Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bhaskar Ramchandra Joshi v. State Of M.P And Others

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jul 11, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, formerly a Sub-Engineer in the Public Works Department (PWD), sought payment of computation and gratuity amounts along with interest dating back to the year 2000. The dispute arose from relief work done on roads in 1989–90, for which no specific fund was initially allotted. The Executive Engineer granted payment from a different fund head (“A/R to roads”) in August 1990. The Auditor objected to this payment, marking the amount as a miscellaneous advance against the petitioner, although the petitioner was not involved in drawing or receiving the amount. The petitioner became aware of this only later and submitted multiple representations seeking adjustment and release of the amount. Despite recommendations by the Executive Engineer and Superintendent Engineer to adjust and release the funds, the respondents failed to act. The petitioner alleged suffering a loss of Rs. 3 lakhs and interest due to this delay and initiated legal proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution. The respondents opposed the claim, stating that the petitioner failed to complete necessary formalities such as preparing muster rolls, causing lapse of fund allotment and justifying withholding of gratuity and computation amounts. The petitioner retired in 2000, and the respondents contended that delay in approaching authorities disentitled the petitioner from relief.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents were justified in withholding the petitioner’s gratuity and computation amounts.
  2. Whether the gratuity and retiral dues can be forfeited or withheld without invoking the relevant statutory provisions.
  3. Whether relief can be denied to the petitioner on the ground of delay in filing the writ petition.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner was not involved in drawing or receiving the amount marked as miscellaneous advance and only became aware later.
  • Despite repeated representations, the respondents delayed adjustment and release of the amount.
  • Verbal assurances were given but not fulfilled.
  • The petitioner suffered financial loss including interest due to delay caused solely by the respondents.
  • The action of withholding gratuity and computation amounts by respondents is illegal and arbitrary.
  • The petitioner is entitled to interest on delayed payment and costs of litigation.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The petitioner failed to prepare and submit muster rolls timely, leading to lapse of fund allotment.
  • The amount was adjusted as a miscellaneous advance against the petitioner due to his failure.
  • Clearance of gratuity and computation amounts could not be made because of petitioner’s delay and procedural lapses.
  • The petitioner approached authorities belatedly and is therefore not entitled to relief.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Madhav Rao Scindia v. Union of India, (1971) 1 SCC 85 Privy Purse payable to ex-rulers is property under Article 300-A of the Constitution. Established that monetary entitlements are protected property rights under the Constitution.
K v. State of A.P, (1985) 1 SCC 523 Right to livelihood is property subject to retirement rules. Confirmed that rights related to employment and retirement benefits constitute property.
State of Kerala v. Padmanabhan, (1985) 1 SCC 429 Right of pension is property under Government service rules. Supported the constitutional protection of pension rights as property.
Madhav Rao Scindia v. State of M.P, AIR 1961 SC 298 Property under Article 300-A includes money, salary, pension, and other dues. Reinforced that various forms of monetary claims by employees are constitutionally protected property.
State of M.P v. Ranojirao, AIR 1968 SC 1053 Property includes pension and other sums payable under statute. Supported that pension and retiral dues are protected property rights.
Deokinandan v. State of Bihar, (1971) 2 SCC 330 Right to receive pension is property under Articles 19(1)(f) and 31(1) of the Constitution and cannot be withheld by executive order. Applied to hold that withholding gratuity and pension without legal authority violates fundamental rights.
Union of India v. Justice S.S Sandhawalia (Retd), (1994) 2 SCC 240 Interest on delayed payment of retiral dues is payable. Directed payment of interest @ 6% p.a. on delayed gratuity and computation amounts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the documentary evidence including letters recommending release of the amount and found no allegations of irregularity or negligence against the petitioner in those communications. The respondents did not initiate any disciplinary or criminal proceedings against the petitioner. The Court emphasized the constitutional protection under Article 300-A that a citizen cannot be deprived of property without lawful authority, defining 'property' broadly to include gratuity and retiral dues. The Court relied on established precedents affirming that pension, gratuity, and other retiral benefits are protected property rights and cannot be withheld arbitrarily or without invoking statutory provisions such as the M.P Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976. The Court found no material evidence that these rules were invoked to justify withholding payments. Further, the Court rejected the respondents’ contention that delay disentitles the petitioner to relief, noting that the petitioner was vigilant and actively pursued his rights through representations and legal notice. The Court concluded that the respondents’ failure to release the amounts was arbitrary and illegal, warranting payment with interest and costs.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

The Court allowed the petition, declaring the respondents’ withholding of gratuity and computation amounts illegal and arbitrary. The respondents were directed to release the amount within 90 days from the date of production of the order, with interest at 6% per annum from the date of entitlement until realization. Additionally, the respondents were ordered to pay litigation costs of Rs. 5,000 to the petitioner within the same period. The decision directly benefits the petitioner by mandating payment and interest but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond reaffirming existing constitutional and statutory protections for retiral benefits.

