Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sulian Alias Chinnathambi Another v. State Of Tamil Nadu, Represented By Inspector Of Police

Madras High Court
Apr 1, 2009
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Court Opinion Summary — T. Sudanthiram, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal arises from convictions in Sessions Case No. 250 of 2003 (Additional Sessions Judge, Chidambaram). Accused Nos. 1 and 2 (appellants) were convicted by the trial court: Accused No. 1 (Sulian alias Chinnathambi) was convicted under sections 324 and 302 IPC and sentenced to concurrent terms including life imprisonment for section 302; Accused No. 2 (Sakila) was convicted under section 302 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment. Aggrieved, they appealed.

Prosecution's case: A dispute between neighbours (PW 1 and PW 2 family) and accused family over fencing led to an altercation on 10.12.2002 at about 7:30 pm. PW 1 (Alamelu) and others accuse the appellants (and a third accused) of attacking the deceased Thottiyathan (and injuring other persons) with a crowbar and brick; the deceased was later declared dead after medical examination. Multiple witnesses (PWs 1–8 are said to have witnessed the occurrence) and medical and police evidence, seizure mahazars, inquest and post-mortem were relied upon by the prosecution.

Investigation resulted in arrests of accused Nos. 1 and 2 on 11.12.2002, recovery of alleged weapons, hospitalisation of accused Nos. 1 and 2 and filing of two crime numbers (623/2002 for murder and 624/2002 for offences under sections 324/323 IPC). The prosecution examined PWs 1–29 and produced exhibits P1–P16 and material objects MOs 1–5. The accused were examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and denied complicity; defence also produced a medical witness and accident registers (marked D1 and D2) showing injuries to the accused. The trial court convicted all three accused. This appeal concerns accused Nos. 1 and 2.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the convictions of accused Nos. 1 and 2 can be sustained where the prosecution did not explain injuries sustained by the accused and did not place before the court the records pertaining to the counter case (crime no. 624/2002).
  2. Whether the testimony of eyewitnesses who are close relatives of the deceased can be relied upon, given alleged inconsistencies and the prosecution's omission to present parts of the transaction (specifically, the part in which the accused were injured).
  3. What inference should be drawn, under binding precedents, from the prosecution's failure to explain injuries on the accused in the context of a murder prosecution.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (as presented to the court)

  • The prosecution has not presented the true version of the occurrence and the genesis of the prosecution case is highly doubtful.
  • The accused Nos. 1 and 2 sustained injuries, which the prosecution failed to explain or account for.
  • PWs 1 to 8 are relatives of the deceased and therefore interested witnesses; their evidence is suspect.
  • Although a counter-complaint/case (crime no. 624/2002) was registered on the basis of the first accused's complaint, the prosecution did not place those materials before the court.
  • The defence produced accident registers (marked D1 and D2) through defence medical witness DW1 to show injuries on the accused.
  • Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court decision in Babu Ram and others v. State of Punjab (as authority on consequences of non-explanation of defence injuries).

