Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Miss. Y. Padma Mythi... v. The A.P University O...

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Jul 17, 1989
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (as contained in the provided text)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Miss Y. Padma Mythili (a minor represented by her father Sri Y.R. Kishen), passed Intermediate in March 1987 and applied for admission to First Year M.B.B.S. (academic year 1988–1989) against seats reserved for Scheduled Tribes after qualifying EAMCET. She furnished a community certificate dated 21-4-1988 issued by the Mandal Revenue Officer (M.R.O.), Visakhapatnam, stating she belonged to the ‘Konda Kapu’ community (recognised as a Scheduled Tribe).

Respondents 2 and 3 called for verification of social status. The petitioner and her father attended an enquiry, filled a questionnaire and supplied documentary evidence. The 2nd respondent issued a show-cause notice and conducted an enquiry; thereafter by proceedings dated 23-11-1988 the 2nd respondent concluded the petitioner could not be treated as a member of the ‘Konda Kapu’ Scheduled Tribe and recommended she not be admitted to the M.B.B.S. under the reserved seats. The petitioner filed Writ Petition under Article 226 challenging denial of admission and the validity of Rule 8(D)(1), and sought interim relief; the Court directed the 2nd respondent to complete the enquiry and pass a final order by 25-11-1988.

The petition challenged the 2nd respondent's proceedings of 23-11-1988; the Court quashed those proceedings, granted relief by mandating admission of the petitioner into First Year M.B.B.S. for the academic year 1989–1990, and awarded costs against the 2nd respondent.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the action of the respondent in not granting admission to the petitioner into First Year M.B.B.S. (1988–1989) against seats reserved for Scheduled Tribes was arbitrary, illegal and unconstitutional.
  2. Whether Rule 8(D)(1) of the rules governing admission into First Year M.B.B.S. and B.D.S., as published by the 1st respondent, was highly arbitrary and illegal (as challenged by the petitioner).
  3. Whether the 2nd respondent's proceedings dated 23-11-1988 rejecting the petitioner's claim to Scheduled Tribe status (Konda Kapu) were sustainable in law, having regard to the documentary and testimonial material produced in support of that status.
  4. What is the appropriate relief/remedy when provisional or delayed determinations of social status cause loss of academic opportunity (particularly whether the Court can mould relief for subsequent academic year).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Position

  • The petitioner produced multiple documents and certificates (including a Mandal Revenue Officer certificate dated 21-4-1988, earlier Tahsildar and District certificates from the 1950s, a certified extract of birth register, and other documentary material) establishing that her father belonged to the 'Konda Kapu' community (a Scheduled Tribe).
  • She attended the verification and furnished required particulars; no substantive further enquiry or cross-examination of her or her father occurred during the 3rd respondent's verification and the petitioner was informed that clearance would be communicated shortly.
  • She contended the 2nd respondent's refusal to treat her as a member of the Scheduled Tribe ignored and improperly rejected the substantial and unimpeachable documentary and testimonial evidence already accepted in earlier enquiries and orders concerning her father.
  • She sought quashing of the 2nd respondent's proceedings and a writ directing admission to the M.B.B.S. course; when immediate admission for 1988–89 could not be given (academic year over), she sought appropriate equitable relief for the subsequent year.

Respondent 2's Position (as reflected in the impugned proceedings)

The opinion sets out the 2nd respondent's reasons in detail; these are reproduced here in summarized form as the factual basis for the 2nd respondent's decision to reject the petitioner's claim of Scheduled Tribe status.

  • Uncommon surname: The petitioner’s surname "Yerubothula" is said to be uncommon among 'Konda Kapu' and is instead mostly found among 'Telaga' and 'Kapu' communities.
  • Inter-marriage and non-endogamy: The petitioner's paternal grandfather's second wife and other spouses in the family were from 'Telaga' or 'Kapu' communities; intermarriage and social equality with 'Telaga'/'Kapu' families suggested non-membership of 'Konda Kapu'.
  • Lack of dialect/traditional knowledge: The petitioner's father did not have a distinct dialect or knowledge of 'Konda Kapu' traditions, marriages, gods and rituals, suggesting non-membership.
  • Questioning the evidentiary value of certificates: Several community certificates from the 1950s and the 1980s were treated as unattested or unreliable on grounds such as lack of enquiries at the native place (Jeypore, Orissa), lack of jurisdiction of issuing authorities, or because copies were not originally marked to the father.
  • Alleged tampering: The petitioner's father's SSLC entries were found tampered/over-written; the 2nd respondent relied upon earlier disciplinary/administrative findings (including the Central Board of Excise & Customs decision) suggesting tampering to secure an ST appointment, and criticized the Secretary, Ministry of Finance's exoneration as erroneous.
  • Suspicion of manipulation: The 2nd respondent suggested that the petitioner’s father and grandfather may have influenced Taluk and Collectorate officials to obtain favourable reports and documents.
  • Non-examination: Certain certificate-givers (e.g., Sri Harihar Misra) were not examined before the 2nd respondent, reducing the weight of their certificates.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court (as stated in the opinion)
Abhoy Pada Saha v. Sudhir Kumar, AIR 1967 SC 115 That a person's surname is irrelevant in determining social status. The Court relied on this authority to hold that the petitioner's surname ("Yerubothula") was not a valid reason to reject her claim to be a member of the 'Konda Kapu' community.
Atul Khullar v. State of J. & K., 1986 Supp SCC 225; AIR 1986 SC 1224 Temporary urban residence or attending urban educational institutions does not defeat a claim to admission based on reserved-category status where the family permanently belongs to a backward/village area. The Court applied this principle to reject the view that the petitioner or her family’s temporary residence or education in Visakhapatnam disentitled her from claiming tribal reservation; the M.R.O. certificate was held to be in order.
Baiya Ram v. Anirudh, (1970) 2 SCC 825 : AIR 1971 SC 2533 Whether a person is a member of a Scheduled Tribe is essentially a question of law; an admission that one is not a member is evidence but not conclusive. The Court invoked the principle to note that prior admissions or entries against a person are not conclusive proof of non-membership and to assess the totality of evidence on the question of tribal status.
State of Maharashtra v. Abhoy, 1984 Supp SCC 701 : AIR 1985 SC 328 Procedural guidance: criticised provisional certificates that can be cancelled later and suggested states devise earlier and more reliable procedures for determining reserved-category status to avoid irreparable harm. The Court referred to this authority when addressing the prejudice caused to the petitioner by delay and provisional/late determinations of social status, and to justify moulding relief (admission in the next academic year) rather than restoration to the same year which was no longer possible.
Lachmeshwar Prasad Shukur v. Keshwar Lal Chaudari, 1940 FCR 84 : AIR 1941 FC 5 (and Patterson v. State of Alabama (1935) 294 US 600) The appellate court’s power to mould relief taking into account supervening changes in fact or law. The Court relied on these authorities to justify making an equitable disposition (directing admission for academic year 1989–1990) because the 1988–89 academic year had passed and the petitioner had lost that year through no fault of her own.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a fact-sensitive review of the record and applied legal principles to determine whether the 2nd respondent's rejection of the petitioner's Scheduled Tribe claim was tenable.

  1. Evaluation of documentary and testimonial evidence: The Court catalogued and examined a large body of documents produced in support of the petitioner's father's membership of the 'Konda Kapu' community — including multiple community certificates from Tahsildar and District authorities (1954–1956), a Tahsildar report and Collector’s report (1957) on scholarship enquiries, a birth-register extract (1933 certified extract issued in 1966), certificates by public figures (e.g., Sri Harihar Misra), employment-exchange and service records showing the father as 'Konda Kapu', and administrative and disciplinary enquiry records arising from allegations made decades earlier.
  2. Review of prior enquiries and administrative conclusions: The Court reviewed (and relied upon) findings from the departmental enquiry (Assistant Collector of Customs' report), the Collector of Customs' order (10-2-1969) which accepted that the father’s claim to 'Konda Kapu' was not disproved, the Central Board of Excise & Customs' subsequent action (which imposed a limited penalty but acknowledged community classification), and the Secretary, Ministry of Finance's appeal decision (29-6-1971) which explicitly observed that the father belonged to the 'Konda Kapu' community and exonerated him of having produced a forged SSLC. The Court also considered the Inspector General of Police (CID) report (31-5-1988) commissioned by the State, which found no basis to continue allegations and recorded that the father belonged to 'Konda Kapu'.
  3. Treatment of the 2nd respondent's reasons: The Court analysed each ground relied upon by the 2nd respondent and found many to be flimsy, irrelevant, or unsound:
    • Surname: Held irrelevant (citing Abhoy Pada Saha).
    • Intermarriage and social alliances: The Court explained that Konda Kapus historically forged alliances with Kapu/Telaga families and that such alliances (without evidence of excommunication or ritual sanction) do not negate tribal status.
    • Dialect/traditions: The absence of a distinct dialect or certain tribal rituals was not persuasive because Konda Kapus had in many areas adopted broader Hindu customs over time.
    • Certificates and reports from the 1950s: The 2nd respondent's rejection of contemporaneous local enquiries and Collector/Tahsildar reports was criticised as fanciful; many of these documents had been proved and used as exhibits in earlier official enquiries and disciplinary proceedings and should not have been dismissed on grounds such as non-marking or lack of local jurisdiction in the manner the 2nd respondent did.
    • Alleged tampering with SSLC: The Court noted prior enquires had considered the SSLC alterations and that senior authorities had given benefit of doubt, and that the cumulative official record supported the father's classification as Konda Kapu.
  4. On the issuing authority and jurisdiction: The 2nd respondent's reliance on G.O.Ms No.147 (requiring certificates from native place) was held to be inapplicable in the rigid manner asserted, because the father had migrated long ago and the G.O. did not lay down absolute terms that a certificate must only be obtained from native village authorities. The Court held the Mandal Revenue Officer's certificate dated 21-4-1988 was in order.
  5. On the power to cancel community certificates: The Court observed that the 2nd respondent's proceedings in effect attempted to cancel certificates issued by competent authorities — an act the 2nd respondent lacked authority to perform in the manner adopted, especially in light of G.O.Ms No.282 which authorizes specified District Magistrates/ADMs to cancel false certificates following prescribed procedures and hearing.
  6. On prejudice and remedy: The Court acknowledged the petitioner had been selected and qualified for admission for 1988–89 but, due to delay and the 2nd respondent's action, lost one academic year. Applying precedents about moulding equitable relief where circumstances have changed, the Court held immediate admission for the elapsed year was impossible; instead it quashed the impugned proceedings and directed admission for the next academic year (1989–1990) without further reference to respondents 2 or 3.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Writ Petition was allowed; the impugned proceedings of the 2nd respondent dated 23-11-1988 were quashed and a writ of mandamus issued directing the 1st respondent to grant admission to the petitioner into the First Year M.B.B.S. course at Andhra Medical College, Visakhapatnam for the academic year 1989–1990 forthwith, without reference to the 2nd or 3rd respondents.

