Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Bindra Builders v. Delhi Development Authority .

Delhi High Court
May 7, 1985
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The matter involves two petitions under Ss.20 and 33 of the Arbitration Act filed by M/s. Bindra Builders against the Delhi Development Authority (DDA). The petitioner seeks (1) a reference to arbitration of 14 disputes listed in Annexure 'A' and (2) a determination of the effect and validity of the arbitration agreement with respect to Claim No. 5 of that Annexure, which is described as:

“Dispute over sanction of substituted item for Makrana white marble provided in the works; Rs. 3.75 lacs.”

The petitioner contracted to construct 201 houses at Siri Fort, New Delhi (Asiad) for about Rs. 2.2 crores. The contract specified the use of "makrana superior marble" (rate said by petitioner to be ~Rs. 781/- per sq. meter). During execution, the petitioner used Rajnagar marble, allegedly because Makrana marble was not available; the petitioner says the respondent's engineers supervised the work and took no objection.

After completion, the Executive Engineer treated Rajnagar marble as a substituted item and assessed a rate ~Rs. 343/- per sq. meter, while the petitioner claimed Rs. 634/-. The Chief Engineer, however, considered the matter to be a reduction for substandard work (inferior quality used) and sought substantial deductions from the petitioner's bills.

The contract contained an arbitration clause empowering the Engineer Member of the respondent to appoint an arbitrator. The petitioner invoked S.20 seeking a direction to the Engineer Member to appoint an arbitrator. The respondent relies on Clause 25-B of the agreement, which provides that the Chief Project Engineer's decision regarding the quantum and justification of reduction for substandard work shall be final and not open to arbitration.

Administrative steps included referral to a committee of six Executive Engineers to examine availability of Makrana marble, identification of the type of marble used, and the basis for payments for non-Makrana marble. The committee reported scarcity of first/second class Makrana white plain stone and that the Rajnagar white medium variety was the normal market material. The committee recommended a substituted item rate of Rs. 325.86, producing a substituted item statement of Rs. 2,77,846/- for sanction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the disputes listed in Annexure 'A' (including Claim No.5 concerning substitution of Makrana marble by Rajnagar marble) are referable to arbitration under the arbitration clause in the contract.
  2. Whether Clause 25-B (making the Chief Project Engineer's decision on the quantum of reduction for substandard work final and not open to arbitration) precludes arbitration of Claim No.5 or whether the arbitrator must determine whether the matter is one of substitution or reduction.
  3. Whether the Engineer Member of the Delhi Development Authority should be directed under S.20 of the Arbitration Act to appoint an arbitrator and, if so, within what time frame and with what directions as to the scope of arbitration.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (M/s. Bindra Builders)

  • The controversy does not fall under Clause 25-B (finality for reductions); instead it is a dispute about substituted item under Clause 12, which empowers the Engineer In-charge to substitute items during progress of the work.
  • Although no written request for substitution was made, the petitioner contends that the use of Rajnagar marble occurred under the supervision and with the acquiescence/acceptance of the Engineer In-charge who supervised the work on site, and no objection was taken.
  • Therefore, the substitution cannot be treated as a reduction for substandard work, and the matter is referable to an arbitrator for decision.
  • It was also argued that once the Executive Engineer prepared a substituted item statement, the respondent should be bound by it and not be allowed to resile (relying on a reported decision — AIR 1966 SC 405).

Respondent's Arguments (Delhi Development Authority)

