- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dhanraj Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab
Factual and Procedural Background
S/Shri Dhanraj Singh alias Shera, Jagsir Singh alias Pappu, and Rajinder Singh alias Gora, residents of village Tungawali, District Bathinda, were convicted under Section 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code for the murder of Sukhmander Singh and sentenced to life imprisonment with fines. The appellants, along with Jagrup Singh and Nachhattar Singh (both acquitted), were charge-sheeted for conspiracy under Section 120-B IPC and for the murder committed on 21.10.1995. The complainant, Shri Sukhdev Singh, alleged that the appellants fired shots causing the death of his nephew, Sukhmander Singh. The police investigation initially favored the complainant but later shifted, resulting in the complainant party being prosecuted and acquitted, while the appellants were convicted based on a private complaint. The trial court acquitted Jagrup Singh and Nachhattar Singh for lack of proof of conspiracy but convicted the three appellants. The appellants challenged this conviction in the present criminal appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the conviction of the appellants under Section 302/34 IPC for the murder of Sukhmander Singh is sustainable despite the police investigation favoring the complainant party initially and later acquitting the appellants.
- Whether the testimony of the complainant and eyewitnesses, who had bad antecedents and possible enmity with the accused, can be relied upon to uphold the conviction.
- Whether the plea of alibi raised by the appellants was sufficiently supported by evidence to create reasonable doubt.
- The extent to which the court should rely on the police investigation report versus the evidence produced at trial.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellants contended their innocence and alleged that the complainant party had a criminal background, having committed murders previously, and falsely implicated them to take revenge.
- They argued that the police investigation was biased, influenced by political intervention, resulting in a wrongful prosecution of the appellants.
- The appellants claimed alibi, stating they were attending a marriage at the time of the occurrence and produced a video cassette as proof, which was not examined in court.
- The appellants challenged the credibility of the eyewitnesses, emphasizing their bad antecedents and the lack of corroboration from independent witnesses.
- They submitted that the medical evidence contradicted the prosecution’s account of the incident.
- They relied on judgments emphasizing the need for strong evidence when police investigation exonerates accused persons.
Complainant and Prosecution Arguments
- The complainant, Shri Sukhdev Singh, asserted that the appellants and their companions conspired and committed the murder, supported by his eyewitness testimony and that of Bikramjit Singh.
- The prosecution emphasized the prompt lodging of the FIR, with detailed allegations including motive and names of accused, lending credibility to the prosecution story.
- They argued that the police investigation was flawed and politically influenced, and the court should rely on the evidence adduced at trial rather than the investigation report.
- Prosecution highlighted that the appellants failed to discharge the burden of proof for their alibi defense by not producing supporting witnesses.
- The medical evidence of three separate gunshot injuries corroborated the prosecution account of three assailants firing upon the deceased.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Vakil v. State of Haryana, 1998 (4) RCR (Criminal) 165 | Benefit of doubt should be given to a person found innocent during investigation, especially when identity is doubtful. | Distinguished on facts: Here the appellants' identity was not in doubt and weapons were attributed to them, so the principle did not apply. |
| Balbir Singh v. State of Haryana, 2000 Criminal Law Journal 169 | Procedure for trials involving multiple accused and the need for separate trials and judgments. | Applied to justify separate trials and judgments for different accused in the present case. |
| Vijender v. State of Delhi, (1997) 6 SCC 171 | Trial court must base findings on evidence adduced at trial and not solely on investigation reports under Section 173 Cr.P.C. | Reiterated that the court cannot rely on police investigation alone and must consider trial evidence independently. |
| Kaptan Singh and others v. State of M.P, 1997(6) SCC 185 | High Court's revisional power should not be exercised unless there is manifest illegality or grave miscarriage of justice; trial court should not rely unduly on defense witnesses. | Supported the court’s reliance on trial evidence over investigation and defense witnesses’ claims. |
| Balwinder Singh v. The State of Punjab, 1996(2) Recent Criminal Cases 92 | Prompt lodging of FIR indicates credibility of prosecution story. | Used to uphold the prompt FIR lodging in the present case as a factor supporting prosecution’s version. |
| Shiv Dhan v. State of Haryana, 1991(1) Recent Criminal Reports 372 | Extra prompt reporting and special report to Magistrate supports genuineness of FIR. | Applied to affirm the genuineness of the FIR in this case. |
| Nahar Singh v. State of Punjab, 1995(3) All Instant Judgments 454 | Minor details need not be present in FIR; presence of accused, weapon, motive, and witnesses in FIR lends guarantee against concoction. | Supported the court’s acceptance that the FIR was not fabricated despite minor omissions. |
| Surjit Singh Alias Gurmit Singh v. State of Punjab, 1992 CAR 311 | Failure of alibi plea and formal defense witnesses supports acceptance of eyewitness account. | Applied to reject appellants’ alibi plea and uphold eyewitness testimony. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court conducted a detailed analysis weighing the evidence presented at trial against the police investigation report. It noted that the police initially investigated based on the complainant’s statement but later shifted to prosecute the complainant party, allegedly due to political intervention. The Court emphasized that the police investigation is not binding on the Court, which must independently assess the trial evidence.
The Court examined the credibility of the complainant and eyewitnesses, acknowledging their bad antecedents but recognizing the context of strong enmity and motive between the parties. The Court found the prompt FIR and detailed allegations credible, supported by medical evidence confirming three distinct firearm injuries consistent with the testimony of the eyewitnesses.
The appellants’ plea of alibi was rejected due to failure to produce supporting witnesses, despite the availability of persons mentioned by the Investigating Officer. The Court held that the burden to prove alibi lies on the accused and they failed to discharge it.
The Court found the appellants’ arguments regarding contradictions and improvements in the witnesses’ statements not sufficient to create reasonable doubt, especially given the nature of firearm injuries and the circumstances of the occurrence.
Overall, the Court endorsed the trial court’s conviction, concluding that the prosecution’s version, supported by eyewitness and medical evidence, was probable and reliable despite the police’s contrary investigation findings.
Holding and Implications
The Court DISMISSED the appeal and upheld the conviction and sentence of the appellants under Section 302/34 IPC for the murder of Sukhmander Singh.
The direct effect of this decision is the affirmation of life imprisonment and fines imposed on the appellants. The Court clarified that police investigation reports are not binding and that trial courts must independently evaluate evidence presented at trial. No new precedent was set beyond the reaffirmation of established principles regarding the evaluation of evidence, burden of proof on alibi, and the limited role of investigation reports in trial proceedings.
R.L. Anand, J. -
S/Shri Dhanraj Singh alias Shera and Jagsir Singh alias Pappu sons of Shri Kulwant Singh and Rajinder Singh alias Gora son of Jagrup Singh, all residents of village Tungawali. District Bathinda, have filed the present criminal appeal and it has been directed against the judgment and order dated 9.11.2000, passed by the Court of Additional District & Sessions Judge, Bhatinda, who convicted the present three appellants under Section 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced them to undergo imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs. 1000/- each. In default of payment of fine, they were directed to undergo R.I. for a period of three months each.
