- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sabirali And Another v. State Of U.P.And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion — Hon'ble Ashok Bhushan, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners are two former employees of the Superintendent Jail, Bareilly: Petitioner No.1 Sabir Ali and Petitioner No.2 Prakash Chandra Lyall. Petitioner No.1 was appointed as a 'Bandi Rakshak'/Warder on 6 March 1972 on a temporary basis; Petitioner No.2 was appointed as a 'Bandi Rakshak'/Warder on 1 December 1974 on a temporary basis. Both continued to discharge duties on their posts, were granted pay scales including selection grade and super selection grade, and had deductions for G.P.F. and insurance made from 1982. Petitioner No.1 superannuated on 31 July 2000 after 28 years' service and Petitioner No.2 superannuated on 30 June 2000 after 26 years' service. Retirement letters described them as temporary employees.
The petitioners sought regularization of their services under the U.P. Regularisation of Ad Hoc Appointments (on Posts outside the purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979 ("1979 Rules") and claimed entitlement to retirement benefits including pension, gratuity and leave encashment. Their service papers were returned by the Joint Director (Treasury & Pension) on grounds that they retired as ad hoc temporary employees and hence pension was not admissible. The State Government ultimately passed an order dated 24 May 2001 refusing regularization on the stated ground that the petitioners did not fulfill educational/physical eligibility, although the Director had submitted a proposal recommending relaxation in physical eligibility. This Court earlier (order dated 28 March 2001) had directed the State Government to take an appropriate decision on regularization; after interim mandamus and further proceedings the present writ petition was finally heard on consent and decided.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the State Government's decision dated 24 May 2001 refusing regularization of the petitioners' services under the U.P. Regularisation of Ad Hoc Appointments (1979 Rules) is valid in the facts of the case.
- Whether the petitioners, having rendered long periods of continuous service (28 and 26 years) and having been granted selection and super selection grade, are entitled to be treated as regular appointees and to receive pensionary and other retirement benefits accordingly.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners were appointed before 1 January 1977 and continued in service; under the 1979 Rules they were consequently entitled to consideration for regularization. The Rules were enforced from 14 May 1979 and the petitioners had completed the necessary period prior to commencement.
- They were entitled to pension and other retirement benefits; reliance was placed on a Government order dated 1 July 1989 that temporary government servants who have completed ten years of regular service are entitled to pensionary benefits.
- The grant of selection grade and super selection grade indicates that their service had been treated as satisfactory and thus supports regularization and entitlement to benefits.
- Reliance was placed on precedents (including Gujarat Agricultural University v. Rathod; Budhi Nath Chaudhary v. Abhai Kumar; Roshani Devi v. State of Haryana; A.P. Srivastava v. Union of India; and Ram Sewak Singh v. Accountant General) to support the contention that long service and departmental treatment justify regularization and pensionary benefits despite technical deficiencies in prescribed qualifications.
Respondent's Arguments
- The petitioners did not fulfil the prescribed qualifications for the post; therefore refusal of regularization was justified.
- The petitioners were not entitled to benefits under the Government order dated 1 July 1989 because they had not completed ten years of "regular service" (the contention being that their service was temporary/ad hoc and not regular).
- The services were ad hoc/temporary and therefore could not be treated as regular for pensionary purposes.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bhagwati Prasad v. Delhi State Mineral Development Corporation, reported in 1990 (1) SCC 361 | The principle that practical experience and long continuous service can justify relaxation of prescribed initial educational/eligibility qualifications for confirmation/regularization; it is harsh to deny confirmation solely for lack of prescribed qualifications where the employee has long and effective practical experience. | The Court relied on this decision to support that lack of a physical qualification did not prevent regularization in view of the petitioners' long service and practical experience. |
| Gujarat Agricultural University v. Rathod, Labhu Bechar and others, reported in (2001) 2 SCC 574 | Holds that long service without complaint is a ground for relaxation of eligibility conditions for absorption/regularization of daily-rated workers; prescribed qualifications should not come in the way of regularization given long experience. | The Court relied on this decision (which itself relied on Bhagwati Prasad) to conclude that the petitioners' long experience entitled them to relaxation of the physical/educational eligibility and hence regularization. |
