- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramanbhai Mathurbhai Patel v. State Of Maharashtra And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner is facing trial for an offence under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act in Summary Criminal Case No. 3684 of 2013 before the Court of Metropolitan Magistrate, 59th Court at Kurla. The complaint was initially filed in the 61st Court at Kurla but was transferred to the 59th Court by the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate. The petitioner challenges the order issuing process against him, seeking that the complaint be returned to the original complainant for presentation before the court having territorial jurisdiction. The dispute centers on two cheques issued by the petitioner in favor of the complainant, which were dishonoured at Ahmedabad, while the complaint was filed in Mumbai (Kurla jurisdiction).
Legal Issues Presented
- Which court has territorial jurisdiction to try an offence under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act when the cheque is payable at all branches of the drawee bank but is dishonoured at one of the branches?
- Whether the complaint should be filed in the court having jurisdiction over the drawer's bank branch where the account is held or where the cheque was dishonoured?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner argued that since the cheques were dishonoured at Ahmedabad, the Mumbai court (Kurla jurisdiction) has no territorial jurisdiction to try the complaint.
- This argument was supported by reference to the Supreme Court judgment in Dashrath v. State of Maharashtra, which the petitioner relied upon to assert jurisdictional impropriety.
Respondent No. 2's Arguments
- The respondent contended that as the cheques were payable at all branches of the respective banks and were dishonoured at the Mumbai branches within Kurla jurisdiction, the complaint was rightly filed in the Metropolitan Magistrate Court at Kurla.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Dashrath v. State of Maharashtra, Criminal Appeal No. 2287 of 2009, 2014 (6) Mh. LJ. (S.C) 404 | Determination of territorial jurisdiction in cases under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act; the court with jurisdiction is where the cheque is dishonoured. | The court applied this precedent to hold that jurisdiction lies with the court where the cheque was dishonoured, which in this case is within the Kurla jurisdiction, thereby validating the complaint's filing there. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the issue of territorial jurisdiction for offences under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act when cheques are payable at all branches of the drawee bank but dishonoured at a particular branch. It referred extensively to the Supreme Court judgment in Dashrath v. State of Maharashtra, which clarified that the jurisdiction to try such offences is determined by the place where the cheque is dishonoured, as per section 177 of the Criminal Procedure Code. The court noted that the drawer had accounts at Gandhinagar branches, but the cheques were dishonoured at Mumbai branches within the Kurla jurisdiction. Since the cheques were payable at all branches, the payee was entitled to present the complaint in the court where the dishonour occurred. The court concluded that the Metropolitan Magistrate at Kurla had territorial jurisdiction to entertain and decide the complaint, dismissing the petition challenging this jurisdiction.
Holding and Implications
The petition challenging the territorial jurisdiction of the Metropolitan Magistrate Court at Kurla was dismissed.
The direct effect of this decision is that complaints under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act may be filed in the court having jurisdiction over the place where the cheque is dishonoured, even if the drawer's bank account is held elsewhere, provided the cheque is payable at all branches. No new precedent was established; the court adhered to the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Dashrath v. State of Maharashtra.
M.L Tahaliyani, J.:— Admitted.
2. Heard finally.
3. The petitioner is facing trial for the offence punishable under section 138 of n.i act vide Summary Criminal Case No. 3684 of 2013 in the Court of Metropolitan Magistrate, 59th Court at Kurla. The complaint was originally filed in 61st Court at Kurla and now it has been transferred to 59th Court at Kurla by the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate. The petitioner is aggrieved by the order passed by the learned Metropolitan Magistrate issuing process against the petitioner to answer the charge for the offence punishable under section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act. He wants that the complaint be returned to the respondent No. 2 (original complainant) for being presented before the Court having territorial jurisdiction to entertain and try the case.
4. The two cheques in question were admittedly issued by the petitioner in favour of the respondent No. 2. The first cheque of Rs. 9,90,000/- was drawn on State Bank of India, Gandhinagar Branch, Ahmedabad, Gujarat. The other cheque was drawn on Bank of Maharashtra, Gandhinagar Branch, Ahmedabad, Gujarat. Both the cheques were payable at par at all branches of the respective banks. The issue raised before me by the learned counsel for the petitioner, during the course of argument, is that both the cheques were dishonoured at Ahmedabad and that, therefore, in view of the judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court in the matter of Dashrath v. State of Maharashtra (Criminal Appeal No. 2287 of 2009), [reported in 2014 (6) Mh. LJ. (S.C) 404 : 2014 (4) Mh. LJ. (Cri.) (S.C) 1] Mumbai Court will have no jurisdiction to entertain and try the complaint.
5. The learned counsel for the respondent No. 2 has submitted that since both the cheques were payable at all branches of respective banks and since both the cheques were dishonoured by the Mumbai branches of State Bank of India and Bank of Maharashtra situated within the jurisdiction of Metropolitan Magistrate, Kurla, the respondent No. 2 was right in filing the complaint in the court of Metropolitan Magistrate at Kurla.
6. The issue which needs determination is as to whether which Court will have territorial jurisdiction to try the offence punishable under section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act, when the cheque payable at all branches of the drawee bank has been dishonoured by one of the branches of the drawee bank. In the present case, the drawer had accounts at Gandhi Nagar branches of the two banks mentioned hereinabove and cheques have been dishonoured by the branches of the said two banks situated within the jurisdiction of Metropolitan Magistrate, Kurla. The question which arises for determination is as to whether the payee has to file complaint in the Court of Magistrate having jurisdiction over Gandhi Nagar branches or the branches which have dishonoured cheques. In this regard, one may refer to the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Dashrath v. State of Maharashtra cited (supra). While summing up the judgment, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has said at para 31 as under:
“31. To sum up:
(i)……………
(ii)……………
(iii)……………
(iv)……………
(v)……………
(vi) Once the cause of action accrues to the complainant the jurisdiction of the Court to try the case will be determined by reference to the place where the cheque is dishonoured.
(vii) The general rule stipulated under section 177 of Criminal Procedure Code applies to cases under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. Prosecution in such cases can, therefore, be launched against the drawer of the cheque only before the Court within whose jurisdiction the dishonour takes place except in situations where the offence of dishonour of the cheque punishable under section 138 is committed along with other offences in a single transaction within the meaning of section 220(1) read with section 184 of the Code of Criminal Procedure or is covered by the provisions of section 182(1) read with sections 184 and 220 thereof.”
7. One may also refer to para 17 of the said judgment where the Hon'ble supreme Court has said as under:
“17. …… In our discernment, it is also now manifest that traders and businessmen have become reckless and incautious in extending credit where they would heretofore have been extremely hesitant, solely because of the availability of redress by way of criminal proceedings. It is always open to the creditor to insist that the cheques in question be made payable at a place of the creditor's convenience,
(emphasis supplied)”.
8. It is thus clear that in the present case by issuing cheques payable at all branches, the drawer of the cheques had given an option to the banker of payee to get the cheques cleared from the nearest available branch of bank of the drawer. It, therefore, follows that the cheques have been dishonoured within the territorial jurisdiction of Court of Metropolitan Magistrate at Kurla. In view of judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Dashrath v. State of Maharashtra cited (supra), the learned Metropolitan Magistrate of Kurla Court has jurisdiction to entertain and decide the complaint in question.
9. I do not find any substance in the petition. The petition stands dismissed.
10. Prayer for stay of this Order for two weeks is rejected.
Petition dismissed.
Alert