2. The present three appellants referred to above, along with Jagrup Singh son of Nand Singh, father of Rajinder Singh appellant and Nachhattar Singh alias Kala son of Jagrup Singh aforesaid were charge-sheeted on two counts; firstly that on 15.10.1995, at about 6.00 P.M. at Bhalerian Petrol Pump. Bhucho, Jagrup Singh and Nachhattar Singh (since acquitted) entered into a conspiracy for committing the murder of Sukhmander Singh and thereby they allegedly committed an offence punishable under Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code and secondly on 21.10.1995 at 11.30 A.M. in the area of Tungwali, the present appellants in furtherance of their common intention intentionally caused the death of Sukhmander Singh with fire arms and thereby committed an offence punishable under Section 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code.
3. It is a case in which we have formulated an impression that the police tried to spoil the case of the complainant Shri Sukhdev Singh by siding with the accused party as a result of which the complainant Shri Sukhdev Singh had to file a criminal complaint against the present three appellants and their two companions.
4. Shri Sukhdev Singh son of Sarban Singh complainant (PW-2) at the first instance lodged First Information Report on 21.10.1995 before S.I. Mukhtiar Singh, SHO of Police-Station, Nathana, by making a statement in which he stated that he was a resident of village Tungwali and does the work of agriculture. He has four brothers and sisters and that he is the youngest. His land is situated at a distance of about 6 kms towards South West from the village on Kucha passage leading from his village to village Kotshmir and their fields adjoin with each other. On 21.10.1995, he along with his nephew Bikramjit Singh (known as Buta Singh also) son of Ranjit Singh and Sukhmander Singh son of Gurnam Singh had gone to plough the land known as Rohiwala. He and his nephew Bikramjit Singh, were talking with each other by standing near the Chari field while his nephew Sukhmander Singh had gone to drink water on the nearby water-pump. At about 11.30 A.M. Dhanraj Singh alias Shera son of Kulwant Singh armed with gun, Jagsir Singh alias Pappu son of Kulwant Singh armed with gun and Rajinder alias Gora son of Jagrup Singh Sarpanch armed with gun came there by emerging out from the Narma field and by reaching near the hand-pump they raised Lakara that they would teach a lesson to the complainant party for committing the murder of their relations. Thereafter, all the three appellants chased Sukhmander Singh deceased of this case and fired three shots. On account of the fear the complainant and his companion Shri Bikramjit Singh alias Buta ran away towards the side of the village and all the three accused went away towards village Naiwala along with their respective weapons. It is stated by the complainant Shri Sukhdev Singh that on account of fear, he and Bikramjit Singh remained underground in the village. Thereafter, they went at the spot to ascertain about the fate of Sukhmander Singh and on reaching there they noticed that Shri Sukhmander Singh had sustained three gun shot injuries, one of the right flank, second on the back side in the middle of the shoulders and the third in between the nape and left ear and on account of these gun shot injuries, Shri Sukhmander Singh had died at the spot. After leaving Bikramjit Singh at the spot to guard the dead body, he returned to the village on foot and reported the matter to his brother Ranjit Singh Sarpanch. Thereafter, he along with Ranjit Singh proceeded towards the Police-Station in order to lodge the report but on the way, the police-party headed by S.I. Mukhtiar Singh, which was present near Railway Crossing of village Burj Kahan Singh Wala in connection with the patrolling, met Sukhdev Singh and Ranjit Singh and Shri Sukhdev Singh gave statement. The statement was read over and explained to Shri Sukhdev Singh who signed the same in token of its correctness and the Thanedar made endorsement underneath the said statement and it was sent to the Police-Station Nathana for the registration of the case on the basis of which formal First Information Report Ex. PB was recorded at 4.30 P.M. and the special report was sent to the Area Magistrate at a distance of 20 kms from the Police-Station and it was received by him at 8.40 P.M. on the same day. With regard to motive, it was stated by the complainant that in August, 1979, the complainant party had committed the murders of Kulwant Singh and Ram Singh brother of Jagrup Singh Sarpanch aforesaid. After that in 1980, brother of Jagrup Singh was murdered by Ranjit Singh brother of the complainant and the complainant party was challaned in these cases. It is further alleged by the complainant that Sarpanch Jagrup Singh son of Nand Singh and his sons Rajinder Singh alias Gora and Nachhattar Singh Kala, Jagsir alias Pappu and Dhanraj Singh alias Shera sons of Kulwant Singh residents of village Tungwali had shot dead his nephew Sukhmander Singh and therefore, the action be taken against the appellants and his two companions Nachhattar Singh and Jagrup Singh.
5. The case was investigated by the Police which came to a different conclusion and it was the finding of the Investigating agency that in fact the murder of Sukhmander Singh has been committed by the complainant party as they want to take the revenge of the entire matter and they have falsely implicated the present appellant and their two companions. For the murder of Sukhmander Singh the challan was submitted by the police against Sukhdev Singh complainant and others but they were acquitted.
6. The case of the prosecution further proceeds that when Shri Sukhdev Singh complainant observed that police has connived with the accused party, he filed a criminal complaint before the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bhatinda and the complainant adopted the allegations of his earlier statement made before the Investigation Officer, Shri Mukhtiar Singh and his case in the complaint was that Sukhmander Singh has been murdered by the three appellants and their two companions Nachhattar Singh and Jagrup Singh who hatched a criminal conspiracy. As per Sukhdev Singh, the case was investigated by the police which came at the spot and prepared inquest report on the dead body of Sukhmander Singh which was sent for post-mortem examination and it was conducted by Dr. S.K. Raj Kumar. The police also recorded the statements of the witnesses : prepared the rough site plan of the place of occurrence and lifted the blood stained earth. So much so the present appellants and their companions were arrested. Their weapons were also recovered in pursuance of their disclosure statements. The conversation of the conspiracy was heard by Mohinder Singh PW. It is further alleged by the complainant that he along with Ranjit Singh, Bhaloli, Bikramjit Singh alias Boota Singh and Gurnam Singh were arrested by the police of CIA staff Bhatinda on 17.11.1995 in connivance with the accused party, and they were tortured and given injuries. The complainant alleged that Jagrup Singh Sarpanch is the man of Chief Minister of Shri Harcharan Singh Brar and he is related with him and that was the reason the police took a somersault and declared the complainant parry as accused while clean chit was given to the accused whose names figured in the FIR No. 57 dated 21.10.1995 registered under Sections 302/34 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code read with Section 25/27 of the Arms Act, at the instance of the complainant. It is also the grudge of the complainant that the police introduced false witnesses. In spite of challaning the accused it wrongly challaned the complainant party for the murder of their own man Sukhminder Singh and when this fact came to the notice of the complainant on 5.1.1996, he filed the present complaint on 6.1.1996 in the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate who recorded the preliminary evidence and came to the conclusion that prima facie offence under Sections 302/34 read with Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code is made out. Therefore, he committed the accused to the Court of Sessions to face the trial vide commitment order dated 28.1.1997 and vide order dated 3.2.1997 the learned Sessions Judge Bhatinda framed charges against the appellants and their two companions under Section 120-B and Section 302/34 IPC. The charges were read over and explained to the accused to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. It may be mentioned here that the challan, which presented by the police against the complainant party, has ended in acquittal.
