- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
S.P Sakthi Devi v. The Collector Of Salem, Salem.
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner claims to belong to the Scheduled Tribe Konda Reddy. She obtained a caste/community certificate from the Deputy Tahsildar, Sankari, dated 5 June 1976, and also secured a certificate from the 18th Metropolitan Magistrate, Saidapet, Madras, in the form prescribed under a Central Government circular for posts/services under the Central Government and related bodies. She was appointed as an Air Hostess in Indian Airlines under the Scheduled Tribe quota.
Indian Airlines (the fourth respondent) sought verification of the genuineness of the petitioner's caste certificate. The Collector of Salem (the first respondent) initiated enquiry proceedings through subordinate officers. On 19 November 1981, a Revenue Inspector conducted an enquiry in the village and recorded statements from the petitioner's father and ten others, all supporting her claim. In December 1981 the Tahsildar (third respondent) held an oral enquiry and received supportive statements. In January 1982 the Sub-Collector (second respondent) examined nearly ten persons who also supported the petitioner's claim. The petitioner produced nine documents in support.
The petitioner's paternal uncle, K.M. Raju, submitted a petition to the Collector alleging that the petitioner does not belong to the Konda Reddy community. The petitioner's father requested that if the uncle is examined, the petitioner should also be allowed to participate in the enquiry. Despite being informed of the familial dispute, the first respondent wrote on 1 December 1982 to the fourth respondent stating that the petitioner does not belong to the Konda Reddy community. Subsequently, the fourth respondent issued a show cause notice on 4 February 1982 proposing disciplinary action. The petitioner challenged the proceedings by filing W.P. No. 1236 of 1983 and sought to quash the first respondent's report dated 1 December 1982 in W.P. No. 1235 of 1983.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether public sector undertakings and other Central Government instrumentalities are bound to accept caste/community certificates issued by the authorities prescribed by the Central Government.
- Whether a caste/community certificate issued by a prescribed public authority constitutes a public document and is binding on other public authorities until it is cancelled.
- Whether an employer or disciplinary authority may, in disciplinary proceedings, independently adjudicate the genuineness of a caste/community certificate issued by a prescribed authority, or whether such matters must be verified/cancelled by the issuing authority or an authorised verifier (such as the District Collector).
- Who has the power to cancel a caste/community certificate and whether disciplinary proceedings may be initiated only after cancellation if the certificate is found to be false.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner relied on valid certificates, including one from the 18th Metropolitan Magistrate, a prescribed issuing authority under the Central Government's letter dated 5 August 1975, and therefore Indian Airlines (a Central Government instrumentality) was bound to act upon such certificate unless it had been cancelled by the competent authority.
- The first respondent acted improperly by relying on a hostile complaint from the petitioner's paternal uncle and did not afford the petitioner a fair opportunity to rebut that complaint. The reports of respondents 2 and 3 had been favourable, but the first respondent allegedly ignored those materials and forwarded a cryptic adverse report to the fourth respondent.
Fourth Respondent's Arguments
- The fourth respondent (Indian Airlines) contended that it has disciplinary jurisdiction to hold an enquiry and decide whether the caste certificate relied upon by the petitioner is genuine, and that no valid cause had been shown to prevent it from conducting such an enquiry even if revenue authorities or the Collector had submitted reports.
- It argued that upon encountering material suggesting possible falsity, the employer may decide on the correctness of the certificate and proceed with disciplinary action irrespective of whether the certificate issued by a competent authority had been cancelled.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| W.A. 783 of 1982 | Held that G.O.Ms. No. 1139 (Social Welfare), dated 23 March 1982, applied only to caste certificates required for State purposes and not to caste certificates for posts in the Central Government. | The Court relied on this holding to reject the contention that public sector undertakings and similar bodies are not bound by Central Government instructions on caste certificates; the Court held Central Government directives are binding on public sector undertakings and agencies receiving Central grants. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded through a series of legal determinations grounded in statutory interpretation, administrative policy documents, and the specific facts:
- The Court examined the Central Government's instructions (Brochure on Reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, 6th Edition (1982), Chapter 19) and concluded that the instructions relating to reservation and the authorities authorised to issue caste certificates (which include Presidency/Metropolitan Magistrates) are binding on Public Sector Undertakings, statutory and semi-government bodies and voluntary agencies receiving Central grants. Consequently, such bodies cannot choose to accept certificates only from authorities other than those prescribed by the Central Government.