Show all summary ...

By invoking the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of Constitution, the petitioner has prayed for the direction to the respondents to pay amount of computation and gratuity with interest from the year 2000. It is also prayed that the respondents be directed to pay the costs of the litigation.

2. The petitioner was working as Sub-Engineer in Public Works Department (PWD). In 1989–90 some relief work was done on different roads. It is the case of the petitioner that no fund was allotted for payment of work, therefore, the Executive Engineer had granted the fund for payment of work from the head “A/R to roads” in August, 1990. The work was inspected and Collector Datia and Revenue Authority showed their satisfaction.

3. The Auditor has taken objection for the payment of Rs. 1,16,113/- done by other head, i.e “A/R to Roads”. Accordingly, the amount paid by the Executive Engineer is marked as miscellaneous advance to the petitioner. The amount was paid by the Executive Engineer through Revenue authority. Petitioner was nowhere in the picture in the matter of drawing or paying the said amount. The petitioner further contends that he came to know about the action taken by respondents regarding the said advance of Rs. 1,16,113/- and then submitted series of representations to the respondents. In turn, the respondent No. 5.Executive Engineer recommended the matter to the Superintendent Engineer on 14-7-2008, Annexure P/2. The Superintendent Engineer authorised the Executive Engineer for adjustment of the amount by letter dated 16-10-2008 Annexure P/3. The Executive Engineer wrote another letter dated 29-12-2008 to the Collector, District Datia for allotment of fund so that the advance amount marked in the name of petitioner can be adjusted. This letter is filed by the petitioner as Annexure P/4.

4. The petitioner contends that verbal assurances were given to him for refund of the amount after allotment from Collector, but the said assurance could not be translated in reality. The petitioner preferred another representation dated 27-10-2010. The petitioner has stated that because of aforesaid improper action on the part of the respondents, the petitioner has suffered a loss of Rs. 3.00 lakhs from the year 2000. The petitioner has also suffered loss of interest on the said amount. The petitioner ultimately sent legal notice on 18-10-2011 Annexure P/6 to the respondent but it could not fetch any result. Although by Annexure P/8 the Executive Engineer recommended that the miscellaneous advance against the petitioner's name be cancelled and allotment be made so that amount can be adjusted, but this letter also could not see the day of implementation. On the basis of aforesaid, it is stated that the action of respondents in not releasing the computation amount and gratuity is bad in law. Lastly, the petitioner contends that delay in payment is solely attributable to the respondents and because of delay the petitioner is entitled for the interest on delayed payment.

5. The said contention is opposed by the respondents by filing return. It is the stand of the respondents that petitioner stood retired from the post of Assistant Engineer on 31-7-2000. It is stated that there was a failure on the part of the petitioner as he did not prepare muster roll of the labourer engaged in the project and did not submit before the competent authority up to March, 1990. The petitioner did not complete the formalities within time and because of this delay the allotment of amount was lapsed and the payment was made by the department in favour of the labourer and this amount was adjusted as a miscellaneous advance in the account of petitioner and for this reason the clearance in respect of payment of gratuity and computation amount could not be made in favour of the petitioner. The petitioner belatedly approached the authority and therefore, he is not entitled for any relief.

6. In view of the aforesaid stand, the question is whether respondents are justified in withholding the said amount and whether said amount of gratuity and retiral dues can be forfeited in the manner respondents have done. Another question is whether relief can be denied on the alleged ground of delay in filing the writ petition.

7. A Perusal of letter Annexure P/2 dated 14-7-2008 shows that it was recommended that the work was measured by Sub Divisional Officer on 100% basis and therefore all the proceedings were complete. Thus, it was recommended that amount be released. The Superintendent Engineer by letter dated 16-10-2008 directed the Executive Engineer to do the needful because he is competent to do so. Thereafter, the Executive Engineer wrote a letter to Collector seeking allotment of fund for the purpose of payment. It is gathered that in none of these letters any allegation is made against the petitioner for any irregularity or negligence etc. On the contrary, recommendation was made to release the amount on the ground that the entire process was supervised by the Revenue authorities.

8. It is also not the case of the respondents that petitioner was subjected to any disciplinary proceedings or criminal case because of alleged inaction in making the payment. The most important question is whether the amount of gratuity and terminal dues can be withheld in this manner. It is apt to remember that under Article 300-A of the Constitution of India, protection has been granted to the citizen that he shall not be deprived of his property save by authority of law. The word ‘Property’ used in this Article has wide meaning.