Prosecution's Arguments

  • PWs 1 to 8 are eyewitnesses and their evidence is consistent; PWs 2 to 4 are injured witnesses whose accounts are credible.
  • The injuries sustained by the accused were not serious.
  • The investigating officer registered a separate case (crime no. 624/2002) against the accused for offences under sections 324 and 323 IPC and relevant notices were served to the first accused.
  • Non-explanation of accused injuries cannot by itself defeat the prosecution case if the evidence of the injured eyewitnesses is otherwise credible — reliance was placed on Krishnan v. State of Haryana.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Babu Ram and others v. State of Punjab The non-explanation of injuries sustained by the accused at or about the time of occurrence is a very important circumstance; it permits inferences that the prosecution suppressed the true genesis, that witnesses denying injuries are unreliable, or that a defence version explaining the injuries becomes probable. (Paras 18–19 cited) The court relied on this principle to hold that failure by the prosecution to explain injuries on the accused and to place counter-case material justified drawing an adverse inference about the prosecution's version and the origin of the occurrence.
Krishnan v. State of Haryana It is settled that mere failure of the prosecution to explain injuries on the accused cannot, by itself, be the sole ground for doubting the prosecution case if the evidence relied upon is otherwise credible. The court considered this authority but distinguished the present facts: although Krishnan allows the prosecution's case to stand despite unexplained minor defence injuries where other evidence is credible, the current case involved non-production of counter-case records and injuries that included skull injury — factors that, in the court's view, made reliance on eyewitnesses unsafe.
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Gajey Singh and another Refers to paragraph 32 which, after discussing Abdul Rashid etc., notes that where there is consistent evidence of injured eyewitnesses and independent witnesses, minor unexplained defence injuries may not demolish the prosecution case; but non-explanation of serious injuries may cast doubt. The court applied the distinction: it found that injuries on the accused included skull injury and were not merely superficial and hence non-explanation raised serious doubts about the prosecution version despite injured eyewitness testimony.
Abdul Rashid Abdul Rahiman Patel and others v. State of Maharashtra Discussed in the context that non-explanation of defence injuries can be a ground to discard the prosecution case where truthfulness of prosecution case is otherwise doubted. The decision was used by the court to support the proposition that where the prosecution's truthfulness is in doubt (here because of omission to place counter-case materials and unexplained defence injuries), the prosecution case may be discarded.
Lakshmi Singh v. State of Bihar Cited within the Babu Ram discussion as authority for drawing inferences from non-explanation of accused injuries. Referenced as antecedent authority forming part of the principle applied in Babu Ram; the court used the chain of authority to justify drawing adverse inferences from the prosecution's omissions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the factual matrix, pleadings and evidence. It accepted that: there was a quarrel between PW 1 and the second accused on the date of occurrence; PWs 1–8 (who are closely related to each other and to the deceased) gave parrot-like testimony attributing overt acts to the accused; medical and other documentary evidence (post-mortem, seizure mahazars, inquest report) supported the prosecution's account of the deceased's injuries and death.

However, the court observed a critical omission in the prosecution's presentation: none of the prosecution witnesses mentioned injuries on accused Nos. 1 and 2, and the prosecution failed to place before the court the complaint and other records pertaining to the counter-case (crime no. 624/2002) which arose from the same transaction. By contrast, the defence produced accident registers (exs. D1 and D2) through DW1 documenting multiple injuries on both accused, including cut injuries and a lacerated wound on the skull area of the accused.

Applying the authoritative principles set out by the Supreme Court (as in Babu Ram and related cases), the court explained that the non-explanation of defence injuries permits significant inferences: that the prosecution may have suppressed the genesis/origin of the occurrence, that witnesses who deny the presence of injuries may be unreliable, and that the defence version explaining the injuries becomes probable. The court distinguished decisions allowing conviction despite unexplained minor injuries (e.g., Krishnan) on the ground that here the injuries included a skull injury and were not merely superficial, and crucial court records relating to the counter-case were not produced by the prosecution.

Given these facts, the court concluded that the prosecution had not presented the true version and that the eyewitnesses had omitted or suppressed material parts of the transaction (specifically, the part where the accused were injured). Because the prosecution had failed to explain the accuseds' injuries and failed to place the counter-case documents, it was unsafe to convict accused Nos. 1 and 2 solely on the testimony of interested eyewitnesses, notwithstanding other prosecution evidence.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal was allowed. The court set aside the convictions and sentences of the appellants/accused Nos. 1 and 2 in Sessions Case No. 250 of 2003 and ACQUITTED them of all charges.