- On whether a caste certificate is a public document, the Court rejected the submission that failure to secure certified copies of records (and the provisions of S. 74 of the Evidence Act) means a caste certificate is not a public document. The Court relied on S. 76 of the Evidence Act as addressing the nature of documents for which certified copies can be obtained and emphasized the public duty performed by the issuing officer. Where a document is issued under seal by a public functionary in the course of exercising public duties, it is a public document. Therefore a caste certificate issued in that manner is a lawful, valid public document until cancelled.
- The Court addressed the locus of power to cancel a caste certificate. Citing S. 21 of the General Clauses Act, the Court noted that a power to make an order includes the power to rescind it; hence the empowered issuing authority or its superior alone may cancel a caste certificate. Until such cancellation, other public authorities are bound to treat the certificate's contents as correct.
- On whether an employer may decide the genuineness of a certificate in disciplinary proceedings, the Court held that an employer cannot, in disciplinary proceedings, re-open the question of genuineness of a certificate that is valid and uncancelled. The correct course where doubt arises is to seek verification from the District Magistrate/Collector (paragraph 14.3 of Chapter 14 in the Brochure), who is the competent verifying authority. The appointing authority may appear in the verification enquiry and place materials before the Collector.
- The Court recognized safeguards for employers: if, after verification, the Collector cancels the certificate or finds it false, disciplinary proceedings (including termination) may follow. Conversely, if the Collector's verification report confirms genuineness, the certificate holder cannot be subjected to further enquiries in disciplinary proceedings to prove caste/community.
- Applying the legal principles to the facts, the Court noted that respondents 2 and 3 had conducted enquiries that produced supporting evidence (including sworn statements and documentary material such as an unregistered 1926 sale deed referencing Konda Reddy). The Sub-Collector concluded there was overwhelming evidence supporting the petitioner's claim. By contrast, the first respondent's adverse communication relied upon hostile family members' oral claims without contra documentary evidence and without properly considering the favourable reports and materials. The Court found that the first respondent's communication of 1 December 1982 was illegal and perverse.
- Consequently, the Court concluded that the petitioner had satisfactorily established that she belonged to the Konda Reddy community and that the certificate issued by the 18th Metropolitan Magistrate remained valid (having not been cancelled). Therefore the fourth respondent could not proceed against the petitioner on the basis that she had produced a false certificate.
Holding and Implications
Both writ petitions are allowed.
Direct holding and operative consequences explicitly stated by the Court:
- A caste/community certificate issued by an empowered public authority under seal continues to be a valid document until it is cancelled by that authority or by a superior authority.
- Such certificates' contents are to be treated as correct by every public authority, undertaking, body or institution bound by instructions relating to such certificates, so long as they are not cancelled.
- The genuineness or correctness of such certificates cannot be gone into in disciplinary proceedings; instead, the department or employer may ask the issuing authority or the District Collector to verify the certificate and may participate in that verification process and place materials before the verifying authority.
- If the certificate is cancelled by the empowered authority, disciplinary proceedings can then be initiated for furnishing false information.
- Appointing authorities have the right to seek verification of the genuineness of certificates by approaching the District Magistrate/Collector or other constituted verifying authority; once the verifying report affirms genuineness, the certificate holder cannot be further required to prove caste/community in other proceedings.
- Where verification is caused, the Collector must follow the procedure laid down in the Government of Tamil Nadu letter dated 7 July 1983.
- The Central Government's instructions relating to the issue of caste certificates for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (as reflected in Chapter 19 of the Brochure) are binding on public sector undertakings, statutory and semi-government bodies, and voluntary agencies receiving Central grants.
Immediate practical outcome in the case: the impugned communication by the first respondent dated 1 December 1982 was held to be illegal; the fourth respondent cannot proceed against the petitioner as if she had produced a false certificate. Both writ petitions were allowed and costs were awarded against the first respondent (advocate's fee fixed at Rs. 250 per set).