7. In order to prove the charges the prosecution examined Dr. S.K. Raj Kumar PW-1, who conducted the post-mortem examination on the dead body of Sukhmander Singh on 22.1.1995 when it was brought in the mortuary by constable Jaswant Singh Chamkaur Singh and it was identified by Mohinder Singh son of Karnail Singh and Naranjan Singh son of Bagga Singh. The length of the body was 5'- 7". It was moderately built and moderately nourished. Corresponding holes were present on shirt. Eyes were semi open and mouth closed. Post mortem stainings were present on dependent parts. Rigor mortis was present. The doctor found the following injuries on the dead body of Sukhmander Singh:
1. Lacerated contused and inverted margins of the wound measuring 4 cm x 3 cm. On right side between middle and posterior calvicular line situated 7-1/2 cm below 7th cervical spine with obliquely placed from below upwards. Clotted blood was present with multiple lacerated wouns oval shaped 17 wounds measuring 1/2 cm x 1/2 cm around the above injury, spread in an area of 22 cm x 11 cm.
On dissection abdominal wall, perltnneum and liver right lower injured. 3 embedded pellets removed. Abdominal cavity full of blood. One grazing wound on sternal head of clavical and measuring 1 cm x 3 cm and one on anterior front of left shoulder oval shaped 1 cm x.3 cm.
2. Lacerated wound with inverted and contused margins measuring 4 cm x 3 cm on right back. Close to midline in between lower ends of scapula. On dissection chest cavity contained blood and right lung punctured and obliquely upwards muscle torn along the verticaicoum one wad recovered and got x-rayed for pellets.
3. Lacerated wound with inverted and contused margins shaped as described in the post mortem report measuring 1.2 x 1 cm. In the left post curricula region situated 3 cm away from outer border of pinna, blackening present around wound and hairs were signed in an area around 5 cm.
On dissection underlying skull fractured and pieces of skull bone embedded in brain matter. Membrance and brain matter injured and haemorrhage seen. 1 wad and 7 pellets recovered.
The doctor also took into possession one wad and seven pallets from the dead body. The doctor further opined as follows :
"As described above, scalp skull and vertebrae remberanees brains spinal cord as described injuries No.3 Condition of lung described as in injury No.2. Condition of abdomen i.e. Walla and peritonbeumn as described in injury No. 1 Mouth pharynx and Oesophagus, stomach and its contents, small intestines and their contents, large intestines and their contents were found healthy. Liver has been described injury No. I. Spleen kidneys, bladder organs of generation were healthy.
In the opinion of the doctor the cause of death was due to shock and haemorrhage on account of injuries which were antemortem in nature and were sufficient to cause death in ordinary course of nature.
8. The probable time that elapsed between injury and death was instantaneous and between death and post-mortem, it was within 36 hours. Ex. PA is the correct carbon copy of the post-mortem report and Ex. PA/1 and PA/2 are the pictorial diagram showing the seats of the injuries. As per the opinion of the doctor, three injuries were the result of three different shots and each injury was individually sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. He further stated that he conducted the post mortem examination the police request. It has also been stated that all the three injuries appeared to have been caused by a weapon which discharged pellets like a shot gun.
9. The stomach and the bladder of the deceased were empty which gives an indication that the deceased might have urinated a little before the death.
10. Prosecution further examined Sukhdev Singh complainant PW- 2 who has supported the allegations of the FIR as well as his complaint and he further deposed that Jagrup Singh since acquitted was close to the Chief Minister Shri Harcharan Singh Brar and due to that influence the main accused were shown innocent by the police and that the complainant party was sent for trial.
11. PW-3 Shri Bikramjit Singh is the eye witness of this case and he has also supported the allegations of the prosecution like Shri Sukhdev Singh.
12. PW-4 is Shri Avtar Singh who deposed that in his presence Jagsir Singh appellant was interrogated and on interrogation he disclosed that he had kept concealed 250/300 bore rifle with 4 cartridges and a 12 bore gun with 8 cartridges in the box (Peti) in his residential house and he could get the same recovered by pointing out the place of concealment. His disclosure statement Ex. PE was recorded and was attested by Avtar Singh. The witness also deposed that Rajinder Singh appellant was interrogated and. he disclosed that he had kept concealed a gun .16 bore with seven cartridges concealed in a box in his residential house and he could get the came recovered. His statement Ex. PF was recorded. Thereafter, the police party firstly went to the house of Jagsir Singh who got recovered 250/300 bore rifle with 4 cartridges and .12 bore gun with 8 cartridges from his Peti and these were taken into possession by making sealed parcel thereof vide recovery memo Ex P.G. Thereafter, the police party went to the house of Rajinder Singh and got recovereu .16 bore gun and 7 cartridges from the specified place of concealment and made a sealed parcel and these were taken into possession vide Memo Ex. PJ.
13. PW-5 is Shri Mohinder Singh who deposed that he heard a conversation between Jagrup Singh and Nachhattar Singh (since acquitted) and they were saying to each other that there had a compromise with Ranjit Singh but since they had influence in the Government and Ranjit Singh and others were trusting them, they should take revenge for the murders.
14. OW-6 is S.I. Mukhtiar Singh who investigated the case on the statement of Sukhdev Singh as stated above but during the course of cross-examination, the witness deposed that all the accused pleaded alibi and he found that the accused had not committed the offence. He recorded the statement of several witnesses. He further deposed that during investigation on 11.11.1995, on the basis of secret information, he searched for Buta son of Ranjit Singh, Baloli son of Gullu. On 16.12.1995, Nirmal Singh the bridegroom produced a movie of his engagement and marriage and also produced his marriage invitation card and those were taken into possession. So much so the statement of Nirmal Singh was also recorded. He further deposed in the crossexamination that on 25.12.1995 he associated Madan Gopal Photographer in investigation who produced before him the movie cassette which was taken into possession vide recovery memo. He also stated that he arrested Ranjit Singh and Sukhdev Singh who were already in detention with CIA staff. The investigation was verified by D.S.P. Shri B.S. Romana. On 26.11.1995, Sukhwinder Singh Vice Chairman, Block Samiti, Bhatinda produced Buta Singh alias Bikramjit Singh and according to this witness, Buta Singh was interrogated. He had disclosed that he had kept .12 bore DBBL Gun and 17 cartridges in a Koop of Turi and lie could get the same recovered by pointing out the place of concealment and in pursuance of the disclosure statement he got recovered the gun and the cartridges. The gun was put in sealed parcel and all these articles taken into possession. The witness also deposed. that he ultimately challaned Buta Singh Baloli, Sukhdev Singh and Ranjit Singh and so much so complaint was also filed under Section 182 of the Indian Penal Code against Sukhdev Singh for lodging a false FIR. It has also come in the statement of PW-6 Mukhtiar Singh that he did not find any foot prints at the place of occurrence because the land was covered with grass. Of course, he saw Narma crop which was pointed out to him and the witnesses but it was not trampled nor there was any foot prints leading to the place of occurrence. He also stated in the cross-examination that he did not find any pellet, wad or cartridge on the spot. So much so after recording the statement of Mohinder Singh, he did not come to know about any conspiracy. The witness however, admitted that the account given in the inquest report was the same as given in the FIR lodged by Sukhdev Singh. He further stated that Shri Ranjit Singh was a man of bad character and his name was entered in bad character register No.10. Finally he stated that after thorough investigation, confirmed by his superiors, it was found that Buta Singh, Baloli, Ranjit Singh and Sukhdev Singh were responsible for the murder of Sukhmander Singh.
