same was allowed by the Appellate Tribunal holding that such a Petition to return the documents was not maintainable before the Debts Recovery Tribunal. The Appellate Tribunal, therefore, directed the borrowers to approach the Bank for appropriate relief. The Respondents/Writ Petitioners again approached the Bank on many occasions requesting for return of documents, but the same was not returned. The Appellant-Bank, by letter dated 14th February, 2008, informed the Respondents that a sum of Rs. 230.03 lakhs is outstanding in the loan account of M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation. The Writ Petitioners, left with no other alternative, moved this Court by filing the aforementioned Writ Petition seeking a Mandamus directing the Appellant-Bank to return the documents of title standing the name of Late N.P.S Mahendran on the ground that the entire loan outstanding has been paid to the Appellant-Bank.

3. The Appellant-Bank contested the Writ Petition on the ground inter alia that the Bank is exercising a general lien on the title documents standing in the name of Late N.P.S Mahendran, who stood as a Guarantor for other facilities and liabilities outstanding against M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation. It was contended by the Bank that such cash-credit facilities were availed from another Branch, namely, Udhagamandalam Branch of the Bank, by one M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation and the deceased, husband of the 1st Respondent, stood as a Guarantor for the said facilities. The said firm committed default and more than Rs. 2.03 Crores is due from the said firm. Hence, the Bank has initiated a proceeding against the firm and the Guarantor and after the death of N.P.S Mahendran, the present Respondents have been impleaded as Legal Representatives.

4. Learned Single Judge found that the entire loan obtained by the deceased, husband of the 1st Respondent was cleared by the 1st Respondent and the Bank has issued a letter dated 24th October, 2007, confirming that the loan account has been closed and the dues were discharged. The learned Judge, therefore, came to the conclusion that the action of the Appellant Bank holding the documents on the ground of general lien is not at all justified. Consequently, the Writ Petition was allowed and a direction was issued for the return of the title deeds in favour of the Respondents/Writ Petitioners. Hence, this Appeal by the Appellant-Bank.

5. Mr. G. Masilamani, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Appellant assailed the impugned judgment and order as being contrary to law and is without jurisdiction. Learned Counsel firstly submitted that the learned Judge has committed serious error in holding that the liability of the Guarantor stands extinguished on his death. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that it is the well settled proposition of law that the Guarantor's liability will be fastened on the estate being inherited by his legal heirs, since the property stood mortgaged in favour of the Appellant-Bank by deposit of Title Deeds by the deceased with an intention to create mortgage. Though the liability in the specific account for which the mortgage was created has been repaid, the Bank is entitled to seek for recovery of the dues in the said account. In this connection, learned Senior Counsel relied upon a decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Industrial Investment Bank Of India Limited v. Biswanath Jhunjhunwala, 2009 (9) SCC 478. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the learned Judge failed to take into consideration the provisions of Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act, which very specifically provides that the Bank is entitled to claim a general lien by retaining the goods and securities bailed to them for the general balance account. Section 171 confers statutory right to the banker to retain the goods and exercise the lien for the recovery of their legitimate dues. In this connection, learned Senior Counsel relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Syndicate Bank v. Vijay Kumar, 1992 (2) SCC 331 : AIR 1992 SC 1066 as also the decision in the case of State Bank of India Kothagiri Branch v. Chokkalingam, 2008 (1) MLJ 1009. Lastly, learned Counsel submitted that the Appellant-Bank, being a public financial institution dealing with public money, has an obligation to recover its dues from the defaulting borrowers.

6. On the other hand, Mr. R. Krishnamoorthi, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Respondents/Writ Petitioners submitted that N.P.S Mahendran, the deceased, husband of the 1st Respondent, deposited the title deeds with an intention to create equitable mortgage only in respect of the loan advanced by the Bank in the name of M/s. Aarthi Bala Tea Plantations and M/s. Sanjay Bala Tea Plantations. After the death of Mr. Mahendran, the entire outstanding dues standing in the name of the aforementioned two firms have been fully paid by the 1st Respondent and the 1st Respondent claimed return of the documents of title. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that after the loan amount against which the Title Deeds were deposited having been fully paid, the Bank has no authority under the law to retain the documents on the ground of general lien by taking recourse to the provisions of Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that one M/s. Somerset Tea Plantations took some loan from a different Branch of the Appellant-Bank, namely, Udhagamandalam Branch in which the deceased, husband of the 1st Respondent, was neither a partner nor a borrower. Even assuming, but not admitting, that the deceased, husband of the 1st Respondent stood as Guarantor in respect of the said loan given to M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation, the said loan is not concerned with the Respondents inasmuch as admittedly the deceased Mahendran never intended to create equitable mortgage in respect of the loan given to M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation. Lastly, it was contended that the learned Single Judge rightly allowed the Writ Petition and directed the Appellant-Bank for the return of the documents of title.

