Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Narayan Madhavrao Warkhinde v. Mogiya Lalya

Bombay High Court
Apr 27, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit originated from a dispute over possession and title of a suit land measuring 13 acres 20 gunthas. The plaintiff claimed ownership based on a sale deed dated 6th September 1965, purchased from Bapurao and Narsingrao with valid permission from the Deputy Collector. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant colluded with the Talathi to get his name recorded in the land records. The suit land included 1 acre 20 gunthas classified as Madat Mash and 12 acres as Khalasa Inam land. The trial court partly decreed the suit, which was appealed by the defendant. The first appellate court accepted the plaintiff’s entitlement to the entire suit land and declared the defendant’s sale deed dated 17th September 1968 illegal. The defendant further appealed, challenging the validity of the plaintiff’s title and the jurisdiction of the civil courts to decide on validation certificates and permissions related to Inam land.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff’s sale deed dated 6th September 1965, executed with permission from the Deputy Collector, conferred valid title and possession despite the absence of mutation in revenue records.
  2. Whether the defendant’s sale deed dated 17th September 1968, executed without prior permission from competent authorities, was valid.
  3. Whether civil courts have jurisdiction to adjudicate on the necessity and validity of permissions or validation certificates relating to Inam and Khalasa land transactions.
  4. Whether the plaintiff’s vendor had absolute title to transfer the suit land, considering the classification of the land as Madat Mash and Khalasa Inam.
  5. The priority and supremacy of earlier sale deeds over subsequent sale deeds under Section 48 of the Transfer of Property Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The original owner was not made a party to the proceedings, thus possession could not have been delivered to the plaintiff on 6th September 1965.
  • No mutation was recorded in revenue records since 1965, undermining the plaintiff’s claim.
  • The defendant purchased the agricultural field in 1968 with valid permission dated 30th December 1976, perfecting his title.
  • The plaintiff’s title is restricted as the transaction required prior permission due to the land’s Inam status.
  • The plaintiff’s vendor had no absolute title to transfer the Inam land.
  • Civil courts lack jurisdiction to decide on validation certificates or permissions related to Inam land sales.
  • The lower courts erred by invalidating the defendant’s validation certificate and sale deed.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The plaintiff’s transaction is not vitiated by lack of permission as no permission was required for sale of Khalasa land.
  • The defendant, being a Gram Sevak, manipulated the records to his advantage and tried to effect mutation illegally.
  • The government took possession of the land following proceedings under Section 145 of the Criminal Procedure Code, which terminated in favor of the plaintiff.
  • Possession was delivered to the plaintiff at the time of sale, confirmed by the Deputy Collector’s proceedings.
  • The plaintiff’s sale deed was executed first in time and is thus superior under Section 48 of the Transfer of Property Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Section 48 of the Transfer of Property Act Priority of rights created by transfer: Earlier sale deeds have supremacy over later ones. The court applied this principle to hold that the plaintiff’s earlier sale deed prevails over the defendant’s subsequent sale deed.
Section 145 of the Criminal Procedure Code Procedure for maintaining public order where possession disputes arise. The court noted that possession proceedings under this section terminated in favor of the plaintiff, supporting his possession claim.
Section 47 of the Hyderabad Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1950 Requirement of permission from Deputy Collector for alienation of certain lands. The court recognized the plaintiff’s sale deed was granted with valid permission under this section, validating the transaction.
Section 2A, Hyderabad Abolition of Inams and Cash Grants Act, 1954 Referral of disputes regarding Inam land to competent authorities for determination. The court relied on the Deputy Collector’s findings under this section to determine the nature of the land and permission requirements.
Section 6 & 6(3) of the Hyderabad Abolition of Inams and Cash Grants Act, 1954 Restrictions on transfer of Inam land requiring prior permission of the Collector. The court accepted that Inam land transfers require permission, which the plaintiff’s vendor had obtained, unlike the defendant.
Section 58 of the Hyderabad Land Revenue Act Occupancy rights to land are heritable and transferable. Supported the plaintiff’s claim to occupancy and transferability of the land rights.
Section 29 of Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966 Classification of occupants and their rights regarding land transfer. Used to contextualize the nature of occupancy rights relevant to the dispute.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the validity of the plaintiff’s sale deed, emphasizing that it was executed first in time with valid permission from the Deputy Collector under Section 47 of the Hyderabad Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1950. The Deputy Collector and Additional Commissioner’s findings confirmed that only 1 acre 20 gunthas of the suit land was Madat Mash (Inam land) requiring permission for transfer, while the remaining 12 acres was Khalasa land not requiring such permission. The defendant’s sale deed, executed later without permission, was declared illegal. The court applied Section 48 of the Transfer of Property Act to affirm the priority of the plaintiff’s earlier sale deed over the defendant’s. It rejected the defendant’s argument that civil courts lacked jurisdiction to examine validation certificates, holding that referral to competent authorities was appropriate and that the lower courts did not exceed their jurisdiction. The court also noted that the defendant’s subsequent permission dated 30th December 1976 was ineffective as it was granted without title or interest in the land. The plaintiff’s possession was supported by government proceedings under Section 145 of the Criminal Procedure Code. Overall, the court found no merit in the defendant’s appeal and upheld the findings of the lower courts.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The court upheld the plaintiff’s entitlement to possession and title of the entire suit land based on the earlier valid sale deed with permission. The defendant’s sale deed and subsequent validation certificate were declared illegal. The decision confirms the principle of priority in transfer of property rights and the necessity of obtaining prior permission for alienation of Inam land. No new precedent was established; the ruling directly affects the parties by affirming the plaintiff’s ownership and possession rights and rejecting the defendant’s claims.

