Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Akshey Lal Pandit (In 5300) v. Rakesh Kumar (In 5691)

Patna High Court
May 11, 2011
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This group of writ petitions was filed under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging the result of a preliminary test conducted by the Bihar Public Service Commission (the Commission) for recruitment to 217 vacancies in the Subordinate Judiciary of Bihar. The petitions contest multiple aspects of the preliminary examination and the Commission's subsequent actions. The Commission opposed the petitions and relied, inter alia, on a directive of the Hon'ble Supreme Court dated 3 December 2010 which noted the advertisement dated 9 August 2008 and indicated that the recruitment process for the 217 vacancies ought to proceed in accordance with the Rules as they stood prior to the Amendment Rules of 2009. The court heard submissions and disposed of the petitions with directions to the Commission aimed at mitigating alleged injustices arising from disputed questions omitted from the preliminary examination.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Bihar Public Service Commission had authority to conduct a preliminary examination prior to the competitive examination contemplated under the Bihar Judicial Service (Recruitment) Rules, 1955.
  2. Whether the preliminary examination was wrongly conducted under the Bihar Civil Service (Judicial Branch) (Recruitment) (Amendment) Rules, 2008 instead of applying the subsequent Amendment Rules of 2009 (which extended reservation benefits to Backward Class and Extremely Backward Class candidates), thereby depriving those candidates of reservation benefits.
  3. Whether the Commission was justified in omitting 25 disputed questions (19 in the Law paper and 6 in General Studies) from consideration and declaring results on a truncated total.
  4. Whether the Commission erred in allowing only 10% of total examinees to take the competitive examination, contrary to the petitioners' contention that candidates should be allowed in proportion of 1:10 (ten candidates per vacancy) as directed by the Supreme Court.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Commission had no authority to hold a preliminary examination prior to the competitive examination under the Bihar Judicial Service (Recruitment) Rules, 1955.
  • The preliminary examination was conducted based on the 2008 Amendment Rules and ignored the Amendment Rules of 2009 that extended reservation benefits to Backward Class and Extremely Backward Class candidates, thereby depriving those candidates of reserved seats and forcing them to compete in the General Category.
  • The Commission omitted 25 questions from consideration; some of those omitted questions had correct options and candidates who answered them correctly were disadvantaged by their omission.
  • The Commission allowed only 10% of examinees to appear in the competitive examination; petitioners contended this was contrary to the Supreme Court direction to allow candidates in the proportion of 1:10 (ten candidates per vacancy).
  • Some petitioners (lawyers) referred to the question papers and alternative answers to demonstrate that most of the omitted questions had correct answers and that omission caused concrete prejudice to certain candidates.

Respondent's (Commission) Arguments

  • The recruitment matter for the Subordinate Judicial Service was before the Hon'ble Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court's order dated 3 December 2010 took note of the advertisement of 9 August 2008 and the Rules as they stood prior to the Amendment Rules of 2009; hence the Commission was obliged to proceed in accordance with the pre-2009 Rules for the 217 vacancies.
  • By Rule 2 of the Amendment Rules of 2008 the Commission was expressly empowered to hold a preliminary examination and to limit admission to the competitive examination to 10% of examinees; accordingly the Commission held the preliminary examination and allowed around 10% to attempt the competitive written examination.
  • The Commission relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Andhra Pradesh Public Service Commission v. Baloji Badhavath [(2009) 5 SCC 1] to support the proposition that the scope and manner of conducting a preliminary examination are matters for the Commission and that courts should not ordinarily interfere unless the procedure adopted is arbitrary or against principles of fair play.
  • The Additional Advocate General objected to any direction that would contravene the statutory Rules (e.g., expanding the percentage of candidates admitted to the competitive examination), arguing that acceptance of such a direction could increase the number admitted to the competitive examination to around 40% instead of the 10% permitted by Rules.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Andhra Pradesh Public Service Commission v. Baloji Badhavath, (2009) 5 SCC 1 Scope and ambit of preliminary examination; principle that the Commission's manner of judging eligibility/merit is its function and courts should not ordinarily interfere unless procedure is arbitrary or violates fair play; preliminary exam is an eligibility criterion and not part of main examination. The court relied on the principles in this judgment to affirm that a preliminary test is an acceptable method of shortlisting candidates and that the Commission's procedure for conducting such a test should not be lightly disturbed unless arbitrary; used to support the conclusion that the Commission was justified in holding a preliminary examination and limiting admission to the competitive exam.
Order of the Hon'ble Supreme Court dated 3 December 2010 (referenced in the opinion) Direction concerning the recruitment process for the 217 vacancies — taking note of the advertisement dated 9 August 2008 and the Rules as they existed prior to the Amendment Rules of 2009; directive to expedite and complete the recruitment process for those vacancies notwithstanding interim orders. The court treated the Supreme Court's order as determinative for the applicable Rules (pre-2009) for filling the 217 vacancies and held that the Commission was required to act in accordance with the Rules as they stood prior to the 2009 amendments; this supported the Commission's reliance on the 2008 Amendment Rules empowering the holding of a preliminary exam and limiting to 10%.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through the following analytical steps, based solely on the material set out in the opinion:

