- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Industries Pro... v. Spl. Tahsildar (Land...
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This matter concerns land acquired for the benefit of a State Undertaking (a Corporation) whose possession of the lands was taken in 1981. In proceedings before the Land Acquisition Officer the compensation was initially fixed at Rs. 40 per cent. The Subordinate Judge at Tiruvellore fixed compensation at Rs. 500 per cent after recording evidence. The petitioner (the State Undertaking) challenged the award by filing writ petitions contending it had not been made a party to the Land Acquisition Original Petition (O.P.) proceedings. This Court allowed those writ petitions by order dated 10-11-1986, set aside the award and directed the Subordinate Judge, Tiruvellore to dispose of the Land Acquisition O.P. proceedings on or before 28-2-1987 after impleading the petitioner and giving it an opportunity to oppose.
The petitioner was impleaded and evidence was being recorded. The petitioner then filed an application for transfer to this Court alleging bias by the Subordinate Judge and alleging the judge was not recording questions posed to the Land Acquisition Officer or the officer's answers. The Land Acquisition Officer (Sathyanarayanan / Satyanarayana), who had filed an affidavit in the transfer proceedings, stated that on 8-4-1987 a question put by petitioner's counsel was disallowed and that the officer's evidence had been wrongly recorded and later corrected at his instance when signing the deposition.
This Court dismissed the transfer petitions but directed the Subordinate Judge to permit the petitioner to recall the witness (Sathyanarayanan) and cross-examine him regarding location of the Church and other relevant facts, and to permit the petitioner to adduce further evidence before disposing the matter, “uninfluenced by any of the observations made in this order.”
Proceedings at the Sub Court, Tiruvellore, show multiple adjournments in August 1987. On several listed dates the petitioner failed to procure the presence of the witness despite summons being served and despite the witness's residential address being close to the Court. The Subordinate Judge ultimately reserved orders and passed the award on 7-10-1987 after discussing the evidence on record.
On 2-11-1987 the petitioner applied to set aside the award dated 7-10-1987, describing it as ex parte, and filed an affidavit alleging reasons for non-production of the witness (including administrative/office procedural issues and that the petitioner had applied for Special Leave in the Supreme Court). The Subordinate Judge rejected that application as it was filed after the award had been passed. The petitioner then filed the present revision petition in this Court challenging that rejection.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the award dated 7-10-1987 can be treated as an ex parte order and accordingly set aside where the petitioner says it was not given the opportunity to recall and examine the Land Acquisition Officer as directed by this Court.
- Whether the Subordinate Judge failed to obey this Court's direction to recall and permit cross-examination of the witness (Sathyanarayanan), and whether such failure renders the subsequent award a nullity.
- Whether the petitioner (a State Undertaking and beneficiary of acquisition) can rely on alleged non-compliance or procedural difficulties to avoid the consequences of not producing its witness despite multiple opportunities.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The award of 7-10-1987 was effectively an ex parte order because the Subordinate Judge did not recall or examine the Land Acquisition Officer as directed by this Court and proceeded to pass the award without giving the petitioner adequate opportunity to examine relevant witnesses.
- The petitioner (Corporation) asserted it requested sufficient time to secure the presence of the official witness (Sathyanarayanan) who was employed in another department and that administrative/office problems (including petitions being returned for rectification) prevented timely presentation of reopening petitions to the Sub Court.
- The petitioner argued the Subordinate Judge should have secured the presence of the official witness because the witness was a party to the I.A.O.P. proceedings and an official witness, implying the Government had responsibility to ensure his attendance.
- The petitioner relied on precedent (including Kausalya Devi v. Land Acquisition Officer and a Division Bench decision in M/S. M.A.V.R Nataraja Nadaraja & sons v. M/S. PRK Nadar & Co.) for the proposition that an order passed after considering evidence can nonetheless be an ex parte order or a nullity where directions were not complied with.
Respondent / Other Party Materials and Court Record
- The Land Acquisition Officer (Sathyanarayanan) filed an affidavit in the transfer petition describing his status and address and stating that a question put on 8-4-1987 was disallowed by the Subordinate Judge and that an answer he gave was recorded as agricultural land though he had said the land purchased for the Church was unfit for cultivation; that was corrected when he was asked to sign his deposition.
