Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ayyagari Suryanarayana Vara Prasada Rao v. Ayyagari Venkatakrishna Veni And Another

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Apr 22, 1988
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case concerns a step-mother who filed an application claiming maintenance from her step-son under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC). The respondent-son was born to his father and his first wife, who died. The father then married the petitioner, making her the step-mother. The Magistrate initially dismissed the maintenance application on the ground that the step-mother was not entitled to maintenance. The step-mother challenged this dismissal by filing two Criminal Revision Petitions, which were allowed by the Additional Sessions Judge following a precedent from this court in Appayyamma v. Bondiah. The respondent-son then filed Criminal Revision Cases challenging this view. The matter was referred to a Division Bench due to doubts raised about the correctness of the earlier ruling.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a step-mother is entitled to claim maintenance under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  2. Whether the expression ‘mother’ in Section 125 CrPC can be interpreted by reference to the personal laws applicable to the parties.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The step-mother does not fall within the meaning of ‘mother’ as used in Section 125 of the CrPC.

Respondent’s Position

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Appayyamma v. Bondiah (1987 (2) APLJ 153) Step-mother entitled to maintenance under Section 125 CrPC. Earlier ruling followed by Additional Sessions Judge but its correctness was doubted by a learned Judge, leading to referral to Division Bench.
Havaben Karimbhai v. Razakbhai (1978) 19 Guj. L.R 237 Step-mother entitled to maintenance under Section 125 CrPC. Followed by Orissa High Court and Appayyamma case; shows divergent judicial views.
Pitel Bewa v. Laxmidhar Jona (1985 Crl. L.J 1124) Step-mother entitled to maintenance under Section 125 CrPC. Supported the view that step-mother is entitled to maintenance.
Ramabai v. Dinesh (1976 Mah. L.J 565) Step-mother not entitled to maintenance under Section 125 CrPC. Contrary view to Gujarat and Orissa High Courts; highlights judicial conflict.
Yamunabai v. Anantrai (1988) 1 SCC 530; AIR 1988 SC 644 Interpretation of ‘wife’ under Section 125 CrPC must consider personal law applicable to parties. Court applied this principle analogously to interpret ‘mother’ in Section 125 CrPC, emphasizing personal law context.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the scope of Section 125 CrPC, which mandates maintenance to certain family members, including ‘mother’. The analysis focused on whether a step-mother qualifies as ‘mother’ under this provision. The court referred to personal laws applicable to the parties, particularly Hindu law, to interpret the term ‘mother’. The Supreme Court’s ruling in Yamunabai v. Anantrai was pivotal, establishing that personal law governs the definitions of familial relationships for the purpose of Section 125 CrPC.

Under Hindu law, ‘mother’ is defined as the woman who gave birth to the child. While a step-mother may be a dependant, she does not have the legal status of ‘mother’ for maintenance claims under Section 125 CrPC. The court distinguished between adoptive mothers, who acquire the status of ‘mother’ by law, and step-mothers, who do not. The Explanation to Section 20(1) of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, which includes ‘childless step-mother’ as a parent for maintenance, was found inapplicable since the petitioner was not childless and had her own children. Consequently, the court concluded that the step-mother cannot claim maintenance as a matter of right under Section 125 CrPC, although other legal remedies may be available to her.

Holding and Implications

The court's final ruling was that the step-mother cannot claim maintenance under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as she does not qualify as ‘mother’ within the meaning of the statute.

The direct effect of this decision is the dismissal of the maintenance claim by the step-mother under Section 125 CrPC. The court clarified that personal law definitions govern familial relationships for the purpose of maintenance claims. No new precedent was set beyond affirming that a step-mother does not have the statutory right to maintenance under this provision, although she may pursue other remedies available under law.

Show all summary ...

Jayachandra Reddy, J.:— The concept of “Maintenance” is always being favoured by all religions and corresponding laws. Under many laws in which the concept of maintenance is recognised, there are provisions insisting upon the maintenance and support of various members of family. It can be insisted where this pious duty is not being discharged dutifully. Therefore, to compel such persons to support these who are to be maintained by them, the necessity of providing some penal provisions was felt, in our Code of Criminal Procedure formerly Section 488 was introduced for compelling persons mentioned therein, having sufficient means to maintain wife, father, mother, etc. In the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, section 125, on the same lines, is introduced and this section authorises the Judicial Magistrate of First Class to Order under certain circumstances payment of maintenance to wife, legitimate, illegitimate minor children, father and mother who are unable to maintain themselves. The object of these proceedings regarding maintenance is to prevent the vagrancy by compelling a person to support the persons mentioned in the provisions of that law. Though these provisions are not strictly penal, yet they certainly entrust a duty, the default of which may lead to vagrancy, and these provisions are intended to check the same and ensure supply of food, clothing, etc. to the deserted wife, children and parents.