  • The respondent denied giving any approval or instructions to use Rajnagar marble in place of Makrana superior marble; the contractor never informed the department that he was using a substituted item nor sought permission during the course of the work.
  • The contractor repeatedly submitted bills and obtained payments representing that Makrana marble was being used; advances were obtained on that basis, thereby concealing the use of Rajnagar marble until after completion when the substituted item claim was first made.
  • The Rajnagar marble used was asserted to be of medium quality, not even of first quality, supporting the contention that the matter should be treated as reduction for substandard work rather than substitution.
  • The respondent invoked Clause 25-B making the Chief Project Engineer's decision on reduction final and non-arbitrable, and therefore sought to preclude arbitration on this point.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Salween Timber and Construction Co., AIR 1969 SC 488 Articulates the test for whether a dispute arises out of, or in connection with, a contract: if recourse to the contract is necessary to determine the claim, the matter falls within the arbitration clause. The court applied this test to conclude that interpretation of contract terms and determination whether the case is of substitution or reduction primarily falls within the domain of the arbitrator.
Shiv Hari Tandon v. Union of India (Suit No. 160-A of 1983, decided 22-4-1985) Affirms that interpretation of contract terms is for the arbitrator; if the contract makes an authority's decision final on certain matters, the arbitrator must give effect to that finality. The court relied on this observation to state that the arbitrator must interpret the contract and, where a contract makes specific decisions final (e.g., Clause 25-B), the arbitrator is bound by them.
Shiva Jute Baling Ltd. v. Hindley and Co. Ltd., (1960) 1 SCR 569 : AIR 1959 SC 1357 Cited by counsel to support the contention that certain determinations vest in the court rather than an arbitrator. The court noted counsel's reliance but held these authorities inapplicable to the present fact-centric inquiry about contract interpretation and did not accept the contention that jurisdictional determination should be made by the court in this case.
Gordhandas Pursottam v. Natvarlal Chandulal and Co., AIR 1952 Bom 349 Cited by counsel in support of the proposition that some matters should be determined by the court rather than arbitrator. The court recorded reliance by counsel but declined to accept that those authorities mandated a court determination in the present circumstances (interpretation of contract and factual inquiry).
Hindustan Steel Ltd. v. Kaushal Construction Co., AIR 1966 Madh Pra 249 Cited by counsel for the same general proposition about court determination of certain disputes. The court observed the reliance but held that the present dispute—requiring contract interpretation and factual findings—falls for the arbitrator to decide, not for pre-emptive court adjudication of jurisdiction.
Reliable Water Supply Service of India (P) Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR 1971 SC 2083 Cited by counsel to support the argument concerning allocation of certain determinations to the court. The court noted the reliance and again declined to apply that line of authority to displace the arbitrator's domain in interpreting contract terms in the present case.
AIR 1966 SC 405 Relied upon by the petitioner to argue that once a substituted item statement had been prepared by the Executive Engineer, the respondent should be bound by it and should not resile. The court held that whether the respondent is bound by the substituted item statement is a matter for the arbitrator to consider; no immediate binding effect was accepted by the court in this order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded stepwise and emphasised the predominantly factual character of the controversy:

  1. The court framed the central factual questions: in what circumstances Makrana superior marble was not used; whether Rajnagar marble was used with the instructions or approval of the Engineer In-charge; and whether the situation amounts to substitution or reduction for substandard work. The court held these to be primarily factual issues on which it could not express a definitive opinion.
  2. The arbitration clause in the contract was described as broad, covering "all questions, claims, right, matter or thing whatsoever in any way arising out of or relating to the contract" and referring them to sole arbitration by the person appointed by the Engineer Member. The contract did, however, contain Clause 25-B carving out finality for the Chief Project Engineer's decision regarding quantum and justification of reduction for substandard work.
  3. The court applied the legal test from Union of India v. Salween Timber: if recourse to contract terms is necessary to decide the claim, the dispute falls within the arbitration clause. Using that principle, the court concluded that interpretation of contract terms and determination—on the basis of facts to be found—whether the matter is one of substitution or reduction falls primarily within the arbitrator's domain.
  4. The court further explained that where a contract specifically makes a particular authority's decision final (as Clause 25-B does), the arbitrator must give effect to such contractual finality and will be bound by that decision to the extent it applies.
  5. The court rejected the petitioner's counsel's submission that the court should determine the jurisdictional question (relying on several precedents), on the ground that the present dispute is about interpreting contract terms in light of facts which must be ascertained; it is not a pure jurisdictional question for the court to decide pre-emptively.
  6. Regarding the petitioner's contention that the respondent should be bound by the substituted item statement prepared by the Executive Engineer, the court held that this too is a matter for the arbitrator to consider and did not accept that the substituted item statement immediately bound the respondent.
  7. Procedurally, having found arbitration appropriate for resolving the factual and contract-interpretation issues (subject to the contractual carve-out for final decisions), the court directed that the arbitration agreement be filed and that the Engineer Member appoint an arbitrator within one month; the arbitrator was to deliver the award within four months of entering upon reference.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The court directed that the disputes be referred to arbitration and ordered the Engineer Member of the Delhi Development Authority to appoint an arbitrator to decide the disputes arising under the contract.