- The record of the Sub Court reveals repeated adjournments and instances where either the petitioner or counsel failed to be present and the witness did not appear despite summons having been served. The Subordinate Judge recorded these procedural steps and ultimately considered the evidence on record and passed the award.
- This Court (in its earlier order refusing transfer) expressly left remedies open to the petitioner: revision in the High Court, appeal against the eventual award, or remedy under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894; and the Supreme Court (on Special Leave) also dismissed the petition, noting there was no ground for transfer and pointing to the statutory remedies available.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Collector, Land Acquisition, Ananthag and another v. M.S.T. Katiji and others (1987 2 S.C.C. 107) | The doctrine of equality before the law: all litigants, including the State as a litigant, must be accorded the same treatment and the law administered in an even-handed manner. | The Court invoked this principle at the outset to emphasize that State Undertakings are not above procedural obligations and to justify criticism of the petitioner's dilatory tactics; the principle supported the conclusion that the petitioner should not be permitted to delay proceedings intended to fix compensation. |
| Kausalya Devi v. Land Acquisition Officer, Aurangabad (Supreme Court decision cited in text) | Addresses consequences when an appellate court's directions on remand are not followed; in that case the Supreme Court found the subsequent judgment to be a nullity because the High Court did not follow remand directions properly. | The Court considered this authority but distinguished it: the facts in Kausalya Devi (no fresh evidence and remand issues) were said to have "no resemblance whatever" to the present case, so the precedent did not support the petitioner's claim that the award was a nullity for non-compliance. |
| M/S. M.A.V.R. Nataraja Nadaraja & Sons v. M/S. PRK Nadar & Co. (Division Bench of this Court) | Principle that an order passed after considering evidence may nonetheless be an ex parte order if one party remained absent and had not let in any evidence (in that case the Division Bench held a decree was under O.XVII R.2 and ex parte in nature despite some proceedings). | The Court distinguished that case: there, defendants had not let in any evidence. In the present matter the petitioner and Government had already let in evidence (including examination of Sathyanarayana and three witnesses) and the Government's evidence served effectively as petitioner's evidence regarding valuation; therefore the Division Bench ruling was not applicable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeds on a fact-based and procedural footing, applying the legal principles discussed in the cited authorities and the record of proceedings. The principal strands of the Court's reasoning are:
- On the scope of the earlier direction: This Court's earlier order directed that the petitioner be permitted to recall the witness (Sathyanarayana) and cross-examine him. The Court construed that direction as placing the obligation on the petitioner to recall and produce the witness rather than placing an onus on the Subordinate Judge or the Government to fetch or secure the witness's presence.
- On practicability and petitioner’s responsibility: The Land Acquisition Officer had filed an affidavit in this Court and had given his address, which was close to the Subordinate Judge's Court. Given that the witness was an official witness who had already filed an affidavit supporting the claimant, the Court concluded it would not have been difficult for the petitioner to secure and bring the witness to Court. The petitioner nevertheless failed to do so despite multiple adjournments.
- On the record of delays: The Subordinate Judge's record (paragraph 11 of the award) and the sequence of adjournments demonstrate that the petitioner repeatedly did not take effective steps to secure the witness and was adopting dilatory tactics to protract the proceedings.
- On whether the award was ex parte or on merits: The Court held the award of 7-10-1987 was passed on merits after considering the evidence on record; it was not an ex parte order in the sense contemplated by Order XVII Rule 2 C.P.C. The Court explained that the award would fall within the explanations to Rules 2 and 3 of Order XVII, C.P.C., and that the petitioner's attack—treating the award as ex parte and seeking setting aside on that ground—was therefore not maintainable.
- On precedents relied upon by petitioner: The Court examined the authorities cited by the petitioner (Kausalya Devi and the Division Bench decision in M/A.V.R. Nataraja Nadaraja) and distinguished them on facts. In Kausalya Devi the remand and non-compliance facts differed materially (no further evidence after remand) and so that authority did not apply. The Division Bench decision involved a situation where one party had not let in any evidence at all; by contrast, here the petitioner (and the Government) had put in evidence, including earlier examination of relevant witnesses.