This summary is confined strictly to the material and conclusions contained in the provided opinion.
1. The petitioner in these petitions claims that she belongs to Scheduled Tribe Konda Reddy and that she has obtained a caste certificate to that effect from the Head quarters Deputy Tahsildar, Sankari, on 5th June, 1976. She was appointed as an Air Hostess in Indian Airlines under the quota reserved for Scheduled Tribes. At that time, she secured a certificate from the 18th Metropolitan Magistrate, Saidapet, Madras, in the form prescribed under circular issued by the Central Government relating to posts-services in the Central Government and in Public Sector Undertakings, Statutory and Semi-Government Bodies, and voluntary agencies receiving grants and aid from the Central Government. She came to know that the fourth respondent-Indian Airlines had sought for verification regarding the genuineness of the caste certificate. The first respondent-Collector of Salem had initiated enquiry proceedings through his subordinate officers. On 19th November, 1981, the Revenue Inspector came to the village and conducted an enquiry in which statements were obtained from the petitioner's father and ten other persons. All of them gave statements in support of her claim. Again in December, 1981, the third respondent-Tahsil-dar, Sankari, conducted an oral enquiry in the presence of the Revenue Inspector and here again, the persons who have appeared before him have deposed in her favour. Again in January, 1982, when the second respondent Sub-Collector, Sankari came for holding an enquiry, nearly ten persons were examined, and they also supported the petitioner's claim. On her behalf, nine documents were produced. She was made to understand that respondents 2 and 3 have sent reports to the first respondent stating that she is a Konda Reddy. On coming to know that her paternal uncle Mr. K.M Raju, out of jealousy and family feud, had submitted a petition to the first respondent stating that she does not belong to Konda Reddy, her father sent a petition to the first respondent to the effect that if his inimical brother is examined, the petitioner should also be permitted to participate in the enquiry. In spite of having been made aware of these factors, the first respondent had written on 1st December, 1982, to the fourth respondent, stating that the petitioner does not belong to Konda Reddy community, which had resulted in the fourth respondent issuing a show cause notice on 4th February, 1982, calling upon her to submit her representations against the proposal to take disciplinary action against her. Challenging this proceeding, W.P 1236 of 1983 is filed. W P. 1235 of 1983 is filed to quash the report of the first respondent dated 1st December, 1982.
2. On behalf of the petitioner, it is contended that when a valid certificate had been secured from the 18th Metropolitan Magistrate, Madras, who is one of the prescribed authorities authorised to issue a caste certificate as per the letter of the Central Government dated 5th August, 1975, the fourth respondent being an instrumentality or agency of the Central Government and wholly owned by it is bound to act upon such a certificate, unless and until the said certificate is cancelled. On the approach made by the first respondent, it is stated that in spite of himself being put on prior notice that the petitioner's paternal uncle out of family feud had come forward with a false complaint, his statement had been relied upon for the impugned report, and that she was not afforded a fair opportunity of rebutting this claim. She states that in spite of all the efforts taken to produce several materials before respondents 2 and 3, who in their turn had forwarded their reports in her favour, the first respondent had deliberately avoided referring to those materials, but forwarded a cryptic report to the fourth respondent relying upon the statements given by her sworn enemies.
3. On behalf of the fourth respondent, Mr. N.G.R Prasad, learned counsel, strenuously pleads that the fourth respondent has the necessary disciplinary jurisdiction to hold an enquiry and decide whether the caste certificate relied upon by the petitioner is genuine or not. He submits that no valid cause has been made out to stall the fourth respondent from conducting an enquiry irrespective of whatever be the reports that may be submitted by the Collector or other Revenue authorities. Having come across certain materials, it cannot be prevented from taking a decision about the correctness, of the certificate, irrespective of the fact whether the certificate already issued by the competent authority is cancelled or not.