Specific operative directions and immediate effects:

  • The arbitration agreement is to be filed and acted upon.
  • The Engineer Member of the Delhi Development Authority is directed to appoint the arbitrator within one month of communication of the order.
  • The arbitrator is to deliver the award within four months of entering upon reference.
  • Both sides are entitled to present their claims before the arbitrator.
  • Where the contract makes any particular authority's decision final (notably Clause 25-B regarding quantum and justification of reduction for substandard work), the arbitrator must abide by such final decisions and cannot question them.

Broader implications: The court did not purport to set a new legal precedent beyond applying established tests (notably Salween Timber) and reiterating that interpretation of contract terms entailing factual determinations ordinarily lies with arbitrators, subject to contractual carve-outs. The direct effect is to remit the factual disputes and contract interpretation to arbitration, with the limited consequence that the Chief Project Engineer's decision on reductions (where applicable under Clause 25-B) remains binding on the arbitrator.

Order accordingly
Show all summary ...

This will dispose of two petitions moved under Ss.20 and 33 of the Arbitration Act by M/s. Bindra Builders. The respondent is the Delhi Development Authority. By the former the petitioner is seeking reference of disputes numbering 14 as mentioned in Annexure ‘A’ attached with the petition to arbitration. The other is for determining the effect and validity of the arbitration agreement with regard to claim No. 5 of that Annexure. That claim is to the following effect:

“Dispute over sanction of substituted item for Makrana white marble provided in the works; Rs. 3.75 lacs.”—

2. The background is that the petitioner executed a contract for the construction of 201 houses on behalf of the respondent at Siri Fort, New Delhi for the “Asiad”. The total amount thereof was about 2.2 crores. Specifications and rates of different items were also agreed upon. One of the terms of the contract was that the petitioner would use ‘makrana superior marble’. The rate according to the petitioner for this was around Rs. 781/- per sq. meter. However, during the course of the execution of the contract the petitioner found that the ‘makrana marble’ was not available and it appeared that mines there were not in operation for some time. As such the petitioner used ‘Rajnagar marble’ which though not of as high quality as ‘makrana’, was next possible available. Its user according to the petitioner was to the knowledge of the Engineers of the respondent who used to supervise the work at the spot and no objection was taken thereto.

Subsequently after the completion of the contract when the petitioner submitted the bills, the Executive Engineer In-charge treated the use of ‘Rajnagar Marble’ as substituted item and allowed the rate of about Rs. 343/- per sq. meter. The petitioner claimed that he should have been allowed the rate of Rs. 634/- per sq. meter. However, the Chief Engineer declined to treat the matter as one of the substituted item but held that it fell in the category of reduction item as the marble actually used was of inferior quality than stipulated for. On its basis substantial amount is sought to be deducted from the bills of the petitioner.

3. There is no dispute that the contract was governed by an arbitration clause under which the Engineer Member of the respondent was competent to appoint an arbitrator. This was earlier also invoked during the course of execution of contract when certain interim disputes had arisen. The petitioner has, therefore, sought in the petition under S.20 of the Arbitration Act that the Engineer Member should be directed to appoint an arbitrator for deciding the dispute as referred to in Annexure ‘A’ attached with this petition.

4. Clause 25-B of the agreement provided as under :

“The decision of Chief Project Engineer regarding the quantum of reduction as well as justification thereof in respect of rates for substandard work which may be decided to be accepted will be final and would not he open to arbitration.”