Other Orders and Consequences:

  • The Writ Petition was allowed with costs of Rs. 1,000 to be recovered personally from the 2nd respondent and advocate's fee of Rs. 250.
  • The Court quashed the 2nd respondent’s impugned proceedings (23-11-1988) that rejected the petitioner's claim to Scheduled Tribe status.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The petitioner is entitled to admission for the academic year 1989–1990 as ordered; the 2nd respondent's decision is invalidated.
  • Procedural implication: The opinion criticises ad hoc and late determinations of social status that cause irreversible prejudice and endorses the need for a more rational, earlier and reliable procedure for issuing/resolving certificates (as reflected in the cited State of Maharashtra v. Abhoy passage), though the Court did not itself establish a new procedural rule beyond its directions in this case.
  • Precedential effect: The Court applied existing authorities to the facts but did not purport to lay down novel legal principles beyond affirming established tests (e.g., surname irrelevance; treatment of temporary urban residence) and the discretionary power to mould relief when circumstances change.

This summary strictly reflects only the facts, reasoning and outcomes as contained in the provided opinion text. No information has been added that was not present in that opinion.

Show all summary ...

1. This is a petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for issue of a Writ more particularly one in the nature of a Writ of Mandamus or an order or a direction declaring the action of the respondent in not granting admission to the petitioner into the First year M.B.B.S course offered by the Medical Colleges of the Government in the State for the academic year 1988-1989 against the seats reserved for the Scheduled Tribes as arbitrary, illegal and unconstitutional and further declaring Rule 8(D)(1) of the rules governing admission into the First year M.B.B.S and B.D.S course as published by the 1st respondent as highly arbitrary and illegal.

2. The material facts giving rise to the above Writ Petition may be briefly stated: The petitioner Miss Y. Padma Mythili being a minor represented by her father and guardian Sri Y.R Kishen studied Intermediate course (10+2) and passed the same in March, 1987. She appeared for the EAMCET (Engineering, Agricultural and Medical Common Entrance Test) held in May, 1980 with hall ticket No. 60905 and sought admission into the First year M.B.B.S course offered by the Medical Colleges of the Government in the State against the seats reserved for successful candidates belonging to Scheduled Tribes. Along with the application the petitioner enclosed a certificate dated 21-4-1988 issued by the Mandal Revenue Officer, Visakhapatnam to the effect that she was a member of ‘Konda Kapu’ community recognised as a “Scheduled Tribe”. She received a telegram from the 3rd respondent calling upon her to appear before him on 6-9-1988 along with any elder member of her family for verification of her social status. The petitioner and her father accordingly appeared before the 3rd respondent with all the certificates and other documentary evidence in support of the petitioner's claim. The 3rd respondent asked the petitioner to fill up a questionnaire wherein she was required to state her place of residence and furnish details of her fore-fathers as also other details such as the traditions and customs of her community. Neither the petitioner nor her father was examined and no other enquiry was conducted. All the necessary information, particulars and details as required were furnished and the petitioner was informed by the 3rd respondent that the result of the enquiry would be communicated to her and clearance of her social status would be given in a short time. However she was not granted admission by the 1st respondent for want of clearance of her social status by respondents 2 and 3 though she was selected for admission into the First year M.B.B.S course. After sufficiently waiting for a long time, the petitioner's father addressed a letter to the 1st respondent on 19-9-1988 requesting him to admit his daughter into the First year M.B.B.S course as classes had been commenced by then. No reply having been received the petitioner was constrained to file the above Writ Petition on 10-10-1988. Along with the Writ Petition the petitioner filed W.P.M.P No. 19540 of 1988 seeking an interim direction to the 1st respondent to admit the petitioner into the First year M.B.B.S course offered by the Andhra Medical College, Visakhapatnam, pending disposal of the Writ Petition. The Government Pleader for Social Welfare however sought time for receipt of instructions. A notice dated 4-10-1988 from the 2nd respondent was received by the petitioner to show cause on or before 14-10-88 as to why the social status claimed by her should not be rejected in the light of the enquiries conducted by him and the material collected during the said enquiries, more fully set out therein. She was also directed to appear before him on 15-10-1988 at 11 a.m along with her father for a personal hearing of her case. On 12-10-1988 the petitioner submitted her explanation in detail with reference to the enquiries made by the 2nd respondent and the material gathered by him during the said enquiries. The petitioner's father also submitted another explanation on 14-10-1988 and handed over the same in person to the Personal Assistant of the 2nd respondent in the office of the 2nd respondent as he could not get any interview with the 2nd respondent. The petitioner's father also made a special request to the Personal Assistant to the 2nd respondent to pass appropriate orders immediately as admissions to the M.B.B.S course had been commenced. The 2nd respondent by another letter dated 21-10-1988 addressed to the petitioner called upon her to appear in person before him on 3-11-1988 for a personal hearing in case she desired to be heard in person, whereupon, the petitioner sent a reply dated 31-10-1988 stating that whatever information was required had already been submitted and that in the absence of any fresh points riased there was nothing more to be submitted. Later, when the Writ Petition came up for further hearing this Court by its order dated 10-11-1988 directed the 2nd respondent to complete the enquiry and pass a final order on or before 25-11-1988. When the Writ Petition came up for further hearing on 25-11-1988 the learned counsel for the petitioner was supplied with a copy of the proceedings of the 2nd respondent dated 23-11-1988 addressed to the 1st respondent wherein it was concluded that the petitioner could not be treated as a member of ‘Konda Kapu’ and could not therefore be considered for admission into the M.B.B.S course as against the seats reserved for the members of the Scheduled Tribes. The petitioner thereupon filed W.P.M.P 23250 of 1988 for quashing the proceeding of the 2nd respondent dated 23-11-1988 by way of amendment and the petition is ordered.

3. It is therefore necessary to extract the gist of the various documents and certificates placed before the 2nd respondent during the enquiry in support of the social status claimed by the petitioner:

(a) The petitioner's father was born on 20-1-1933 at Jeypore, Orissa State and his brith register extract issued by the office of the Health Officer, Jeypore Municipality on 12-4-1966 he was shown as ‘Konda Kapu’ against the column “Caste”. In the year 1934 the petitioner's grand father migrated to Vizianagaram. The petitioner's, father had his secondary school education in the Maha Rajah's High School, Vizianagaram and collegiate education in the Maharajah's College, Vizianagaram. On the first page of his Secondary School Leaving Certificate he was described as ‘Konda Kapu’ against the column “Caste”. The petitioner was first known as Yerubothula Appa Rao and he changed his name from Y. Appa Rao to Y. Rajendra Kishan. The change was recognised by the Andhra University by its proceedings dated 4-4-1956.

(b) As early as on 5-6-1954 the Tahsildar, Vizianagaram formerly forming part of the erstwhile Visakhapatnam district issued a certificate stating that the father of the petitioner was a member of ‘Konda Kapu’ community recognised as a Scheduled Tribe under the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950.

(c) On 23-11-1954 the Tahsildar, Vizianagaram certified that the petitioner's father was a member of Scheduled Tribe describing his sub-caste as ‘Konda Kapu’ and the same was counter-signed by the Sub Collector, Vizianagaram.

(d) On 12-1-1956 the Additional District Magistrate and Manager, Vizianagaram Estate issued a certificate stating that the petitioner's father was a member of ‘Konda Kapu’ community recognised as a Scheduled Tribe under the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950.

(e) On 9-6-1956 Sri G. Suryanarayana, member of the erstwhile Andhra Legislative Assembly certified that the petitioner's father was a member of Scheduled Tribe, his sub-caste being ‘Konda Kapu’.