15. On the closure of the prosecution evidence, the statements of the accused were recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and all the incriminating circumstances appearing in the prosecution evidence were put to the accused. The accused denied those circumstances and stated that they have been falsely implicated in this case.
16. Shri Jagsir appellant took the following stand before the learned trial Court.
"I am innocent. The complainant party is a criminal of first degree. They are habitual to commit crime since their childhood, for which they have been convicted and sentenced up to Supreme Court and were sentenced to life imprisonment and other imprisonments. They are season/sailora in criminal litigation. They have murdered themselves Sukhwinder Singh and the case was investigated by SHO, D.S.P. Circle and S.S.P. Bathinda and found as after thorough investigation innocent and their challan is pending in your honours Court. Ranjit Singh is known as Tandebhan as he killed the people like a maize plant which is made to fall by a strong wind. They had committed the murder themselves and they have concealed most material points in the FIR to mould their version in any manner they like. They have concealed in the FIR what type of weapon was used and from which distance and where hit and they have tried to implicate the entire family. Myself Rajinder Singh and Dhanraj Singh attributed one injury each. When according to law one injury attributed to each accused is a phenomena not known to the criminal courts and they have also tried to implicate my uncle Jagroop Singh and my cousin Nachhattar Singh in conspiracy in the FIR without mentioning when they conspired and at what time they conspired and in whose presence they conspired and who ever heard them. This was purposely concealed so that they may produce a false witness to falsely involve my uncle Jagrup Singh and my cousin Nachhattar Singh. This murder has taken place due to sale of illicit liquor which is the police version and S.I. Mukhtiar Singh found a working still near the fields of the deceased. Jagroop Singh had defeated Ranjit Singh in Sarpanch Elections and as such he lost income which he was getting illegally from the people being a clog and authority of a Sarpanch and he had made this false case against us to save his near relations because Ranjit Singh was with Sukhdev Singh, his brother, at the time of lodging the FIR and he has avoided to come in the witness box to avoid healthy cross-examination so that truck may not come to light. The complainant party alleges that we have not been challaned by the police due to the influence of S. Harcharan Singh Brar, the then Chief Minister, Punjab. This is a made up story because it has come in evidence that Ranjit Singh is a friend of S. Beant Singh deceased Chief Minister of Punjab and he also appeared as a defence witness in support of Ranjit Singh, his other brothers and party men in case State v. Ranjit Singh etc. but the justice is above all. They were convicted and sentenced up to Supreme Court and they have undergone the sentence. Beant Singh and Harcharan Singh Brar belong to one and same Congress party and we have no affiliation with Sh. Harcharan Singh Brar not any relationship with him. It is also worth mentioning that this party can concoct FIR in no time which is altogether false. Gurnam Singh, father of deceased Sukhwinder Singh, lodged a FIR for the murder of Jagtar Singh son of Ranjit Singh and named 7 accused namely Jagroop Singh, Nachhattar Singh, Dhanraj Singh, Rajinder Singh, Paramjit Singh, Sukhdev Ram and Parminder Singh. The police has not challaned any one of them and they have not filed any complaint against any one of them, although the incident is alleged to have taken place on 24.10.1996 and the case is pending in this Court and the police has challaned other persons. On the date and time of alleged occurrence, Nachhattar Singh, Jagroop Singh and Rajinder Singh had joined the marriage party from Rohan to village Chainewala and video cassette of the marriage was taken into possession by the police and which fact has been admitted by Mukhtiar Singh SI, who investigated this case and appeared as PW in the present case and we had surrendered before the Ilaga Magistrate at Bathinda soon after knowing the incident and pleaded our false implication."
The other co-accused adopted the stand of Shri Jagsir Singh.
17. When called upon to enter into their defence, the accused produced Ex. D. 1 the copy of the judgment dated 3.12.1982. Ex. D2 certified copy of the report under Section 173 Cr.P.C. Ex. D.3 another certified copy of the report under Section 173 Cr.P.C. D.4 certified copy of the FIR, D.5 certified copy of the complaint. D.6; certified copy of the FIR No. 39. The accused also tendered in defence Ex. D.7 the copy of the judgment dated 11.10.1989 passed by the Court of Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Gidderbaha and the copy of the FIR No. 22 Ex. D.8. All these documents have been produced by the defence mainly in order to show about the antecedents of the witnesses examined by the prosecution in the present case.
18. The learned trial Court vide the impugned judgment believed the story of the prosecution in part by holding that S/Shri Dhanraj Singh, Jagsir Singh and Rajinder Singh are responsible for the murder of Sukhmander Singh and they were convicted and sentenced in the manner as stated above. However, it came to the conclusion that the prosecution has not been able to prove the conspiracy aspect of the case. Resultantly, Jagrup Singh and Nachhattar Singh were given the benefit of doubt and they were acquitted. On the same day i.e. on 9.11.2000 S/Shri Ranjit Singh, Sukhdev Singh, Bhola Singh and Boota Singh were acquitted.
19. Aggrieved by the judgment of conviction and order of sentence, passed by the learned trial Court, the present appeal by the three appellants referred to above.
20. We have heard Shri R.S. Ghai, senior Counsel, appearing on behalf of the appellants, Shri G.S. Gill, learned DAG, appearing on behalf of the State assisted by Shri A.P.S. Deol, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the complainant Shri Sukhdev Singh and with their assistance have gone through the record of this case.
21. It was a case where the investigation started on the statement of Sukhdev Singh who named the three appellants in the FIR besides two persons Nachhattar Singh and Jagrup Singh for hatching a criminal conspiracy. At one point of time, the investigation started for the benefit of the complainant party as is evident from the statement of Shri Mukhtiar Singh PW-6 but in the mid-way the trend of the investigation took a somersault against the prosecution and it is the cry of Shri Sukhdev Singh and the complainant party that this somersault was a deliberate attempt on the part of the police on the political intervention of Shri Harcharan Singh Brar Ex-Chief Minister of the State as a result of which the police fabricated the evidence for the benefit of the accused and made a false story of plea of alibi as a result of which the complainant party was prosecuted for the murder of Sukhmander Singh and the challan case which was submitted by the police against the complainant party failed. Seeing the partial attitude of the police, the complainant had to file a criminal compliant in which the present three appellants were convicted and sentenced.
22. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants submitted that the learned trial Court has erred in believing the witness Sukhdev Singh and Buta Singh alias Bikramjit Singh who had bad antecedents. As per the admission of the complainant Shri Sukhdev Singh in the First Information Report, they had been committing murders after murder. In fact, these people are the persons of tainted personality. They have killed Sukhmander Singh their own person in order to take the revenge of the old enmity which was persisting between the parties and Sukhdev Singh has named the present appellants and their two companions falsely. The counsel Shri Ghai also submitted that the occurrence as narrated above by Shri Sukhdev Singh in the First Information Report and in the trial Court could not take place. There is no corroboration to the statement of these inimical witnesses from any independent source. The counsel further submitted that the Investigating agency has found the version of Sukhdev Singh as a false version and so much so Sukhdev Singh along Bikramjit Singh alias Buta Singh, Bhola alias Bhaloloi and Ranjit Singh son of Sarban Singh were prosecuted for the murder of Sukhmander Singh. In such a situation the law Courts should be very definite and must rely a very strong evidence before recording the conviction against a person who has been found innocent during the course of investigation. The counsel submitted that the primary duty to investigate the offence is of the police and when the police itself has given a clean chit to the accused, therefore, in such a situation, a very strong evidence is required to disbelieve the investigation which has been conducted by none else but by the agency of the State.
23. Learned counsel for the appellants drew my attention to the judgment of this Court reported as 1998 (4) RCR (Criminal) 165 Vakil v. State of Haryana wherein in para No. 12 of the judgment it was observed that investigation is the primary function of the State police and if during the course of investigation, a particular person has been found to be innocent, the benefit of doubt should go to that person whose identity according to the State itself was doubtful. The cited judgment which has been relied upon by the counsel for the appellants and which was authored by one of us (Justice R.L. Anand) is not applicable to the facts in hand. In the cited case during the course of investigation it was found by the investigating agency that one of the appellants was not involved and, therefore, he was not challaned by the police. He was summoned by the trial Court in the proceedings under Section 319 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. It was the case of the State itself that the identity of the person by the name of Sarwan Singh, was doubtful. In those circumstances, it was remarked by the High Court that such a person should get the benefit of doubt. Here is a case where the identity of any of the appellants is not in doubt. They were known to the complainant party. The weapons which have been attributed to all the appellants, have also been mentioned. In these circumstances, we are inclined to hold that the learned counsel for the appellants cannot take the benefit of the judgment of Vakil Singh v. State of Haryana (Supra).
24. The learned counsel for the appellants Shri Ghai, again referred to a judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported as 2000 Criminal Law Journal 169: [2000(3) All India Criminal Law Reporter 712 (Pb. & Hry.)] Balbir Singh v. State of Haryana. We have also gone this citation wherein it was observed as follows :
"When two commitments are made before Court of Session pertaining to the same offence and pertaining to the same victim, one giving one version against one accused and the other giving another againt a different accused. In such cases the most appropriate procedure to be followed by a Sessions Judge should be the same as followed in the present case, i.e. the two trials were separately conducted one after the other by the same Court before the same Judge and judgments in both cases were separately pronounced on the same day. No doubt the Sessions Judge should take care that he would confine his judgment in one case only on the evidence adduced in that particular case. If more than one Public Prosecutor are available at the same station it is advisable that the Public Prosecutor who prosecuted the case should avoid prosecuting the other case."
Our attention was also invited to para No.24 of this judgment wherein it was observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as under :
"The Court should have been absolutely certain that the police version was false, fabricated and accentuated by sinister motive in order to dumb a thoroughly innocent teenager (Guria) to the very serious criminal charge of murder. At any rate, the Court should have been absolutely certain that the police officials and the real culprits have entered into a criminal conspiracy to rescue the real murderer. Unless the Court reaches such a degree of satisfaction a criminal Court cannot afford to conclude that the prosecution instituted on a private complaint has succeeded in proving beyond all reasonable doubt that it was this accused who had committed the murder of Om Parkash."
We have gone through this citation very minutely and in our opinion, this judgment will also not come to the rescue of the appellants. Here is a case where the version has been unfolded by Sukhdev Singh who deposed that he saw the murder of Sukhmander Singh along with Bikramjit Singh when all the three had gone to the fields in order to plough the fields. He was categorical in his statement and in the complaint that all the three appellants were carrying fire arms and they fired upon Sukhmander Singh who had gone to hand pump in order to take the water. In these circumstances, our primary concern is whether the testimony of Sukhdev Singh and that of Shri Bikramjit Singh alias Buta Singh should or should not be accepted and whether their presence at the time of the occurrence is highly probable or not. We have to determine whether the occurrence has taken place in the manner as stated by these witnesses and whether these witnesses in spite of the disqualifications and their earlier antecedents can be labelled as a truthful witnesses or not. So far as the challaning of the complainant party is concerned; the position of the law is well settled and it has been observed several times by the law Courts that finding of guilt cannot be based on the result of a investigation by the police which should be based solely on the evidence produced during trial. If any judgment is required on this aspect, a reference can be made to (1997) 6 Supreme Court Cases, 171, Vijender v. State Of Delhi., where in para No. 25, of the judgment it was observed as follows :
"The reliance of the trial Court on the result of investigation to base its findings is patently wrong. If the observations of the trial Judge in this regard is taken to its logical conclusion it would mean that a finding of guilt can be recorded against an accused without a trial, relying solely upon the police report submitted under Section 173 Cr.P.C. which is the outcome of an investigation. The result of investigation under Chapter of the Criminal Procedure Code is a conclusion which an Investigating Officer draws on the basis of materials collected during investigation and such conclusion can only form the basis of a competent court to take cognizance thereupon under Section 190(1)(b) Cr.P.C. and to proceed with the case for trial where the materials collected during investigation are to be translated into legal evidence. The trial Court is then required to base its conclusion solely on the evidence adduced during the trial and it cannot rely on the investigation or the result thereof.
This very ratio was again reiterated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in a case reported as 1997(6) Supreme Court Cases 185: [1997(2) All India Criminal Law Reporter 592 (SC)], Kaptan Singh and others v. State of M.P. and another. It was observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the cited judgment in para No.5 as under :
"The revisional power of the High Court while sitting in judgment over an order of acquittal should not be exerci3ed unless there exists a manifest illegality in the judgment or order of acquittal or there is grave miscarriage of justice. In the instant case one of the grounds that largely weighed with the trial Court for acquitting the appellants was that an Inspector of CID who had taken up the investigation of the case and was examined by the defence testified that during his investigation he found that the story as made out by the prosecution was not true and on the contrary the plea of the appellants that the dacoity with murder was committed by some unknown criminals and they were falsely implicated was true. The High Court was therefore, fully justified in commenting upon the trial Court's impermissible and undue reliance on the evidence of the defence witness i.e. the I.O. and for that matter, the result of his investigation."