5. The respondent is purporting to act under this clause and holding the case as one of reduction for substandard work. The decision of the Chief Project Engineer in this regard is made final and not open to arbitration. To this extent, therefore, the arbitrator is held bound by the finality of the decision given by the Chief Project Engineer. A reduction @ Rs. 956/- per sq. meter on this score is being sought from the bills of the petitioner.

6. The petitioner on the other hand is asserting that the controversy does not fall under cl.25-B and that this was a case of substituted item and Cl.12 of the agreement was applicable under which the Engineer In-charge was empowered to substitute any item during the progress of the work. Although no specific request in writing for this was made to the Engineer In-charge by the petitioner during the progress of the work, it is contended that since the work was being executed under his supervision and instructions, he acquiesced and accepted this substitution. This substitution it is contended cannot be treated as reduction item and, therefore, no finality can be attached to the decision of the Chief Project Engineer. The controversy it is pleaded is referable to arbitrator for decision.

6-A. The respondent has on the other hand entirely denied that any approval or instructions were given from its side to enable the contractor to use inferior quality of ‘Rajnagar marble’ instead ‘makrana white marble of first quality’. At no stage he informed the department that he was using substituted item of ‘Rajnagar marble’ nor sought its permission. Rather it is pointed out that all through the contractor had been submitting bills and obtaining payments disclosing that he was using ‘makrana marble’ as stipulated. Advances in running payment of the works on the basis of ‘makrana white marble of first quality’ were throughout obtained by him concealing the fact of his using the ‘Rajnagar marble’. The substituted item statement was for the first time submitted after the completion of the work and not during its course.

7. The ‘Rajnagar marble’ used was further stated to be not even of first quality but of medium quality.

8. It appears that the Executive Engineer planned to treat the case as one of substituted item and as such the matter was referred to a committee of six Executive Engineers by the Additional Chief Engineer for examination specially of the following aspects:

“The circumstances under which Makrana was not used by the contractors in the works. Was it on account of non-availability of enough quantity of Makrana Marble in the market at the time of execution of the work? Identification of the type of marble used in the various works at Asian Games Village. The basis on which a payment should be made to the contractors under terms of contract for use of marble stone other than that obtained from Makrana quarries.”

9. The report was then inter alia submitted as under :

“One major piece of information that emerged after discussions that 1st class or 2nd class makrana marble white plain stone was not available in sufficient quantities even at the source for the last few years. In fact there is no normal dealing in 1st class makrana marble in Delhi. The availability of 2nd class makrana marble white plain marble is in meagre quantities in Delhi. The normal quality of marble being marketed in Delhi and used in both Govt. arid private constructions is Raj Nagar white medium variety.”

10. The Executive Engineer then submitted that due to the non-availability of makrana marble stone the contractor used marble stone from other quarries like Raj Nagar etc., which were just in the vicinity of makrana quarries. It was also added that on account of use of the marble stone from quarries other than makrana in the buildings, there had not been felt any perceptible difference as far as functioning, structural soundness and aesthetics were concerned. It was, therefore, mentioned that the substitution was inevitable. After considering the rates prevalent it was stated that the rate of Rs. 325.86 would be fair to both the department and contractor, and as such substituted item statement amounting to Rs. 2,77,846/- was prepared and submitted for sanction.

11. I have heard the parties and given my utmost consideration to the entirety of the circumstances. It is obvious from the above narration that the controversies are mostly factual. In what circumstances the ‘makrana superior marble’ was not used and ‘Rajnagar marble of medium quality’ was utilised is a question of fact. It is also a question of fact whether the user of Rajnagar marble was under the instructions or approval of the Engineer Incharge or other Officers. No opinion, therefore, can be expressed on them. It is also apparent that the terms and conditions of the contract between the parties have to be minutely gone into and then in the context of the appraisement of the facts determined whether the case was one of substitution or of reduction. The arbitration clause in the present case is quite wide. All questions, claims, right, matter or thing whatsoever in any way arising out of or relating to the contract, business, drawings, specifications, estimate, instructions, orders of these conditions or otherwise concerning the works or the execution or failure to execute the same, whether arising during the progress of the work or after the completion of the work or abandonment thereof have to be referred to the sole arbitration of the person appointed by the Engineer Member of the Delhi Development Authority. There has been exception made with regard to finality of the decisions of Chief Project Engineer regarding the quantum of reduction as well as justification thereof in respect of the rates for sub-standard work and to this extent they are not opened to arbitration. (Vide cl.25-B).