Show all summary ...

1. Heard.

2. Regular Civil Suit No. 3/1989 was decided by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Biloli, who partly decreed the suit. Being aggrieved by the same Regular Civil Appeal No. 179/1992 was preferred before the 4th Additional District Judge, Nanded, who decreed the suit accepting entitlement of the plaintiff to recover entire suit land from the defendant. The first appellate Court also declared the sale deed in favour of the defendant dt. 17th Sept., 1968, relating to suit land as illegal.

3. Facts:

The parties are referred with the status ‘plaintiff and ‘defendant’. Plaintiff sought possession of suit land based on a sale deed dt. 6th September, 1965, having purchased it from Bapurao and Narsingrao for Rs. 2500/- under a valid permission from the Deputy Collector. The plaintiff asserted, possession of the land was taken at the time of execution of the sale deed. It is alleged, the defendant, in collusion with Talathi, got his name entered in record of rights.

3. From the suit land, 1 acre 20 gunthas is Madat Mash and 12 acres is Khalasa Inam land, as is evident from the Deputy Collector's and Commissioner's orders (Exhs. 122 and 132).

4. Submissions

5. Mr. Deshmukh submits, original owner was not made party to the proceedings by the plaintiffs. There could not be a delivery of possession in favour of plaintiff (respondent to the appeal) on 6-9-1965, as there was no mutation in revenue record since 1965 and, consequently, in the year 1968, the defendant/appellant has purchased the agricultural field. There was a valid permission in favour of the appellant dt. 30-12-1976 by the competent authority and, in the light of such permission, the appellant (defendant) had perfected his title to the suit property. The title of the plaintiff (respondent) is restricted title as the prerequisite of the transaction was a permission from the competent authorities, it being a Madat Mash Inam and Khalsa Inam land.

6. The appeal is admitted on 20th August, 1993, vide ground Nos. 5, 6, 8, 9, 10 and 12 mentioned hereinafter.

“5. The vendor of the plaintiff has no absolute title to pass to the Plaintiff being Inam land.