Direct consequences and orders pronounced by the court:

  • The convictions and sentences imposed on accused Nos. 1 and 2 are set aside; they are acquitted of all charges.
  • Any fine paid, if any, shall be refunded to the appellants/accused Nos. 1 and 2.
  • The bail bond executed by accused No. 2 (Sakila) is to stand cancelled.
  • Accused No. 1 (Sulian alias Chinnathambi) is directed to be released forthwith if his custody is not required in any other case.
  • The appeal is otherwise disposed as "Appeal allowed." (No further alteration of other accused's conviction was recorded in the operative part relating to accused Nos. 1 and 2.)

Broader implications: The court based its decision on established Supreme Court authorities regarding the significance of non-explanation of injuries on the accused and the prosecution's duty to place all relevant records of related counter-cases. The opinion did not purport to lay down a new precedent; it applied existing authorities to the facts of this case and rested its decision on the direct effect for the parties (acquittal and consequential orders).

Show all summary ...

T.Sudanthiram, J.:-

(1) The appellants herein, who are accused nos. 1 and 2 in sessions case no. 250 of 2003 on the file of the additional sessions judge, chidambaram, stand convicted and sentenced as follows: a. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi was convicted for the offences under sections 324 and 302 ipc and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for three years and to pay a fine of rs. 500/ - , in default, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for three months for the offence under section 324 ipc; to undergo life imprisonment and to pay a fine of rs. 1000/ - , in default, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year for the offence under section 302 ipc and the sentences were ordered to run concurrently. A. 2 - sakila was convicted for the offence under section 302 ipc and sentenced to undergo life imprisonment and to pay a fine of rs. 1000/ - , in default, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year. Aggrieved by the said conviction and sentence, the accused nos. 1 and 2 have preferred this appeal.

