- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramasamy v. Rukmani And Another
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This revision challenges the order of the Sessions Judge, Periyar District at Erode in Crl.R.P. No. 38 of 1991, which reversed the Judicial Magistrate, Kangeyam's order in M.C. No. 11 of 1990 concerning a maintenance claim under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
The first respondent (wife) and the revision petitioner (husband) had been living separately since 1982. The wife filed a petition under Section 125 CrPC alleging desertion and that the husband had married a second wife, claiming maintenance for herself and the second respondent (their daughter). The petition asserted that on 13.7.1982 a registered agreement (Ex.R-1) recorded a payment of Rs. 3,000 to the wife and Rs. 1,000 to the daughter as an interim maintenance arrangement, and that the husband was now employed drawing a salary over Rs. 1,500 so maintenance of Rs. 300 and Rs. 200 respectively should be paid.
The Magistrate dismissed the petition holding that the wife had executed a registered release deed (Ex.R-1) giving up her claim after receiving Rs. 4,000 lump sum; thus she could not again claim maintenance under Section 125 CrPC. On revision, the Sessions Judge reversed the Magistrate, holding the Ex.R-1 arrangement was temporary and ordered maintenance at Rs. 300 (wife) and Rs. 200 (child). The husband filed the present revision against the Sessions Judge's order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a registered release deed (Ex.R-1) by which a wife and her daughter accepted a lump-sum payment and purportedly gave up future claims for maintenance bars the wife and child from claiming maintenance under Section 125 CrPC.
- Whether a release deed executed by a parent can bind a minor child, particularly where the lump-sum paid for the child appears inadequate.
- Whether change of circumstances (husband's improved employment and increased cost of living) permits revival or enhancement of maintenance despite an earlier lump-sum agreement or release.
- If maintenance is payable, what should be the appropriate quantum in the circumstances of this case?
Arguments of the Parties
Revision Petitioner (Husband) — Primary Arguments
- The wife executed Ex.R-1 (a registered agreement) after receiving Rs. 3,000 for herself and Rs. 1,000 for the daughter; by that document she gave up any right to claim maintenance in future.
- Relying on precedents (Mohiswara Rao v. Durgamba and Kodukula Kameswaramma v. Kodukula Thammanna), the petitioner argued that a contract by a Hindu spouse accepting a fixed sum and giving up future claims is valid and bars subsequent claims for increased maintenance even if circumstances change.
- The petitioner urged that Ex.R-1 should therefore be treated as having extinguished the wife's right to claim maintenance under Section 125 CrPC.
Respondents (Wife and Daughter) — Positions Reflected in the Opinion
- The wife claimed maintenance on grounds of desertion and that the husband had taken a second wife and was living with her.
- The Sessions Judge (on revision) treated Ex.R-1 as only an interim arrangement and held the wife and daughter remained entitled to maintenance.
- The opinion also presents the position that the lump-sum payments (Rs. 3,000 and Rs. 1,000) were inadequate—particularly for the minor—and that the daughter cannot be bound by an agreement adverse to her interests signed by the mother on her behalf.
- The respondents relied on the fact of change in circumstances: the husband’s employment status improved (permanent employee drawing ~Rs. 1,500), and the rise in cost of living made the earlier lump-sum insufficient.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mohiswara Rao v. Durgamba, I.L.R 47 Mad. 308 | Holds that a contract by a Hindu widow to receive a fixed sum for maintenance and not to claim increases in future is a valid agreement and bars claims for increased maintenance. | The petitioner relied upon this decision to argue Ex.R-1 extinguished further claims. The court considered this reliance but found that the circumstances here (inadequacy of the lump-sum and later change in circumstances) did not permit absolute application of that principle to bar maintenance under Section 125. |
| Kodukula Kameswaramma v. Kodukula Thammanna, A.I.R 1939 Mad. 798 | Similar proposition: a party accepting a fixed sum and agreeing not to claim future increases cannot later claim enhanced maintenance. | Also relied upon by the petitioner. The court treated the precedent as distinguishable for the present facts, given the court's findings about adequacy and change of circumstances. |
| Bai Tahira v. Ali Hussain Fisalli, 1979 Crl.L.J. 151 | Established that lump-sum payments must be reasonable and effective as a substitute for periodical maintenance; illusory or inadequate lump sums cannot extinguish the right to maintenance. | The court applied the principle to hold that the Rs. 3,000 (wife) and Rs. 1,000 (child) were paltry and not a reasonable substitute for lifetime maintenance, supporting the respondents' right to claim additional maintenance. |
| Mohd. Ahmed Khan v. Shah Bano Begum, A.I.R 1988 S.C. 945 | While noting an error in Bai Tahira concerning mehar, the Supreme Court accepted the underlying principle that a reasonable lumpsum may be substituted but must be adequate; approved core aspects of Bai Tahira. | The opinion records that Mohd. Ahmed Khan endorsed the principle that lumpsum payment must be reasonable; the court relied on that acceptance to reinforce that the small lump-sum in this case could not bar additional maintenance. |
| Seshamma v. Thiyuuammal, (1963) 2 M.L.J. 408; A.I.R 1964 Mad. 217 | Interpreted Section 25 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956: amount of maintenance fixed by decree or agreement may be altered subsequently if there is a material change of circumstances. | The court relied on this decision to hold that even if an agreement existed, the wife could claim enhanced maintenance after the commencement of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, if material change of circumstances is shown (which the court found here). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded through the following analytical steps, each grounded in the facts and cited authorities as recorded in the opinion:
- Relationship and Desertion: The court noted that the marital relationship had not been legally dissolved—the husband had simply married a second wife and was living with her while the first wife lived separately. The court treated the husband's second marriage (without obtaining divorce) as a factor that supports the first wife's entitlement to separate residence and maintenance.
