- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Umashankar Singh & Anr. v. Keshwa Singh & Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners filed an application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging an order dated 27.9.2012 passed by the learned Sub-Judge, 5th, Siwan, in Title Suit No. 275/1984. The impugned order refused to mark certified copies of a registered deed of gift as exhibits. The Court below rejected the petition on the ground that certified copies of the document could not be exhibited, prompting the petitioners to seek relief.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether certified copies of a registered deed of gift are admissible in evidence without the parties to the document being examined to prove it.
- Whether the Court below erred in refusing to exhibit certified copies of the deed of gift on the ground that certified copies cannot be exhibited without original documents and proof by parties.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The impugned order is contrary to the provisions of Section 77 read with Sections 74(2) and 76 of the Evidence Act, 1972.
- A certified copy of a registered agreement for sale is admissible in evidence even if the parties to the document are not examined to prove it.
- Relied on the Supreme Court judgment in State Of Haryana v. Ram Singh (2001) 6 SCC 254 to support their contention.
Respondents' Arguments
- The Court below rightly rejected the petition for exhibiting certified copies due to absence of original documents and lack of proof by the parties to such documents.
- The suit was filed in 1984, and there was no explanation for the delay in taking steps to get the documents exhibited during all these years.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State Of Haryana v. Ram Singh (2001) 6 SCC 254 | Certified copies of registered documents are admissible in evidence without examination of parties; interpretation of Section 77 read with Sections 74(2) and 76 of the Evidence Act, 1872, and Section 51-A of the Act. | The Court relied on paragraphs 5 and 6 of this judgment to hold that the Court below erred in rejecting the certified copies as inadmissible solely because parties were not examined. |
| Madamanchi Ramappa v. Muthaluru Bojjappa AIR (cited in State Of Haryana v. Ram Singh) | Certified copy of registered sale deed admissible without witness proof. | Referenced to support the principle that certified copies need not be proved by calling a witness. |
| Land Acquisition Officer and Mandal Revenue Officer v. V. Narasaiah | Section 51-A allows acceptance of certified copies of registered documents as evidence without examining parties. | Confirmed that certified copies under the Registration Act, 1908, including copies under Section 57, may be accepted as reliable evidence. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the impugned order in light of the Supreme Court’s ruling in State Of Haryana v. Ram Singh, which clarified that certified copies of registered documents are admissible without the necessity of examining the parties to the document. The Court noted that the lower Court erred in rejecting the certified copies solely because the parties were not examined. The Court recognized that Sections 74(2), 76, and 77 of the Evidence Act, along with Section 51-A, provide for the admissibility of certified copies as reliable evidence. The Court also acknowledged that while the certified copies are admissible, the Court retains the discretion to reject the transaction if mala fide or sham is demonstrated. Given these principles, the Court set aside the impugned order and directed the lower Court to take the certified copies of the deed of gift dated 22.4.1974 into evidence, holding that this course was in the interest of justice despite the suit being at an advanced stage of argument.
Holding and Implications
The impugned order dated 27.9.2012 is set aside and the certified copies of the deed of gift are directed to be taken into evidence as exhibits.
The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioners are allowed to have the certified copies of the deed of gift admitted as evidence in the pending suit. No new precedent is created; rather, the Court applies established Supreme Court jurisprudence to correct the lower Court’s error. The ruling reinforces the principle that certified copies of registered documents are admissible evidence without requiring examination of the parties to such documents, promoting procedural fairness and evidentiary efficiency.
1. Petitioners in the present application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India are aggrieved by order dated 27.9.2012 passed by learned Sub-Judge, 5th, Siwan. in Title Suit No. 275/1984, whereby the Court below has refused to mark the certified copies of registered deed of gift as an exhibit. From the impugned order it appears that the Court below has rejected the petition for exhibiting the certified deed of gift on the ground that certified copies of the document could not be exhibited.
2. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners has submitted that the impugned order is contrary to the provisions as contained in Section 77 read with Sections 74(2) and. 76 of the Evidence Act, 1972. He submits that a certified copies of a registered agreement for sale is admissible in evidence even if parties to the document are not examined to prove it.
3. In support of his submission he has placed reliance upon a Supreme Court judgment reported in (2001) 6 SCC 254 (State Of Haryana v. Ram Singh).
4. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents, on the other hand, has submitted that the Court below rightly rejected the petition for exhibiting certified copies of the documents in the absence of original documents and the same not being proved by the parties to such documents. He further submits that the suit was filed in the year 1984 and there is no explanation as to what prevented the petitioners from taking steps for getting the said documents exhibited during all these years.
5. In my opinion, in view of the Supreme Court judgment reported in (2001) 6 SCC 254 (State Of Haryana v. Ram Singh), the Court below ought not to have refused to exhibit the certified copies of the deed of gift. Paragraphs 5 and 6 of the said judgment lays down the law and read thus:—
“5. Counsel for the State was right when he submitted that the High Court erred in rejecting Exhibits-R-2 and R-3 as inadmissible only on the ground that the parties to the documents had not been examined by the State. It is not the law that a certified copy of a registered agreement for sale is inadmissible in evidence unless the parties to the document are examined to prove it. That would be contrary to what Section 77 read with Sections 74(2) and 76 of the Evidence Act, 1872 and more specifically Section 51-A of the Act provide. As far as the provisions of Evidence Act are concerned, a certified copy of the registered sale deed is admissible in evidence and does not need to be. proved by calling a witness. (See Madamanchi Ramappa v. Muthaluru Bojjappa AIR at p. 1637).
6. Section 51-A of the Act is to the same effect. In Land Acquisition Officer and Mandal Revenue Officer v. V. Narasaiah, it was held that by virtue of Section 51-A, a certified copy of a document registered under the Registration Act, 1908 including a copy under Section 57 of the Act may be accepted as evidence of the transaction recorded in such documents. It is open to the Court to accept the certified copy as reliable evidence and without examining parties to the documents. This does not however preclude the Court from rejecting the transaction itself as being mala fide or shorn provided such a challenge is laid before the Court.”
6. In view of the above, the impugned order dated 27.9.2012 passed by Sub-Judge 5th, Siwan in Title Suit No. 275 of 1984 is set aside. The Court below is directed to take into evidence as exhibits certified copies of the deed of gift dated 22.4.1974 This according to me, is in the interest of justice, though the suit is at the advance stage of argument.
7. This application is, accordingly, allowed.
Alert