6. Since no permission was obtained by the vendor of the Plaintiff, the impugned say does not convey any title to the Plaintiff.

8. The plaintiff had not sought for relief of validation certificate regarding the suit land.

9. The Civil Courts has no jurisdiction to decide question as to whether the sale transaction requires to be validated.

10. The Court below had shown jurisdiction not vested in it to decide as to which of the two sale deed should be preferred for validation.

12. The Court below also travelled beyond its legal authority to hold that validation certificate issued in favour of the Defendant regarding the sale deed dated 17th June, 1968 is illegal.”

7. Mr. Godhamgaonkar, Counsel, appearing for the respondent (original plaintiff) asserts, the transaction of plaintiff is not vitiated even if no permission was obtained from the competent authorities. No permission was required for sale of Khalsa land. The defendant was a Gram Sevak, he prevailed over the vendor, got saledeed on 17th September, 1968 and successfully tried to effect mutation, same was questioned before the Deputy Collector, consequently, possession of the land was taken over by the Government in terms of section 145 of Criminal Procedure Code. The proceedings are terminated in favour of the respondent (plaintiff). There was a delivery of possession in favour of the plaintiff, reflected in the sale deed. It was so confirmed by the Deputy Collector in the proceedings.

8. Observation:

9. The sale deed in favour of the plaintiff (respondent) is at Exh. 107. It is attached with a permission granted by the Deputy Collector, Degloor, on 3rd September, 1965 under section 47 of the Hyderabad Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act (No. 2 of 1950) for alienation. This document illustrates that the vendor Bapurao Mahadu and Narsinga Mahadu conveyed absolute title in favour of the plaintiff for entire 13 acres 20 gunthas of the land, with a recital that its possession was handed over to the plaintiff as owner.

10. On the other hand, the sale deed of the defendant (appellant) Narayanrao, from the same vendor Bapurao and Narsingrao, for 13 acres 20 gunthas of the land, for Rs. 4,000/, dt. 17-9-1968, is without affording any permission from the competent authorities with an inscription that such permission is not warranted. The fact remains, the sale deed in respect of the suit land in favour of the plaintiff (Exh. 107) was first in time than the sale deed dt. 17-9-1968 (Exh. 108) in favour of the defendant Narayanrao. The defendant, in arrogance of his power purchased the land already sold, he cannot be a authority to brand plaintiffs sale-deed to be void and hence to have a mileage on the situation. Section 48 of Transfer of Property Act ordains to accept supremacy of the former sale deed in all the terms than the later. The transferor cannot prejudice the rights of transferee by any subsequent dealing with the property. Section 48 of the Transfer of Property Act reads as under:

“48. PRIORITY OF RIGHTS CREATED BY TRANSFER:

Where a person purports to create by transfer at different times rights in or over the same immovable property, and such rights cannot all exist or be exercised to their full extent together, each later created right shall, in the absence of a special contract or reservation binding the earlier transferees, be subject to the rights previously created.”

11. Now, the submission of Mr. Deshmukh that the transaction of the plaintiff was devoid of permission, and could not survive in the eyes of law, needs again to be evaluated.

12. Based on the controversies raised by the parties in Special Civil Suit No. 58/1975, learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, has referred the issues to the learned Deputy Collector (LR), Nanded, under section 2A of Hyderabad Abolition of Inams and Cash Grants Act, 1954, formulating following three issues:

“(1) What is the nature of Inam of the suit land survey No. 53 admeasuring 13 acres 20 gunthas of Goundgaon.

(2) Whether this land may be alienated with or without permission of the Collector.

(3) Whether the plaintiff was entitled to the validation certificate in preference to that of the defendants.”

