- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Lotan Ramchandra Shimpi And Ors. v. Shankar Ganpat Kayasth And Ors.
Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from Civil Appeal No. 266 of 1981 where the appellants-plaintiffs challenged the judgment and order dated 21 October 1982 of the Assistant Judge, Dhule, which confirmed the trial Court's judgment and decree dated 9 July 1981 in Regular Civil Suit No. 60 of 1977 (Civil Judge, Junior Division, Sakri).
The plaintiffs sought recovery of possession of suit lands (gat No. 56: survey No. 35/2 and gat No. 60: survey No. 36/1) situated at village Bhadane under the Specific Relief Act. The plaintiffs allege that the defendants forcibly dispossessed them. The plaintiffs are heirs of Ramchandra Shimpi (husband of plaintiff No. 2 and father of plaintiffs Nos. 1 and 3), who had purchased the lands under section 32-G of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948; mutation entry No. 260 recorded Ramchandra as cultivator for 1976-77, and after his death the plaintiffs had their names entered in the revenue record as heirs.
The record indicates that deceased Ramchandra executed an agreement to sell (referred to as Exh. 55), a registered document, in favour of the defendants and received Rs. 23,000 at that time, with possession said to have been handed over to the defendants. The plaint and subsequent proceedings state the remaining Rs. 2,000 was to be paid upon execution of a sale deed after obtaining requisite permission; no such permission was obtained before the suit was filed. (The opinion also records that Exh. 55 was executed on 26 November 1976; an earlier passage refers to an execution in 1975.)
At trial, after framing issues and recording evidence, the trial Court dismissed the suit. The appellate Court affirmed that dismissal on 21 October 1982. The present appeal challenges primarily whether the defendants are entitled to protection under section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act and whether the agreement to sell is barred by section 43 of the Tenancy Act, thereby entitling the plaintiffs to restoration of possession.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the defendants are entitled to protection under section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act in respect of possession obtained pursuant to the agreement to sell (Exh. 55).
- Whether the agreement to sell (Exh. 55) and the consequent transfer/possession are barred by section 43 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act (the statutory bar on alienation) and therefore invalid.
- Whether the appellants-plaintiffs, as heirs of the original purchaser under section 32-G, are entitled to restoration of possession of the suit lands.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments (as recorded)
- The agreement to sell (Exh. 55) is barred by section 43 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act because lands purchased under section 32-G cannot be transferred without prior sanction of the Collector; any transfer in contravention is invalid.
- Because the agreement itself is invalid, the defendants cannot claim protection under section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act.
- Pleadings may be imperfect, but under principles stated in Bhagwati Prasad v. Chandramaul the Court should not allow technical deficiencies in pleading to defeat substantive justice if the matter was in issue and evidence was led on it.
- Relied upon authorities (Parshuram Kathod Gaikar and Meram Pocham) to show a complete bar on alienation and that possession given pursuant to contracts of sale without statutory sanction is unlawful and not protected by section 53-A.
Respondents' Arguments (as recorded)
- The defendants contended that possession of the suit lands was lawfully given to them by deceased Ramchandra under a registered agreement to sell (Exh. 55) and that they are not in unauthorised or illegal possession.
- Counsel for respondents argued there was no "complete transfer" as defined under the Tenancy Act, relying on a commentary on the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act (page 420) describing requisites for valid transfer; therefore, section 43's bar would not apply.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Parshuram Kathod Gaikar v. Pandu Mahadu Hard, 1993 Mh.L.J. 1570 | Statement that "There is total and complete bar on alienation of agricultural lands in question without previous sanction of Collector. The bar includes any attempt of doing so or execution of document in pursuance thereof." | The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that an agreement to sell executed in contravention of section 43 is barred and that such an agreement cannot confer lawful title or lawful possession. |
| Bhagwati Prasad v. Chandramaul, A.I.R. 1966 S.C. 735 | Principles on pleadings and substance over form: relief should generally be founded on pleadings, but where the matter was involved in the trial and evidence was led, technical defects in pleadings should not defeat substantive justice. | The Court invoked this principle to justify treating imperfect pleadings as not fatal where the substantial matter (title/possession) was in issue and evidence was led, permitting the appellants to rely on the statutory bar despite pleaded defects. |
| Meram Pocham & another v. The Agent to the State Government (Collector), District Adilabad, A.I.R. 1978 A.P. 242 | Held that possession given to petitioners pursuant to contracts of sale without previous sanction under the relevant tenancy statute was unlawful and that section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act would not safeguard that possession. | The Court treated this authority as closely analogous and used it to conclude that possession delivered under an agreement to sell without the necessary statutory permission is unlawful and not protected by section 53-A. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court undertook a fact-based and precedent-informed analysis:
- Fact assessment: The Court noted the admitted facts — deceased Ramchandra executed a registered agreement to sell (Exh. 55), accepted Rs. 23,000 at or about the time of execution, and delivered possession of the suit lands to the defendants. The record also indicates the remaining consideration (Rs. 2,000) was to be paid after obtaining required permission, which was never obtained.
- Statutory rule: The Court considered section 43 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act which imposes a prior-sanction requirement from the Collector for transfers of land purchased under certain tenancy provisions and declares transfers in contravention invalid.
- Precedential support: The Court relied on Parshuram Kathod Gaikar to emphasise a "total and complete bar" on alienation without prior sanction, and on Meram Pocham to show that possession given pursuant to sale contracts without requisite statutory sanction is unlawful and not protected by section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act.
- Pleadings and evidence: The Court accepted the submission rooted in Bhagwati Prasad that imperfections in pleadings should not defeat substantive rights where the matter was in issue and evidence was led; accordingly, the plaintiffs' failure to word the plaint perfectly did not bar relief when the illegal nature of the agreement and possession were in evidence.
- Rejection of respondents' position: The Court rejected the respondents' argument (based on a commentary) that there was no complete transfer and so section 43 would not apply. The Court held that the existence of a registered agreement to sell plus delivery of possession without statutory sanction rendered the agreement invalid and the possession illegal.
- Conclusion from reasoning: Because Exh. 55 was executed in contravention of the statutory bar, it was "without authority," invalid, and incapable of execution; possession delivered pursuant to it was illegal. Consequently, plaintiffs (as heirs of Ramchandra) were entitled to recovery of possession even if the plaint did not allege forcible dispossession in precisely drafted terms.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
APPEAL ALLOWED; the judgments and orders of both Courts below are set aside and the suit is decreed.
Direct consequences and directions given by the Court (as recorded):
- The respondents-defendants are directed to hand over vacant and peaceful possession of the suit lands to the appellants-plaintiffs without any encumbrance on or before 31 December 1994.
- Because the defendants had admittedly paid Rs. 23,000 to the deceased Ramchandra at the time of the agreement to sell, the Court held it to be a legal and moral obligation that the plaintiffs refund that amount to defendant No. 1. The Court directed the appellants-plaintiffs to deposit Rs. 23,000 in the trial Court on or before 15 December 1994. On depositing that amount the plaintiffs were to file their application (darkhast) for possession; after restoration of possession, the respondents-defendants would be at liberty to withdraw that amount. The Court specifically ordered refund without interest.
- Certified copy expedited; the opinion concludes with the succinct directive: "Appeal allowed."
Broader implications: The opinion applies established precedent to the facts and does not purport to announce a novel principle. The Court did not articulate any new general rule beyond its application of section 43 (the statutory bar), the inapplicability of section 53-A where possession stems from a transfer lacking statutory sanction, and the application of rules on pleadings from Bhagwati Prasad. (The opinion does not state that a new precedent was being laid down.)
Cases referred :
1. Parshuram Kathod Gaikar v. Pandu Mahadu Hard, 1993 Mh.L.J. 1570.
2. Bhagwati Prasad v. Chandramaul, A.I.R. 1966 S.C. 735.
3. Meram Pocham v. The Agent to the State Government (Collector), District Adilabad, A.I.R. 1978 A.P. 242.
Advocates appeared :
M.V. Sali, for the appellants.
L.V. Kapse, for respondent No. 1.
V.H. BHAIRAVIA, J.:-Being aggrieved by the judgment and order dated 21st October, 1982 passed by the learned Assistant Judge, Dhule, in Civil Appeal No. 266 of 1981 confirming the judgment and decree dated 9th July, 1981 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Junior Division, Sakri, in Regular Civil Suit No. 60 of 1977, the appellants-plaintiffs have preferred this appeal.
The suit was filed for recovery of possession of the suit lands, being gat No. 56 (survey No. 35/2 and get No. 60 (survey No. 36/1), situated at village Bhadane, under the Specific Relief Act. It was alleged that the defendants have forcibly dispossessed the plaintiffs from the suit lands. The suit was contested by the defendants contending that the possession of the suit lands has been lawfully given to the defendants by the deceased father of the plaintiffs under an agreement to sell (Exh. 55), which is a registered document. After framing issues and recording evidence, the learned trial Judge dismissed the suit by his judgment and order dated 9th July, 1981. Appeal preferred by the plaintiffs against the said order came to be dismissed by the learned appellate Judge by his judgment and order dated 21st October, 1982. Hence this appeal.