9. Property in legal sense means an aggregate of rights which are guaranteed and protected by law. It extends to every species of valuable right and interest, more particularly, ownership and exclusive right to a thing, the right to dispose of the thing in every legal way, to process it, to use it and to exclude everyone else from interfering with it. The dominion or indefinite right of use or disposition which one may lawfully exercise over particular things or subjects is called “property”. The exclusive right of possessing, enjoying and disposing of thing is property in legal parameters. Therefore, the word “property” connotes everything which is subject of ownership, corporeal or incorporeal, tangible or intangible, visible or invisible, real or personal; everything that has an exchangeable value or which goes to make up wealth or estate or status. Property, therefore, within constitutional protection denotes group of rights inhering citizen's relation to physical thing, a right to possess, use and dispose of it in accordance with law. The property is the most comprehensive of all terms which can be used, in as much as it is indicative and descriptive of every possible interest which the party can have. The term “property” has a most extensive signification and according to legal definition, consists of free use, enjoyment and disposition by a person of all his acquisitions without any control of diminution, save only by the laws of the land.

10. The Apex Court on different occasions had considered the scope and ambit of property. In Madhav Rao Scindia v. Union of India, (1971) 1 SCC 85 : AIR 1971 SC 530 opined that Privy Purse payable to ex-rulers is property. In Nagraj, K v. State of A.P, (1985) 1 SCC 523 : AIR 1985 SC 551, Apex Court opined that right of person to his livelihood is property which is subject to rules of retirement. In State of Kerala v. Padmanabhan, (1985) 1 SCC 429 : AIR 1985 SC 356 the Apex Court opined that right of pension is property under the Government service Rules. In Madhav Rao Scindia v. State of M.P, AIR 1961 SC 298 and State of M.P v. Ranojirao, 1968 MPLJ (S.C) 785 : AIR 1968 SC 1053, the Apex Court opined that property in the context of Article 300-A includes ‘money’, salary which has accrued pension, and cash grants annually payable by the Government; pension due under Government Service Rules; a right to bonus and other sums due to employees under statute. This view was also taken in 1971 MPLJ (S.C) Note 56 : (1971) 2 SCC 330 : AIR 1971 SC 1409, Deokinandan v. State of Bihar. Bombay High Court in the case reported in 2012 (3) Mh. L.J 126, Shapoor M. Mehta… v. Allahabad Bank…. opined that retiral benefits including pension and gratuity constitute a valuable right in property. In Deokinandan (supra) Apex Court opined as under:

“(i) The right of the petitioner to receive pension is property under Article 31(1) and by a mere executive order the State had no powers to withhold the same. Similarly, the said claim is also property under Article 19(1)(f) and it is not saved by sub-article (5) of Article 19. Therefore, it follows that the order denying the petitioner right to receive pension affects the fundamental right of the petitioner under Article 19(1)(f) and 31(1) of the Constitution and as such the writ petition under Article 32 is maintainable.”

11. In the light of aforesaid legal position, it is crystal clear that right to get the aforesaid benefits is constitutional right. Gratuity or retiral dues can be withheld or reduced only as per provision made under M.P Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976. In the present case, there is no material on record to show that respondents have taken any action in invoking the said rules to stop or withhold gratuity or other dues. This is also settled in law that delay cannot be a ground for non-payment of retiral dues. Even otherwise, the record shows that respondents continuously recommended the case of the petitioner for release of the amount in question which gave bona fide impression to the petitioner that his grievances will be readdressed departmentally. When it could not be materialized, at the end, he sent legal notice and then filed this petition. The petitioner cannot be termed as sleeping litigant or a fence sitter. He was vigilant for his rights and, therefore, cannot be thrown on the ground of delay and laches. In fact there is no delay in filing the petition.

12. On the basis of aforesaid analysis, I have no doubt that respondents have erred in withholding the amount of the petitioner regarding gratuity and computation. The delay is solely attributable to the respondents and petitioner cannot be blamed for the same. Accordingly, petition is allowed. The action of the respondents in not paying the amount in question is declared as arbitrary and illegal. The respondents are directed to release the amount within 90 days from the date of production of this order. The amount shall carry interest @ 6% p.a on delayed payment from the date of entitlement till the date of realization as per judgment of Supreme Court reported in (1994) 2 SCC 240, Union of India v. Justice S.S Sandhawalia (Retd.). In addition, the petitioner shall get costs because respondents have unnecessarily compelled him to file this avoidable litigation. It is calculated as Rs. 5000/-, which shall be paid by the respondents to the petitioner within the same time.

13. Petition is allowed.

Petition allowed.