- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Sushila Verma And Others Revisionists v. State Of U.P And Another Opp. Parties.
K.D Shahi, J.:— The instant revision has been filed by revisionists Smt. Sushila Verma, Km. Rajni Verma, Hariom Verma, Vikas Verma and Vijay Verma (mother-in-law, Nanad, father-in-law, Dewar and husband respectively of respondent No. 2, namely, Babita Rani Verma) against the summoning order dated 3.2.1999 passed by IIIrd Upper Civil Judge (Junior Division), district Bijnor in complaint case No. 11 of 1999 (Smt. Babita v. Vijay Verma) under Sections 498-A, 323, 504, 506 I.P.C and Section 3/4 of Dowry Prohibition Act.
2. The facts giving rise to the instant revision are that respondent No. 2 filed a complaint and gave her statement under Section 200 Cr. P.C and also examined the witnesses under Section 202 Cr. P.C On the examination of witnesses on record, the learned Magistrate summoned the accused persons finding a prima facie case against them. Being aggrieved by the order dated 3.2.1999 the present revision has been preferred by the revisionists.
3. At the stage of summoning only the evidence under Sections 200 and 202 Cr. P.C is to be seen. At the stage of evidence under Sections 200 and 202 Cr. P.C the defence case is not to be examined nor the accused persons can furnish their defence at that stage. It is after the summoning order is passed, they may appear before the Court below and may apply for dispensing the attendance under Section 205 Cr. P.C and may also apply before the learned Magistrate to quash the summoning order.
4. In view of the ruling reported in K.M Mathew v. State of Kerala,1 in which it has been held that the order issuing process under Section 204 Cr. P.C is an interim order and not a judgment and that order can be varied, rescinded or recalled by the learned Magistrate and the proceedings dropped, if the complaint on the very face of it does not disclose any offence against the accused. It was further held in this case that Section 397 Cr. P.C too is express bar to the revision. At the time of framing of the charge as well, the accused persons can apply that there is no sufficient evidence against them and they may be discharged. But at this stage of revision, the evidence of the accused is not to be seen. The order passed by the learned Magistrate in this case does not appear to be illegal or incorrect on the face of it.
5. It is true that the dowry cases are increasing day by day. Nobody can rule out that cruelty and harassment of the ladies have also increased but it is also apparent that if the wife is being harassed by her husband and mother-in-law or any other member of the family, then the entire family including bachelor girls, old ladies and innocent family members are also being implicated. It is the duty of the Court to watch the interest of both of the parties, therefore, it shall always remain open to the learned lower Court to release the accused persons on bail immediately, if the complaint has been filed purposely to harass them. It is also always open to the lower Court to exempt the personal attendance of the ladies and bachelor girls because after all these proceedings are not meant to humiliate anybody.
6. The revision was contested by the revisionists merely on the ground that a similar proceeding is pending before the Dowry Prohibition Officer under the proceedings of Dowry Prohibition Act. I have gone through the provisions of the said Act. The said dowry prohibition officer can only make an enquiry. He has got no power to punish and the punishment shall be only by a Magistrate, therefore, proceedings before the dowry prohibition officer of the same offence cannot be a bar for a regular trial in the Court. This revision has got no force and is hereby dismissed. The observations made above should not be treated to be on expression of opinion of the merit of the case either way.
Revision Dismissed.
Alert