| Ram Sewak Singh v. Accountant General, Lekha 2nd PR-1, Allahabad and others, reported in (1991) 2 UPLBEC 1027 | Decision addressing entitlement to pensionary benefits for a temporary employee who had rendered long service (held entitled to retirement benefits in that case). | The Court cited this authority to support the proposition that long service by temporary employees in a permanent department can justify pensionary benefits where regularization was not finalized through no fault of the employee. |
| A.P. Srivastava v. Union of India and others, reported in (1995) 3 UPLBEC 1842 | Cited by petitioners; the specific rule or principle from this decision is not detailed in the opinion. | The opinion records that petitioners relied on this decision but does not elaborate its application or the precise principle drawn from it in these proceedings. |
| Budhi Nath Chaudhary and others v. Abhai Kumar and others, reported in 2001 SCC (Labour & Service) 589 | Cited by petitioners; the opinion does not state the specific rule or principle drawn from this case. | The opinion notes reliance on this precedent by petitioners but does not describe how the Court applied it in reasoning. |
| Roshani Devi and others v. State of Haryana and others, reported in 1999 SCC (Labour & Services) 130 | Cited by petitioners; the specific principle relied upon is not set out in the opinion. | The Court records that petitioners relied on this case, but the opinion does not explain its specific application to the facts before the Court. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by reference to the undisputed facts: the petitioners were appointed on temporary/ad hoc basis before 1 January 1977 (6 March 1972 and 1 December 1974 respectively), continued in service until superannuation (28 and 26 years of service), and were granted selection grade and super selection grade. The 1979 Rules provide that any person directly appointed on ad hoc basis before 1 January 1977 who was continuing in service on the date of commencement and possessed requisite qualifications at the time of such ad hoc appointment shall be considered for regular appointment. The Rules came into force on 14 May 1979, and the petitioners had completed the relevant period by then, thus entitling them to consideration.
The Court noted an unreasonable delay by the State Government in processing regularization (papers referred on 11 June 1984, decision only on 24 May 2001 after interim mandamus). The order dated 24 May 2001 refused regularization on grounds of lack of educational/physical eligibility but did not specify what qualification was lacking; the Director had, however, proposed granting relaxation in physical eligibility. The petitioners' counsel informed the Court that the deficiency was a one-centimeter shortfall in height, but the respondents had not specified it in their materials; the Court accepted that such a deficiency, if that was the case, had been addressed by the Director's recommendation for relaxation.
The Court analyzed relevant precedents (notably Bhagwati Prasad and Gujarat Agricultural University v. Rathod) and held that long continuous service and practical experience can justify relaxation of prescribed eligibility conditions and that denying regularization on technical qualification grounds in such circumstances would be harsh and unreasonable. The Court further observed that the petitioners' receipt of selection grade and super selection grade indicated that their service had been treated as satisfactory — a factor reinforcing entitlement to regularization. The Court also referred to the reasoning in Ram Sewak Singh to show that long-serving temporary employees may be entitled to pensionary benefits where regularization was not finalized due to departmental or governmental inaction.
Applying these principles to the facts — petitioners' long service, the Director's recommendation to relax physical eligibility, the absence of any clear specification of a disqualifying deficiency in the State Government's order, and the selection/super-selection grades — the Court concluded that the State Government's refusal to regularize was erroneous and unreasonable.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The Court quashed the State Government order dated 24 May 2001 and held that the petitioners are entitled to regularization under the U.P. Regularisation of Ad Hoc Appointments (on Posts outside the purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979, and to pension and other retirement benefits as admissible to a regular recruited employee.
Direct consequences ordered by the Court:
- The petitioners shall be treated as regularized in accordance with the 1979 Rules.
- The petitioners are entitled to pension and other retirement benefits corresponding to regular employees.
- The respondents are directed to pay pension and other benefits within six months from the date of production of a certified copy of the order.
- No order for payment of interest on the retirement benefits was made in favour of the petitioners.
- Each party shall bear its own costs.
Broader implications: The opinion applies established principles (as discussed in Bhagwati Prasad and Gujarat Agricultural University v. Rathod) that long continuous service and departmental recognition of satisfactory service can justify relaxation of prescribed qualifications for regularization; the Court did not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond applying these precedents to the facts. The opinion does not state that it establishes a new precedent beyond the application in this case.