(2) The case of the prosecution, in brief, is as follows: p. W. 1 - alamelu is the wife of p. W. 2 - thiagarajan. Accused nos. 1 and 2 are husband and wife. A. 3 - madhiazhagan is the brother of a. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi. P. Ws. 1 and 2 are the neighbours of accused nos. 1 and 2. There was dispute between them with regard to fencing. There had been panchayat also in respect of it. A. 2 - sakila was searching for onion basket for past two days prior to the occurrence day. On 10. 12. 2002, at about 6 p. M. , when she found the onion basket in front of the house of p. W. 1 - alamelu, she questioned p. W. 1 - alamelu as to how it was available in front of her house. P. W. 1 - alamelu told a. 2 - sakila that if her plastic basket was available, she could take it to her house. A. 2 - sakila scolded p. W. 1 - alamelu saying that she had committed theft, in turn, p. W. 1 - alamelu also abused her. At about 7. 30 pm, a. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi returned to his house and a. 2 - sakila informed him about the occurrence. Then, a. L - sulian alias chinnathambi also started abusing p. W. 1 - alamelu. At that time, the deceased - thottiyathan, who was junior paternal uncle of p. W. 2 - thiagarajan, was sitting in front of the house. P. W. 2 - thiagarajan, the husband of p. W. 1 - alamelu and p. W. 3 - thangasamy and p. W. 4 - devendiran, who are the brothers of p. W. 2 - thiagarajan, also returned home and p. W. 1 - alamelu informed them about what had happened. A. 3 - madhiazhagan came there at that time and went to the house of a. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi. A. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi came out of the house with m. O. 1 - crowbar and attacked the deceased - thottiyathan on his head and a. 2 - sakila attacked the deceased - thottiyathan on his chest with a brick. P. W. 4 - devendiran tried to catch - hold of a. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi and at that time, a. 3 - madhiazhagan brought m. O. 2 - aruval from the house. And attacked p. W. 4 - devendiran with it on the head, right hand thumb, right leg and a. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi attacked p. W. 3 - thangasamy with m. O. 1 - crowbar on his head and left eyebrow. As p. W. 2 - thiagarajan tried to prevent it, a. 3 - madhiazhagan attacked him with m. O. 2 - aruval on his head, left side of chest and left leg. After attacking them, all the three accused ran away from the scene of occurrence. The occurrence was witnessed by p. Ws. 1 to 8. P. Ws. 9 and 10 took the deceased in tvs - 50 vehicle to p. W. 16 - dr,natarajan, who was available in that village. At about 8. 45 pm, p. W. 16 - dr. Natarajan on seeing thottiyathan, declared him dead. The body of the deceased - thottiyathan was brought back to house and laid down. P. Ws. 1, 3 and 4 went to the police station by walk as no bus facility was available at that time and p. W. 1 - alamelu gave complaint to p. W. 27 - sub inspector lakshmanan of kattumannarkoil police station and on receiving ex. P1 - complaint on 11. 12. 2002 at 2 a. M. , he registered a case in crime no. 623 of 2002 for the offences under sections 302 and 324 ipc and prepared ex. P13 - flrst information report. P. W. 28 - lnspector jayapal, on receiving the information, went to the police station at 9. 30 am on 11. 12. 2002 and received the copy of ex. P13 - fir. He went to the scene of occurrence at 10. 30 a. M. And prepared ex. P2 - observation mahazar and ex. P14 - rough sketch, in the presence of witnesses p. W. 14 - lakshmanan and p. 15 - ravi from the scene of occurrence, he recovered m. O. 3 - plastic basket and m. O. 4 - broken brick weighing about 1 kg under exs. P3 and p4 - mahazars respectively in the presence of same witnesses. He held inquest from 12. 15 p. M. To 3 pm on the body of the deceased - thottiyathan in the presence of panchayatars and prepared ex. P15 - inquest report. He gave ex. P5 - requisition for conducting post - mortem on the body of the deceased - thottiyathan. P. W. 17 - dr. Veeranarayanan received ex. P5 - requisition on 11. 12. 2002 at 5. 05 pm and conducted autopsy on the body of the deceased - thottiyathan on 12. 12. 2002 at 11 a. M. And found the following - "external injuries: 1) contusion about 3 inches x 2 inches behind the left. Ear pinna - on which 1 inch x 1 inch abrasion seen. 2) abrasion about inch x 1/2 inch on the left pinna dorsal aspect. 3) contusion about 2 inch x 2 inch on the left chest below and around the left nipple. 4) contusion about 2 inch x 2 inch over the occipital area of scalp. 5) abrasion about 1 inch x inch on the left upper scrotum. All injuries are anti - mortem. Internal examination: thorax: on opening the left side chest exposing the contusion - - subcutaneous and intramuscular haematoma present - underlying 5th and 6th ribs at left side were broken. On opening the thoracic cavity left side lung multiple laceration seen and about 1 litre of blood clots and fluids were present. Right lungs - congested - heart - empty. C/s pale. Hyoid bone intact. Stomach: partially digested food particle seen about 100 gms. Pelvis - no fracture. Spinal column - normal. Bladder - empty. Head: on opening the skull there is subcutaneous haematoma over the occipital area. The occipital bone fractured about 1 inch horizontally and 1/2 inch in oblique direction. About 100 gms of clotted blood in skull cavity - membrane intact. Brain - normal c/s pale. " he also opined that the deceased would have died of shock and. Heamorrhage due to head injury and left lung injury about 40 hrs to 42 hrs prior to post - mortem examination. Ex. P6 is the post - mortem certificate issued by him. P. Ws. 2, 3 and 4 were sent to the hospital on police memo and p. W. 17 - dr. Veeranarayanan examined p. W. 2 - thiagarajan at about 6. 10 pm on 11. 12. 2002 and noted the following injuries: "1) lacerated wound about 1 cm x cm x cm over the right side scalp - occipital area - dark red scab wound. 2) contusion about 3 cm x 2 cm over the left elbow joint - lateral aspect - dark colour. 3) abrasion about 1 cm x 1 cm over the right knee joint - dark colour scab wound. " he gave an opinion that the injuries are simple in nature and issued ex. P9 - accident register. P. W. 17 - dr. Veeranarayanan examined p. W. 3 - thangasamy at about 6 pm on 11. 12. 2002 and found the following injuries: "1) lacerated wound about 1 cm x cm x cm on the left side scalp - parietal area - covered dark coloured scab. 2) contusion about 2 cm x 2 cm on the left forehead above left eye brows - on which abrasion about cm x cm with dark brown scab wound. " ex. P8 is the accident register issued by him. P. W. 17 - dr. Veeranarayanan examined p. W. 4 - devendiran at about 6. 30 p. M. On 11. 12. 2002 and noted the following injuries: "1) lacerated wound about 1 cm x cm x cm over the scalp occipital area/dark colour scab around the wound. 2) contusion about 3 cm x 2 cm over the right leg - front - dark colour. 3) contusion about 2 cm x 1 cm over the right hand thumb - dorsum - dark red colour. " he also issued ex. P10 - accident register. P. W. 28 - inspector jayapal, who was in search of the accused, arrested both the accused no. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi and accused no. 2 - sakila on 11. 12. 2002 itself at 8. 15 p. M. At vadavaru neur echampoondi village and recorded the confession statement given by a. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi in the presence of p. W. 18 - gunasekaran and another. Ex. P11 is the admissible portion of it. In pursuance of the confession, he recovered m. O. 1 - crowbar and m. O. 2 - aruval from a bush near the bridge under ex. P12 - mahazar in the p resence of the same witnesses. Then, the accused nos. 1 and 2 were brought to the police station. A. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi gave a complaint and case was registered 11 pm in crime no. 624/2002 for the offences under sections 324 and 323 ipc and both the accused were sent to chidambaram government hospital through police memo. As the accused nos. 1 and 2 were admitted as in - patient in the hospital, requisition was given to the magistrate to remand them. P. W. 29 - inspector sankaran took up the further investigation and he investigated the case in both the crime numbers. On 13. 12. 2002, he examined p. W. 16 - dr. Natarajan and others. On 15. 12. 2002, he arrested a. 3 - madhiazhagan at 6. 30 a. M. Near bridge at kollidam railway colony and subjected him to judicial remand. On 18. 12. 2002, he examined p. W. 17 - dr. Veeranarayanan and recorded his statement. On completion of the investigation, he filed final report on 25. 5. 2003 against the accused. .