- On the role of the Government: The Court rejected the petitioner's argument that it was the Government's duty to secure the attendance of the official witness, stating that whether the duty lay on the Government or on the petitioner, the practical fact was that the petitioner did not take the necessary steps to secure the witness and therefore cannot blame the trial process.
- On consequences for litigation conduct: The Court emphasized the need for even-handed administration of law (drawing from Katiji) and criticized the petitioner—a State Undertaking—for employing delay tactics in proceedings meant to fix compensation to a citizen whose property was acquired.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Civil Revision Petition is dismissed.
Direct consequences and orders:
- The Subordinate Judge's rejection of the petitioner's application seeking to set aside the award of 7-10-1987 was upheld.
- The revision petition fails and is dismissed with costs. Counsel's fee awarded: Rs. 500/-. (Endorsement in the judgment: VCS/RR.)
Broader implications:
The Court did not purport to lay down any new legal precedent beyond applying established principles. The practical consequence emphasized by the Court is that even State entities or beneficiaries of acquisition cannot adopt dilatory tactics to frustrate proceedings to fix compensation; the petitioner was held responsible for failing to procure its witness and therefore could not treat the subsequent award as ex parte or a nullity. No broader or novel legal rule was announced; the decision resolves the dispute between the parties on the record before the Court.
Note: This summary is based exclusively on the text of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond what is explicitly stated therein.
1. This is a case in which the principle enunciated by the Supreme Court in Collector, Land Acquisition, Ananthag and another v. M.S T. Katiji aud others . 1987 2 S.C.C 107. that the doctrine of equality before law demands that all litigants, including the State as a litigant, are accorded the same treatment and the law is admininistered in an even handed manner is attracted. In the present case, the petitioner is a State Undertaking which is a Corporation for whose benefit the lands were acquired and it is stated that the possession of the lands was taken as early as in 1981. In the proceedings for fixation of compensation, the land Aquisition Officer fixed the compensation at the rate of Rs. 40 per cent. The Subordinate Judge at Tiruvellore, after recording evidence, fixed the compensation at Rs 500/- per cent. Aggrieved by the compensation fixed by the learned Subordinate Judge, the present petitioner filed a batch of writ petitions challenging the validity of the award on the ground that the petitioner was not made party to the Land Acquisition Original Petition proceedings before the Subordinate Judge. Their contention was accepted by this Court and by an order dated 10-11-1986 the writ petitions were allowed and the award was set aside and the learned Subordinate Judge, Tiruvellore was directed to dispose of the Land Acquisition Original Petition proceedings on or before 28-2-1987 after impleading the present petitioner as a party to the proceedings and giving opportunity to oppose the same. Thereafter the petitioner was impleaded as a party and evidence was being recorded.
2. The petitioner filed a petition for transfer before this Court alleging that the learned Subordinate Judge, who was hearing the Land Acquisition O.Ps was biased against the petitioner and that he was not recording the questions put to the Land Acquisition Officer and the answers given by him when he was in the witness box. The transfer application was contested and after arguments were heard, the Land Acquistion Officer by name Sathyanarayanan, who was the Special Tahsildar, filed an affidavit in this Court describing himself as Special Tahsildar, (Land Acquisition) Krishna water Schemes, Tiruvallur and giving his address as No. 45, N G O. Colony, Tiruvallur, Chengalpattu District. In that affidavit, he stated that when he was giving evidence on 8-4-1987, a question was put to him by counsel appearing for the petitioner herein as follows:—
“Whether the land purchased for the church was situate within the complex area or town area?”
According to the affidavit of the Land Acquisition Officer, that question was disallowed by the learned Subordinate Judge and the Judge also refused to record the question, and the answer which he may give and then allow or disallow the question. It was also stated in the affidavit by the Land Acquisition Officer that during the course of evidence he stated that the land purchased for the Church was unfit for cultivation, but it was recorded by the learned Judge as agricultural land and the same was corrected at his instance at the time when he was directed to sign the deposition.