Hon’ble Ashok Bhushan, J. -- Heard counsel for the petitioner and the learned standing counsel. Counter and rejoinder affidavits have been exchanged. With the consent of the parties the writ petition is being finally decided. 2. The facts of the case as emerge from the pleadings of the parties are; 3. Petitioner No.1 Sabir Ali was appointed as ‘Bandi Rakshak’/Warder on 6th March, 1972 on temporary basis by the Superintendent Jail, Bareilly. Petitioner No.2 Prakash Chandra Lyall was also appointed as ‘Bandi Rakshak’/Warder on 1st December, 1974 on temporary basis by the Superintendent Jail, Bareilly. Both the petitioners continued to discharge duties on their respective posts from the date of their initial appointments and were given pay scale of ‘Bandi Rakshak’/Warder, selection grade and super selection grade. Deductions towards G.P.F. and Insurance was also made with effect from 1982. After attaining age of 58 years petitioner No.1 was superannuated on 31.7.2000 and the petitioner No.2 was superannuated on 30.6.2000. Letters of retirement were issued to petitioners No.1 and 2 dated 31.7.2000 and 30.6.2000 respectively. In both the aforesaid retirement letters petitioners have been referred as temporary employees. Petitioner No.1 rendered 28 years of service whereas the petition No.2 rendered 26 years of service. Petitioners claim that they are entitled for all retirement benefits including the gratuity, pension, leave encashment etc. 4. Petitioners’ papers along with service books were sent to the Joint Director, (Treasury & Pension) but the same were returned with the endorsement that the petitioners retired on the post of ‘Bandi Rakshak’/Warder as ad hoc temporary employees hence pension is not admissible to them. The aforesaid letter dated 28.8.2000 with regard to the petitioner No.1 and 25.8.2000 with regard to petitioner No.2 of the Joint Director (Treasury & Pension) have been annexed as Annexure-3 and 4 to the writ petition. Petitioners’ claim that they were entitled to be regularized in accordance with rules, namely, U.P. Regularisation of Ad Hoc appointments (on Posts out side, the purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979 and it was due to inaction and negligence of the respondents that their services could not be regularized. The petitioners have also placed reliance on the Government order dated 1.7.1989 to the effect that the temporary Government servants who have completed ten years of regular service are entitled for pension. Respondent wrote to the Director General, Karagar Prashasan Evam Sudhar Sevayen, Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow stating that papers for regularization of the petitioners have already been forwarded by letter dated 4.7.1999 and the petitioners have already attained the age of superannuation but orders have not yet been received. It was stated that clear orders be sent so that proceedings for payment of pension be taken. The petitioners have also submitted letter dated 4.9.2000 to the Director General for their regularization. This Court by order dated 28.3.2001 in the present writ petition has directed that the State Government shall take appropriate decision in respect of the petitioners’ claim for regularization in accordance with law within a period of one month from the date of production of a certified copy of the order. In pursuance of the aforesaid direction the State Government passed an order dated 24.5.2000 refusing to regularize the petitioners’ services under the U.P. Regularisation of Ad hoc appointments (on Posts out side the Purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979. It has been stated that since the petitioners do not fulfil the educational qualification/physical eligibility hence they cannot be considered for regular appointment under the U.P. Regularisation of Ad hoc appointments (on Posts out side the Purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979. The order further notes that the Director has submitted a proposal by granting relaxation in physical eligibility. The aforesaid order has been brought on record by means of Supplementary affidavit and has also been prayed to be quashed. 5. A counter affidavit has been filed by the learned standing counsel in which it has been stated that the papers for regularization of the petitioners’ services were forwarded and were pending with the State Government. It is admitted that the petitioners were appointed on temporary basis. Paragraph 7 of the counter affidavit further admits that the petitioners were given pay scale of ‘Bandi Rakshak’/Warder, selection grade, super selection grade and other facilities available to the ‘Bandi Rakshak’/Warder. Deductions were also made from the salary of the petitioners for the G.P.F., Insurance, leave encashment in May, 1982. It has further been stated in paragraph 13 that the matter of regularization of the petitioners was also referred to the respondent No.2 on 11.6.1984 which is still pending. Certain breaks in service of the petitioners were also mentioned. However, neither in the counter affidavit nor in the order of the State Government dated 24.5.2001 it has been mentioned as to what is the educational qualification or the physical eligibility which is lacking in the petitioners. The petitioners have also filed rejoinder affidavit reiterating their claim in the writ petition. The counsel for the petitioners contended that the petitioners who have rendered 28 and 26 years of service respectively are entitled for pension. It is further contended that the petitioners were fully entitled for their regularization of service in accordance with aforesaid 1979 Rules and regularization cannot be refused after rendering 28 and 26 years of service on the ground that the petitioners lack educational qualification/physical eligibility. Reliance has been placed by the counsel for the petitioners on the decision of this Court in the case of Gujarat Agricultural University v. Rathod, Labhu, Vecher and others, reported in UPLBEC 2001 (1) page 834; Budhi Nath Chaudhary and others v. Abhai Kumar and others, reported in 2001 SCC (Labour and Service) page 589 and Roshani Devi and others v. State of Haryana and others, reported in 1999 SCC (Labour & Services) page 130. The counsel for the petitioners secondly contended that by virtue of Government order dated 1.7.1989 even temporary employees who have rendered ten years service are entitled for pension; hence the petitioners are entitled for pension by virtue of the aforesaid Government order. It has further been contended that the petitioners having been granted selection grade and super selection grade their services for all purposes were treated to be satisfactory and regular service. Reliance is also placed on the apex Court’s judgments in the case of A.P. Srivastava v. Union of India and others, reported in (1995) 3 UPLBEC 1842 and Ram Sewak Singh v. Accountant General, Lekha 2nd PR-1, Allahabad and others, reported in (1991) 2 UPLBEC 1027. 