2. The question that arose in the instant case is whether a step-mother is entitled for maintenance under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

3. The step-mother filed an application M.C 18 of 1986 on the file of the II Addl. Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Eluru, against her step-son claiming maintenance. It must be mentioned that the respondent-son was born to his father through legally wedded second wife, but she died. The father married this lady, i.e, the petitioner, and by virtue of that marriage she became the step-mother to the respondent. A preliminary objection was raised by way of an application before the learned Judicial Magistrate of First Class that she is not entitled to maintenance and that objection was upheld and that application was allowed, and the petition for maintenance was dismissed.

4. Against these two orders, the step-mother filed two Crl. Revision Petitions (34 and 35 of 1986) before the learned Addl. Sessions Judge, West Godavari Division at Eluru, who following a judgment of this court reported in Appayyamma v. Bondiah (1) 1987 (2) APLJ 153, allowed the two revisions. As against those two revisions, the step-son filed these two Crl. R.Cs which came up for hearing before Ramanujulu Naidu, J. The learned Judge doubted the correctness of the view taken in Appayyamma's case (1) (supra) and has referred these two cases to a Division Bench. That is how these cases are before us.

5. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that step-mother does not come within the meaning of ‘mother’ which expression appears in Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

6. In Appayyamma's case (1) (supra) the learned Judge (Radhakrishna Rao, J.) agreed with the views taken by the Gujarat and Orissa High Courts. The decision of Gujarat High Court reported in Havaben Karimbhai v. Razakbhai (2) (1978) 19 Guj. L.R 237 was followed by Orissa High Court in Pitel Bewa v. Laxmidhar Jona (3) 1985 Crl. L.J 1124. There it was held that the step-mother is entitled to maintenance under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Bombay High Court however took a different view in Ramabai v. Dinesh (4) 1976 Mah. L.J 565.

7. Ramanujulu Naidu, J. in his order of reference, observed that there is a fundamental difference between the status of an adoptive mother and a stepmother and the view taken by the High Courts that the adoptive mother gets the status of mother for the purpose of Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is a correct proposition, particularly having reference to the principles of Hindu Law. But the same cannot be applied to a step-mother. Since the learned Judge (Ramanujulu Naidu, J.) felt this is an important question, he has referred the same to the Division Bench.

8. The first question that arises for consideration is: Wether in interpreting the expression ‘wife’, ‘mother’, ‘father’ and ‘child’ used in Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure can the Courts have recourse to the Provisions of personal law to appreciate the context in which they are used? In Yamunabai v. Anantrai (5) (1988) 1 SCC 530 : AIR 1988 SC 644 the Supreme Court held that “The attempt to exclude altogether the personal law applicable to the parties from consideration is improper. S. 125 has been enacted in the interest of a wife, and one who intends to take benefit under sub-sec. (1)(a) has to establish the necessary condition, namely, that she is the wife of the person concerned. This issue can be decided only by a reference to the law applicable to the parties.” It must be mentioned in that case a second wife claimed maintenance and the question came up whether she comes within the meaning of ‘wife’ for the purpose of Sec. 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Their Lordships in that context held that the expression ‘wife’ must be given the meaning in which it is understood in law applicable to the parties, and subject to the explanation (b) under clause (1) of Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure Viz., the ‘wife’ includes a woman who has been divorced by, or has obtained a divorce from, her husband and has not remarried. It is held that a woman who is married second time and which marriage is unlawful according to Hindu law, cannot attain the status of wife and therefore cannot claim maintenance under section 124 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, though she has other remedies. It can therefore be seen that in considering the question whether the step-mother gets the status of mother, the court has to consider the personal law applicable to the parties. In the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 Section 20(1) provides maintenance of children and aged parents. The explanation to this section reads thus:

“In this section “parent” includes a childless step-mother.” But this may not be of any help in interpreting the meaning of the word ‘mother’. According to Hindu law the ‘mother’ is one who has given birth to the child. No doubt a step-mother can be a dependant, but she cannot, as a matter of right, claim maintenance under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Even otherwise in the instant case the respondent-step-mother is not childless and she is having her own children. Therefore the Explanation to section 20(1) of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act is of no help so far the respondent is concerned.

9. At this stage we may also point out that in the case of adoption it must be remembered that the son becomes “aurasa” son to the adoptive mother thereby she gets the status of ‘mother’. The same analogy cannot be applied to the case of a stepmother.

10. For the above reasons we hold that the step-mother cannot attain the status of a ‘mother’ for the purpose of claiming maintenance under sec. 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. She may seek the other remedies open to her in law.

11. The Crl. R.C is allowed.