3. This Court considered the affidavit filed by the Land Acquisition Officer as well as the arguments advanced on both sides and found that there was no ground for transfer ring the matter to any other Judge. Ulti mately, the following order was passed:—
“In the result, the petitions fail and stand dismissed. However, the Subordinate Judge is directed to give opportunity to the petitioner to recall the witness. Sathyanarayan, (Special Tahsildar Land Acquisition), Krishna Water Schemes, Tiruvallur who has sworn to an affidavit and cross-examine him with reference to the location of the Church and other relevant facts and also adduce further evidence on his side and then dispose of the same according to law as expeditiously as possible as per order already passed by this Court, uninfluenced by any of the observations made in this order”.
4. Thereafter, the matter was called in the Sub Court, Tiruvallore, on 4-8-1987. It was adjourned to 7-8-1987 to enable the peti tioner to examine Sathyanarayanan. On 7-8-1987 the petitioner did not take any steps for summoning the witness. It applied for adjournment and the matter was adjour ned to 10-8-1987. On 10-8-1987 the learned Subordinate Judge was on leave and the matter was posted to 11 8-1987. Even on that date, the petitioner did not take any steps to summon the witness. It prayed for further adjournment on the ground that he had applied for special leave in the Supreme Court of India against the order of this Court dismissing the transfer petition. The matter was adjourned to 13-8-1987. On 13 8-1987 it was found that summons were served on Sathyanarayana and he was called but he was not present in Court. Learned counsel for the petitioner herein prayed for adjournment and that was granted by the Court. The matter was adjourned to 14-8-1987. Again further adjournment was sought and the matter was adjourned to 178-1987, 18-8-1987, and 20-8-1987. On 20-8-1987, the petitioner filed an application for summoning the witness once again. That application was ordered and the matter was posted to 21-8-1987. On 21-8-1987 neither the petitioner nor its counsel was present in Court. The witness was also not present in Court. There was further adjournment and there was a prayer by the petitioner that the matter was pending before the Supreme Court of India and it would be taken for hearing on 9-9-1987 and the matter should be kept pending till then. Again, another opportunity was given by the trial Court and the matter was adjourned. The Supreme Court dismissed the application for Special Leave on 1-9-1987 with the following observations:—
“We have heard learned Additional Solicitor General. We are afraid there is no ground for transfer. The petitioner, if he feels aggrieved by any order passed by the learned Subordinate Judge, is at liberty to move the High Court in revision, or prefer an appeal against the eventual award or has the remedy by way of appeal under the relevant provisions contained in the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. The Special leave petition is dismissed accordingly”
5. Even thereafter, the petitioner was not ready with the witness. It has to be mentioned at this stage that the residental address of the witness Sathyanarayana, as given by him in the affidavit filed in this Court in the transfer petition, is situated within a short distance from the Subordinate Judge's Court. In spite of the fact that the witness had not attended the Court on 13-8-87 though he was served with summons after waiting till 21-9-1987, the learned Subordinate Judge thought that it would not be proper for him to keep the matter pending thereafter and reserved orders in the main Land Acquisition O.Ps Ultimately, he passed the award on 7-10-1987 after discussing the evidence on record.
6. On 2-11-1987 an application was filed by the petitioner herein for setting aside the award dated 7-10-1987 describing it as an ex-parte order. In support of the application, an affidavit was filed by the Deputy General Manager (Law) of the Petitioner Corporation in which the following averments were made:
“7. It is submitted that this Hon'ble Court should have recalled and examined Satyanarayanan as per the directions of the High Court, The said witness is an official witness employed in some other Department, Hence, the petitioner corporation requested this Hon'ble Court to grant sufficient time for securing the presence of the witnesses through proper channel. But this Hon'ble Court adjourned the cases day to day and finally closed the cases, reserving for orders on 21-9-1987. The petition filed by the petitioner Corporation for reopening the case was taken up by this Hon'ble Court by 10-30 Hrs. on 21-9-1987 and counsel representing the petitioner Corporation could not reach the Court in time. Hence, orders were passed on the petition that the witness was not available for examination. Since the referring officer Satyanarayanan was a party in the proceedings, tnis Hon'ble Court should have secured the presence of the said witness as per the directions of the High Court: but this Hon'ble Court dismissed the petition on the ground that the petitioner Corporation did not produce the said referring officer. On the other hand, the petitioner Corporation was not aware that it should produce the said witness on 21-9-1987. Hence, the petitioner Corporation presented a petition for reopening the cases, But the office refused to receive the same and directed the counsel for the petitioner Corporation to present the same in open Court. While the petition was presented in the open Court, the counsel for petitioner Corporation was asked to file individual petitions for each case and also urgent petitions and the counsel for the petitioner Corporation accordingly filed the petitions, but they were returned for rectifying some defects.
8. It is submitted that the defects were rectified and the cases represented to this Hon'ble Court. But this Hon'ble Court passed orders on 7-10-1987 without examining the witnesses as directed by the High Court in Tr. C.M.P 8003/1987 in C.M.P 8004/87 and also without giving sufficient opportunity to the petitioner Corporation to examine other witnesses and advance arguments. If the order passed by this Hon'ble Court on 7-10-1987 is not set aside and the petitioner Corporation is not given adequate opportunity to recall the referring officer Satyanarayanan and others and examine them, public interest will be greatly prejudiced. The ex parte order passed on 21-9-1987 for not producing the witness Satyanarayanan is not due to negligence, but it was for the reasons as stated above. The petitioner Corporation has not been negligent, but was unable to produce the said witness for reasons as stated above. It is, therefore, just and necessary that the order passed by this Hon'ble Court on 7-10-1987 is set aside and the above said I.A.O P, Mo 237/84 and the batch of 63 cases are disposed off on merits and in public interest.”
7. The learned Subordinate Judge rejected the application with an endorsement that as the award had been passed on 7-10-1987 and as the application was filed after the passing of the award it was rejected. It is against the said order rejecting the application, the present revision petition has been filed.
8. It is contended by learned counsel for the petitioner that the trial Court has not obeyed the direction given by this Court in the transfer petition to the effect that the witness Satyanarayanan, Special Tahsildar, Land Acquisition should be recalled and an opportunity should be given to the petitioner to cross-examine him with reference to the location of the church, etc. According to learned counsel, it is the duty of the Court to have recalled the witness by itself and examined him and given an opportunity to the petitioner to cross-examine him. 1 do not think so. The direction given by this Court is that the petitioner should recall the witness. It is stated in the affidavit filed in the lower Court in support of the application that the witness is an official witness employed in some other department. As stated already, the said witness had filed an affidavit in this Court in the transfer petition after the arguments were over supporting the claim of the petitioner. It would not have been difficult for the petitioner to have secured and brought the witness to Court, particularly when the witness is residing within a short distance from the Court.
9. The record discloses that the petitioner has been adopting dilatory tactics to keep the case protracting and pending for a long time. In spite of several opportunities having been given to the petitioner, it has not taken effective steps to secure the witness and examine him. According to learned counsel for the petitioner, the witness being a party to the I.A.O.P proceedings, it is the duty of the Government to have secured the presence of the said witness Sathyanara-yanan, the land Acquisition Officer in Court and ought to have examined him. Whether it is the duty of the Government or the duty of the petitioner herein, the fact remains that the petitioner did not want to get along with the proceedings before the learned Subordinate Judge, but was only keen in protracting it. The Learned Subordinate Judge has set out the various proceedings with the relevant dates in paragraph 11 of his award. A perusal of paragraph 11 of the award will clearly show that it is the petitioner who has to blame itself for not having examined the concerned witness Sathyanarayana.
10. In any event, the present application filed in the lower Court for setting aside the award treating it as an exparte order is certainly not maintainable. The award is pass ed on merits after considering the evidence on record. It is not as if the petitioner has not let in any evidence at all in the I.A.O.P proceedings Before it filed the application for transfer of the Land Acquisition O.P, it has itself cross-examined the concerned witness. The argument that the award is an exparte order and can be treated only as an exparte order within the meaning of O.XVII R. 2 C.P.C, is fallacious. The award is passed on merits after considering the entire evidence available on record and hence it would only come under explanation to R. 2 and R. 3 of O.XVII C.P.C Therefore, the application filed by the petitioner in the lower Court to set aside the award as if it was passed ex parte is not maintainable.
11. More so, the revision petition in this Court. Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the award is a nullity inasmuch as the learned Subordinate Judge has not carried out the directions given by this Court. He relies upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Kausalya Devi v. Land Acquisition Officer, Aurangabad. In that case, the Supreme Court set aside the judgment of the Bombay High Court and sent the case back to that High Court for fresh disposal. After remand, neither party had any further evidence to let in. Regarding that aspect, the Bombay High Court stated as follows:—
“…Since there is no change in the record and no additional evidence is offered and the High Court judgment was pronounced on the evidence already recorded, we see no reason to differ in any way with the well considered earlier judgment of this Court. We therefore, declare that a copy of that judgment which will be our substantive judgment, be placed on record in a judgment of this Court after remand by the Supreme Court.”
The Supreme Court, when the matter went again before them, held that the earlier judgment having been set aside, that for all intents and purposes had become non existent, and, therefore the Bombay High Court was wrong in merely attaching a copy of the judgment before remand with the order passed after remand as their substantive judgment. In those circumstances, the Supreme Court held that the Bombay High Court had not followed the directions issused by the Supreme Court as an appellate Court and hence the judgment passed on the second occasion by the Bombay High Court was a nullity. The facts of the case have no resemblance whatever to the facts of the present case.
12. Learned counsel relies upon the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in M/S. M.A.V.R Nataraja Nadar and sons, Virudunagar by its Partner and 2 others v. M/S. PRK Nadar & Co., Pattiveeranpatti by Partner for the proposition that any order passed after considering the evidence will still be an exparte order if one of the parties remained absent. In that case, the plaintiff's evidence was closed and the defendants did not go into the witness box. The defendants applied for adjournment and the case was adjourned to a particular date. As the defendants were not ready on the adjourned date, the Court proceeded on the footing that they were adopting delaying tactics and passed a decree under O.XVII R. 3, Code of Civil Procedure. But, the Division Bench of this Court took the view that it was still an order passed under O.XVII R. 2, Code of Civil Procedure and it was oniy an exparte order and not a judgment on merits within the meaning of O.XVII R. 3 Code of Civil Procedure. In that case as between two contesting parties, one party had not let in any evidence This is not a case like that. In this case, the petitioner herein and the Government are ranged on the one side and the claimant on the other. Admittedly the Government had closed its evidence. The petitioner had before the filing of the transfer petition elicited evidence in its support by examining Satyanarayana, the Land Acquisition Officer. Apart from that, as seen from paragraph 11 of the award, the petitioner had examined three witnesses, in April, 1987. Further, the evidence which was let in by the Government in this case tantamounts to evidence on behalf of the petitioner. The enquiry is one to ascertain the value of the property acquired. As regards the value of the property, the petitioner sails with the Government. Hence, the ruling of the aforesaid Division Bench of this Court cannot be invoked by the petitioner in this case.
13. There is no merit whatever in the revision petition. It is really unfortunate that a State Undertaking should indulge in dilatory tactics in a proceeding intended for fixing the just compensation payable to the citizen who is deprived of his property. The Government having initiated the proceedings under the Land Acquisition Act is bound to pay compensation as prescribed therein. But, it is not open to the beneficiary of the acquisition to play with the Court. That is why I started this judgment with the observation of the Supreme Court that the doctrine of equality before law demands that all litigants, including the State as a litigant, are accorded the same treatment and the law is administered in an even-handed manner. The order of the Subordinate Judge rejecting the frivolous application of the petitioner without numbering it is quite valid and proper.
14. In the result, the Civil Revision Petition fails and is dismissed with costs. Counsel's fee Rs. 500/-.
VCS/RR
Alert