(f) The Petitioner's father and some other students prosecuting higher studies applied for grant of scholarships of the Central Government for the years 1955-1956 and 1956-1957 claiming to be members of the Scheduled Tribes. The Collector, Visakhapatnam by his letter dated 13-12-1956 directed the Tahsildar, Vizianagaram to investigate into the claim of the petitioner's father and submit his report as to whether he actually belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ or not. The Tahsildar, Vizianagaram enquired into the claim of the petitioner's father and submitted his report dated 30-1-1957 stating that he was a member of ‘Konda Kapu’. During the enquiry, the petitioners paternal grand father was examined. The report may be usefully extracted:

N. Lakshmi Kantam, B.A To Tahsildar, The Collector Vizianagaram Visakhapatnam

Sub: Award of scholarships to Scheduled Tribes—Bogus adoption of ‘Konda Kapu’.

Ref: Your confidential No. 34862/56-S2 dt. 13-12-56.

2. This office No. 8644/56 dt. 28-1-57

3. Your telegram dt. 29-1-57.

In continuation of my report cited, I beg to report that another person by name Sri Yerubothula Venkatarao, father of Yerubothula Apparao now residing at Vizianagaram has attended the enquiry. He states that his son Y. Apparao had been to Madras—seeking employment. Hence his statement could not be obtained. I, therefore, recorded the statement from the father of the candidate, which is herewith submitted for perusal. He has produced S.S.L.C register of his son and certificate issued by the Tahsildar and counter-signed by the Sub Collector, Vizianagaram and a testimonial of Sri Harihar Misra, M.L.A Jeypore which shows the caste of the candidate as ‘Konda Kapu’. Copies of these documents are also herewith submitted.

The birth place of the candidate is Jeypore and he has relations only at Jeypore but not in any plain areas. The deponent has moved to Vizianagaram from Jeypore because he could procure bus driver job herewith which he is maintaining his family.

Remaining candidates were summoned already and they are yet to attend the enquiry.

Sd. N. Lakshmikantam,

Tahsildar”.

4. On receipt of the said report, the Collector, Visakhapatnam by his D.O letter dated 13-2-1957 addressed to the Tahsildar, Vizianagaram called upon him to make further enquiries into the social status claimed by the petitioner's father as his earlier report might have been based on the entries found in the S.S.L.C register of the petitioner's father. Thereafter, the Tahsildar, Vizianagaram made confidential enquiries and submitted his report to the Collector, Visakhapatnam on 26-3-1957, which may be usefully extracted:

“Dear Sir,

Sub: Award of scholarships to Scheduled Tribes—Bogus adoption of ‘Konda Kapu’.

Ref: Your D.O.R.C 34862/5-S2 dt. 10-3-1957.

My confidential enquiries reveal that Yerubothula Venkatarao, father of Yerubothula Apparao was a native of Jeypore. He moved to Vizianagaram from Jeypore in the year 1934 seeking employment. He has been residing here and maintaining his family. He is now working as Bus driver and residing in Thupakala street, Vizianagaram. He belongs to ‘Konda Kapu’ caste and he got his son educated at Vizianagaram.

Yours faithfully,

Sd. N. Lakshmikantam,

Tahsildar.

Sri V. Venkataratnam,

P.A to the Collector,

Visakhapatnam.”

5. After completing the enquiry the Collector, Visakhapatnam submitted his report dated 22-4-1957 to the Deputy Secretary to Government, Social Welfare and Labour Department, Hyderabad and the report runs thus;

Sub: Award of Scholorships to Scheduled Tribes—Bogus adoption of ‘Konda Kapu’.

Ref: (1) Government Memo No. 1338-F. 56-12 dt. 23-4-56.

(2) My report R.C No. 34862/56-S2 dt. 10-3-57.

(3) Government D.O No. 1338.F/56/23 dt. 15-3-57.

Enquiries about the community of the candidates who applied for renewal of fresh grant of scholarships, revealed result noted against each;

Particulars of the candidate in the list. Name of the candidate and father's name; Result of Enquiry List 3, item No. 87 1956-1957 Yerubothula Apparao, son of Venkatarao He blongs to ‘Konda Kapu’ community. 2. ………………………………. 3 ……………………………….. 4 ……………………………… 5 ……………………………….

I am awaiting reports of the Taluk Officers in respect of the remaining candidate I shall send the final report on receipt of replies from them.

Sd……………………..

for Collector, Visakhapatnam,

22-4-57”

(g) On 22-1-1957 Sri Harihar Misra, Ex-Member of the Legislative Assembly, Jeypore, issued a certificate to the effect of that Sri Yerubothula Venkatarao, the paternal grand-father of the petitioner was a member of ‘Konda Kapu’ community.

(h) The petitioner's father registered his name in the Employment Exchange Visakhapatnam on 9-8-1956. He produced his Secondary School Leaving Certificate in original before the Employment Exchange and on the strength of the particulars contained therein his community was noted as ‘Konda Kapu’ in the record of registration. In response to the requisition received from the Collector of customs, Madras, for recruitment of Preventive Officers Grade II in the Madras Customs House his name was sponsored by the Employment Exchange Visakhapatnam along with some other names. He appeared for a written test wherein he secured more than 50% of marks as required under the rules and he also passed the viva voce examination conducted therefor. He was selected and appointed as Preventive Officer. Grade II in a vacancy reserved for Scheduled Tribes. He joined in service in the year 1957 and on the first page of his Service Book he was shown to be a member of Scheduled Tribe (Konda Kapu).

(i) Ten years later on a complaint received against the father of the petitioner that he was not a member of the Scheduled Tribe of ‘Konda Kapu’ the Collector of Customs, Madras, directed enquiry into his social status and appointed Sri H.T Soares, Assistant Collector of Customs as the enquiry Officer. The following charge was framed by the Enquiry Officer;

“That the said Sri Y.R Kishen, permanent Preventive Officer Grade I, Customs House, Madras, behaved in a highly objectionable and improper manner in connection with his appointment as Preventive Officer Grade II, Customs House, Madras, in the year 1956 inasmuch as he secured the said appointment in a vacancy reserved for Scheduled Tribes by furnishing (1) false information about his community to the Employment Exchanges Visakhapatnam and to the Collector of Customs, Madras, that he belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ community which is a Scheduled Tribe and (2) by producing a forged SSLC in support of the same while in fact he belonged to ‘Telaga’ community which is not a Scheduled Tribe.”

6. After conducting a thorough enquiry into the charge and after examining ten witnesses produced by the Presenting Officer Sri M.S.R Swamy, Inspector of Police, appointed under Rule 14(5)(c) of the C.C.S (C.C.A) Rules as also five witnesses including Sri Harihara Misra, former M.L.A Jeypore, Orissa Legislature and Dr. Sathpathi, Assistant Surgeon, Jeypore Municipality on behalf of the petitioner's father and after marking a number of exhibits on either side, the Enquiry Officer submitted his report to the Collector, Customs, Madras, on 29-6-1968. The material part of the report of the Enquiry Officer may be usefully extracted;

“For all practical purposes Sri Y. Venkatarao (father of the charged officer) might have been descended from a line of forebearers who inhibited the hill slopes of the Agency areas around Visakhapatnam district, and, therefore, the evidence tendered by P.W 9 does not disprove the contention of the defendant that his father was ‘Konda Kapu’ to which tribe, he as his legitimate son claims to belong. I am, therefore not relying on the evidence-tendered by P.W 9 to clinch the question of the caste of the charged officer.

The issue regarding the caste of the charged officer therefore revolves on one main point. Whatever caste he might actually belong to, there has been a change of caste during his scholastic career. If he actually was born ‘Konda Kapu’ he became ‘Telaga’ and reverted to ‘Konda Kapu’ at the time of registration in the Employment Exchange. If, on the other hand he was born ‘Telaga’ he maintained this caste till the time he registered at the Employment Exchange and then changed to ‘Konda Kapu’ with the object of securing employment in a vacancy reserved for Scheduled Tribe candidates and caused his S.S.L.C to be altered to support his claim to be ‘Konda Kapu’ tribe. These are, in effect, the alternate issues, to be faced. From the evidence tendered and from the examination of the witnesses for and against, I find that there is insufficient data for conclusive proof of his actual caste. The evidence brought in by the Presenting Officer which is based on entries in school and college records and in the birth register of half brother and half sister, does not in actual fact prove that his caste is not ‘Konda Kapu’ and, therefore, the benefit of doubt regarding his true caste is given to the charged officer and his claim to belong to the ‘Konda Kapu’ tribe is not disproved. The charge that he has furnished false information about his community to the Employment Exchange, Visakhapatnam and to the Collector of Customs, Madras is not, therefore, proved.”

