Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Pithampur Steels Ltd. v. Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd.

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Dec 13, 2012
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a borrower company, had availed a cash credit facility from the State Bank of India (SBI). Due to default in repayment, SBI instituted a civil suit for recovery of Rs. 1,58,34,341.84 before the District Judge, Indore. After the establishment of the Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 (RDDBFI Act) tribunal, the suit was transferred to the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT), Jabalpur and decreed in favor of SBI. The petitioner’s appeal before the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal (DRAT) was dismissed. SBI initiated execution proceedings, and subsequently, Kotak Mahindra Bank acquired the rights and interest in the financial assets of SBI and was impleaded in the execution proceedings.

Invoking Section 13(2) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SARFAESI Act), Kotak Mahindra Bank issued a notice to the petitioner demanding discharge of liability. Upon failure to pay, possession of secured assets was taken under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act. The petitioner challenged this possession by filing an application under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act before the DRT, which set aside the notice and directed re-delivery of possession.

The first respondent (Kotak Mahindra Bank) appealed to the DRAT, which allowed the appeal and remanded the matter to the DRT for deciding other questions except those already decided. The petitioner then filed this petition under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India challenging the DRAT order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Debts Recovery Tribunal was justified in holding that the bank could not proceed under the SARFAESI Act after initiating recovery under the RDDBFI Act.
  2. Whether the initiation of proceedings under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act was barred by limitation.
  3. Whether the absence of a declaration of Non-Performing Asset (NPA) in the notice under Section 13(2) vitiates the entire action of the first respondent.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The action taken by the first respondent under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act was illegal due to the absence of a valid notice.
  • The action was barred by limitation.
  • The notice under Section 13(2) did not contain a declaration of NPA, rendering the notice invalid and the consequent action vitiated.

First Respondent’s Arguments

  • The remedies under the RDDBFI Act and SARFAESI Act are supplementary and not mutually exclusive; the bank was entitled to proceed under SARFAESI Act despite initiating recovery under the RDDBFI Act.
  • The proceedings under Section 13(2) were not barred by limitation as the decree under the RDDBFI Act was a live claim with execution proceedings pending.
  • The notice under Section 13(2) complied with statutory requirements, including classification of the debt as NPA.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Modern Times Industries v. DRAT, Allahabad 2012 (1) DRTC 325 (All.) Clarification that remedies under RDDBFI Act and SARFAESI Act are supplementary and not mutually exclusive. The court relied on this precedent to uphold the DRAT’s view that the first respondent could proceed under the SARFAESI Act despite prior action under the RDDBFI Act.
ACE Media Advertisers v. Bank of Baroda (2009) (75) ALR 701 Support for the principle that remedies under RDDBFI Act and SARFAESI Act complement each other. Used to affirm that the SARFAESI Act is an additional remedy and not inconsistent with the RDDBFI Act.
Transcore v. Union of India AIR 2007 SC 712 = (2008) 1 SCC 125 Supreme Court ruling that remedies under RDDBFI Act and SARFAESI Act are complementary and the doctrine of election does not apply. The court applied this Supreme Court precedent to support the legality of proceeding under SARFAESI Act notwithstanding ongoing RDDBFI Act proceedings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the interplay between the RDDBFI Act and the SARFAESI Act, emphasizing that these Acts provide supplementary remedies rather than parallel or mutually exclusive ones. Citing relevant precedents, including a Supreme Court judgment, the court affirmed that the first respondent bank was entitled to proceed under the SARFAESI Act even after initiating recovery under the RDDBFI Act. The court noted that the definition of “Debt” under both Acts is consistent, reinforcing the complementary nature of the remedies.

Regarding limitation, the court reasoned that since the recovery decree was already under execution, the claim was “live” and not barred by limitation.

On the issue of the notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act, the court examined the notice issued by the first respondent and found clear and categorical statements indicating classification of the debt as a Non-Performing Asset and a demand for payment. The court held that the statutory requirements of Section 13(2) were duly complied with, rejecting the petitioner’s contention of invalidity due to lack of NPA declaration.

Consequently, the court found no merit in the petition and upheld the DRAT’s order.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed.