In the present case, there are two versions one given by Shri Sukhdev Singh and one given by the investigating agency. The Investigating Agency recorded the statements of certain witnesses and came to the conclusion that the version given by Shri Sukhdev Singh was false and in fact the murder of Shri Sukhmander Singh has been committed by Sukhdev Singh, Bikramjit Singh, Ranjit Singh and Bhola Singh of their own and in order to take the revenge against their own enemies they have implicated the present appellants and Jagrup Singh and Nachhattar Singh. We have to weigh the probabilities. Sukhmander Singh is a close relation of S/Shri Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh. He was their nephew. It does not stand to the test of reasonable probability that the complainant party would kill their own person and try to implicate the opposite party. If the complainant party is to take the revenge on, account of this previous enmity, there was no difficulty on the part of the complainant to again take the law into their own hands and commit the murder of the accused party or any one of their companions. The appellants have taken a plea of alibi that they were present on the marriage of one Nirmal Singh who produced the Video Cassette of his engagement and marriage. Shri Mukhtiar Singh the Investigating Officer has also stated in the cross-examination that he recorded the statements of several witnesses namely Baldev Singh, Gamdur Singh sons of Chatin Singh, Bahadur Singh, all residents of Lehra Bagha, Mahala Singh and Gullu Singh residents of Tungwali, Paramjit Singh of Tungwali, Bhura Singh alias Kulwant Singh of Chak Ram Singh Wala. He has named 10 to 12 persons in his cross-examination but strange enough not a single witness has been examined by the accused in the trial Court in support of their plea of alibi. So much so Nirmal Singh the bridegroom who produced the Movie of his engagement and marriage has not been examined by the defence for the reasons best known to it. So far as the position of the law is concerned it has been observed in Section 105 of the Evidence Act which lays down that when a person is accused of any offence, the burden of proving the existence of circumstances bringing the case within any of the General Exceptions in the Indian Penal Code or within any special exception or proviso contained in any other part of the same Code, or in any law defining the offence, is upon him, and the Court shall presume the absence of such circumstances. The appellants took the plea of alibi which in criminal jurisprudence is a complete defence and in these circumstances a heavy onus was upon the appellants to produce the witnesses in support of that plea. Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act further lays down that when any fact is especially within the knowledge of any person the burden of proving that fact is upon him. The accused have corne with a specific plea that they were not present at the time of the occurrence and at the place given by the complainant party. Rather they were attending the marriage of one Nirmal Singh. In these circumstances it was for the accused-appellants to discharge the onus in the same reasonable manner as is required to be done on the part of the prosecution. By simply relying upon the cross-examination of Shri Mukhtiar Singh, S.I. the accused cannot take the benefit because the prosecution has been deprived of its valuable right of cross- examination vis-a-vis those persons whose statements were recorded by Shri Mukhtiar Singh under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
25. Faced with this difficulty, the learned counsel for the appellants submitted that Mukhtiar Singh was the prosecution witness and if the defence hasigained a point in the cross- examination, which cannot be allowed to produce the witnesses in defence in order to demolish the case of the prosecution. The argument of the learned counsel for the appellants may look alluring because as per the law of evidence admitted facts need not be proved but the learned counsel Shri Ghai has ignored a very vital factor that it is in the substantive statement of Shri Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh who have deposed against the appellants and they have never admitted the plea of alibi as propounded by the accused. Rather it is the case of the complainant in the trial Court that the police agency took a somersault on the political intervention of Shri Harcharan Singh Brar Ex-Chief Minister of the State of Punjab and on his asking the complainant party was taken into custody by CIA Staff and this fact has also been admitted by the Investigating Officer Shri Mukhtiar Singh who admitted in the cross-examination that he arrested Ranjit Singh and Sukhdev Singh who were already in detention with the CIA staff. It suggests that at the initial stage, the police agency was with the complainant party but later on account of political intervention it started its investigation against the complainant. This aspect of the case has also been considered by the learned trial Court elaborately and it will be nroper for us if we reproduce the observations of the learned trial Court in this judgment also.
"I am not inclined to accept this argument, because the statements of Parminder Singh and Ram Singh were recorded by the police after about 1-1 /2 months of the occurrence. Till they made the statements to the police they did not tell the real facts to anybody. It has been alleged by the accused party that the complainant party had close links with S. Beant Singh, the then Chief Minister, who had also appeared as a defence witness in their favour in some other murder case. It has also come in evidence that after S. Beant Singh was assassinated S. Harcharan Singh Brar took over as Chief Minicar, who is very close to the present accused and after he took over as Chief Minister the facts were tilted in favour of the accused by the Investigating Agency and although the accused were arrested and weapons of offence were recovered from them and they were sent to judicial lock up, yet they were not challaned by the police and instead the complainant party was challaned for causing the murder of their own blood-relations. According to the defence version Sukhmander Singh deceased was murdered by his cousion Bikramjit Singh alias Boota Singh P.W. but there is no motive for Boota Singh to murder his cousin. It is alleged that they had quarrelled over illicit liquor and the investigating officer also found the implements of working still and dismantled working still at the spot, but his testimony on this point cannot be relied upon, because when he had first visited the place of occurrence after registering the case at the instance of Sukhdev Singh, he prepared site plan, but did not show any implement of working still lying at the spot. After 1-1/2 months he again visited the spot and then again prepared site plan indicating that some implements of working still were lying there. Moreover, even if it is accepted that some implements of working still were there, even there there is no evidence as to why both the cousins had quarrelled and why Boota Singh fired at his cousin Sukhmander Singh. So, it cannot be believed that Boota Singh had murdered Sukhmander Singh without any rhyme or reason. On the other hand, there is a strong motive for the accused to commit murder of Sukhmander Singh, because admittedly both the parties are enemies of each other and many murders have been committed by both the groups and in order to take revenge the accused have murdered Sukhmander Singh. It appears that the prosecution tilted the story after S. Harcharan Singh Brar took over as Chief Minister of Punjab and therefore, it cannot be said that the police version is correct or that it should be accepted. The F.I.R. in the present case is quite prompt and in Balwinder Singh v. The State of Punjab, 1996(2) Recent Criminal Cases page 92, it has been held by our own Hon'ble High Court that prompt lodging of the FIR leads to show that story put forward by prosecution witnesses is without blemish and therefore the conviction was upheld. Similarly, in Shiv Dhan v. State of Haryana, 1991(1) Recent Criminal Reports page 372, our own Hon'ble High Court has held that where there is extra prompt reporting the matter to police and sending of special report to the Magistrate, in such a case it is difficult to believe that a false story was concocted. Similarly in Nahar Singh v. State of Punjab, 1995(3) All Instant Judgments page 454, it was held as under :
"Indian Penal Code 1860 - Section 302 - FIR - Occurrence taking place at 2.00 P.M.-FIR lodged at 4.30 P.M. - Prompt lodging of FIR coupled with the fact that there was hardly any delay in sending the special report to the llaqa Magistrate - Name of accused, nature of weapon used, name of eye witnesses and motive mentioned in FIR - All these facts lends unmistakable guarantee that the FIR has not been concocted-Minor details are not supposed to be incorporated in FIR."
In Surjit Singh Alias Gurmit Singh v. State Of Punjab., 1992 CAR page 311 the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that were the defence witnesses merely are formal and plea of alibi failed and the witnesses did not even remotely touch the alibi of the appellant then the eye witnesses account is natural and has to be accepted. It is also an admitted fact in this case that when the Investigating Agency filed application for discharge of the accused in this case the same was declined by the learned. Magistrate and the prosecution then filed revision against that order of the learned Magistrate, which was dismissed by the Sessions Court and then that order was challenged by the accused in the Hon'ble High Court, but the Hon'ble High Court also dismissed the revision of the accused and that is why these accused persons were also committed to the Court of Session for trial by the Ilaqa Magistrate along with the other group of accused. i.e. the complainant party for trial for the murder of the same man, i.e. Sukhmander Singh. Now it is to be seen whether the murder has been committed by the present accused or by Boota Singh alias Bikramjit Singh. There is no evidence on this file to prove that the murder was committed by Boota Singh alias Bikramjit Singh and therefore, the plea that they (accused persons) were declared innocent by the police and so they are liable to be acquitted cannot be accepted in view of the ocular evidence that they have committed the murder of Sukhmander Singh."