- Nature of Ex.R-1: The Sessions Judge had held Ex.R-1 to be interim. The revision petitioner argued Ex.R-1 was a valid release deed extinguishing future maintenance claims. The court examined Ex.R-1 and observed it stated the wife had given up her right to maintenance after receiving Rs. 4,000; however the court did not accept that the mere form of the document automatically barred future claims.
- Minor's Interests: The court emphasized that an agreement signed by the mother on behalf of the minor that is adverse to the minor's interests is not binding on the minor. It found Rs. 1,000 paid for the daughter to be manifestly inadequate to provide for a minor girl's maintenance until majority; thus the daughter could ignore the parental agreement adverse to her interests.
- Adequacy of Lumpsum: Applying the principle in Bai Tahira (and noting its approval in Mohd. Ahmed Khan), the court held that a lump-sum payment must be a reasonable substitute for periodical maintenance; an illusory or paltry amount cannot extinguish the right to maintenance. The court found Rs. 3,000 to the wife (paid in 1982) to be insufficient to preclude future claims.
- Change of Circumstances and Statutory Right: The court relied on the doctrine in Seshamma interpreting Section 25 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956: maintenance fixed by agreement or decree may be altered if there is a material change of circumstances. The court found two material changes: (a) the husband’s employment situation improved—he became a permanent employee drawing about Rs. 1,500 per month (an increase from being a lorry driver at the time of Ex.R-1), and (b) the cost of living had risen such that the earlier lump-sum was no longer sufficient.
- Conclusion from Application: On the combined basis of the inadequacy of the lump-sum, the non-binding nature of agreements adverse to a minor, and the existence of material change of circumstances recognized under Section 25 (and applied alongside Section 125 CrPC principles), the court concluded the wife and daughter were entitled to additional maintenance notwithstanding Ex.R-1.
- Quantum Consideration: The court took into account the husband's present salary and his duty to maintain himself and other family members. Balancing the husband's means and the prior lump-sum payment, the court adjusted the maintenance downward from the Sessions Judge's amounts and fixed Rs. 200 per month for the wife and Rs. 150 per month for the daughter as reasonable in the circumstances.
Holding and Implications
Holding: Subject to modification of the maintenance amounts, the revision is otherwise dismissed. The maintenance payable is modified to Rs. 200 per month to the first respondent (wife) and Rs. 150 per month to the second respondent (daughter).
Implications:
- Direct Effect on Parties: The husband (revision petitioner) must pay maintenance of Rs. 200 per month to his wife and Rs. 150 per month to his daughter. The earlier contention that Ex.R-1 extinguished future claims was not accepted as an absolute bar.
- Minor's Protection: The court expressly treated transactions adverse to a minor's interest as not binding on the minor; it found the Rs. 1,000 lump-sum inadequate for the daughter's maintenance and allowed her to claim recurring maintenance.
- No Broad New Precedent Announced: The decision applies and distinguishes existing authorities (as set out above) to the facts of this case; the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel principle beyond applying established authorities (Bai Tahira, Mohd. Ahmed Khan, Seshamma) and recognized rules regarding adequacy of lump-sum payments and protection of minors.
Result as Stated in the Opinion: The revision petition is dismissed except that the maintenance ordered is modified to Rs. 200 (first respondent) and Rs. 150 (second respondent). No order is necessary in Crl.M.P. No. 4533 of 1992 as a consequence of this result.
This revision is against the order of the learned Sessions Judge, Periyar District at Erode in Crl.R.P No. 38 of 1991 reversing the order of the Judicial Magistrate, Kangeyam in M.C No. 11 of 1990 in the claim of maintenance under Sec. 125, Code of Criminal Procedure.