(3) To prove the case, the prosecution examined p. Ws. 1 to 29; marked exs. P. 1 to p. 16 and produced m. Os. 1 to 5.

(4) The accused were examined under section 313 cr. P. C. With regard to the incriminating circumstances and they denied their complicity. A. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi has stated that he and his wife were in the house and p. Ws. 2 to 4 entered the house and cut his hand with aruval and p. W. 4 - devendiran cut him with aruval on his right side of the head and they also beat on his left leg. A. 2 - sakila also has stated that p. W. 3 - thangasamy pulled her holding the hair and p. W. 2 - thiagarajan kicked her on chest and cut on her leg with aruval and p. W. 4 - devendiran beat her with a crowbar. P. W. 2 - thiagarajan again attempted to attack her on head and one kannan prevented it. A. 3 - madhiazhagan has stated that he was not connected with the occurrence and he was not present at the scene of occurrence and he was sitting on the sledge. D. W. 1 - dr. Santhi was examined and exs. D1 and d2 accident registers in respect of accused nos. 1 and 2 were marked on the side of the accused.

(5) The trial court, after considering the oral and documentary evidence, convicted and sentenced all the three accused, as stated above.

(6) The learned counsel for the appellant mr. Anthony jesus submitted that the prosecution has not come out with the true version with regard to the occurrence and the very genesis of the prosecution case is highly doubtful. The accused 1 and 2 have sustained injuries and the prosecution has not explained the injuries sustained by the accused. P. Ws. 1 to 8 are the relatives of the deceased and they are interested witness. The learned counsel further submitted that though counter complaint was registered on the basis of the complaint given by the first accused, the prosecution has not placed those materials. Even the accident registers in respect of accused nos. 1 and 2 have been marked by the defence as exs. D1 and d2 by examining the doctor d. W. 1. The learned counsel for the appellant has relied on the decision of the honourable supreme court in babu ram and others v. State of punjab.

