Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Major D.N Sood And Another v. Shanti Devi (Smt) .

Supreme Court Of India
Dec 15, 1995
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns an appeal arising out of eviction proceedings initiated by the respondent (landlord) against the appellant (tenant) under Section 14-D of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 (“the Act”).

In those proceedings, the Additional Rent Controller, Delhi, by order dated 22-9-1992, granted the appellant leave to defend. Aggrieved by the grant of leave to defend, the respondent filed a revision petition before the Delhi High Court under Section 25(B)(8) of the Act.

The appellant objected to the maintainability of the revision petition, relying on earlier judgments of the Delhi High Court which had held that an order granting leave to defend is interlocutory in nature and that no revision lies against such an order.

By the impugned judgment dated 2-3-1995, a learned Single Judge of the High Court disagreed with the earlier view of the Court and held that a revision under Section 25(B)(8) of the Act is maintainable against an order granting leave to defend. The learned Judge reasoned that when the earlier judgments were delivered, Sections 14-B, 14-C and 14-D were not part of the Act and had later been introduced by the Amendment Act of 1988, and that in view of this changed scenario, a revision should be held to lie against such an order.

The present appeal challenges that High Court judgment holding the revision to be maintainable. The Court granted leave to appeal and heard learned counsel for the parties.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Section 25(B)(8) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, a revision petition to the High Court is maintainable against an order of the Rent Controller granting leave to defend in eviction proceedings.
  2. Whether a learned Single Judge of the High Court, sitting singly, can depart from the view taken in earlier decisions of coordinate Benches of the same High Court, or whether such disagreement must be resolved by referring the matter to a larger Bench.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant objected to the maintainability of the respondent’s revision petition before the High Court under Section 25(B)(8) of the Act.
  • In support of this objection, the appellant relied on earlier judgments of the Delhi High Court which had held that an order granting leave to defend is interlocutory in nature and that a revision does not lie against such an interlocutory order.

Respondent's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s specific legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Earlier judgments/decisions of the Delhi High Court That an order of the Rent Controller granting leave to defend in eviction proceedings is an interlocutory order, and no revision lies against such an order under Section 25(B)(8) of the Act. The Court reaffirmed that these earlier decisions, not having been overruled by a larger Bench, remained binding on Single Judges of the High Court. On the basis of these decisions, the Court held that the respondent’s revision petition before the High Court was not maintainable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court focused primarily on two aspects: (1) the doctrine of judicial discipline within the High Court, and (2) the continued applicability of the earlier High Court decisions on maintainability of revisions against orders granting leave to defend.

First, the Court held that the learned Single Judge of the High Court was not justified in departing from the law laid down in the earlier decisions of coordinate Benches. Those earlier decisions had already determined that an order granting leave to defend is interlocutory in nature and that no revision lies against such an order under Section 25(B)(8) of the Act.

The Court stated that if the learned Single Judge was not inclined to agree with that established view, particularly in light of the amendments introduced by the Amendment Act of 1988 (which added Sections 14-B, 14-C and 14-D to the Act), the proper course would have been to refer the matter to a larger Bench for reconsideration. Sitting singly, the learned Judge could not validly disagree with or overrule the earlier coordinate Bench decisions.

Until reversed by a larger Bench, the earlier view remained binding. Accordingly, the Court concluded that the High Court’s impugned judgment—holding that a revision lies against an order granting leave to defend—could not be sustained.

Applying the binding earlier decisions of the High Court, which had not been overruled, the Court held that the respondent’s revision petition before the High Court was not maintainable. On that basis, the Court set aside the impugned High Court judgment and dismissed the revision petition.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal was allowed. The judgment of the Delhi High Court dated 2-3-1995 was set aside, and the revision petition filed by the respondent under Section 25(B)(8) of the Act was dismissed as not maintainable. The Court directed that the Additional Rent Controller shall proceed with the respondent’s eviction petition and hear and dispose of it expeditiously within a period of six months. No order was made as to costs.

Implications: The immediate consequence is that the order of the Additional Rent Controller granting leave to defend stands, and the eviction petition will now proceed on merits before the Additional Rent Controller, to be decided within six months. The opinion reaffirms that earlier coordinate Bench decisions of the High Court remain binding on Single Judges unless and until overruled by a larger Bench. The decision, as presented, addresses the parties’ dispute and the internal judicial discipline of the High Court; no broader or new legal precedent beyond this was expressly discussed.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Leave granted.

2. We have heard learned counsel for the parties.

3. This appeal arises out of a petition filed by the respondent (landlord) for the eviction of the appellant (tenant) under the provisions of Section 14-D of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”). In the said proceedings the appellant has been granted leave to defend by the Additional Rent Controller, Delhi by order dated 22-9-1992. Feeling aggrieved by the said order passed by the Additional Rent Controller, the respondent filed a revision petition in the Delhi High Court under Section 25(B)(8) of the Act. The appellant raised an objection about the maintainability of the said revision petition and placed reliance on the earlier judgments of the High Court holding that an order granting leave to defend is interlocutory in nature and a revision does not lie against the said order. By the impugned judgment the learned Single Judge of the High Court has disagreed with the said view in the earlier judgments of the Court and has held that a revision lies under Section 25(B)(8) of the Act against an order granting leave to defend. The learned Judge has differed from the earlier judgments of the High Court on the ground that at the time the said judgments were delivered, the provisions of Sections 14-B, 14-C and 14-D were not there and they were introduced by the Amendment Act of 1988 and that in view of the changed scenario it must be held that a revision to the High Court will lie against an order of the Rent Controller granting leave to defend.

4. We are unable to endorse this approach of the learned Judge in departing from the law laid in the earlier decisions of the High Court holding that an order granting leave to defend is an interlocutory order against which a revision does not lie. If the learned Judge was not inclined to agree with the said view, on the basis of the amendments introduced in the Act by the Amendment Act of 1988, the proper course for him was to refer the matter to be considered by a larger Bench. Sitting singly the learned Judge could not disagree with the view expressed earlier by other coordinate Benches of the High Court. Till the view taken in the earlier decisions was reversed by a larger Bench the learned Judge was bound by it. We are, therefore, unable to uphold the impugned judgment of the High Court taking the view that the revision filed by the respondent was maintainable and on the basis of the law as laid down in the earlier decisions of the High Court, which has not been overruled, it must be held that the revision filed by the respondent was not maintainable.

5. The appeal is therefore, allowed, the judgment of the High Court dated 2-3-1995 is set aside and the revision petition filed by the respondent is dismissed as not maintainable. The Additional Rent Controller will proceed with the eviction petition submitted by the respondent and hear and dispose of the same expeditiously within a period of six months. No costs.