4. In W.A 783 of 1982, this Court held that G.O.Ms No. 1139, Social Welfare, dated, 23rd March, 1982, issued by the Government of Tamil Nadu would be applicable only in respect of caste certificates required for its purposes and not in respect of caste certificates required to be produced for posts in Central Government. A contention is taised to the effect that the fourth respondent and similarly placed Public Sector Undertakings, Nationalised banks and other instrumentalities or agencies of the Central Government have the right to decide, whether the caste certificates issued by the authorities alone could be acted upon, irrespective of whatever be the directives of the Central Government as found in its letter, dated 5th August, 1975, read with earlier instructions. In Chapter 19 of the Brochure on Reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in Services, 6th Edition (1982). at page 286 (hereinafter referred to as the Brochure), it is stated thus—
“19.1 The various instructions given in this Brochure relate to reservations for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in posts/services under the Government. The Public Sector Undertakings, Statutory and Semi-Government Bodies, etc., under the control of the Government, have also been asked to make reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled tribes in their services on the lines of the reservations in services under Government by separate instructions as mentioned in the following paragraphs.
Paragraph 19.2 deals with the directives forwarded by the Bureau of Public Enterprises to the administrative Ministries for issue to the Public Undertakings. One of the innumerable instructions given in the Brochure relates to how and in what manner caste certificates are to be obtained, and as to which of the authorities are authorised to issue them. A Presidency Magistrate is one such authority. When instructions issued by the Central Government relating to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes are binding on its Public Sector Undertakings and even voluntary agencies receiving grants-in-aid from the Central Government, the plea raised by more than one counsel appearing on behalf of Nationalised Banks and their Recruitment Board, Indian Airlines and like institutions that they are not bound by the instructions issued by the Central Government in this regard, has to be necessarily rejected. They have no right to make a choice and claim that they would accept the certificate issued only by one of the prescribed authorities or any authority other than what have been prescribed by the Central Government.
5. The next contention is that a caste certificate is not a public document and it is only a communication reflecting the statement of facts and hence, irrespective of whether the issuing authority or the Collector/District Magistrate in the District had cancelled it or not, it is open to the employer to hold an enquiry and decide about the correctness of the certificate, and further pursue with the disciplinary proceedings against the concerned personnel. The caste certificate is issued by a publx authority authorised to issue it after holding an enquin, as circumstances may warrant. It is a public duty to be discharged by a public servant, on authority conferred upon him to issue such a certificate The contention on behalf of the fourth respondent and by the Central Government Standing Counsel is that a caste certificate is not conclusive of what is contained therein, and the employer has the jurisdiction to decide upon the correctness of the claim made therein, by calling upon the certificate holder to adduce eviderce in support of the contents of the certificate, and failing which, suitable action could be taken against the certificate holder. In support of the claim that it is not a public document, it is stated that when certified copy could not be secured of the records relating to issue of caste certificate, it would not come within the definition of ‘public document’ under S. 74 of the Evidence Act. This contention lacks strength because S. 76 of the Evidence Act takes care of the nature of documents in respect of which alone certified copies could be obtained. Hence, this aspect cannot be a determinative factor to hold as to whether a caste certificate is a public document or not. What is paramount is to find out whether in the course of discharge of public duties, the concerned public authority is enjoined to discharge the public duty, and if so, then the document which comes into existence consequent to such public duties, issued with seal and authority of his office would be a public document. Once a caste certificate comes into existence in this form any other public functionary is duty bound to act upon the same. On being issued, it is a lawful and valid document. So long as it is not canceled in the eye of law, it being a valid document, the holder of it, could rely upon it to establish his caste. Except the prescribed authority, no other authority or public bodies or undertakings, etc., having been conferred with powers to issue caste certificates, he cannot choose to declare in any proceeding and more so in disciplinary proceedings, that the valid caste certificate contains false particulars. Further in G.O.Ms No. 9, Social Welfare, dated 3rd January, 1983, instructions were given that records of local enquiry must be maintained, as permanent records for verification in future, which is also indicative of the fact that caste certificate is a public document Hence, it is held that a caste certificate is a public document.
6. The next point taken is, when the power to cancel a caste certificate has not been conferred on empowered authorities, there is no need for the concerned employer to wait till the concerned authority cancels the certificate, and only thereafter take a decision about the correct caste of the candidate or employee or servant. Under S. 21 of the General Clauses Act, a power to make an order includes the power to rescind it. Hence, the empowered authority who had brought into existence the lawful and valid caste certificate or his higher authority alone could cancel a caste certificate. Unless and until it is done, all public authorities in Central Government and Public Sector Undertakings and bodies, etc., which are under its control are bound to treat the contents of such certificate as correct.