13. On analysis of the evidence and the legal position, the learned Deputy Collector, crystallized the issues answering that only 1 acre 20 gunthas of land out of survey No. 53, situate at Goundgaon, taluka Degloor, is Madat Mash and the remaining area (12 acres) can be treated as Khalsa land. So far as issue No. 2 is concerned, he has observed, that the ownership of the Inam land, which is re-granted to the occupant, dt. 1-7-1960 is restricted; he cannot sale, transfer or mortgage or partition without prior permission of the Collector, the occupancy of the Inam lands have been re-granted to the occupants on the nominal price i.e six times of assessment to the Inamdars and, Kabij-E-Kadim, eight times of the assessment of the assessment to the protected tenant and 12 times of the assessment to the ordinary tenant. According to the learned Deputy Collector, hence, Inam lands re-granted to the occupant under section 6 of the Hyderabad Abolition of Inams and Cash Grants Act, 1954, can be sold with prior permission of the Collector under section 6(3) of the Hyderabad Abolition of Inams and Cash Grants Act, 1954 and the land other than the Inam can be sold to any person with permission of the competent authorities under section 47 of the Hyderabad Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1950. After amendment of the section, no permission now is required to be obtained for sale of agricultural lands. The learned Deputy Collector has also observed that, the case of plaintiff can be regularized after obtaining amount of 20 times of assessment as NAZARANA.

14. In the present case, both the purchasers have not obtained permission from the Collector. The regularization in the year 1976 by the subsequent purchaser Narayanrao is without title or interest in the land. Hence, the transaction between the land holders and Shri Narayanrao (appellant) is itself illegal. On the other hand, the sale transaction with permission of Deputy Collector, Degloor, in favour of Shri Mogiya Lalya (plaintiff) can be held as lawful and legal. The regularization can be made to the extent of 1 acre 20 gunthas which has been treated as Inam land after obtaining amount of NAZARANA of 20 times of assessment of the land revenue.

15. This order of the learned Deputy Collector was questioned, by defendant/appellant Narayanrao before the Appellate forum Additional Commissioner, Aurangabad, however, before the appellate forum present appellant Narayanrao lost. Thus, the permission in favour of the plaintiff by the Deputy Collector, under section 47 of the Hyderabad Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act was treated to be valid. This order of the learned Additional Commissioner has reached finality as it has answered the issue formulated by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division.

16. The permission subsequently sought by the defendant dt. 30-12-1976 under the banner of validation certificate was not at all required and it could not prevail upon the original permission in favour of the plaintiff having been confirmed by the Deputy Collector and by the Additional Commissioner on 9-2-1987.

17. Section 29 of Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966, conceive occupants as (a) Class I, (b) Class II and (c) Government lessee. The Class I occupants shall consist of persons who (a) hold unalienated land in perpetuity and without any restrictions on the right to transfer and (b) immediately before the commencement of this Code hold land in full occupancy or Bhumiswami rights without any restrictions on the right to transfer in accordance with the provisions of any law relating to land revenue in force in any part of the State immediately before such commencement. Under section 58 of the Hyderabad Land Revenue Act, occupancy right to land shall be deemed to be heritable and transferable (Act No. 9 of 1309 Fasali).

18. Conclusions:

19. Taking survey of above facts, it could not be said that the plaintiffs vendor had no absolute title to pass to the plaintiff, it being an Inam land or that for want of permission by the vendor, the transaction of the plaintiff is without any title. It is not necessary that the plaintiffs should have sought declaration of validation certificate regarding the suit land, as it is beyond the scope of Civil Court. The Civil Court justifiably referred the matter about requisition of permission, for adjudication to the competent authorities. The finding of the Court about not accepting the so-called validation certificate in favour of the defendant was based on the findings recorded by the learned Deputy Collector and the Additional Commissioner. Consequently, the so-called validation of 1976 in favour of the defendant for sale deed dt. 17th June, 1968, was rightly declared as illegal. There is no deflection of main issues by the Courts.

20. The substantial questions of law formulated from the grounds referred above are answered against appellant (defendant). Second Appeal lacks merit, dismissed, with costs.

Appeal dismissed.