7. The Enquiry Officer however held that the petitioner's father had produced a forged Secondary School Leaving Certificate to the Collector of Customs, Madras in support of his claim that he belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ community. To that extent that part of the charge was held to be proved against the father of the petitioner. On receipt of the report, the Collector of Customs while accepting the first part of the report, exonorated the petitioner's father of the second part of the charge by his order dated 10-2-1969 which runs as follows:

“The undersigned has carefully gone through the records of the case and the findings of the Enquiry Officer. The undersigned does not think the fact the records maintained in the schools and colleges showed Shri Kishen's caste as ‘Telaga’ can be considered as any additional independent evidence to support the argument that he only belonged to the ‘Telaga’ community, in view of the fact that what was entered in the school records at the time of his first entry to the elementary school in 1941, had merely been carried over from time to time in the transfer certificates and other documents issued thereafter. In other words, if the caste had been wrongly declared as ‘Telaga’ during his first admission to the school, the same mistake had been carried over right through. The question therefore that arises is whether the declaration of caste given in the first instance by the Officer's father to the school authorities was correct or not. It is on record that the declaration should have been given orally as there is no documentary evidence in the form of any written declaration in support. Thus, what was supposed to have been declared orally at the time of the Officer's entry into school has been adopted in all subsequent documents in the schools and colleges. The undersigned feels that it would not be improper to consider that consequent on the promulgation of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Lists Modifications Order, 1930 in which ‘Konda Kapu’ community inhabiting the hills and places adjoining Vizianagaram district was classified as a Scheduled Tribe, the question of correctness of the declaration of the officer's community as ‘Telaga’ in the first instance should have cropped up in his mind. Presumably, realising that being a ‘Konda Kapu’ he would be eligible for the benefits to which Scheduled Tribes are entitled, the officer would have thought it fit to declare his true caste of ‘Konda Kapu’ in all his subsequent documents starting from his application dated 12-12-1955 to the University for admission to the B.A Degree Examination.

8. The enquiry records do not unequivocally establish that the officer does not belong to ‘Konda Kapu’ or does belong only to the ‘Telaga’ community. At the most, the undersigned considers that all that can be done is to draw an inference that because his caste which was originally mentioned in the school records as ‘Telaga’ was subsequently changed to ‘Konda Kapu’ (fraudulently or otherwise), the latter declaration should be false. As against this is the very strong fact that Revenue Authorities, on discreet enquiries, had come to the definite finding that the officer had declared his caste as ‘Konda Kapu’ even in 1955 in his application to the University and this was done long before he registered his name in the Employment Exchange, and, as a consequence, secured the appointment in the Custom House. It is not anybody's case that he declared his caste as ‘Konda Kapu’ for the first time to the Employment Exchange on 9-8-1956. Obviously on 12-12-1965, while declaring his caste ‘Konda Kapu’ in his application to the University, the charged officer could not have foreseen any officer from the Customs Department a year later.

9. What the undersigned has to consider is the charge that the officer behaved in a highly objectionable and improper manner for securing appointment by furnishing false information about his community. The subsequent declaration as ‘Konda Kapu’ can deemed to be false only if it is conclusively established that the original declaration of his caste as ‘Telaga’ was true and correct. The records do not serve to establish that he does belong only to the ‘Telaga’ community. Hence the undersigned considers that the question of his subsequent declaration that he belonged to the ‘Konda Kapu’ community being false does not arise in the absence of existence of any proof to the contrary.

As regards the second portion of the charge of production of a forged SSLC book, the undersigned finds that the entries in the book have been tampered with by making erasures and overwritings without any due attestation. The original entry which is not decipherable has been erased and in its place the words ‘Hindu Konda Kapu’ have been substituted. The fact as to when and by whom the corrections were made has not been brought out. The charge is not that he forged the SSLC book but that he produced a forged SSLC book. To bring here the charge, it has to be observed that the writing in the book was fraudulently altered. Fraudulent intention is therefore a necessary ingredient. No doubt, the responsibility of keeping the book in proper custody lay in the officer and it is therefore reasonable to believe that the erasures and alterations could not have been made without his knowledge. If the corrections had been made before the officer got his name registered in the Employment Exchange, it cannot be said that they were made for the purpose of securing an appointment in the Custom House. Once it has not been established that the Officer does not belong to ‘Konda Kapu’ community, a correction to that effect would only have the effect of an unauthenticated entry, as it would not amount to false information. It is relevant in this connection to refer to the note contained in the SSLC book which reads that ‘erasures and unauthenticated or fraudulent alterations in the certificate will lead to the cancellation of the same (vide Rule 6 of the SSLC Subsidiary rules).’ According to this note any unauthenticated alteration has the effect of nullifying the validity of the certificate itself. It should not be forgotten that the SSLC book was produced before the Employment Exchange as well as before the Collector of Customs, Madras, at the time of interview. As the erasures and over-writings were there even then, an assumption that the authorities were satisfied as to the genuineness of the entries in the SSLC book cannot be wrong, since, if it had been found otherwise, the book would have been rejected as note genuine and acceptable.

Whereas on consideration of the records of the disciplinary proceedings initiated against Shri Y.R Kishen, and having regard to the circumstances of the case, the undersigned is satisfied that it will be neither fair nor equitable in the interest of justice to hold the charge as proved on flimsy grounds, and passes the following order;—

Now, Therefore, the undersigned hereby orders that the further proceedings be dropped and the charged officer, Shri Y.R Kishen, Preventive Officer, Grade I, be exonerated from the charge levelled against him.”

No. C. 13/5/64-Corr. Vig. Custom House, Madras-1, Date: 10-2-1969”.

j) The Central Board of Excise & Customs reviewed the order of the Collector of Customs, Madras dated 10-2-1969 and by its memorandum dated 2-5-1970 called upon the petitioner's father to show-cause as to why the finding recorded by the Enquiry Officer that the second part of the charge that he had forged his SSLC register to secure employment in a vacancy reserved for Scheduled Tribes was proved against him, should not be accepted. The Central Board of Excise & Customs however agreed with the finding of the Collector of Customs, Madras that the petitioner's father belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ community. In and by the said memorandum it was proposed to inflict on him the penalty of stoppage of one increment without cumulative effect. To the said memorandum the father of the petitioner submitted a datailed explanation on 9-7-1970. He pleaded that he was rightly exonerated by the Collector of Customs, Madras of the entire charge framed against him. The explanation did not find acceptance with the Central Board of Excise & Customs and it passed the following order on 14-12-1970 inflicting on him the penalty of stoppage of one increment without cumulative effect.

“As however Shri Kishen belongs to ‘Konda Kapu’ community and the evidence on record does not establish his mala fide in producing the forged SSLC, the Board taking a lenient view of the matter had come to the provisional conclusion of imposing the proposed penalty of stoppage of one increment without cumulative effect. None of the contentions raised by Shri Kishen in reply to the show cause notice is tenable. The Board see no justification to alter their provisional conclusion. Accordingly the penalty of stoppage of one increment without cumulative effect is confirmed.”

10. The Central Board of Excise and Customs however agreed with the finding of the Collector, Customs, Madras, relating to the first part of the charge that he belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ community.

k) Against the said order of the Central Board of Excise & Customs the petitioner preferred a memorandum of appeal on 14-2-1971 to the Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue & Insurance, New Delhi and the same was allowed by the Finance Secretary by his order dated 29-6-1971 and the same may be usefully extracted hereunder:

“Shri Y.R Kishen in his appeal dated 14-2-1971 and having regard to all the facts and circumstances of the case the Finance Secretary has observed that it is admitted by all concerned that Shri Kishen belongs to the ‘Konda Kapu’ community which is a recognised Scheduled Tribe, and not to ‘Telaga’ community which is not a Scheduled Tribe. Therefore, there has been no misrepresentation or false representation about his community on the basis of which he obtained a post in the Customs Department under Government. As regards the question whether Shri Y.R Kishen produced a forged S.S.L.C the Finance Secretary has observed that a document could be considered to be forged only if the entries therein are false or incorrect or designed to mislead but in this case it is not held that any of the entries in the S.S.L.C is false. To that extent the SSLC is not a forged document. However, there are marks of erasure and over-writings in the S.S.L.C which indicate that alterations have been made in the certificate. It is also true that earlier Shri Kishen's father described himself as belonging to ‘Telaga’ community and several of the school and other records show Shri Kishen as one of the Telaga community: but subsequently, for the first time in 1954 and again in 1956, he obtained a certificate from the local District authorities to establish that he belongs to ‘Konda Kapu’ community. There are indications of alteration to this effect in the registers maintained by the College authorities when he was, studying there. Shri Kishen's contention that the alterations may have been made by the College Authorities themselves after he had produced proof of his belonging to Konda Kapu community is not altogether beyond belief. There is no evidence or proof that he himself got the entries changed or altered as he was not deriving any benefit by making this change. He could take advantage of the concessions offered to Scheduled Tribe candidates only on the production of a certificate from the District Authorities and not on the basis of the SSLC. In the circumstances, the Finance Secretary has agreed with the findings of the Collector of Sustoms, Madras contained in order No. C. 13/5/64-Corr. Vig. dated 10-2-1969 and has given benefit of doubt to Shri Kishen and thus exonerated him of the charge against him. Accordingly the Finance Secretary has allowed the appeal of Shri Kishen and set aside order No. 4/17/69-Ad. V dated 14-12-1970 of the Central Board of Excise & Customs.”

11. The unimpeachable evidence extracted above and placed before the 2nd respondent was rejected by him by his proceedings dated 23-11-1988 holding that the petitioner could not be treated as a member of the Scheduled Tribe of ‘Konda Kapu’ and could not therefore be considered for admission into the M.B.B.S course against the seats reserved for Scheduled Tribers. The reasons assigned by the 2nd respondent are enumerated hereunder:

1) The surname of the petitioner, “Yerubothula” is uncommon amongst the tribe of ‘Konda Kapus’ and the said surname is mostly found amongst the members of the communities of ‘Telaga’ and ‘Kapu’.

2) The second wife of the petitioner's paternal grand father was a member of ‘Telaga’ or ‘Kapu’ community. Even his first wife was not a member of ‘Konda Kapu’. The petitioner's mother Smt. Kamalamma alias Kamala also belongs to ‘Telaga’ or ‘Kapu’ community.