The court’s decision directly confirms the legality of proceeding under the SARFAESI Act despite concurrent proceedings under the RDDBFI Act and affirms the validity of the notice issued under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act. No new precedent was established; the ruling reinforces existing principles that the remedies under the two Acts are complementary and that execution proceedings under the RDDBFI Act constitute a live claim not barred by limitation. The petitioner’s challenge based on the absence of an NPA declaration in the notice was rejected, validating the procedural compliance of the first respondent.

Show all summary ...

ORDER

SHANTANU KEMKAR, J:

Heard on the question of admission.

Through this petition under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner borrower has challenged the order dated 23.08.2012 (Annexure P-3) passed by Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal (for short DRAT) Allahabad by which the first respondent's Appeal No. R-122/2011 challenging the order dated 07.09.2011 passed by Debts Recovery Tribunal, Jabalpur (for short DRT) in Securitisation Application No. 162/2011 has been allowed and the case has been remanded back to the DRT for deciding the questions other than the questions decided by the said order.

2. Briefly stated the petitioner company had availed the cash credit facility from the State Bank of India (for short the SBI). As the petitioner defaulted in making payment a Civil Suit No. 2-A/1998 for recovery of Rs. 1,58,34,341.84/- N.P was instituted against it by the SBI before the District Judge, Indore. On establishment of the Tribunal under the Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 (for short RDDBFI Act) the said Civil Suit was transferred to the Tribunal and was registered as T.A No. 905/98. The Tribunal vide order dated 15.11.2000 decreed the said TA in favour of the SBI. The appeal filed by the petitioner under Section 20 of the RDDBFI Act before the DRAT bearing No. R02/2001 was dismissed by the DRAT vide order dated 07.03.2011 The decree holder SBI filed execution proceedings for recovery of the decretal amount before the recovery officer. During the pendency of the execution on account of acquisition of rights and interest in the financial assets of the SBI by the first respondent Kotak Mahindra Bank, the first respondent was impleaded in the said execution in place of the SBI.

3. Thereafter, invoking the provision under Section 13(2) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (for short the SARFAESI Act) the first respondent Kotak Mahindra Bank issued a notice dated 31.12.2010 to the petitioner, requiring the petitioner to discharge the liability. Since the petitioner failed to discharge its liability within time specified in the said notice, possession of the secured assets of the petitioner was taken by the first respondent under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act.

4. Challenging the action of taking over of the possession by the first respondent, the petitioner approached the DRT by filing an application under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act. The petitioner raised the grounds that (a) the action taken by the first respondent under Section 13(2) is illegal as no valid notice was issued and (b) the said action taken under Section 13(2) was barred by limitation. The DRT vide order dated 07.09.2011 allowed the application and set aside the notice dated 31.12.2010 issued by the first respondent under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act and also directed the first respondent to re-deliver the possession of secured assets to the petitioner, which was taken by it under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act.

5. Aggrieved by the order dated 07.09.2011 passed by the DRT the petitioner filed an appeal under Section 18 of the SARFAESI Act before the DRAT. The DRAT vide order dated 28.03.2012 passed in Appeal No. R-122/2011 allowed the appeal filed by the first respondent and remanded the matter back to the DRT for deciding the other question except the question decided in appeal by DRAT. Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner has filed this petition.

6. We find that before the DRAT two questions were raised by the first respondent. Firstly, that the DRT was not justified in holding that since the Bank has proceeded to take action under the RDDBFI Act, it could not have proceeded to take action under the SARFAESI Act and secondly that the DRT had committed error in holding that the initiation of the proceedings by the first respondent under Section 13(2) was barred by limitation.

7. Heard learned counsel for the parties at length, perused impugned order and annexures.

8. Although learned counsel for the petitioner did not seriously urged the two grounds deciding which the matter was remanded to the DRT, however we are dealing with both the said grounds. We are also dealing with the ground strenuously urged by the learned counsel for the petitioner that in the absence of declaration of NPA in the notice under Section 13(2) the entire action of the first respondent is vitiated.