2. Since an important question of law is involved in this appeal, it is necessary to state a few facts of this case. It is the case of the plaintiffs that the suit lands, being gat No. 56 (survey No. 35/2) and gat No. 60 (survey No. 36/1) were purchased by their predecessor Ramchandra Shimpi i.e. husband of plaintiff No. 2 and father of plaintiffs Nos. 1 and 3, under section 32-G of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948. Accordingly, mutation entry No. 260 was effected and the name of deceased Ramchandra Shimpi continued as cultivator of these lands in 1976-77. On the death of Ramchandra, the plaintiffs as the heirs of deceased Ramchandra got entered their names in the revenue record. It reveals from the record that deceased Ramchandra in his life time executed an agreement to sell (Exh. 55) in favour of the defendants in 1975 for the consideration of Rs. 25,000/- and at the time of executing the agreement to sell, which is a registered document, Rs. 23,000/- were paid to deceased Ramchandra by the defendants and possession of the suit lands was simultaneously handed over to the defendants. It is the further case of the plaintiffs that the suit lands were purchased under section 32-G of the Tenancy Act by deceased Ramchandra. By virtue of the operation of the Tenancy Act, deceased Ramchandra had no right to sell or transfer these lands. Therefore, possession of the suit lands with the defendants is unauthorised and illegal and the plaintiffs are entitled for restoration of the possession of the suit lands. The trial Court, after framing issues and recording evidence, dismissed the suit by its judgment and order dated 9th July, 1981 and in appeal, the said judgment and order of the trial Court was confirmed by the appellate Court by its judgment and order dated 21st October, 1982. Both the courts below held that the plaintiffs have failed to prove that the defendants have forcibly dispossessed them from the suit lands and further held that the defendants are not in unauthosied or illegal possession of the suit lands. Both the courts below further held that it is an admitted fact that deceased Ramchandra had executed an agreement to sell, a registered document, and received Rs. 23,000/- and parted with possession of the suit lands. The remaining amount of Rs. 2,000/- was agreed to be paid on executing a sale deed after obtaining the necessary permission for sale from the competent authority. It reveals from the record that no such permission was obtained till the suit came to be filed. It also reveals from the record that notice was issued by the plaintiffs to the defendants. It is further held that the defendants are entitled for protection under section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act. It is submitted that though the appellate Court discussed the arguments regarding the statutory bar under section 43 of the Tenancy Act, the learned appellate Judge has failed to appreciate the legal consequences of the agreement to sell in question. This being the factual position of the suit lands, the question is as to whether the defendants are entitled for protection under section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act? And whether the appellants-plaintiffs are entitled for restoration of possession of the suit lands?
3. Heard both the learned Counsel for the parties. Mr. M.V. Sali, learned Counsel appearing for the appellants-plaintiffs, emphatically submitted that both the courts below have wrongly relied on the document (Exh. 55), the agreement to sell, without applying their mind to the bar of transfer under section 43 of the Tenancy Act, and held that the defendants are not in unauthorised or illegal possession of the suit lands. The learned Counsel for the appellants has relied upon section 43 of the Tenancy Act, which reads thus :-
43(1) : "No land purchased by a tenant under sections 32-F, 32-I, 32-O, 33-C or 43-ID or sold to any person under section 32-P or 64 shall be transferred by sale, gift, exchange, mortgage, lease or assignment without the previous sanction of the Collector. Such sanction shall be given by the Collector in such circumstances, and subject to such conditions, as may be prescribed by the State Government :
Provided that, no such sanction shall be necessary where the land is to be mortgaged in favour of Government or a society registered or deemed to be registered under the Bombay Co-operative Societies Act, 1925, for raising a loan for effecting any improvement of such land.
(2) Any transfer of land in contravention of sub-section (1) shall be invalid."
4. The learned Counsel for the appellants has submitted that even the agreement to sell is also barred by section 43 of the Act. The learned Counsel, in support of his argument, relied on a ruling in (Parshuram Kathod Gaikar v. Pandu Mahadu Hard & another)1, 1993 M.L.J. page 1570, wherein it has been observed thus :-
"There is total and complete bar on alienation of agricultural lands in question without previous sanction of Collector. The bar includes any attempt of doing so or execution of document in pursuance thereof."
5. The learned Counsel further emphatically submitted that the pleadings of the plaintiffs in the plaint might not have been happily worded but justice should not be defeated on such technical wrong notion of law. In support of his submission, the learned Counsel has relied on a ruling in (Bhagwati Prasad v. Chandramaul)2, A.I.R. 1966 S.C. 735, wherein it has been observed thus :-
"Uudoubtedly if a party asks for a relief on a clear and specific ground, and in the issues or at the trial, no other ground is covered either directly or by necessary implication, it would not be open to the said party to attempt to sustain the same claim on a ground which is entirely new. But in considering the application of this doctrine to the facts of a particular case, Court must bear in mind the other principle that considerations of form cannot over-ride the legitmate considerations of substance."