3) The spouses of the paternal uncles and paternal aunts of the petitioner are from ‘Telaga’ or ‘Kapu’ community. On that account none of them was excommunicated for violation of the rule of endogomy either by the members of ‘Kapu’ or ‘Telaga’ community or by the members of ‘Konda Kapu’ community. On the other hand, the members of the families of the petitioner are being treated by the members of the families of ‘Kapu’ and ‘Telaga’ communities as their equals.

4) The petitioner's father does not have any dialect of his own and he does not know the traditional-marriage patterns of the ‘Konda Kapu’ community.

5) The petitioner's family does not also know the various Gods and Goddesses associated with the festivals and rituals of the ‘Konda Kapu’ tribe.

6) The unattested community certificate dated 23-11-1954 issued by the Tahsildar, Vizianagaram and countersigned by the Sub-Collector, Vizianagaram and the unattested community certificate dated 12-1-1956 issued by the Additional District Magistrate and Manager, Vizianagaram Estate have no evidentiary value for the reason that no enquiries were conducted by them at Jeypore about the social status of the petitioner's father. The same cannot also be relied upon as they had no jurisdiction over the native place of the petitioner's father i.e, Jeypore Orissa State.

7) The community certificate dated 21-4-1988 issued to the petitioner by the M.R.O Visakhapatnam based on the certificate dated 29-8-1985 issued earlier by the then M.R.O Visakhapatnam cannot also be relied upon as no enquiries were made by them into the social status claimed by the petitioner's father in the light of instructions issued in G.O.Ms No. 147, Social Welfare (E) Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh, dated 27-4-1977. Both the Mandal Revenue Officers who issued the certificates did not also care to enquire into the question whether they had jurisdiction over the residence of the petitioner.

8) The extract of the register of admissions and withdrawals maintained in the Maharajah's High School, Vizianagaram in the year 1949 reveals that the petitioner's father Sri Yerubothula Appa Rao now known as Rajendra Kishen was described as a resident of Vizianagaram belonging to ‘Telaga’ community. The petitioner's father secured readmission in the same school on 27-6-1950 and his caste was again recorded as ‘Telaga’. In the Transfer Certificate issued to the petitioner's father by the Headmaster of the Maharajah's High School, wherefrom he had studied and passed SSLC examination in March 1951 he was described as belonging to ‘Telaga’ community.

9) The entries on the first page of the petitioner's father's Secondary School Leaving Certificate were found tampered with and against column of ‘caste’ in the certificate, the words ‘Konda Kapu’ were found over-written.

10) Sri Yerubothula Mohan Rao, brother of the petitioner's father serving as Assistant Depot. Clerk in the Depot, of the A.P.S.R.T.C Vizianagaram was described as belonging to ‘Kapu’ community in his Service Register. Both of his daughters were described as belonging to ‘Telaga2 community in the records maintained at the Maharajah's Girls High School, where they had studied.

11) The correspondence between the District Collector, Visakhapatnam and the Tahsildar, Vizianagaram relating to the claim of the social status of the petitioner's father for awarding scholarship by the Central Government to him in the years 1955-1956 and 1956-1957 and the subsequent report submitted by the Collector, Visakhapatnam to the Deputy Secretary to Government, Social Welfare and Labour Department confirming the social status claimed by the petitioner's father and recommending grant of scholarship to him cannot be looked into as copies of the same are not marked to the petitioner's father. It is surprising how the petitioner's father secured the said documents and it only indicates that the petitioner's father and grand father were carefully following the progress of the enquiries conducted in regard to their social status and that they must have influenced the enquiries through some persons in the Taluk Office, Vizianagaram and the Collectorate, Visakhapatnam.

12) The birth extract of the petitioner's father issued by the Office of the Health Officer, Jeypore Municipality on 12-4-1966 has no value as the same was signed by a Maistry of the Union Board, Jeypore. Further the veracity of the entries made therein has to be verified carefully after calling for the concerned registers from Jeypore.

13) It was found by the Central Board of Excise and Customs that the petitioner's father had tampered with the entries on the first page of his SSLC register about his social status with an intention to secure employment in a vacancy reserved for the candidates belonging to Scheduled Tribes and imposed the penalty of stoppage of one increment on him. The Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Government of India was clearly in error in exonerating the petitioner's father of the said charge by giving him the benefit of doubt.

14) The community certificate issued by Sri Harihar Misra cannot also be relied upon in the absence of proof of the same by examining him.

12. The counter-affidavit filed by the 2nd respondent need not be specially adverted to as it merely incorporates the gist of the impugned proceedings issued by him.

13. The reasons assigned by the second respondent for rejecting the social status claimed by the petitioner are either flimsy or irrelevant or unsound or untenable.

14. ‘Konda Kapus’ are a sub-division of ‘Kapus’ and the same is mentioned by Rev, J. Cain as being engaged in cultivation and timber trade in the eastern ghats near the Godavari river. (Volume III-K, Castes and Tribes of Southern India by Edgar Thurston at page 230).

15. In the erstwhile State of Madras of which the State of Andhra Pradesh originally formed part, a notification was published in the Fort. St. George Gazette dated 12-6-1934 inviting applications for appointment to posts in the Madras Ministerial Service. Reservation in recruitment to the posts in favour of “Hill and aboriginal tribes” was made and in the annexure appended to the notification ‘Kapus’ of Vizianagaram and Godavari districts were classified as “Hill and aboriginal tribes”.

16. Sri V.N Kudva, ICS former Agent to the Governor, East Godavari district was called upon to submit a report by the erstwhile Government of Madras on aboriginal tribes, the conditions and progress achieved by them and the following observations from his report dated 17-5-1977 may be usefully extracted:

“In a part of Yellavaram taluk which adjoins the Vizagpatnam taluk there are the Konda Doras and Konda Kapus who are more civilised than the Konda Reddys and Koyas.

17. The Konda Reddys, Konda-Kapus and Konda Doras who avoid beef, are rapidly adopting Hindu customs and manner and are recognised as caste Hindus. During my recent tours it came to my notice that the Konda Reddi Muscadar or Musurumilli had succeeded in marrying a woman of the Telaga community”.

18. In determining the social status of a candidate his sur-name is irrelevant, as laid down in Abhoy Pada Saha v. Sudhir Kumar (1) AIR 1967 SC 115.

19. The fact that the spouses of the petitioner's father, grand father, paternal uncles and paternal aunts were selected and drawn from the families of either ‘Telaga’ or ‘Kapu’ community does not detract them from claiming to be ‘Konda Kapus’ if in fact the petitioner's paternal grand father belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ community. In course of time, to improve their social status ‘Konda Kapus’ sought alliances with the families of ‘Kapus’ and ‘Telagas’ and many eligible, educated and well placed bachelors amongst ‘Kunoa Kapus’ succeeded in choosing their spouses from the families of ‘Telagas’ or ‘Kapus’ There is no question of excommunication of these male members from ‘Konda Kapu’ community on that account as no such religious practices or tenets are pointed out by the 2nd respondent.

20. It is also not pointed out by the 2nd respondent that ‘Konda Kapus’ have any special dilect of their own. In any event as stated by Sri V.N Kudva, ‘Konda Kapus’ in course of time embraced religious and cultural traditions and habits of caste Hindus as they advanced in life. The fact that to-day most of Konda ‘Kapus’ are highly educated and well placed does not debar them from claiming the said status and for their children, the incidental concessions and benefits conferred upon them, for pursuing higher education and for seeking better employment. If in the opinion of the Government of India ‘Konda Kapus’ do not require any special protection any longer it is for Parliament to delete that Tribe from the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950.

21. The other ground assigned by the 2nd respondent for rejection of the social status claimed by the petitioner that the community certificate should have been obtained by the petitioner from Jeypore, comprised in the Orissa State, as it was the native place of her paternal grand father, late Y Venkatarao as laid down in G.O.Ms No. 147 Social Welfare (E) Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh, dated 27-4-1977 is wholly untenable. In the first instance, the assumption, that the petitioner's grand father was a native of Jeypore is wrong. It is true that the petitioner's paternal grand father was eking out his livelihood at Jeypore. There is absolutely nothing on record as to how and under what circumstances he choose to reside at Jeypore to meet his both ends. It is true that the petitioner's father was born at Jeypore on 20-1-1933. But in the year 1934 the petitioner's grand father migrated to Vizianagaram to eke out his livelihood. There was therefore, no question of obtaining community certificate from any authority at Jeypore. The G.O relied upon by the 2nd respondent does not also envisage issue of community certificates by any authority from outside of the State and the G.O is not capable of compliance in the Orissa State. In fact, Konda Kapus belonging to the Andhra Pradesh and not the Orissa State are classified as a Scheduled Tribe under the Constutition (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950.

22. The petitioner's father had his secondary school education and collegiate education at Vizianagaram only and thereafter in the Andhra University, Visakhapatnam After studying for some time in the Andhra University, the petitioner's father joined in service as Preventive Officer Grade II in the Customs House, Madras, in the year 1957. It is not claimed that the petitioner's father acquired any proporties at Vizianagaram. There is little possibility of any fruitful investigation into the question of social status of the petitioner's father being conducted now at Vizianagaram where none of the ancestors of the petitioner's father is alive. Very often it happens that people leave their villages of origin in search of employment and severe off all connections with their native villages without leaving any trace of their origin and nativity. In such cases there is remote possibility of ascertaining the background of such families from their villages of origin for the reason that for the past several decades no one belonging to such families resides in those villages or leaves any property belonging to those families. I must however observe that G.O.Ms No. 147 Social Welfare (E) Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh, dated 27-4-1977 does not lay down in unqualified terms that in every case the community certificate should be obtained by a person from the concerned authority of his native village.