6. Learned standing counsel refuting the submissions of the learned counsel for the petitioners contended that the petitioners having not fulfilling the qualification required for the post has rightly been refused for regularization. It has further been contended that the petitioners are not entitled for the benefit of the Government order dated 1.7.1989 since they have not completed ten years regular service. It is contended that the services of the petitioners cannot be treated as regular service, since it was only temporary and ad hoc. 7. I have heard counsel for the parties and perused the record. There is no dispute between the parties with regard to appointment of the petitioners as temporary employees and their superannuation on 31.7.2000 and 30.6.2000. The question which is to be considered as to whether in the facts of the present case the decision of the State Government refusing regularization of the services of the petitioners is valid or not. The date of appointment of the petitioners which is not disputed is 6.3.1972 and 1.12.1974 respectively. Petitioners have continued to work till their superannuation. In accordance with the U.P. Regularisation of Ad hoc Appointment (on Posts out side the Purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979 any person who was directly appointed on ad hoc basis before January 1, 1977 and is continuing in service, as such, on date of commencement of these Rules, possessed requisite qualifications prescribed for regular appointment at the time of such ad hoc appointment shall be considered for regular appointment. The aforesaid Rules were enforced with effect from 14.5.1979. Admittedly the petitioners were appointed since before January 1, 1977 and had also completed three years before commencement of the Rules. Thus immediately after enforcement of the aforesaid Rules the petitioners became entitled for consideration of the regular appointment. In the counter affidavit it has been stated that the papers for consideration of regularization of the petitioners were referred on 11.6.1984. The said matter was ultimately decided on 24.5.2001 that, too, after issuing interim mandamus by this Court in the present writ petition. There is unreasonable delay on the part of the State Government even considering the claim of the petitioners for regularization. As observed above, neither in the order dated 24.5.2001 nor in the counter affidavit there is any whisper as to what qualification the petitioners lack. The order dated 24.5.2001 however, clearly mentions that the Director, Karagar has sent proposal to the State Government for regularization of the petitioners by giving special relaxation in physical eligibility. It has been stated by the counsel for the petitioners that the petitioners have come to know that the qualification which is found to be lacking is to the effect that the petitioners are short in height by one centimeter. The respondents having not chosen to mention the qualification which is lacking with the petitioners and no material having come forward, it can be accepted that the aforesaid qualification was lacking. The order dated 24.5.2001 has also noted that the Director has granted special relaxation in the physical eligibility to the petitioners. The issue is as to whether the petitioners could have been refused for regularization in the facts of the present case when there was recommendation for relaxing the said deficiency by the Director General himself and further when the petitioners after servicing the department for 28 and 26 years have already attained the age of superannuation, it is unreasonable on the part of the State Government to tell the employee after he attained the age of superannuation that he lack qualification for appointment. In 1990 (1) SCC page 361 Bhagwati Prasad v. Delhi State Mineral Development Corporation . reported in 1990 (1) SCC page 361 the Apex Court held in paragraph 6:
"6. The main controversy centres round the question whether some petitioners are possessed of the requisite qualifications to hold the posts so as to entitle them to be confirmed in the respective posts held by them. The indisputable facts are that the petitioners were appointed between the period 1983 and 1986 ever since, they have been working and have gained sufficient experience in the actual discharge of duties attached to the posts held by them. Practical experience would always aid the person to effectively discharge the duties and is a sure guide to assess the suitability. The initial minimum educational qualification prescribed for the different posts is undoubtedly a factor to be reckoned with, but is so at the time of the initial entry into the service. Once the appointments were made as daily rated workers and they were allowed to work for a considerable length of time, it would be hard and harsh to deny them the confirmation in the respective posts on the ground that they lack the prescribed educational qualifications."Recently the apex Court in Gujarat Agricultural University v. Rathod Labhu Bechar and others reported in (2001) 2 Supreme Court Cases, 574 has considered the said issue again relying on Bhagwati Prasad’s case (supra) and it was held by the apex Court in paragraphs 28 and 30:
"28. We feel that daily rate workers who have been working on the aforesaid posts for such a long number of years without complaint on these posts is a ground by itself for the relaxation of the aforesaid eligibility condition. It would not be appropriate to disqualify them on this ground for their absorption, hence clause (a) needs modification to this effect. 30. Thus in view of their long experience, on the fact of this case, and for the posts concerned the prescribed qualification, if any, should not come in the way of their regularization. Clause (b) provides for the regularization of daily wagers in a phased manner to the extent of available sanctioned post."8. In view of the aforesaid decisions of the Apex Court it is clear that lack of above physical qualification was no impediment in the regularization. The petitioners despite lacking of physical eligibility were entitled for regularization specially when, they have rendered 28 and 26 years of service respectively. Further the petitioners were granted selection grade, super selection grade which fact is admitted in paragraph 7 of the counter affidavit, petitioners’ service has to be treated to be satisfactory. The grant of selection grade and super selection grade is also on the condition of service being satisfactory. Further, in the present case the Director General who is the Head of Department has already recommended for relaxing the physical eligibility for the petitioners. The State Government took erroneous view of the matter in refusing the claim of the petitioners for regularization on the post of ‘Bandi Rakshak’/Warder. The State Government has also not taken into consideration the special features of the case i.e. the petitioners had rendered 28 and 26 years of service and they have already been granted selection grade and super selection grade and further the Head of the Department has already recommended for relating the aforesaid physical qualification. In ( 1991) 2 UPLBEC 1027 Ram Sewak Singh v. Accountant General, Lekha 2nd Pr-I, Allahabad and others, this Court while considering the case with regard to entitlement of pension by a temporary employee who has rendered more than thirty years of service held him to be entitled for the retirement benefits. It was held by this Court in the above judgment in paragraph 12 as under:
"12…………The Public Works Department of the State of Uttar Pradesh is not a temporary department and is one of the permanent departments of the State Government. It is not known why and under what circumstances a person who was appointed in 1940 and also granted increments and promotion etc. from time to time was allowed to continue for a period of more than 16 years without any orders for confirmation to the substantive post. It is for the department concerned and the responsible officers of the same department to seek orders from the Government, if was necessary, for regularizing the person who has been working in the department for 16 years or more without any order for confirmation. It is unjust that a person may work in the department which is a permanent department of the State without any fault of his as a purely temporary employee, not entitled for any pensionary benefit. If the higher officers of the department and the government have no care or interest in the matters of such employees it would be a sorry state of affairs. There are certain Government orders issued from time to time. One of such orders annexed with the writ petition is Annexure-7 which provides such benefits to the temporary government servants for pensionary benefits or other benefits in case of death of such employees. It is quoted in the aforesaid Government order No.Kha-3 11.52/10-915-89, dated 1.7.1989 that no temporary government sevant is entitled for any pensionary benefit unless the post on which he was working was a permanent/substantive post. If such a temporary employee whose matter about regularization could not be finalized in spite of the Government orders and such employee retired from service or died in harness, such government employee would be entitled for pensionary benefits provided they have completed a minimum of 10 years’ qualifying service. It is not disputed that the petitioner worked in a permanent department of the State and the post of Technical Assistant and the post of Junior Engineer to which he was later promoted is of substantive permanent post in the department."In view of the aforesaid the order of the State Government dated 24.5.2001 cannot be sustained and it is held that the petitioners were entitled to be regularized in accordance with the U.P. Regularisation of Ad hoc appointments (on Posts out side the Purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979. The petitioners having already completed the age of superannuation, it is directed that the petitioners be treated to be regularized in accordance with the said 1979 Rules and entitled to the pensionary benefits as admissible to the regular recruited employee. 9. The second submission of the counsel for the petitioners that a temporary employee who has rendered more than 10 years’ service is entitled to be paid pension as per Government order dated 1.7.1989 is not necessary to be considered, in view of the above observations that the petitioners were wrongly refused regularization as they were entitled to be regularized in service. 10. In view of the foregoing discussions the petitioners are entitled for the reliefs sought in the writ petition. The order of the State Government dated 24.5.2001 annexure-3 to the Supplementary affidavit filed by petitioner No.2 is quashed and it is further directed that the petitioners be held to be entitled for regular appointment in accordance with the U.P. Regularisation of ad hoc appointments (on Post out side the Purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979 and the petitioners be further extended benefit of pension and other retirement benefits which are admissible to a regular employee. The respondents are directed to pay pension and other benefits within a period of six months from the date of production of a certified copy of this order. In view of the facts of the present case no order for payment of interest on the retirement benefits is passed in favour of the petitioners. 11. The writ petition is allowed as indicated above. Parties shall bear their own costs. (Petition allowed) _____________
Alert