7. After considering the rival contentions made by the learned Counsel appearing for the parties, we would like to first quote the conclusion arrived at by the learned Single Judge, as revealed from paragraphs 9 and 10 of the judgment.

“9. No doubt, Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act facilitates the Bank to retain the documents as a security for general balance of account, any goods bailed to them. In the case on hand, it is not the case of the Respondent-Bank that either the First Petitioner's husband, Late N.P.S Mahendran or the First Petitioner herself is due to the Bank for the loan availed by them. In fact, even in the Counter Affidavit, the First Respondent made it very clear that the First Petitioner's husband as well as the First Petitioner had cleared all the dues to the bank and hence, they have issued a letter dated 24.10.2007 confirming the same. But, it is the case of the Respondent-Bank that one M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation has obtained loan from the Bank and the First Petitioner's husband Late N.P.S Mahendran stood as a guarantor to the facilities availed by the said firm. The Guarantor is now no more and the First Petitioner, being the wife of the Guarantor, can no more be held responsible for the same. As stated already, the First Petitioner's husband was not the principal borrower and he only stood as a Guarantor and on his death, it shall also be extinguished. In view of the above facts and circumstances, I am of the considered view that the Respondent-Bank cannot plead that they have general lien as per Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act.

10. That apart, even according to the Respondent-Bank, the property of the principal borrower, viz., M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation is worth about several crores and in such event, the same could be recovered from the said company instead of harbouring on the dead person's property. Even in the Counter Affidavit, it is clearly stated that the outstanding dues from the same M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation is to the tune of Rs. 2.03 Crores only. If the same could be realized from the said Company without making any tall claim from the Petitioners' property, there is no rhyme or reason in withholding the documents of the Petitioners which was owned by Late N.P.S Mahendran.”

8. From the aforesaid conclusion, it is clear that the learned Single Judge, without disputing the stand of the Appellant-Bank that it can retain the documents as a lien on the basis of the power conferred by Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act, took a view that having regard to the fact that the Respondent's husband Mahendran, who was the guarantor in respect of the loan advanced to one M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation, died and therefore, on his death, the liability as against the guarantor stands extinguished. With due respect, the learned Single Judge is not correct in law in holding that the liability under the guarantee stands revoked or extinguished on the death of the Guarantor. Section 131 of the Contract Act clearly provides that in case of death of Guarantor, the date of guarantee/continuing of the guarantee executed in favour of the Bank stands revoked in respect of future transactions. Hence, we have no hesitation in holding that the liability of the guarantor cannot be extinguished on his death so far the liability which existed on the date of the death of the Guarantor. It is well settled that on the death of the Guarantor, the liability exists and such liability can be fastened on the estate of the deceased, being inherited by his legal heirs, and the creditor can recover the dues out of the estate of the deceased.

9. After having decided the above question in favour of the Appellant-Bank, we now move on to consider the more important question in this appeal, viz., as to whether the Appellant-Bank shall be entitled to retain the documents of title in respect of the property which has been inherited by the Respondents claiming a right of general lien under Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act. Before we delve into the factual and legal aspects, it would be necessary to look into Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 and for easy reference the same is extracted as herein below:

“171. General lien of bankers, factors, wharfingers, attorneys, and policy-brokers.— Bankers, factors, wharfingers, attorneys, of a High Court and Policy-brokers may, in the absence of a contract to the contrary, retain as a security for a general balance of account, any goods bailed to them; but no other persons have a right to retain, as a security for such balance, goods bailed to them, unless there is an express contract to that effect”.

10. The case of the Appellant-Bank is that they have a right to retain the title deeds of the property delivered to them in the normal course of business transaction by exercising general lien under Section 171 of the Act and therefore, they are not bound to return the same till the liability in the other account, where the mortgagor (husband of the 1st Respondent herein, since deceased), was a Guarantor, is discharged.

11. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Appellant-Bank mainly placed reliance on a decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Syndicate Bank v. Vijaya Kumar, 1992 (2) SCC 331 : AIR 1992 SC 1066.

12. As noticed above, Section 171 of the Act states that the bankers like the Appellant-Bank, in the absence of a contract to the contrary, retain as security for a general balance account, any goods bailed to them. Therefore, what is required to be seen in the instant case is whether there is any contract to the contrary, which prevents the Bank from exercising their general lien and as to whether any goods have been bailed to them. It cannot be disputed that the property in question was not bailed to the Appellant-Bank by the deceased borrower at any point of time. Further, it is an undisputed fact that the property in question was offered by (late) N.P.S Mahendran to cover his liability in respect of the loans, which he had borrowed in the accounts of M/s. Sanjay Bala Tea Plantation and M/s. Aarthi Bala Tea Plantation and his self-acquired properties were mortgaged to secure this specific loan transaction. No document has been placed before us to show that the borrower had given any authorisation to the Bank to hold the documents of the mortgaged property, given to secure the loan transaction for M/s. Sanjay Bala Tea Plantation and M/s. Aarti Bala Tea Plantation, for the purpose of any other loan availed in any other branch by M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation in which (late) N.P.S Mahendran, stood as a Guarantor. Thus, the issue boils down to the question as to whether there is any contract to the contrary, which prevents the Appellant-Bank from exercising its general lien under Section 171 of the Act.