23. The petitioner was admittedly born at Visakapatnam and she had her education upto the Intermediate course at Visakapatnam. In fact the petitioner's father owns a house at Visakhapatnam. The petitioner's father thus embraced Visakhapatnam at least as his temporary if not permanent residence, though over decades he was moving from place to place during the course of his employment.

24. In Atul Khullar v. State of J. & K. (2) 1986 Supp SCC 225 : AIR 1986 SC 1224, it was held:

“The temporary residence in an urban area cannot deny those candidates the right to admission on the basis of a reserved category if in fact they belong permanently to a village in a backward area. A candidate may belong to a village in terms of the requirement prescribed by the Anand Committee Report and because of the lack of higher educational facilities he may have to reside temporarily in a city where such education is available. It may also be that a parent of the candidate may pursuant to his employment have taken up residence in an urban area. That in itself does not snap the bond between the candidate's family and the village, so long as the assumption of residence in the city is occasioned by temporary necessity”.

25. The community certificate dated 21-4-1988 issued to the petitioner by the Mandal Revenue Officer, Visakhapatnam is therefore in order.

26. Another reason assigned by the 2nd respondent in rejecting the community certificate issued by the Mandal Revenue Officer, Visakhaptnam is that it was clearly based upon the earlier certificate issued by the Tahsildar Visakhapatnam on 29-8-1985 and that both of them never conducted any independent enquiry into the social status of the petitioner as contemplated by G.O.Ms No. 147 Social Welfare (E) Department Government of A.P dated 27-4-1977. The G.O authorising issue of community certificates for members of ‘Konda Kapus’ does not lay down in particular what types of enquiries are to be made by the competent authorities noted therein. All that is stated therein is that the compentent authority of any Taluk in respect of which the members of a particular Scheduled Tribe claim nativity should issue.

27. In W.P No. 5726 of 1982 the petitioner therein sought admission into the College of Engineering Kakinada East Godavari against the seats reserved for Scheduled Tribes and enclosed to the application the community certificate issued by the Tahsildar Yellavaram to the effect that he was a member of ‘Konda Kapu’ community. The same was rejected by the Director of Tribal Welfare on the ground that no enquiries as envisaged by G.O.Ms No. 147 Social Welfare (E) Department Government of A.P dated 27-4-77 were made. Adverting to the said contentions Justice Rama Rao by his judgment dated 11-11-82 allowed the Writ Petition holding that the Tahsildar was not obliged to disclose the material or the enquiry he had made before issuing the certificate. It must be therefore presumed that the Mandal Revenue Officer Visakhapatnam made the necessary enquiries before issuing the certificate dated 21-4-1988.

28. In any event during the enquiry conducted by the 2nd respondent the petitioner produced before the 2nd respondent a community certificate dated 5-6-1954 issued to the petitioner's father by the Tahsildar Vizinagaram and another community certificate dated 23-11-1954 also issued by the Tahsildar Vizianagaram and counter-signed by the Sub-Collector Vizianagaram and another community certificate dt. 12-1-1956 issued by the Additional District Magistrate and Manager Vizianagaram Estate to the father of the petitioner to the effect that he was a member of ‘Konda Kapu’ a Scheduled Tribe. There was then no question of their making any enquiries as contemplated by G.O.Ms No. 147 Social Welfare (E) Department Government of A.P dated 27-4-1977 before issuing community certificates.

29. The certificates dt. 5-6-1954 and 23-11-1954 relied upon by the petitioner in support of her social status were rejected by the 2nd respondent on the ground that they were unattested copies little nothing that the same were proved and marked as Exs. D-16 and D-17 during the enquiry conducted by the Assistant Collector of Customs in the year 1967 pursuant to the order passed by the Collector Customs House Madras into the charge framed against the father of the petitioner that he secured appointment as Preventive Officer, Grade II in the Customs House Madras by furnishing false information about his status to the Employment Exchange Visakhapatnam and to the Collector of Customs Madras, that he belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ community a Scheduled Tribe and by producing a forged Secondary School Leaving Certificate in support of his claim while in fact he belonged to ‘Telaga’ community which is not a Scheduled Tribe. It therefore follows that the ground of rejection of those certificates the authenticity of which was not only not doubted but also proved beyond doubt during the enquiry conducted by the Assistant Collector Customs is fanciful if not flimsy.

30. What is more the reports dated 30-1-1957 and 26-3-1957 made by the Tahsildar, Vizianagaram in compliance with the requisition received from the Collector Visakhapatnam for the purpose of grant of scholarship of the Central Government to the petitioner's father and the subsequent report of the Collector of Visakhapatnam dt. 22-4-1957 addressed to the Deputy Secretary to Government Social Welfare and Labour Department Hyderabad holding that the petitioner's father belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ community and recommending grant of scholarship to him clinchingly and undoubtedly establish that the petitioner's father was a member of Scheduled Tribe. Significantly these reports were also proved and marked as Exs. D-10, D-12 and D-13 during the enquiry conducted by the Assistant Collector Customs. The said reports were rejected by the 2nd respondent on a flimsy ground that the same were not marked to the petitioner's father. Another desparate ground of rejection of those reports by the 2nd respondent is that the petitioner's father and her grand father would have manoeuvred those reports by influencing the then Tahsildar Vizianagaram and the Collector Visakhapatnam.

31. In support of her claim the petitioner also relied upon the community certificate dt. 22-1-1957 issued by Sri. Harihar Misra former Member of the Legislative Assembly Orissa State and ex-President of the Jeypore Union Board and an extract from the Register of Births maintained at Jeypore in the year 1933. The community certificate dt. 22-1-1957 issued by Sri Harihar Misra reads that the petitioners paternal grand father was a resident of Jeypore town till the end of 1934 and that he belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ caste. The extract from the Register of Births maintained by the Jeypore Municipality reads that the petitioner's father was born on 20-1-1933. His caste was described as ‘Konda Kapu’ and Venkata Rao and Sattiyamma were recorded as his parents. The information of particulars of his birth caste and parentage was furnished by his father as noted against column No. 15 of the extract. The information was registered by one Sri K. Appalaswamy Maistry Union Board as noted against column No. 16. At the end of the information the then President of the Union Board Jeypore Sri Harihar Misra appended his signature. A certified extract of the same was furnished by the Health Officer Jeypore Municipality and it bears the seal of the Health Officer of the Jeypore Municipality dt. 12-4-1966.

32. The community certificate issued by Sri Harihar Misra was rejected by the 2nd respondent on the ground of his non-examination. The extract from the Register of Births was rejected by the 2nd respondent on the ground that it is un-attested and also on the ground that it was signed by one K. Appala Swamy Maistry Union Board Jeypore on behalf of the Registrar of Births. The 2nd respondent also added that the extract would have been brought into existence by the petitioners father in the year 1966 in collusion with the officials of the Jeypore Municipality to get over the incriminating evidence gathered and collected from the records of the educational institutions where he had studied.

33. It is unfortunate that the 2nd respondent did not even care to peruse the entries made in the extract. Sri K. Appala Swamy, Maistry, Union Board, Jeypore had merely registered the information furnished by the petitioner's paternal grand father as noted against column No. 15. The extract was signed by the then President of Union Board, Jeypore, Sri Harihar Misra and a certified extract of the same was issued on 12-4-1966 by the Health Officer. Jeypore Municipality. Both Sri Harihar Misra and the then Health Officer Dr. Sathpathi, Assistant Surgeon, Public Health, Jeypore Municipality were examined as D.Ws 1 and 2, on 7-12-1967 by the Assistant Collector, Customs, during the enquiry conducted against the father of the petitioner and both of them proved the entries contained in the extract. Also Sri Harthar Misra proved the community certificate dated 22-1-1957 issued by him. Dr. Sathpathi stated that the extract relied upon by the petitioner was issued from the Register of Births maintained by the Jeypore Municipality in the year 1933 and that it bore his signature and the seal of his office dt. 12-4-1966 though he had no personnal knowledge of the contents in the extract. It is curious that the 2nd respondent deliberately ignored the statements of Sri Harihar Misra and Dr. Sathpathi recorded by the Assistant Collector, Customs on oath on 7-12-1967 in proof of the community certificate and the certified extract of Register of Births, marked as Exs. D-6 and D-7 respectively and brushed aside the two documents on flimsy and wholly untenable grounds. The comment levelled by the 2nd respondent that the certified extract of births would have been brought into existence in the year 1966 with a view to circumvent the incriminating evidence gathered and collected against the petitioner's father from the records maintained in the educational institutions where he had studied is wholly ill-founded for the reason that Sri Harihar Misra stated on oath before the Assistant Collector, Customs, during the enquiry that he had issued the community certificate dated 22-1-1957 to the petitioner's paternal grand father certifying his social status as ‘Konda Kapu’ on the strength of the entries made in the Register of Births maintained in the Jeypore Municipality in the year 1933. It therefore follows that even in the year 1957, the entries found in the certified extract of the register of births produced by the petitioner's father in support of his daughter's claims were in existence. The truth of the entries contained in the extract from the Register of Births maintained by the Jeypore Municipality and relied upon by the petitioner in support of her social status is established beyond doubt. While furnishing the information to the Jeypore Municipality all the relevant particulars of the birth of the petitioner's father on 20-1-1933, the petitioner's paternal grand father would have little visualised that our country would attain freedom on the 15th of August, 1947 and would not have predicted that we give unto ourselves a Constitution containing special provisions for the advancement of members of the Scheduled Tribes in matters of public employment. It therefore follows that both the extract from the register of births maintained by the Jeypore Municipality and the community certificate issued by Sri Harihar Misra relied upon by the petitioner clinchingly and conclusively establish the social status of the petitioner's father and the same were brushed aside and ignored by the 2nd respondent on reckless grounds.

34. I must also observe that no reasons were assigned by the 2nd respondent for ignoring the community certificate issued to the petitioner's father on 9-6-1956 by Sri G. Suryanarayana, formerly Member of the erstwhile Andhra Legislative Assembly, representing the constituency of Vizianagaram. The certificate reads that the sub-caste of the petitioner's father is ‘Konda Kapu’.

35. Reliance is also placed by the petitioner upon the findings recorded by Sri H.T Soares, Assistant Collector of Customs on the charge framed against the father of the petitioner as also the orders passed by the Collector, Customs House, Madras, the Central Board of Revenue and the Secretary, Ministry of Finance, New Delhi, thereon. It may be recalled that the petitioner's father was selected and appointed as Preventive Officer, Grade II in a vacancy reserved for Scheduled Tribes in the year 1957. Ten years later, on a complaint received against him that he was not a member of Scheduled Tribe of ‘Konda Kapu’ the Collector, Customs, Madras directed enquiry into his social status and appointed Sri H.T Soares, Assistant Collector, Customs, as the Enquiry Officer. The following charge was framed against him by the Enquiry Officer:

“That the said Y.R Kishan ‘permanent Preventive Officer Grade I’ Customs House, Madras behaved in a highly objectionable and improper manner in connection with his appointment as Preventive Officer Grade II, Customs House, Madras in the year 1956 inasmuch as he secured the said appointment in a vacancy reserved for Scheduled Tribes by furnishing (1) false information about his community to the Employment Exchange, Visakhapatnam and to the Collector of Customs, Madras, that the belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ community which is a Scheduled Tribe and (2) by producing a forged S.S.L.C in support of the same while in fact he belonged to ‘Telaga’ community which is not a Scheduled Tribe”.

36. After conducting a thorough enquiry into the charge and after examining ten witnesses produced by the Presenting Officer appointed under Rule 14(5)(c) of the C.C.S (C.C.A) Rules, as also five witnesses including Sri Harihar Misra, former M.L.A Jeypore, Orissa Legislature and Dr. Sathpathi, Assistant Surgeon, Jeypore Municipality and after marking a number of exhibits on either side, the Enquiry Officer submitted his report to the Collector, Customs. Madras on 29-6-1968. The Enquiry Officer found that the petitioner's father's claim that he belonged to ‘Konda Kapu tribe was not disproved and that the first part of the charge framed against him that he had furnished false information to the Employed Exchange, Visakhapatnam and to the Collector, Customs’ Madras about his community was therefore not proved. The Enquiry Officer however held that the petitioner's father had produced a forged Secondary School Leaving Certificate before the Collector of Customs Madras in support of his claim that he balonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ community. To that extent the other part of the charge was held to be proved against him.

37. On receipt of the report, the Collector of Customs, Madras while accepting the finding on the first part of the charge, also exonerated the petitioner's father of the second part of the charge by his order dated 10-2-1969.

38. The Central Board of Excise and Customs, however reviewed the order of the Collector, Customs, Madras dated 10-2-1969 and inflicted the penalty of stoppage of one increment on the petitioner's father accepting the finding of the Enquiry Officer on the second part of the charge. It must be mentioned that the Central Board of Excise and Customs agreed with the finding of the Collector of Customs, Madras, relating to the first part of the charge that he belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ community.

39. Against the said order of the Central Board of Excise and Customs, the petitioner preferred a memorandum of appeal on 14-2-1971 to the Secretary Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue and Insurance, New Delhi and the same was allowed by the Finance Secretary by his order dated 29-6-1971 fully agreeing with the order of the Collector of Customs. Madras Surprisingly the 2nd respondent refused to attach any weight to the various orders referred to above on the ground that the petitioner's father was exonerated of the charge framed against him by the Collector of Customs, Madras by confering benefit of doubt on him. The 2nd respondent curiously found that the petitioner's father had tampered with the entries in his SSLC register with a view to secure employment as Preventive Officer Grade II in a vacancy reserved for Scheduled Tribes. What is more, the 2nd respondent remarked that the Secretary, Ministry of Finance was clearly in error in exonerating the petitioner's father of the charge framed against him. The comment levelled by the 2nd respondent is both impertinent and audacious. It therefore follows that right from the year 1957 till to-day the petitioner's father is being regarded and treated as a member of ‘Konda Kapu’ community, classified as a Scheduled Tribe by the Union Government. The 2nd respondent cannot thrust upon him a different social status for his children.

40. In an unreported judgment of Sardar Alikhan J. rendered on 1-9-1987 in W.P Nos. 7725 of 1984 and 7119 of 1987 it was held:

“It can be safely said that in an overwhelming majority of cases unless there are other definite circumstances pointing to the contrary, the son or the nephew of a member of ‘Konda Kapu’ community would also be considered to be a member of the same community.”

41. The other comment levelled by the 2nd respondent for rejecting the social status claimed by the petitioner is that in the records maintained in the educational institutions at Vizianagaram where the petitioner's father studied upto Intermediate and where the petitioner's father's younger brother and his two daughters also studied all of them were recorded either as ‘Kapu’ or ‘Telaga’.

42. As already stated after migrating to Vizianagaram the petitioner's paternal grand father styled himself as belonging to ‘Telaga’ or ‘Kapu’ community to bolster up his status obviously to choose good spouses for his children from the forward community of Kapu’ or ‘Telaga’ In fact all those documents relied upon by the 2nd respondent were considered in extenso during the enquiry initiated against the petitioner's father by the Collector of Customs, Madras and it was found by the various authorities, that those documents would not displace the weighty, overwhelming and unimpeachable evidence adduced by the petitioner's father in support of his social status.

43. In Baiya Ram v. Anirudh (3) (1970) 2 SCC 825 : AIR 1971 SC 2533 it was held:

“Whether a particular person is a member of a Scheduled Tribe so declared by the President under Article 342 of the Constitution is essentially a question of law. Though an admission made by him expressly or by implication that he is not a member of a Scheduled Tribe is evidence against him in an election petition the evidence is not conclusive.”

44. I must also observe that Sri D.V.L.N Ramakrishna Rao IPS, Inspector General of Police CID, Andhra Pradesh was directed by the Government of Andhra Pradesh to cause enquiries to be made regarding the false caste certificates produced by certain IAS and IPS officers serving in the State of Andhra Pradesh at the instance of the Government of India for forwarding the same to the Government of India and he submitted his report dated 31-5-1988 to the Secretary to Government Social Welfare (K) Department, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad and the report runs thus:

‘Government of Andhra Pradesh through letter No. 139.J2/83-2, dated 3-8-1983 communicated a representation of Sri G. Anjaneyulu, General Secretary, APSTs Employees Association, Secunderabad sent to the Hon'ble Minister of Home Govt. of India, New Delhi for causing enquiry regarding false caste certificates produced by certain IAS and IPS Officers working in A.P for forwarding the same to the Government of India.

45. Enquiry report against the following officers mentioned in the petition referred to by the Inspector of the CID are enclosed.

1. Sri M. Venkataratnam IAS.

2. Sri M.V Krishna Rao, IPS.

3. Sri K.V Satyanarayana Murthy, IPS.

4. Sri R.K Ragala, IPS.

5. Sri Muthyam Reddy, Dy. Supdt. of Police.

6. Sri P Rama Rao, Retd. DSP. and

7. Sri Y.R Kishan, Dy. Collector Customs.

46. Of the 17 officers mentioned in the petition, reports on 9 were already sent Reports on 7 are enclosed after due enquiries. The enquiries against 7 officers mentioned in para 1 reveal the following.

Sri M. Venkata Ratnam, IAS.

47. An officer of the CID contacted Sri M. Venkataratnam, IAS, Chairman, Andhra Bank. During the enquiry he handed over the following documents. Among them there is a photostat copy of the letter of Government of Andhra Pradesh (Memorandum No. 2797/59/17, dt. 30-8-60) issued under the designation of the Chief Secretary, Govt. of A.P dated 30-8-60. On perusal, it came to light that the Government of India also enquired regarding his community certificate and have dropped further action. Therefore no further action is necessary.

Sri M.V Krishna Rao IPS.

48. An officer of CID. contacted Sri M.V Krishna Rao IPS, Supdt. of Police CID, Hyderabad and asked him to furnish the particulars causing enquiry regarding his caste, he had stated that he came out successfully in UPSC, IPS as a general candidate.