7. Yet another contention taken is, in spite of becoming aware of the falsity of such certificate, they would be compelled to keep those certificate holders in service-employment in spite of powers vested in them to initiate disciplinary proceedings and that such a situation should not be allowed to exist. Here again, this argument overlooks the enablement provided in Chapter 14 to verify the correctness of caste certificate if deemed necessary. Paragraph 14.3 in Chapter 14 enables an appointing authority if considered necessary for any reason to verify the claim of a candidate through the District Magistrate of the place where himself or his family ordinarily resides. Hence, at tte titre of remand itself io such of those cases wherein any doubt is entertained, an opportunity is to be given to vouchsafe the correctness or genuineness of the certificate. Irrespective of the several categories of empowered authorities, if the question of verification arises, a highly responsible authority being the District Magis'rate-Collector, is authorised to verify the correctness of the certificate. This Court considers that the Central Government after considerable care had chosen only responsible auiborities, on whom the concerned Governments have disciplinary control, to issue such certificates and furthermore, an enablement having been provided in such of those cases, where a verification is necessary, to ascertain the correctness of the certificate, no prejudice is caused to recruiting bodies in acting upon such authorised caste certificates. Further-more, if alter remand had been made, circumstances warrant a verification to be made and if it is proved that the candidate's claim is false, then he may be terminated in accordance with the relevant rules/orders. This being sufficient safeguard provided to act upon caste certificates, the concerned employer cannot insist upon taking a decision regarding the correctness of the caste certificates in disciplinary proceedings.
8. On the contention that for a false representation made or for filing a not genuine document in support of employment, the power vests in the appointing authority to initiate disciplinary proceedings, and therefore, in the said proceedings, the disciplinary authority has the right to decide whether a caste certificate is genuine or not, it has to be held that it being a public document authorised to be issued with seal, and the empowered authority, having the jurisdiction to rescind it if it is found to be incorrect, and added to all these, in deserving cases, when the Collector could be called upon to verity about their genuineness, and in such an enquiry, the concerned authority could place whatever materials it had come across and once it is determined by the Collector that the contents of the certificate are true and correct, thereafter the same could not be subjected to any further enquiry in a disciplinary proceeding. If the Collector cancels the certificate, undoubtedly, on the basis of such a report, disciplinary action could be taken to terminate the services of the certificate holder. This is precisely staed in paragraph 14.3 in Chapter 14.
9. When verifications are called for, as to what procedure is to be followed, the Government of Tamil Nadu in letter dated 7th July 1983 had stated that a Collector can cancel a community certificate issued by a subordinate officer when it is found to be false. As to what he had to do under such circumstances, clear-cut directives having been issued, the recruiting agency or bodies/institutions, etc., will have to look to the Collector regarding the genuineness or otherwise of the certificate. The procedure followed by him having been specifically stated and the consequences which would fall not only on the candidate but also on the issuing authority, if the caste certificate is proved to be false, there is absolutely no scope to accept the contention of some of the counsel appearing for those bodies that the empowered authorities would act in an irresponsible manner. When the Central Government had issued directives, as to how these caste certificates are to be issued and acted upon, and particular relating to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, the policy of the Government is not to cause undue hardship to them. In proving their caste, it is just and proper to hold that, unless and until a caste certificate is cancelled it is binding on all concerned authorities/institutions/bodies undertakings, etc.
10. As for the petitioner, she filed not only a certificate issued by a Deputy Tabsildar but also by the 18th Metropolitan Magistrate, Madras. Her S.S.L.C, certificate states that she belongs to Scheduled Tribe. The Headmaster of Government High School, Sinnappampatti has certified that she belongs to Indian Hindu Konda Reddy Community. The sale deed dated 30th December, 1926 in favour of her grand father mentioning therein the words was produced. This was executed on a stamp of that year. It was not registered. Several persons examined by respondents 2 and 3 have stated that her father is a Konda Reddy. The Collector of Ramnad in his circular, taking note of the attitude of the subordinate officers being reluctant to issue community certificates in respect of Konda Reddy ommunity, had stated that even if no documentary evidence is available, sworn affidavit by the person/parent/guardian in stamp paper with two respectable persons stating about community may be obained. Certifying authority can make enquiry and verify with villagers conceined and the community people before issuing the certificate. Now in this case, several persons have supported the claim of the petitioner. In spite of such materials existing, the first respondent had relied upon the allegations made in the petition filed by K.N Raju, the paternal uncle of the petitioner, who had himself stated that between himself and the father of the petitioner dus to partition dispute, they are not on talking terms. The other complainant is P.R Radhakrishnan, who is the son of the petitioner's aunt. Except the oral claims made by them, they had not produced any contra documentary evidence to dislodge the reliance placed by the petitioner on the basis of ancient documents, etc. The Tahsildar, Sankaii, the third respondent in his report dated 10th December, 1981, had stated that the villagers have given sworn statements and since the sale deed of 1926 specifically refers to Konda Reddy, the petitioner belongs to the said caste. The second respondent—Sub-Collector, who is an I.A.S officer, after considering all details not only of the content of documents, but also the claims made by all deponents had come to the conclusion that there is overwhelming evidence in support of the claim of the petitioner. In spite of such materials and reports existing the first respondent who had already issued a circular that Konda Reddy community is non-existent in Salem District, had chosen to rely on oral claims made by two complaints, who are close relations to the petitioner and who are admittedly inimical towards her and there being total absence of consideration of the contents of the reports submitted by respondents 2 and 3 and the materials produced by the petitioner, the impugned communication of the first respondent dated 1st December, 1982 is illegal, as the conclusion arrived at therein is obviously perverse. As pointed out by the Sub Collector when overwhelming evidence exists in support of the claim of the petitioner, it is fruitless to remit the matter for passing fresh orders, as claimed by the counsel for the first respondent. The certificate issued by the 18th Metropolitan Magistrate Madras, being a competent authority to issue such a certificate, and it having not yet been cancelled, and the petitioner having satisfactorily established that she belongs to Konda Reddi community, there is no warrant for any further enquiry to beheld. But for the illegal and invalid communication of the first respondent, the fourth respondent would not have issued the impugned show cause notice. Now that it is held that the petitioner is a Konda Reddy and the certificate of 18th Metropolitan Magistrate being a valid certificate, the fourth respondent cannot further proceed against the petitioner as if she had produced a false certificate. Hence, it is held that—
1. A Caste/Community certificate issued by an empowered public authority under seal continues to be a valid document till it is cancelled by the said authority or by his superior authority.
2. Their contents are to be treated as correct and every public authority, undertakings, bodies, institutions, etc., which are bound by instructions relating to such certificates, are bound to act upon them, so long as they are not cancelled.
3. In no disciplinary proceedings, their genuineness or correctness of their contents can be gone into. It is open to the department or employer or organisation, to ask the issuing authority or District Collector, as the case may be, to verify whether the certificate as issued could be still valid, on materials which have since come to their knowledge, They can appear in the verification enquiry and place the materials.
4. If the certificate is cancelled, then disciplinary proceedings can be initiated for having furnished false information.
5. Appointing authorities have the right to verify the genuineness of the certificates by approaching the District Magistrate—Collector of the District or such other constituted authority and once the report is received that the certificate is genuine, thereafter the certificate holder cannot be further harassed to prove his caste/community in any other manner.
6. In causing verification, the Collector is bound to follow the procedure laid down in letter dated 7th July, 1983 of Government of Tamil Nadu.
7. In view of what is stated in Chapter 19 of Brochure on Reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, in services, 6th edition (1982), the instructions issued by the Central Government from time to time relating to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, pertaining to issue of caste certificates are binding upon public sector undertakings, statutory and semi-Government be dies and volunary agencies receiving grant-in-aid from the Central Government, as provided therein.
11. For the reasons stated above, both the writ petitions are allowed with costs payable by the first respondent. Advocate's fee Rs. 250 one set.
VCS.
Alert