  1. Applicability of Rules: The court first considered the binding effect of the Hon'ble Supreme Court's order dated 3 December 2010, which referred to the advertisement of 9 August 2008 and the Rules as they stood prior to the Amendment Rules of 2009. On that basis the court concluded the Commission was required to follow the pre-2009 Rules for filling the 217 vacancies.
  2. Authority to Hold Preliminary Examination: The court examined the statutory position and the 2008 Amendment Rules (specifically Rule 2 of the Amendment Rules of 2008) and concluded the Commission was expressly empowered to hold a preliminary examination and to restrict the number of candidates advancing to the competitive examination.
  3. Precedential Support: The court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Andhra Pradesh Public Service Commission v. Baloji Badhavath and the established line of authority that permits holding preliminary examinations, particularly where the applicant pool is large relative to vacancies. The court noted that superior courts should not ordinarily interfere with the Commission's method unless it is arbitrary or violates fair play.
  4. Fact Application — Necessity of Shortlisting: The court applied the above principles to the factual context: 217 advertised vacancies and more than 21,000 applications. On this basis the Commission's decision to conduct a preliminary test to shortlist candidates was considered justified and reasonable.
  5. Assessment of Omitted Questions: The court specifically addressed the omission of 25 questions (19 from Law, 6 from General Studies) and expressed clear concern over the Commission's failure to ensure correctness of optional answers when setting the papers. The court acknowledged that some candidates who correctly answered the disputed questions would be disadvantaged by their omission from scoring.
  6. Remedial Measure to Mitigate Injustice: Rather than quashing the entire preliminary examination and directing a re-examination (which would delay an already delayed recruitment process), the court opted for a remedial direction: increase the effective qualifying range by 25 marks so that candidates who scored between 129 and 153 (inclusive) — i.e., those below the last qualified score of 154 but within 25 marks of it — would also be considered qualified to take the competitive examination. The same adjustment was to apply to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes candidates. This was done to mitigate injustice while avoiding re-running the whole preliminary test.
  7. Consideration of Objections: The court recorded objections by the Additional Advocate General that the direction might contravene statutory Rules and substantially increase the proportion of candidates permitted to take the competitive exam (to about 40%). The court weighed that concern against the potential injustice to candidates disadvantaged by omitted questions and chose the remedial measure as a proportionate step.
  8. Preservation of Higher Court Outcome: The court made clear that its directions were subject to the ultimate outcome of the proceedings pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions were disposed of by the court subject to specific directions. The core ruling can be summarized as:

DISPOSED OF — subject to directions described below and subject to the ultimate decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court.

Directives and Immediate Effects

  • The Commission is to extend its result or the qualifying marks by 25 marks to mitigate the effect of the 25 omitted questions.
  • Specifically, candidates who failed to secure 154 marks (the score of the last qualified candidate) but who secured 129 marks or more shall also be considered qualified to take the competitive written examination.
  • The Commission shall publish a supplementary merit list of those candidates who secured less than 154 but 129 or more in the preliminary test.
  • The same direction shall apply to candidates in the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes categories.
  • The Commission may thereby be required to allow a larger number of candidates to take the competitive written examination (with attendant administrative steps), but the court accepted that no irreparable prejudice would be caused to the Commission and the approach would avoid the delay that re-conducting the preliminary examination would cause.
  • All directions are subject to the final decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the pending proceedings.

Broader Implications

The court's order provides a case-specific remedial measure aimed at mitigating injustice resulting from omitted disputed questions in a preliminary examination. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new general rule or binding precedent beyond the facts of the case; it explicitly preserves the effect of any future or ultimate ruling by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Consequently, the immediate legal consequence is the supplementation of the merit list and enlargement of the pool of candidates qualified for the competitive examination for these 217 vacancies; the opinion does not assert that a broader precedent has been created.

Note: All information in this summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion text. No outside facts or inferences beyond that text have been added.

Show all summary ...

1. This group of writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution are filed by the learned Advocates to challenge the result of the preliminary test conducted by the Bihar Public Service Commission for recruitment to 217 vacancies in the Subordinate Judiciary of the State of Bihar

2. The main challenge in these writ petitions is four-fold. First; the Bihar Public Service Commission (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Commission’) has ho authority to conduct preliminary examination prior to the competitive examination contemplated under the Bihar Judicial Service (Recruitment) Rules, 1955. Second; the disputed preliminary examination was conducted on the basis of the Bihar Civil Service (Judicial Branch) (Recruitment) (Amendment) Rules, 2008 ignoring the subsequent amendment by Amendment Rules of 2009. Prior to the amendment by the Amendment Rules of 2009 the reservation was confined to the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe candidates; whereas under the Amendment Rules of 2009 the benefit of, reservation has been extended to Backward Class and the Extremely Backward Class candidates also. Thus, by not following the Amendment Rules of 2009, the candidates belonging to the Backward Class and the Extremely Backward Class have been deprived of the benefit of reservation. In other words they are compelled to compete with the other candidates in General Category. Third; the dispute js in respect of the omission of 25 questions from consideration. According to the petitioners some of those 25 questions did not have the correct option but the others had the correct option. The candidates who have attempted such questions and answered correctly stand to disadvantage on account of the omission of those questions from consideration. Fourth; the petitioners have challenged the decision of the Commission to allow only 10 per cent of the total examinees to take the competitive examination contrary to the Supreme Court direction to allow the candidates to take competitive examination in the proportion of 1:10 i.e for every single vacancy at least 10 candidates' should be allowed to take the competitive examination. Some of the Lawyers have referred to the question papers and the alternative answers. They have tried to demonstrate that most of the questions omitted from consideration had the correct answer.

3. The petitions are contested by the Commission. Learned Additional Advocate General Mr. Lalit Kishore has appeared for the Commission. He has submitted that the matter of recruitment to the Subordinate Judicial Service is seized by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. The matter is yet pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court. He has submitted that the Hon'ble Supreme Court has, in its order dated 3rd December, 2010, taken note of the advertisement dated 9th August, 2008 and the Rules then existing i.e as they stood prior to amendment by the Amendment Rules of 2009. In the circumstances, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed;

“…In light of the said order there was no occasion for the State or for the Public Service Commission to hold any doubt on the question of applicability of rules for filling up the existing 217 vacancies. We have been informed that preliminary examination for said recruitments had been held on 31st. December, 2009, but the results were not announced because of the aforesaid controversy. We direct that in so far as these 217 vacancies are concerned, the process of recruitment already initiated shall be expedited and completed, preferably within six months. This exercise shall be completed notwithstanding any interim orders by any Court.”

4. He has submitted that in view of the aforesaid direction issued by the Hon'ble Supreme Court the Commission was required to proceed in accordance with the Rules as they stood prior to the Amendment Rules of 2009. He has submitted that by Rule 2 of the Amendment Rules of 2008, the Commission is expressly empowered to hold preliminary examination and to allow only 10% of the total examinees to attend the competitive examination. Accordingly, the preliminary examination has been held; the result is declared and the Commission has allowed around 10 per cent of the examinees to attempt the competitive written examination. He has also relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Andhra Pradesh Public Service Commission v. Baloji Badhavath [(2009) 5 SCC 1]. In the said judgment the Hon'ble Supreme Court has considered the scope and ambit of the preliminary examination. The Court has, in paragraph 25 of the judgment, observed;

“How the Commission would judge the merit of the candidates is its function. Unless the procedure adopted by it is held to be arbitrary or against the known principles of fair play, the superior courts would not ordinarily interfere therewith….…”

“29. Indisputably, the preliminary examination is not a part of the main examination. The merit of candidate is not judged thereby. Only an eligibility criterion is fixed. The papers for holding the examination comprise of general studies and mental ability. Such a test must be held to be necessary for the purpose of judging the basic eligibility of the candidates to hold the tests. How and in what manner the State as also the Commission would comply with the constitutional requirements of Article 335 of the Constitution of India should ordinarily not be allowed to be questioned.”

5. In view of the above referred direction issued by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in its order dated 3rd December, 2010, we are of the opinion that for filling up 217 vacancies advertised, the Commission has rightly followed the Rules as they stood prior to the amendment by the Amendment Rules of 2009.

6. The question of validity of a preliminary examination is set at rest by several judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court over the years. It is well settled that in case of large number of applicants compared to the number of vacancies advertised, the Public Service Commission or any agency for that matter may hold a preliminary examination to shortlist the number of candidates who may be allowed to take the competitive examination/interview.

7. In the present case against the 217 vacancies advertised the applications received were more than 21,000. In view of comparatively large number of applicants, in our opinion, the Commission was fully justified in holding the preliminary test with a view to shortlisting the candidates eligible to take the competitive examination. In any case, for the present matter, the Commission is expressly empowered to hold a preliminary test.

8. In the present case, as provided under the Amendment Rules of 2008, 10 per cent of the candidates appearing in the examination have been declared successful to take the competitive written examination. We see no error in the decision of the Commission to restrict the number of successful candidates for taking the competitive examination to 10 per cent of the total examinees.

9. Next question is about omission of 25 questions from consideration. It is submitted that preliminary examination was divided into two papers; one of General Studies for 100 marks and second of Law paper for 150 marks. Out of 150 questions set out in the paper of Law, 19 questions had a doubtful answer and in the paper of General Studies, 6 questions had some controversy in respect of the correct answer. In the circumstances, the Commission has decided to omit the said 25 questions from consideration and to declare result on the basis of 225 questions alone.

10. The aforesaid omission is disturbing. It is beyond our comprehension that the constitutional institution, specialized in making recruitment, aided by the experts such as the Commission should set the question papers without ensuring that the optional answers contain the correct answer. This also speaks volumes about the sincerity with which the examination papers are set by the paper setters. It is quite possible that some of the examinees have correctly attempted some of those 25 questions. They would certainly stand to lose on account of omission of those 25 questions from consideration.

11. In the interest of justice, we consider it expedient that the Commission should extend its result or the qualifying marks by 25 marks. Meaning thereby that all those candidates who have failed to secure 154 marks (last one of the qualified candidate) but have secured 129 or more marks, should also be considered qualified to take the competitive examination. The Commission will publish a supplementary merit list of the candidates who have secured less than 154 marks but 129 marks or more in the preliminary test. Same direction will apply to the candidates in the categories of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.

12. Learned Additional Advocate General Mr. Lalit Kishore has strongly objected. He has submitted that the aforesaid direction is in contravention of the statutory Rules. He has submitted that if the aforesaid direction is permitted to stand, the Commission will have to allow around 40 per cent of the examinees to take the competitive written examination instead of 10 per cent of the examinees permitted by the Rules. He has submitted that in the past whenever such controversy arose the Hon'ble Supreme Court has approved the omission of disputed questions from consideration and declaration of result on the limited or truncated marks.

13. We are alive to both the situations. But, as discussed hereinabove the declaration of the result based on truncated question paper will lead to injustice to at least some of the examinees. We are also of the opinion that the constitutional institute like the Commission cannot be allowed to take the things so casually. Therefore, in spite of the statutory Rules; we have issued the above directions to mitigate the injustice that may be caused to some of the examinees. Lest we may have to direct the Commission to hold the preliminary examination afresh. That would delay the recruitment process already delayed. On the other hand, except that the Commission will have to arrange written examination for larger number of examinees, no prejudice is going to be caused to the Commission. Subject to the above directions all these petitions are disposed of.

14. We also clarify that these directions are subject to the ultimate decision that will be rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the proceeding pending before it.