2. The first respondent herein is the wife of the revision petitioner and after the birth of the second respondent herein, due to the incompatibility between them, they were living separately from the year 1982 onwards. The first respondent filed the petition under Sec. 125 Code of Criminal Procedure claiming maintenance alleging that her husband, the revision petitioner herein, had deserted her and also has married a second wife and therefore she is entitled to claim maintenance. She has also mentioned in the petition that on 13.7.1982 in the presence of the Panchayatdars Rs. 3,000 to the first respondent and Rs. 1,000 to the second respondent was paid as an interim arrangement for their maintenance and as the husband is now employed in Jeeva Transport Corporation drawing a salary of more than Rs. 1,500 they are entitled to maintenance at the rate of Rs. 300 and 200 respectively. The learned Magistrate, Kangeyam, dismissed the petition holding that the wife has executed a registered release deed giving up her claim for maintenance after receiving a lumpsum payment of Rs. 4,000 towards maintenance for herself and her children and she is not entitled to again claim maintenance under Sec. 125, Code of Criminal Procedure. On revision before the learned Sessions Judge, Periyar District, he reversed the findings of the learned Judicial Magistrate holding that the arrangement under the release deed 13.7.1982 was only temporary and therefore the revision petitioner herein is bound to pay maintenance to his wife and daughter. He fixed the maintenance at Rs. 300 to the wife and Rs. 200 to the child. As against this order of the learned Sessions Judge, the husband has come forward with his revision.
3. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits before me that though the first respondent herein was married to the revision petitioner in the year 1977, after a few years. She was reluctant to live with the revision petitioner, resulting in a panchayat, in which both parties had agreed to live separately and Ex.R-1 registered agreement also was executed by the first respondent after receiving a sum of Rs. 3,000 for herself and 1,000 for her daughter towards their maintenance and having agreed to live separately from her husband after receiving a lumpsum payment and also after giving up her right of maintenance under this document, the wife is not entitled to invoke Sec. 125, Code of Criminal Procedure claiming maintenance now. The learned counsel relied upon two decisions of this court in Mohiswara Rao v. Durgamba, I.L.R 47 Mad. 308 and Kodukula Kameswaramma v. Kodukula Thammanna, A.I.R 1939 Mad. 798, wherein it was held that a contract by a Hindu widow with her husband's copraceners to receive a fixed sum for maintenance and not to claim any increase in future maintenance even in case of change of circumstances, is a valid agreement and the widow is not entitled to claim any increase in the maintenance amount originally fixed even if there was change of circumstances. According to the learned counsel, in view of these decisions, as the first respondent had accepted Rs. 3,000 as maintenance for herself and Rs. 1,000 for her daughter under Ex.R-1 and has given up her right also to claim any maintenance in future, the right given up by them voluntarily under the registered instrument cannot be revived and therefore, the learned Sessions Judge is not correct in fixing the maintenance to the respondents herein. The learned Sessions Judge, Periyar District, has found that the arrangement under Ex.R-1 was only interim and therefore the wife and child are entitled to claim maintenance. But on a perusal of Ex.R-1, it does not seem to be an interim arrangement. It reads that the wife had given up her right of maintenance as she had received Rs. 4,000 as maintenance for herself and her daughter. Therefore, certainly it cannot be treated as an interim arrangement.
4. Even if it is taken that it is a release deed giving up the right to claim maintenance in future, the question is whether the wife and child are entitled to revive the claim of maintenance even if a lumpsum payment was made initially. It should be borne in mind that the relationship of husband and wife, between the revision petitioner and the first respondent is not snapped and still it continues. Secondly, it is admitted by the petitioner that he has married a second wife, and is living with her. Therefore, the first respondent herein is entitled to live seperately. Simply, because the revision petitioner herein had paid certain amount in the presence of the panchayatdars towards the maintenance of the respondents herein, he is not entitled to take a second wife. Even if he felt that he could not live with the first respondent herein, he should have initiated the proceedings for the divorce of the first respondent and then married a second wife. Without doing that, as he has married a second wife when his first wife is alive, the first wife is certainly entitled for a separate residence.
5. Even though the first respondent has executed the release deed Ex.R-1 for herself, and on behalf of her daughter, if the terms of the document are adverse to the interests of the minor, certainly the document is not binding upon the minor. Under this document only Rs. 1,000 has been paid to the minor daughter, for her maintenance. This cannot be said to be an adequate amount for the maintenance of a minor girl till she attains majority. Even this Rs. 1,000 may not be sufficient to maintain a minor girl for one year. Therefore, the first respondent cannot act against the interests of her daughter, the second respondent, and on this ground also, the second respondent is entitled to ignore this agreement between her parents.