The position of law in this regard is well settled that where the test for determining whether the dispute is one arising out of the contract or in connection with the contract is whether recourse to the contract by which both the parties are bound is necessary for the purpose of determining whether the claim of the party is justified or otherwise. If it is necessary to take recourse to the terms of the contract for the purpose of deciding the matter in dispute, it must be held that the matter is within the scope of the arbitration clause and the arbitrators have jurisdiction to decide that dispute. Seen in this regard the decision of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Salween Timber and Construction Co. AIR 1969 SC 488. The controversy, therefore, in the present case with regard to the interpretation of different terms and conditions of the contract and further whether in the context of facts which the parties may bring forth, the case would be one of substitution or of reduction is primarily within the domain of the arbitrator. If he finds that the case is of substitution, he would naturally adjudicate upon the same. If however, he comes to the view that the case is one of reduction, then to that extent he will be bound by the decision of the Chief Project Engineer in terms cl.25-B. Thus I had the occasion to observe in similar circumstances in the case Suit No. 160-A of 1983 Shiv Hari Tandon v. Union of India decided on 22-4-1985 as under:

“Adverting to the other plea about the expected matters, it need hardly be impressed that the interpretation of the terms of contract is entirely within the domain of the arbitrator. He has to give effect to the same. In case any of the terms envisages that particular authority's decisions on certain matters have to be final, the arbitrator would certainly be bound by those decisions and would not question them. By doing so he would be only acting in terms of the contract and giving effect to those terms while determining the rights of the parties. This is made clear and it is directed that the arbitrator will act accordingly. Whether any particular work could be considered as extra items or not would also depend upon the interpretation of the contract and the arbitrator as such will consider them. His appointment as arbitrator arises from the clause existing in the contract and naturally he acts within the limits of the contract.”

12. I am unable to accept the contention of Mr. Vohra that the determination of this dispute by the court is one of jurisdiction of the arbitrator and this essentially vests in court. He has placed reliance in this regard upon the decisions reported as Shiva Jute Baling Ltd. v. Hindley and Co. Ltd., (1960) 1 SCR 569: (AIR 1959 SC 1357), Gordhandas Pursottam v. Natvarlal Chandulal and Co., AIR 1952 Bom 349, Hindustan Steel Ltd. v. Kaushal Construction Co., AIR 1966 Madh Pra 249 and Reliable Water Supply Service of India (P) Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR 1971 SC 2083. I am, however, unable to agree inasmuch as the present is not one of determining the jurisdiction of the arbitrator, but that of interpreting the terms and conditions of the contract in the context of the facts ascertained.

13. It has also been sought to be urged by Mr. Vohra that once the Executive Engineer had prepared substituted item statement, the respondent should be bound by the same and should not be allowed to resile. In support reliance was placed upon AIR 1966 SC 405. In my view, however, this will be a matter for the learned arbitrator to consider. Mr. Vohra also sought to urge that the respondent is acting in a very high handed manner as to allow deduction of Rs. 956.14 per sq. meter which would be more than even the price of the makrana marble. Ex facie that would appear unreasonable. However, no opinion is expressed about that and the matter would receive due adjudication in arbitration in the light of what is observed in this order.

14. The result, therefore, is that the arbitration agreement is directed to be filed and in terms thereof the Engineer Member of the Delhi Development Authority is directed to appoint arbitrator for going into the disputes and differences arising between the parties under the contract in dispute. Both the sides will be entitled to submit their claims before the arbitrator. To the decision of any particular authority is made final under the contract, the arbitrator will abide by the same and not question that (sic). The appointment of arbitrator will be made within a month of the communication of this order. The award be delivered within four months of the entering upon reference.

Order accordingly