Shri Sukhdev Singh while appearing as PW-2 has categorically stated in the examination-in-Chief that Jagrup Singh Sarpanch was close to the then Chief Minister Shri Harcharan Singh Brar and due to that influence the main accused were shown innocent by the police while the complainant party was sent up for trial. In the cross-examination, the witness further deposed that he had seen Jagrup Singh since acquitted in the company of Harcharan Singh Brar on many occasions. He had seen him with Shri Brar at public functions. He categorically denied the suggestion that Jagrup Singh was not related to Shri H.S. Brar but he belongs to that party. Thus, from this suggestion also it is evident as to why the police took the somersault of the investigation for the disadvantage of the complainant party The position of the law is further settled that the moment plea of alibi bursts, the law will presume the accused at the place where the prosecution says. Meaning thereby it has to be inferred by the law Courts that the present appellants were present at the time of the occurrence and they were responsible for the commission of the crime.
26. Be that as it may, now it is to be seen whether the version which has been given by Shri Sukhdev Singh and corroborated by Bikramjit Singh stands proved from their statements or not. Shri Sukhdev Singh deposed that on the date of occurrence at about 11.30 A.M. he along with his nephew Sukhmander Singh and Bikramjit Singh had gone to. plough the fields. Shri Sukhmander Singh deceased went to bring the water from the hand pump while he and Bikramjit Singh stayed by the side of the Watt and were talking with each other when in the meantime all the three accused-appellants along with the weapons emerged out from the Narma field and they raised Lalkara that they would teach a lesson for committing the murders of their men. Sukhdev Singh further deposed that the attack was opened by Dhanraj Singh who fired a shot from his firearm hitting Sukhmander Singh in his right flank who took a turn and fe;l down. Thereafter, Jagsir Singh fired a shot by coming close to Sukhmander Singh and standing near his feet, which shot hit Sukhmander Singh in his back. After this Rajinder Singh came near the deceased and fired a shot on his left ear from a close range. Further Sukhdev Singh deposed that he and Bikramjit Singh ran away towards the Narma field and the accused also ran way from the place of occurrence. After 2/3 minutes Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh came near Sukhmander Singh and found him dead and after leaving Bikramjit Singh at the spot Sukhdev Singh returned to the village and informed his brother Shri Ranjit Singh. It has also come in the statement of Sukhdev Singh that in the year 1980 brother of Jagrup Singh was murdered and Sukhmander Singh deceased was prosecuted for that murder but was acquitted. The above statement of Sukhdev Singh has also been corroborated in all material particulars by Bikramjit Singh PW-3.
27. The learned counsel Shri Ghai has vehemently attacked the statement of Shri Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh on the ground that as per his own version Sukhdev Singh admits in the First Information Report that in the month of August, 1979, the complainant party had committed the murders of Kulwant Singh and Ram Singh brother of Jagrup Singh Sarpanch and also in the year 1980 brother of Jagrup Singh was murdered by Ranjit Singh who is the brother of Sukhdev Singh. Not only this, in the FIR it has been stated by the complainant that all the three accused ran after Sukhmander Singh and fired three shots. There is no mentioned about the actual seats of injuries. Moreover, Sukhdev Singh stated in the FIR that after the occurrence they ran back towards the village. They remained underground on account of fear but at the trial they had made material improvements by omitting all these factors and also by stating that immediately after the occurrence they went near the dead body and saw Sukhmander Singh who had already succumbed to the injuries. In our opinion the version given by Shri Sukhdev Singh and corroborated by Bikramjit Singh is a truthful version. We cannot lose sight of the fact that three persons were armed with deadly weapons like fire arms and they were causing injuries upon a person who was un-armed. When firearm injuries are being caused within the sight of the eye witnesses, every eye witness will be so scared that it may be difficult for each one of them to give a unanimous account.
28. We have to see whether the story of the prosecution is probable or not. It is the case of the prosecution that on the date of occurrence all the three persons namely Sukhdev Singh, Bikramjit Singh and Sukhmander Singh had gone to the fields at about 11.00 A.M. in order to plough the fields. It is not an abnormal act on the part of an agriculturist. Agriculturist tries to take the assistance of his relatives or friends or co- villagers in the agricultural pursuits. The learned counsel Shir Ghai vehemently submitted that it is the case of the prosecution that the PWs had taken along with them a pair of bullocks one was of Gurnam Singh and other was of Sukhdev Singh but the Investigating officer did not find any bullock nor Gurnam Singh has been examined. The submission raised by Shri Ghai is not acceptable to the Court for the simple reason that the investigating officer went to the spot after 4.30 P.M. when the occurrence had taken place at about 11.00 A.M. It is equally possible that when Sukhdev Singh left the place of occurrence in order to lodge the report, somebody else might have taken the bullocks from the spot not realising their importance. The non-examination of Gurnam Singh is not a fatal circumstance so as to disbelieve the statement of Sukhdev Singh.
29. It was further submitted by the counsel for the appellants that Sukhdev Singh admitted that he, Bikrarjit Singh and Sukhmander Singh had ploughed about one kanal each of their respective land but there is no corroboration to this effect. He also submitted that Shri Sukhdev Singh admitted that all the three had their own tractors and in these circumstances, the story of taking the bullocks to the place of occurrence cannot be accepted. The submission of the counsel for the appellants is totally devoid of any merit. Firstly the land of S/Shri Bikramjit Singh, Sukhmander Singh and Sukhdev Singh are in separate tucks. Sukhdev Singh has stated in his statement that his land was at a distance of 5 killas from the place of occurrence while that of Shri Bikramjit Singh is at a distance of 3 killas. Therefore, if the Investigating Officer has not seen the ploughed area of the fields of Bikramjit Singh and Sukhdev Singh or that of Sukhmander Singh, it is not the fault of the complainant. Assuming for the sake of arguments that all the persons had three tractors there is no bar on their part to borrow the bullock from Gurnam Singh. It all depends how much area is to be cultivated or ploughed. For a small area to be ploughed, the requirement of a tractor is not necessary and this work can be done with the help of two pair of bullocks. We cannot lose sight of the fact that one pair of bullock belonged to the complainant and therefore, we are inclined to reject this argument of Shri Ghai also.
30. The counsel further submitted that the village Tungwali is fairly a big village. The occurrence has taken place at about 11.00 A.M. Several persons must be present in the surrounding fields but strange enough not a single person has been examined by the prosecution to establish the presence of the witnesses or that of the accused. So much so, the gentleman Ranjit Singh to whom the occurrence was narrated by the complainant in the village has also not been examined and, therefore, a reasonable doubt has been created about the genuineness of the story. The submission of the counsel for the appellants cannot be accepted. Nowhere Shri Sukhdev Singh has admitted in his cross- examination that several persons were working in the nearby fields and they had the occasion to witness the occurrence. The glance to the statement made by Shri Sukhdev Singh before the Investigating Officer would show that underneath the endorsement it has been stated by the Investigating Officer that Shri Ranjit Singh was present along with Sukhdev Singh. The statement of Shri Sukhdev Singh was recorded by the Investigating Officer in the presence of Ranjit Singh from which a reasonable inference can always be drawn that Shri Sukhdev Singh narrated the occurrence to Ranjit Singh who accompanied the complainant in order to lodge the report with the police.