(7) Per contra, the learned prosecutor submitted that p. Ws. 1 to 8 are the eyewitnesses to the occurrence and among them, p. Ws. 2 to 4 are the injured witnesses. Their evidence is consistent with regard to the occurrence. The injury sustained by the accused are not serious injuries. The investigating officer also registered a case in crime no. 624 of 2004 for the offences under section 324 and 323 ipc and after investigation, it has been referred and referred notice was also served to the first accused. The learned prosecutor further submitted that as the evidence of injured eye - witnesses are credible, the non explanation of the injury on the accused cannot be a ground for rejecting the prosecution case and he also relied upon the decision of the honourable supreme court in krishnan v. State of haryana.

(8) This court considered the submissions of both parties and perused the records carefully. According to the prosecution case, there was a dispute between p. W. 1 family and the accused family. Admittedly on the date of occurrence, there was a quarrel between p. W. 1 and the second accused. There had been exchange of words between them. According to the witnesses to the occurrence, it was only the first and second accused attacked the deceased with crowbar and brick. The first accused also attacked p. W. 3, third accused attacked p. Ws. 2 and 4 with aruval. All the witnesses p. Ws. 1 to 8 as a parrot like repetition spoken about the occurrence attributing overt act to the accused. But none of the witness had spoken about the injuries sustained by the accused 1 aid 2. Even ex. P. 1 complaint given by p. W. 1 nothing is stated about the accused being injured. According to the prosecution case, after the arrest of the accused 1 and 2, the complaint was received from the first accused and the case was registered in crime no, 624 of 2002 and both the accused were sent to the hospital and they were admitted as inpatient. In spite of that, the prosecution has not placed before the court the complaint given by the first accused. It is only on the defence side, d. W. 1, the doctor who treated a. 1 and a. 2 was examined and the accident registers are marked as exs. D. 1 and d. 2 in respect of accused nos. 1 and 2 respectively. D. W. 1 doctor had noted the following injuries on the first accused and issued ex. D. 1: "alleged to have been assaulted by five known persons on 10. 12. 2002 at 7. 30 p. M. At his residence by means of (matter in another language) 1. A cut injury 2 cm x1 cm x cm over the right forearm below the elbow dried blood present. 2. A cut injury 5 x 1 x cm over the right parietal region of scalp dried blood present. 3. Contusion 4 x 3 cm above the right knee. 4. Contusion 3 x 2 cm above the outer aspect of left thigh. 5. Contusion 3 x 2 cm over the left gluteal region injuries 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 are simple nature. Treated as inpatient. " d. W. 1 doctor had noted the following injuries on the second accused and issued ex. D. 2: "alleged to have assaulted by five known persons on 10. 12. 2002 at 7. 30 p. M. , at her residence by means of (matter in another language). 1) a cut injury 6 x 4 x 2 cm in front of right thigh lower c/3 (?) shape coyering the wound. 2) contusion 4 x 3 cm over the left gluteal region. 3) a lacerated wound 4 x 1 x cm over the right parietal region of scalp dried blood present. Injury nos. 1, 2, 3 are simple in nature. Treated as ip"

(9) It is not the case of the prosecution that the accused sustained injuries at different occurrence. The time of occurrence mentioned in the accident registers relating to the prosecution witnesses and also accident registers relating to the accused 1 and 2 are one and the same, i. E. , on 10. 12. 2005 at 7. 30 p. M.

(10) In the decision of the honourable apex court in babu ram and another v. State of punjab (supra) it has been observed in paragraphs 18 and 19 as follows: "18. It is a well - settled law that in a murder case, the non - explanation of the injuries sustained by the accused at about the time of the occurrence or in the course of altercation is a very important circumstance from which the court can draw the following inferences: - 1. That the prosecution has suppressed the genesis and the origin of the occurrence and has thus not presented the true version; 2. That the witnesses who have denied the presence of the injuries on the person of the accused are lying on a most material point and therefore their evidence is unreliable; 3. That in case there is a defence version which explains the injuries on the person of the accused it is rendered probable so as to throw doubt on the prosecution case. [see lakshmi singh v. State of bihar] 19. Further, it is important to point out that the omission on the part of the prosecution to explain the injuries on the person of the accused assumes much greater importance where the evidence consists of interested or inimical witnesses or where the defence gives a version which completes in probability with that of the prosecution one. " in the decision relied on by the learned prosecutor in krishnan and others v. State of haryana (supra) it is observed that "it is well - settled that merely because prosecution has failed to explain the injuries of the accused, the same cannot be a solitary ground for doubting the prosecution case, if otherwise, evidence relied upon is found to be credible. In the decision of the honourable supreme court in state of uttar pradesh v. Gajey singh and another, in which it has been observed in paragraph - 32 as follows: 32. A three - judge bench of this court in abdul rashid abdul rahiman patel and others, v. State of maharashtra, observed that it is well settled that if injuries on the defence are not explained by the prosecution, the same may be taken to be a ground to discard the prosecution case, in case the truthfulness of prosecution case is otherwise doubted. But in cases like the present one, where there is consistent evidence of the injured eyewitnesses apart from evidence of independent eyewitnesses, even if it assumed that the prosecution has failed to explain the minor and simple injuries on the defence, the same cannot be taken to be a ground to reject the testimony of such witnesses. In the instant case, the injuries were neither superficial nor minor therefore, non explanation of serious injuries in the instant case doubts the very genesis of the prosecution version. "

(11) In view of the ratio laid down by the honourable supreme court, this case has to be considered. All the eye - witnesses examined by the prosecution are closely related to each other and the deceased. It is well settled that the eye - witnesses of close relatives cannot be discredited, provided their evidence is cogent, consistent and trustworthy and stands close scrutiny. In the instant case, though a case was registered in crime no. 624 of 2002, on the basis of the complaint given by the first accused. The prosecution has not placed all the records including the complaint. When a case and counter case has arisen in the course of same transaction, it is the duty of the prosecution to place the records relating to both the cases and further duty is cast upon the prosecution to point out clearly the genesis of the occurrence, and thereby, enabling the court to find out the truth and fix the aggressors. Further out of five injuries sustained by the first accused, two of the injuries are cut injuries, one on the right fore arm and another on the right skeletal region on the skull. Out of the three injuries sustained by the second accused, one is the cut injury on the right thigh and another one lacerated wound over the right parietal region of scar. Though the injuries are described as simple injuries by the doctors, having sustained injury on the skull, it cannot be termed only as minor and superficial injuries. In view of the non - explanation of the injuries sustained by the accused and also due to failure on the part of the prosecution by not placing all the records pertaining to the counter case, this court is to draw the inference that the prosecution has not presented the true version and the origin of the occurrence is not established and the eye - witnesses have deliberately suppressed the part of the transaction in which the accused are injured. In the said circumstance, it is very unsafe to convict the accused placing reliance on the evidence of eye - witnesses.

(12) In the result, the criminal appeal is allowed and the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellants/accused nos. 1 and 2 in sessions case no. 250 of 2003 on the file additional sessions judge, chidambaram are set aside and the appellants/accused nos. 1 and 2 are acquitted of all the charges and the fine amount paid, if any, is to be refunded to them. The bail bond executed by accused no. 2 - sakila shall stand cancelled. The appellant no. 1/ accused no. 1 - sulian alias chinnathambi is directed to be released forthwith if his custody is not required in any other case. Appeal allowed.