6. The coming to the binding nature of this document upon the first respondent/wife, any agreement between the parties should be equitable and it should serve the purpose for which it was executed. Only Rs. 3,000 has been received by the first respondent for her maintenance till her life time. Within 5 years after the marriage, this agreement came into existence. Therefore, the first respondent must have been in her early 20s and therefore it cannot be stated that Rs. 3,000 paid under this document will be sufficient for her maintenance till her life time. In Bai Tahira v. Ali Hussain Fisalli, 1979 Crl.L.J 151 The Apex Court, while considering the claim of the maintenance of a divorced Muslim wife, has observed that the payment of illusory amounts by way of customery or personal law requirement will be considered in the reduction of maintenance rate but cannot annihilate the rate unless it is a reasonable substitute. It is further observed that the purpose of the payment under any customary or any personal law must be to obviate destitution of the divorce and to provide her with wherewithal to maintain herself, that the whole scheme of Sec. 127 (3) (b) is manifestly to recognise the substitute maintenance arrangement by lumpsum payment organised by the custom of the community or the personal law of the parties and there must be rational relation between the sum so paid and its potential as provision for maintenance to interpret, otherwise is to stultify the project. Eventhough the above expression refers to the project. Even though the above expression refers to the customary or personal law, by which lumpsum payment is payable, the ratio of the decision is that a lumpsum payment must be reasonable to meet the requirement and it cannot be to obviate the right to claim maintenance. Even though in the latest decision in Mohd. Ahmed. Khan v. Shah Bano Begum, A.I.R 1988 S.C 945, while referring to the above decision, the mistake therein with regard to the mehar amount, which is not intended for the maintenance, but is paid only as a mark of respect, the principle therein has been accepted by their Lordships of the Supreme Court. In paragraph 10 of the latter Judgement, it is observed, though Bai Tahira was correctly decided, we would like respectably, to draw attention to an error which has crept in the Judgement. Therefore, the principle laid down in Bai Tahira v. Ali Hussain Fisalli, 1979 Crl.L.J 151, has been approved by the later decision also. Therefore, the lumpsum payment by the husband to his wife towards maintenance, cannot be illusory but to meet the real needs of the wife towards her maintenance. It is needless to say that the paltry sum of Rs. 3,000 paid to the first respondent herein in the year 1982, will not be sufficient for her till her life time when especially she happens to be a young woman in the early twenties. Therefore, certainly, she is entitled to claim additional maintenance due to the change of circumstances, viz., the cost of living going up day by day.
7. In addition to these circumstances referred to above, the law also is settled now that irrespective of an agreement between the husband and wife with regard to any maintenance the wife is entitled to claim for increase of maintenance after the commencement of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956. This aspect has been considered by a Bench of this Court in Seshamma v. Thiyuuammal, (1963) 2 M.L.J 408: A.I.R 1964 Mad. 217. In that case, when the Hindu wife agreed to receive maintenance at a particular rate in a court proceeding, entered into a compromise and a compromise decree was passed fixing the rate of maintenance and also restricting her right to claim additional maintenance. However, this Court has found that after commencement of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 Sec. 25 of the Act gives right to the wife to claim enhanced maintenance in the event of change of circumstances. Sec. 25 reads, “the amount of maintenance, whether fixed by a decree of court or by agreement either before or after the commencement of this Act may be altered subsequently if there is a material change in the circumstances justifying such alteration.” Therefore, even if an agreement came into existence after commencement of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, the wife is entitled to ask for additional maintenance if the change of circumstances is proved. At the time of Ex.R-1 agreement, the revision petitioner was only a lorry driver and admittedly now he is permanent employee in Jeeva Transport Corporation drawing a minimum salary of Rs. 1,500 per month. This is a change of circumstance No. 1. The second change of circumstance is that the cost of living has gone up steeply and the meagre sum of Rs. 3,000 paid in the year 1982, may not be sufficient for her maintenance even for one year. Therefore that change of circumstances also cannot be disputed. Hence, certainly, the respondents who are the wife and daughter of the revision petitioner, are entitled to claim additional maintenance and invoke Sec. 125, Code of Criminal Procedure.
8. Coming to the quantum of maintenance as the revision petitioner's salary is around Rs. 1,500, he has to maintain himself and other family members. Therefore, I feel that Rs. 200 to the first respondent and Rs. 150 to the second respondent will be a reasonable amount taking into consideration the lumpsum payment made already. Therefore, the maintenance amount fixed by the lower court has to be modified accordingly.
9. In the result, subject to the modification of the maintenance amount to Rs. 200 and Rs. 150 to the first respondent and second respondent respectively, the revision is otherwise dismissed. In view of the order passed in the revision no order is necessary in Crl.M.P No. 4533 of 1992.
Alert