31. It was then submitted by the counsel for the appellants by referring to the medical evidence that the occurrence has not taken place in the manner as suggested by the witnesses. We are not convinced with the submission. A reference to the site plan prepared by the Investigating Officer would show that the dead body of Sukhmander Singh was lying at a distance of about 3 Karms from the point where the deceased wanted to take water from the hand-pump. It is the case of the prosecution that on hearing the Lalkara the deceased tried to run away but was fired at. So far as the position of the eye witnesses is concerned, they were at a distance of about 20/21 Karms. Shri Sukhmander Singh was the soft target as he was at a little distance from the assailants and, therefore, if he has been murdered within the sight of Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh, it is not an improbability. The counsel Shri Ghai also submitted that accused were three. They were carrying firearms while Sukhdev Singh, Bikramjit Singh and Sukhmander Singh were empty handed. In all probabilities, the accused would have also committed the murders of Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh alias Buta Singh and very fact that these people have not been harmed would show that they were not present at the time of the occurrence. This submission of the counsel for the appellants has been examined by us and we are of the opinion that it is not acceptable and does not create a dent in the story of the prosecution.
32. We cannot lose sight of the fact that it has come in the statement of the witnesses that the deceased was also responsible for the murder of the accused party. The deceased was near to the accused. He is also the nephew of Shri Sukhdev Singh. He was the family member of the complainant. Moreover, he was the soft target. In these circumstances, there is no improbability if Sukhmander Singh was murdered. Seeing the intention of the accused, Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh managed to escape from the spot either by running or by hiding themselves in the Narma crop.
33. It was also submitted by the counsel for the appellants that the FIR in this case has been lodged with delay. The occurrence took place at about 11.00 A.M. The statement was recorded at 3.30 P.M. Formal FIR was recorded at 4.30 P.M. but the special report of this case reached to the Area Magistrate at 8.15 P.M. at a distance of 20 kms from the Police Station Nathana. Therefore, the version given by Shri Sukhdev Singh has been concocted and exaggerated. We are not convinced with this submission. It is a case of fire arm. It has come in the statements of the witnesses that they tried to hide themselves lest they may not become a prey in the hands of the assailants. The complainant came to the village. He informed the occurrence to Ranjit Singh. He also informed about the occurrence to lady folk. Thereafter they proceeded on foot towards the police station. The Railway Crossing of village Buraj Kahan Singh Wala is at a distance of 10 kms from the village. Even the place of occurrence is at a distance of 7 kms. from the village. Therefore, this time must have been consumed by the complainant. The version was registered with the police-station at 4.30 P.M. and before reaching the special report to the area Magistrate, the investigation of this case had already been started. Therefore, we are not inclined to give benefit to the appellant with regard to the alleged delay.
34. It was also submitted on behalf of the appellants that the antecedents of S/Shri Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh and that of Sukhmander Singh deceased were very bad. They were involved in many cases. They were notorious in character and before acting upon the statements of such witnesses the law Courts should scrutinise their evidence with care and caution specially when there is a strong enmity between both the parties. This aspect of the case has also been examined by us and in our opinion, the argument which was raised by the learned counsel for the appellants should go against the appellants because it is a case of enmity. Murders are being committed in order to take the revenge. Even in the present case the motive of the crime illustrated by the complainant party is that it has been committing murders of the accused party in the past i.e. in the year 1979 and 1980 and, therefore, the present crime can be committed by the accused party in order to take the revenge of those murders which have allegedly been committed by the complainant party. The ball was in the court-yard of the accused party. It was also submitted by Shri Ghai that the earlier murders were committed somewhere in the year 1979 or 1980 and now after a lapse of 15 year, it is highly unlikely that the accused party would take the law into their own hands. We are not convinced with this argument. Motive is a hidden element which is locked in the heart of the author of the crime. When it may sprout into action cannot be judged precisely. The fact remains that the relations between the parties were strained and when direct evidence of a case is convincing and reliable the motive goes to the back seat.
35. They ocular account unfolded by Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh has been corroborated by the medical evidence of Dr. S.K. Raj Kumar, PW-1 who conducted the post mortem Examination. We had already reproduced above the observations of the doctor in the earlier portion of this judgment. A reading of the statement of Dr. S.K. Raj Kumar would show that this is a murder of three shots as is evident even from the seats of the injuries. The doctor has categorically stated that three injuries were the result of three different shots. It suggests that at least three appellants were there and this is the case of the prosecution. The counsel for the appellants submitted that the medical evidence in this case contradicts the oral account given by Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh as the condition of the injuries is such that these injuries could not be caused in the manner as stated by the witnesses. The submission of the learned counsel for the appellants again is devoid of any merit. In fire arm cases to describe the injuries, with precision is a remote possibility. The witnesses confused themselves in observing the target of the gun shot injuries. Moment this Court comes to the conclusion that the presence of Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh is probable then no advantage can be taken by the appellants who have failed in their plea of alibi.
36. An argument was also built by the counsel for the appellants by referring to the post mortem report that the occurrence might have taken place much priJr to 11.30 A.M. i.e. in the early hours of the morning of 21.10.1995. It was a blind murder and the false witnesses have come forward and therefore, their statements should not be believed especially when Sukhdev Singh and Bikramjit Singh are very poor in their antecedents. We are not convinced with this argument. As per the opinion of the doctor, the probable time that elapsed between the death and post mortem was 24 to 36 hours. The post mortem was conducted on 22.10.1995 at 9.05 P.M. Firstly the witnesses are categorical with regard to the time of occurrence and secondly the probable duration that elapsed between the death and post mortem given by the doctor is an opinion evidence and there can always be a margin of few hours on either side with regard to this duration. It was also the argument of Mr. Ghai that the witnesses have improved in material particulars at trial by making exaggerated statements. In the FIR the details of the injuries have not been mentioned but at the trial Shri Sukhdev Singh has given the details of the seats of the injuries., In our opinion, this submission of Mr. Ghai deserves to be rejected. Elucidation of a particular fact at the trial is not a serious improvement. We all know that FIR is not an encyclopaedia of all the facts. In the first information report it is clearly mentioned by the complainant that three shots were fired upon the deceased. During trial, the details of those three shots have been given by the witnesses and, therefore, it is not a material improvement which may cause a reasonable doubt with regard to the genuineness of the story of the prosecution.
37. No other point was urged by the counsel for the parties.
38. The net result is that we endorse the findings of the learned trial Court vis-a-vis the appellants and we are of the considered opinion that the learned trial Court after, proper appreciation of the entire evidence, has rightly convicted and sentenced the appellants in the complaint case irrespective of the fact that appellants were found innocent by the investigating officer and by his superiors. The opinion of the Investigating Agency is not binding upon the law Courts which can always formulate an independent opinion about the commission of the crime and about the participation of the assailants. Therefore, we maintain the conviction and sentence of the appellants and by seeing no merit in this appeal, dismiss the same.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert