- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M.M. Sabharwal v. Mahalakshmi Real Estates And Investments (P) Ltd.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners, identified as A-5 and A-6, are accused in three criminal cases (C.C Nos. 4307, 4308, and 4309 of 2004) pending before the VII Metropolitan Magistrate Court, George Town, Chennai. These cases pertain to offences under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, related to cheques issued in 2004. The petitioners filed a petition under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code seeking to quash these cases. They claim to have resigned as Directors of the first accused company in 1999, prior to the issuance of the cheques in 2004, and argue that the complaint lacks specific allegations against them. The petitioners also submitted statutory notices and copies of Form 32 evidencing their resignation, which they contend were not considered by the complainant before filing the complaint.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act can be maintained against petitioners who resigned as Directors of the accused company prior to the issuance of the cheques.
- Whether the absence of specific allegations and averments in the complaint against the petitioners, regarding their responsibility for the conduct of the company’s business at the relevant time, justifies quashing the proceedings against them.
- Whether the High Court can consider unimpeachable documentary evidence, such as Form 32, while exercising inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash the complaint.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- No specific allegations or averments are made in the complaint against the petitioners.
- The petitioners resigned as Directors in October 1999, before the cheques were issued in 2004.
- A statutory notice was issued and replied to, denying their directorship at the time of the cheque issuance, supported by Form 32 filed with the Registrar of Companies.
- The complainant did not consider the reply or documentary evidence and mechanically alleged that the petitioners consented and connived in the offence.
- Relied on the precedent set in B. Raman and others v. Shasun Chemicals and Drugs Limited, emphasizing the necessity of specific averments and the requirement to give an opportunity to explain the position of accused persons in the company before prosecution.
- Additional case law was cited to support the absence of allegations that the petitioners were responsible for the company’s business conduct at the relevant time.
Respondent/Complainant's Arguments
- Prima facie materials exist to substantiate the allegations in the complaint against the petitioners.
- Specific allegations state that the petitioners were Directors of the company when the loan transaction commenced in 1985 and that they were originally responsible.
- Even if the petitioners resigned subsequently, they should be considered accused, and these grounds can be contested during trial.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| B. Raman and others v. Shasun Chemicals and Drugs Limited, 2006 (4) CTC 529 | Requirement of specific averments that accused persons were in charge and responsible for the company’s business at the relevant time; necessity to consider replies to statutory notices before filing a complaint under Section 138 NI Act. | Used to hold that the complaint must specifically allege responsibility and connivance; the court found the complainant failed to consider the petitioners’ resignation and reply to the statutory notice. |
| Lachhman P. Udhani v. Redinton India Limited, 2006 (4) CTC 43 | Quashing of complaint when Directors resigned prior to issuance of cheque; defence documents like Form 32 can be considered in exceptional cases under Section 482 Cr.P.C. | Applied to support quashing of complaint against petitioners who resigned before cheque issuance. |
| State Of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi, 2005 (1) CTC 134 | High Court may consider unimpeachable evidence while exercising inherent powers to quash proceedings under Section 482 Cr.P.C. | Supported the court’s decision to consider Form 32 as unimpeachable evidence to quash proceedings against petitioners. |
| K.P.G Nair v. Jindal Menthol India Limited, (2001) (10) SCC 218 | General principle regarding specific allegations in complaints under Section 138 NI Act. | Referenced to substantiate absence of specific allegations against petitioners. |
| Monaben Ketanbhai Shah v. State of Gujarat, 2004 (4) CTC 317 (SC) | Requirement of specific averments in complaints under Section 138 NI Act. | Referenced to support petitioners’ contention regarding lack of specific allegations. |
| S.V Majumdar v. Gujarat State Fertilisers Company Limited, 2005 (3) CTC 380 (SC) | Principles relating to prosecution under Section 138 NI Act and responsibility of accused persons. | Referenced in context of specific allegations and responsibility. |
| S.M.S Pharmaceuticals v. Neeta Bhalla, 2005 (5) CTC 65 (SC) | Principles governing complaint under Section 138 NI Act. | Referenced to support petitioners’ arguments. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the timing and substance of the petitioners’ resignation as Directors, noting that the cheques were issued in 2004, whereas the petitioners resigned in 1999. The petitioners had replied to the statutory notice with documentary evidence (Form 32) evidencing their resignation, which the complainant failed to consider before filing the complaint. The court relied on established precedents that require specific allegations in the complaint that accused persons were in charge and responsible for the company’s business at the time of the offence. The court acknowledged that although Form 32 is generally a defence document, it can be considered under Section 482 Cr.P.C. if it is unimpeachable and of sterling quality. Finding the complaint contained only omnibus allegations without specific averments against the petitioners, and recognizing the failure to consider their resignation, the court concluded that the complaint against the petitioners constituted an abuse of process of law.
Holding and Implications
The court quashed the proceedings against the petitioners (A-5 and A-6) in so far as the offences under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act are concerned.
The learned Magistrate was directed to proceed with the trial against the other accused persons in accordance with law. The decision directly affects the petitioners by removing them from the criminal proceedings, but does not establish a new precedent beyond the application of existing principles. The court emphasized the importance of specific allegations and consideration of statutory notices and documentary evidence before prosecution under Section 138.
Petition filed under Section 482, Cr.P.C seeking to call for the records in C.C Nos. 4308, 4309, 4307 of 2004 now pending on the file of the VII Metropolitan Magistrate Court, George Town, Chennai and quash the same.
COMMON ORDER:
The petitioners are A-5 and A-6 in C.C Nos. 4307, 4308 and 4309 of 2004 on the file of the learned VII Metropolitan Magistrate, George Town, Egmore, Chennai for an offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act filed by the respondent/complainant.
2. The cheques in question in all these cases were issued during 2004. After observing formalities, the cases have been taken cognizance by the learned Magistrate.
3. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submit that there are no specific allegations and averments in the Complaint against the petitioners. The petitioners have resigned from the first accused-Company on 01.10.1999 and 15.10.1999 respectively and during the course of the issuance of the cheques, the petitioners were no more the Directors of the Company.
4. That a statutory notice has been given on 21.01.2004 for which a reply has been given on 06.02.2004, denying the allegation that the petitioners are Directors of the Company. Along with the notice, copies of Form 32, submitted before the Registrar of Companies have also been sent. The same has not been taken into consideration and mechanically without application of mind it has been alleged that the petitioners have consented and connived for the commission of the offence.
5. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners relied on a case B. Raman and others v. Shasun Chemicals and Drugs Limited, rep. by its Company Secretary, No. 3, Doraiswamy Road, T. Nagar, Chennai-600 017, 2006 (4) CTC 529, wherein it has been held as follows:
“The object of notice is to give a chance to the drawer of the cheque to rectify his omission and also to protect an honest drawer. Service of notice of demand in Clause (b) of the Proviso to Section 138 is a condition precedent for filing a Complaint under Section 138. By sending a notice to the Company as well as the persons in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the Company, he can make a demand, asking them to pay the amount. Some may reply that they are not in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the Company. Some may reply that they are not connected with the Company in any way and some may rectify the omission, by making efforts to pay the amount to the payee, in the name of the Company. In that event, the complainant may either drop the action of filing the Complaint or, in the event of non-payment of the cheque amount, he may choose the persons, who are really responsible for the commission of the offence and, then, initiate prosecution against them.
27. When it is a settled law, as laid down by the Supreme Court, that there must be a specific averment in the Complaint against the accused persons to the effect that they are in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the Company, during the relevant time the offence has been committed, with their connivance, i.e, all the more reason, the complainant shall give an opportunity to those persons to explain the complainant about their position in the Company. In other words, the complainant can prosecute the Company as well as the other Directors, only when he is satisfied that the persons, sought to be prosecuted, are in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the Company and also, in spite of the demand of the cheque amount through service of notice, they have not chosen to pay the amount within time.”
6. Learned counsel relied on the following decisions to substantiate that there are no allegations and averments in the Complaint to substantiate that the petitioners are in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the Company.
K.P.G Nair v. Jindal Menthol India Limited, (2001) (10) SCC 218
Monaben Ketanbhai Shah v. State of Gujarat, 2004 (4) CTC 317 (SC)
S.V Majumdar v. Gujarat State Fertilisers Company Limited, 2005 (3) CTC 380 (SC)
S.M.S Pharmaceuticals v. Neeta Bhalla, 2005 (5) CTC 65(SC)
Lachhman P. Udhani v. Redinton India Limited, 2006 (4) CTC 43
7. Per contra the learned counsel for the respondent/complainant submits that prima facie materials are available to substantiate the allegations in the Complaint. Specific allegations have been made that the petitioners are Directors of the Company. The loan transaction with the complainant commenced during 1985 and it was continuing. At that time the petitioners were Directors of the Company. They would have resigned subsequently. As they were Directors, originally, they must be taken as accused in the case and at any rate, these grounds could be agitated during the course of trial.
8. I have perused the materials available on record and heard the submissions made.
9. The cheques in question have been issued during January 2004. By way of reply notice dated 06.02.2004 the complainant has been informed about the resignation of the petitioners as Directors. Copies of Form 32 submitted before the Registrar of Companies, to substantiate the resignation, also has been enclosed. In spite of that, such aspect has not been taken into consideration in the private Complaint. It has been simply stated as follows:
“A-4 to A-10 being Directors of the accused comlpany are involved in the day to day affairs of the management of the first accused. The cheques were issued with the consent and connivance of all the accused.”
10. It has been held by this Hon'ble Court in B. Raman and others v. Shasun Chemicals and Drugs Limited rep. by its Company Secretary, No. 3, Doraiswamy Road, T. Nagar, Chennai-600 017, 2006 (4) CTC 529, that if an explanation is given to the statutory notice by way of reply, the same must be taken into consideration before filing of the Complaint. In a similar situation, in a case in Lachhman P. Udhani v. Redinton India Limited, 2006 (4) CTC 43, referred above, the case was quashed as Directors have resigned from the Company long prior to the issuance of the cheque.
11. Though Form 32 is a defence document, and such defence materials could not be looked into at the time of enquiry, exercising inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C, if the materials are of unimpeachable and sterling quality, the same could be looked into for the purpose of quashing the proceedings. This proposition has been held in the judgment reported in State Of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi, (2005(1) CTC 134:
“It is evident from the above that this Court was considering the rare and exceptional cases where the High Court may consider unimpeachable evidence while exercising jurisdiction for quashing under Section 482 of the Code.
12. The averments contained in Para 6 of the Complaint are omnibus allegation and there is no specific allegation against the petitioners. In spite of intimation of their resignation during 1999 the same was not taken into consideration. In such circumstances, I find that the Complaint against the petitioners is an abuse of process of law and liable to be quashed and accordingly the proceedings in so far as the petitioners are quashed. The learned Magistrate may proceed with the trial of the cases in accordance with law in so far as the other accused persons are concerned. These petitions are ordered accordingly. Consequently, connected Crl.M.Ps are closed.
Alert