"If a plea is not specifically made and yet it is covered by an issue by implication and the parties knew that the said plea was involved in the trial, then the mere fact that the plea was not expressly taken in the pleadings would not necessarily disentitle a party from relying upon it if it is satisfactorily proved by evidence. The general rule no doubt is that the relief should be founded on pleadings made by the parties. But where the substantial matters relating to the title of both parties to the suit are touched, though indirectly or even obscurely, in the issues, and evidence has been led about them, then the argument that a particluar matter was not expressly taken in the pleadings would be purely formal and technical and cannot succeed in every case. What the Court has to consider in dealing with such an objection is : Did the parties know that the matter in question was involved in the trial, and did they lead evidence about it? If it appears that the parties did not know that the matter was in issue at the trial and one of them has had no opportunity to lead evidence in respect of it, that undoubtedly would be a different matter. To allow one party to rely upon a matter in respect of which the other party did not lead evidence and has had no opportunity to lead evidence, would introduce considerations and in doing justice to one party, the Court cannot do injustice to another."
6. The learned Counsel further submitted that though admittedly there is an agreement to sell, the defendants are not entitled for the protection under section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act as the said agreement to sell (Exh. 55) itself is barred by section 43 of the Act. The author of the agreement to sell deceased Ramchandra had no right to transfer the suit lands without the permission of the competent authority under section 43 of the Tenancy Act. In support of his argument, he has relied on a ruling in (Meram Pocham and another v. The Agent to the State Government (Collector), District Adilabad, and others)3, A.I.R. 1978 A.P. 242, wherein it has been observed thus :-
"Held that possession given to the petitioners in pursuance of the contracts of sale, without obtaining previous sanction of the Tahsildar under section 47, Hyderabad Tenancy Act, was unlawful and section 53-A T.P. Act would not safeguard that possession."
The facts of the abovecited case are almost identical to the facts of the present case. The relevant provision governing the tenancy rights in that area is similiar to the provision governing the tenancy rights in the instant case. In view of the settled legal position, the judgments and order of both the courts below, in my opinion, are unsustainable. However, Mr. L.V. Kapse, learned Counsel for the respondents, submitted that there was no complete transfer of the suit lands as defined under the Act. He vehemently submitted that the view taken by the courts below is correct and need not be disturbed in this second appeal. In this connection, the learned Counsel has cited the commentary on Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act at page 420, wherein the requisites for valid transfer have been discussed. Relying on this commentary, the learned Counsel has tried to convince this Court that the view taken by the appellate Court holding that there was no complete sale and transfer and, therefore, the bar of section 43 of the Tenancy Act does not come into play. With respect, it is not possible to accept this argument in view of the above observations supported by two authorities cited above. It is an admitted fact that there is an agreement to sell executed by deceased Ramchandra in favour of the defendants and possession of the suit lands was also delivered simultaneously. However, the agreement to sell (Exh. 55) itself is without authority, is an invalid document and is incapable of its execution by any competent Court and on the strength of the invalid and illegal document, the possession parted with would be illegal and the defendants are held to be in unauthorised and illegal possession of the suit lands right from the execution of the agreement to sell and delivery of possession. It reveals from the records that on 26th November, 1976, agreement to sell (Exh. 55) was executed by deceased Ramchandra without authority. Therefore, the plaintiffs being the heirs of Ramchandra are entitled for recovery of possession of the suit lands from the defendants. It does not matter if the plaintiffs have not specifically pleaded in the plaint and even if there is failure in proving that possession of the suit lands had been taken forcibly from the plaintiffs by the defendants, the appellants-plaintiffs are entitled for restoration of possession of the suit lands because the defendants have no right to retain possession of the suit lands.
7. Having regard to the above observations, the appeal is allowed. The judgments and order of both the Courts below are set aside and the suit is decreed. The respondents-defendants are directed to hand over the vacant and peaceful possession of the suit lands without any encumbrance to the appellants-plaintiffs on or before 31st December, 1994.
8. Mr. Kapse, learned Counsel for the respondents, has submitted that in view of the consideration of Rs, 23,000/- which the defendants have admittedly paid to deceased Ramchandra, the plaintiffs must be directed to refund the same to defendant No. 1 with interest. The law of equity is the essence of justice. In view of the admitted fact that deceased Ramchandra had received Rs. 23,000/- from the defendants at the time of executing the agreement to sell, it is the legal and moral obligation of the plaintiffs to refund this amount to defendant No. 1 without interest. Therefore, the appellants-plaintiffs are directed to deposit in the trial Court Rs. 23,000/- on or before 15th December, 1994. On depositing this amount, the plaintiffs shall file darkhast for possession. After restoration of possession of the suit lands to the appellants-plaintiffs, the respondents-defendants will be at liberty to withdraw that amount.
Certified copy expedited.
Appeal allowed.
Alert