49. The Enquiry Officer met the Joint Secretary, General Administration Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad and requested to permit to peruse the file relating to Sri M.V Krishna Rao, IPS to clarify about his selection to IPS as a general candidate. On perusal the following facts have come to light. The file contains a reference No. 20-1-75 PERS-II Ministry of Home Affairs, Govt. of India, New Delhi dated 5-3-75 (Grih Mantralaya) to Government of Andhra Pradesh. On further perusal of file, there is another reference No. 753.SCC/75-1, dated 24-3-75, GAD. Government of A.P Hyderabad. Perusal of this file disclosed the list of the IPS officers in India categorywise (a) General (Open); (b) Short Service Commission Quota (Army) (d) S.Cs and S.Ts In the list, the name of Sri M.V Krishnarao figured at S. No. 18 with the rank of 31 in the list of 67 under general category. It is evident from above that Sri M.V Krishnarao got selected as an IPS officer under the general category only but not the category of Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe, nor has he declared his caste as Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe.

Sri K.V Satyanarayanamurthy I.P.S

50. Sri K.V Satyanarayanamurthy is an IPS officer of Tamilnadu circle. He has produced documentary evidence such as birth extract 1916 from Narsaraopet Municipality. Copy of extract of SSLC first page of G.B.M School, Visakhapatnam, Copy of Transfer Certificate from Engineering College, Kakinada, Copy of Judgment of Calcutta High Court, Copy of extract of Admission register of P.R College, Kakinada and Copy of Admission Register of College of Engineering, Kakinada etc. The birth extract obtained from Narsaraopet Municipality, Community certificate issued by the Tahsildar, Kakinada and the judgment copy issued by the Calcutta High Court show that Sri K.V Satyanarayanamurthy belongs to ‘Dandasi’ caste which is a Scheduled Caste. There is no basis in the allegation that he declared himself as a Scheduled Caste ‘falsely.’

Sri R.K Ragala, IPS.

51. Sri R.K Ragala hails from village Konalova presently in Addateegala Mandalam in E.G Dt. He had his school education in Peddapuram and college education in Kakinada. During the enquiry, the documents like the birth extract of the father of Sri R.K Ragala, Sri Sriramulu could be secured. The birth extract of Sri R.K Ragala dated 15-7-1937 could also be secured from Mandal Revenue Officer, Pithapuram. Besides copy of Admission register of U.L.C.M High School, Peddapuram and first of SSLC register issued on the basis of the admission could also be secured. All the three documents were sufficient enough to show that Sri R.K Ragala belongs to Kondakapu caste. Most of these documents were issued much before the act of reservations came into force. Therefore allegations that Sri R.K Ragala got selected to IPS by producing a false caste certificate is not true.

Sri M. Muthyam Reddy, DSP.

52. An officer of CID had already conducted an enquiry and the report was sent to Secretary to Home Department, Govt. of A.P Hyderabad on 6-5-78. Contents of their report reveal that Sri M. Muthyam Reddy belongs to ‘Konda Kapu Community.

Sri P. Ramarao, Retd. DSP.

53. An Enquiry Officer of CID enquired into Sri P. Ramarao, who produced the following documents (a) Xerox copy of the certificate issued by the Village Munsif on 31-5-48; (b) Xerox copy of caste certificate dt. 25-9-52 issued by the RDO Tekkali (c) Xerox copy of first page of Service Book printed in Composite Madras State, dated 6-11-50 and other statements. In all the above documents ‘Konda Kapu’ is mentioned in the columu of caste which is in favour of Sn P. Ramarao and all these documents were written prior to 1956 i.e, from which date the act of reservations was passed and came into force.

Sri Y.R Kishan, Dy. Collector, Customs.

54. Enquiries with Sri Y.R Kishan, Dy. Collector, Customs, Madras and Security of various records secured by the Investigating Officer of the CBI, Hyderabad in connection with an enquiry in Rc. No. 83/84 of SPE, Hyderabad and the extract produced by “Sri Y.R Kishan disclosed that it is a fact that he belongs ‘Konda Kapu’ community and he secured in Customs Department in the Scheduled Tribes quota and that the charge-sheet made against him by the CBI was set aside by the Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India, New Delhi in reference F. No. 4/17/69-Ad. V. dated 14-12-1970, vide 16013/22/71, Ad. V. dated 29-6-1971. The Secretary, Ministry of Finance also set aside the proceedings of the Central Board of Excise and Customs in imposing the punishments of stoppage of increment and he was set free of all the allegations levelled against him in the CBI enquiry and also subsequent departmental proceedings, scrutiny of various copies of documents and extracts of education certificates also prove that Sri Y.R Kishan belongs to ‘Konda Kapu’ Community.

55. Hence the allegations levelled against Sri Y.R Kishan are not true and no further action is called for.

56. As the enquiries conducted by this Branch on the petition reveal no evidence in support of the allegations, no further action is called for.”

57. Fortunately for the petitioner enquiry into the real social status of her father was also conducted by the Government of Andhra Pradesh through its officer of the status of the Inspector General of Police, and he found that Sri Y.R Kishan, the father of the petitioner, belonged to ‘Konda Kapu’ community, that the allegations levelled against him were not true and that no further action was called for. The said report dated 31-5-1988 of the Inspector General of Police, CID should have set at rest the controversy if any regarding the social status of the father of the petitioner. It is not known whether the said report was either suppressed by the 2nd respondent or not brought to his notice. Be that as it may, it is no longer open to the 2nd respondent to challenge or doubt the social status claimed by the petitioner's father.

58. In State of Maharashtra v. Abhoy (4) 1984 Supp SCC 701 : AIR 1985 S.C 328 it was held:

“To avoid disputes like the present one where admission is granted on a provisional which is liable to be varied or cancelled at a later stage causing irreperable harm and deep frustration to the candidate who secured coveted admission on a provisional certificate but the spectre of explusion haunts him, State of Maharashtra should devise and frame a more rational method for obtaining much in advance a certificate on the strength of which a reserved seat is claimed. The present method of issuing provisional certificate which can be invalidated at a later stage is objectionable for more than one reason. We consider it more desirable that the State of Maharashtra shall devise a proper procedure which much commence soon after the candidate clears examination by the Board at the end of X year in Secondary school for issuing the final certificate after making whatever necessary enquiry they may want to initiate before the certificate can be granted and submitted for admission on passing Higher Secondary examination. The intending candidate may be directed to preferably make the requisite application as soon as or soon after he gets admission in XI standard. On receipt of the application, the enquiry may start as early or possible and the candidate will have to submit to such enquiry to obtain a regular certificate whatever enquiry is to be held must be completed at least two months before the result of Higher Secondary examination is declared whereafter one becomes eligible to seek admission to a medical college. We hope that the State of Maharashtra will devise a proper scheme in this behalf.”

59. I must also observe that the impugned proceedings of the 2nd respondent virtually amount to cancellation of the various community certificates issued by the competent authorities at Vizianagaram and Visakhapatnam, and the 2nd respondent has no authority to do so as laid down in G.O.Ms No. 282 Social Welfare (J2) Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh, dated 19-12-1988 which runs as follows’.

“The Government, after careful examination of the matter, hereby authorise the District Magistrates/Additional District Magistrates of the Revenue Districts to cancel the false Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Caste certificates issued by non-officials and officials duly following the procedure prescribed and giving an opportunity to the individuals concerned to be heard.”

60. For this reason also the impugned proceedings are without jurisdiction and are liable to be quashed. It may be noted that the petitioner though qualified and selected for admission into the First Year M.B.B.S course for the academic year 1988-1989 offered by the Medical colleges of the Government of the State, she was denied admission due to intervention of the 2nd respondent. She was subjected to a lot of harassment by the 2nd respondent on account of the wholly uncalled for and unwarranted probe into her social status. No interim direction could be given to the 1st respondent to admit her into the First year M.B.B.S course offered by the Andhra Medical College, Visakhapatnam as prayed for in W.P.M.P No. 19540 of 1988 pending disposal of the Writ Petition due to the stiff opposition of the Government Pleader for Social Welfare based upon the impugned proceedings of the 2nd respondent filed into the Court on 25-11-1988. The petitioner thus lost one precious year in the M.B.B.S course besides undergoing any amount of mental agony. As the academic year 1988-1989 is over, no admission into the M.B.B.S course for that academic year as prayed for by the petitioner can be granted. The delay in disposal of the Writ Petition shall not however deny her the necessary redress and this Court has to mould the just relief she is entitled to as on to-day. Reference may be made to Lachmeshwar Prasad Shukur v. Keshwar Lal Chaudari, 1940 FCR 84 : (AIR 1941 FC 5) which is a leading case on the point. Gwyer C.J in the above case referred to the rule adopted by the Supreme Court of the United States in Patterson v. State of Alabama (1935) 294 US 600 at p. 607:

“We have frequently held that in the exercise of our appellate jurisdiction we have power not only to correct in the judgment under review but to make such disposition of the case as justice requires. And in determining what justice does require, the Court is bound to consider any change, either in fact or in law, which has supervened since the judgment was entered.”

61. In the result the impugned proceedings of the 2nd respondent dated 23-11-1988 are quashed and a Writ of Mandamus shall issue directing the 1st respondent to grant admission to the petitioner into the First year M.B.B.S course offered by the Andhra Medical College, Visakhapatnam for the academic year 1989-1990 forthwith without reference to either the 2nd respondent or the 3rd respondent.

62. The Writ Petition is accordingly allowed with costs of Rs. 1,000/- to be recovered personally from the 2nd respondent. Advocate's fee: Rs. 250/-.