13. In Chitty on Contracts, 29th Edition (2004), Volume-II, Page 496 on Bankers' Lien, it is stated as follows:

“…. The most frequent example of circumstances inconsistent with the general lien is in the case of a deposit expressed to cover an advance for a specified purpose. However, once the original purpose has been fulfilled by repayment of the specified advance, if a customer knowingly permits the banker to retain the security, a general lien may ultimately be implied and its protection then claimed in respect of other advances”.

14. In the instant case, the borrower, (late) N.P.S Mahendran, has admittedly deposited the Title Deeds of the property to secure a loan transaction availed in respect of two Plantation Companies. This fact has not disputed by the Appellant-Bank. Therefore, we have no hesitation to hold that this contract/mortgage, had been created by the deceased borrower for a specific purpose and for a specific loan and the contract was self-contained and the terms and conditions were binding upon both the borrower as well as the Bank. In other words, the deposit of Title Deeds by which the mortgage was created by the deceased borrower was for a specific purpose to cover an advance for a specific loan. When such is the situation, the borrower having deposited the documents in order to secure a specific transaction, the Bank cannot contend that they could hold the documents for a balance due in a different loan account where the said N.P.S Mahendran is not a borrower. Further, the language of Section 171 of the Act, is explicit to the fact that the bankers are entitled to retain as a security for a ‘general balance account”. Admittedly, it is not the case of the Appellant-Bank that the amount, which is now said to be due on account of the borrowings of M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation, is a general balance account of the deceased borrower N.P.S Mahendran.

15. In the case of Syndicate Bank v. Vijaya Kumar, referred supra and relied on by the learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant-Bank, it is to be noted that the borrower therein issued a letter in favour of the Bank stating that the Bank is at liberty to adjust from the Fixed Deposit receipts without any reference to the loan and he agreed that the Fixed Deposit receipts shall remain in the Bank so long as any amount on any account is due to the Bank from them either singly or jointly or with others. Thus, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, while interpreting such a letter covering the transaction executed by the borrower therein, rendered a finding that the Bank is entitled to a general lien over the Fixed Deposit receipts given by the borrower therein.

16. As noticed above, the facts of the present case are couched differently. There was a specific contract/agreement between the deceased borrower and the Bank, by which the borrower offered the property in question to secure only a particular transaction. Therefore, this agreement/mortgage has to be construed as a “Contract to the Contrary” and therefore, we have no hesitation to hold that the Bank cannot claim these documents by invoking the power of general lien under Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.

17. In George Henry Chambers v. Patrick Davidson, L.R 1PC 296, while discussing on the aspect regarding lien by the Banks, Lord Westbury, observed as hereunder:

“But lien is not the result of an express contract, it is given by implication of law. If, therefore, a mercantile relation, which might involve a lien, is created by a written contract, and security given for the result of the dealings in that relation, the express stipulation and agreement of the parties for security exclude lien, and limits their rights by the extent of the express contract that they have made. Expressum facit cessare tacitum. If a consignee takes an express security, it excludes general lien.”

18. On facts it appears that the Appellant-Bank, did not at the first instance inform the Respondents that the document that had been mortgaged by (late) N.P.S Mahendran, would be retained by them in exercise of their right of general lien till the facilities availed by M/s. Somerset Tea Plantation was fully settled. In fact, the Appellant-Bank by their letter dated 24.10.2007, certified that the loan accounts standing in the names of M/s. Aarthi Bala Tea Plantations, M/s. Sanjay Bala Tea Plantations, N.P.S Mahendran and Jeyanthi Mahendran, have been closed by payment of entire dues to the bank and the security documents given to the Bank will be released on obtaining necessary approval from the controlling office. As the bank failed to return the documents, one of the Guarantors had approached the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT) by filing an Application for return of documents. The DRT passed order for return of such documents and at that stage the Bank took a ‘U’-turn in the matter and filed an Appeal before the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal and the Appellate Tribunal, set aside the order passed by the DRT stating that the borrower has to approach the Appellant-Bank for return of the documents and the Tribunal cannot issue directions. It is only at that stage by a communication dated 14.02.2008, for the first time, the Bank informed the Respondents that they are holding the documents in exercise of its general lien. Thus, the approach of the Bank also appears to be not very appreciable.

19. After having given our anxious considerations to all the above factual and legal aspects, we are of the firm view that the Appellant-Bank was not justified in retaining the documents in question which were deposited by (late) N.P.S Mahendran, husband of the 1st Respondent herein. For the above reasons, we dispose of the Appeal by directing the Appellant-Bank to return the title deeds to the Respondents within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. No costs.