9. As regards the first ground raised before and decided by the DRAT we find that in the case of Modern Times Industries v. DRAT, Allahabad2012 (1) DRTC 325 (All.) and ACE Media Advertisers v. Bank of Baroda(2009) (75) ALR 701 the Allahabad High Court has held that the remedy under RDDBFI Act and SARFAESI Act are not the separate remedies but are the remedies which are supplementary to each other. While holding so the Allahabad High Court relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Transcore v. Union of IndiaAIR 2007 SC 712 = (2008) 1 SCC 125 in which it was observed that it is wrong to say that the RDDBFI Act and SARFAESI Act provide parallel remedies. The remedy under RDDBFI Act short as compared to the SARFAESI Act, which refers to acquisition and assignment of the receivables to the asset reconstruction company and which authorizes banks/financial institutions to take possession or to take over management which is not there in RDDBFI Act. It is for this reason, the SARFAESI Act is treated as an additional remedy in Section 37 of the SARFAESI Act, which is not inconsistent with the RDDBFI Act. It has been further observed by the Supreme Court that the remedies of enforcement of security interest under the SARFAESI Act and RDDBFI Act are complimentary to each other and there is no inherent or implied inconsistency between these two remedies under the two different Acts, and as such, the doctrine of election has no application in the matter for exhausting the remedy by invoking the provisions of Section 13(2) of SARFAESI Act. In the circumstances, we affirm the view taken by the DRAT that the first respondent Kotak Mahindra Bank was entitled to proceed under SARFAESI Act inspite of the fact that it had initiated recovery proceedings under the RDDBFI Act. It is also pertinent to mention here that the term ‘Debt’ as defined under Section 2(g) of the RDDBFI Act includes any liability whether payable under a decree or order of any civil Court or any arbitration award or otherwise or under a mortgage and subsisting on and legally recoverable on the date of application. The definition of ‘Debt’ under RDDBFI Act has been adopted under Section 2(ha) of the SARFAESI Act. In this view of the matter the view taken by the DRAT in this regard is upheld.

10. As regards the question of limitation decided by the DRAT, since the decree passed under the RDDBFI Act was already put to execution and recovery proceedings were pending, it was a “live claim” and therefore, the DRAT has rightly held that the proceedings could not have been treated to be barred by limitation.

11. In the circumstances, we find that the view taken by the DRAT for deciding both the questions raised before it, is perfectly legal and proper and needs no interference in this writ petition.

12. Learned counsel for the petitioner next contended that in the notice dated 31.12.2010 issued under Section 13(2) there exists no declaration of NPA, therefore, the notice was invalid and, as such, no further action could have been taken on the basis of the said invalid notice. So far as this argument is concerned, in our considered view, it is wholly misconceived. Section 13(2) requires the debt to be classified as NPA and also requires issuance of notice in writing to discharge the liability. On going through the notice dated 31.12.2010 which was issued by the first respondent under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act, we find that the first respondent Kotak Mahindra Bank had clearly stated as under:-

“The Company failed to maintain financial discipline and defaulted in the repayment of the loan amounts as and when the same fell due for payment. In view of the defaults committed by the Company, SBI in accordance with the Reserve Bank of India directives and guidelines classified in its books the account of the Company as Non Performing Asset [NPA]. SBI also filed a recovery suit before the Hon'ble Debts Recovery Tribunal - Jabalpur (DRT). The said suit was decreed in favour of SBI by the Hon'ble DRT and a Recovery Certificate was issued in favour of SBI.

During the pendency of the recovery proceedings, SBI had assigned the debts of the Company together with the underlying securities in favour of Kotak Bank. SBI has assigned all its rights, title and interest in all the agreements, deeds, documents and benefits under the decree and/or recovery certificate, issued by any Court/Authority and/or Tribunal in respect thereof; in relation to or in connection with the facilities to Kotak Bank. Kotak Bank is therefore entitled to initiate, adopt appropriate legal action and/or continue to pursue any existing 7 legal action in its own name against the Company, its Directors/Guarantors for recovery of the outstanding amounts due and payable by the Company and its Directors/Guarantors under the said facilities.

Despite repeated requests made to the Company to discharge its liability and despite issuance of Recovery Certificate by Hon'ble Debts Recovery Tribunal - Jabalpur, the Company has failed and neglected to repay the said dues/outstanding liabilities.

Taking into account the Company's conduct with respect to the non-payment of the legitimate dues, Kotak Bank has become entitled to and does issue this notice to you U/s 13(2) of SARFAESI Act.

Under the circumstances, Kotak Bank hereby calls upon the Company, Pithampur Steels Limited and demands to pay to Kotak Bank at Mumbai within a period of 60 (Sixty) days from the date of this notice; an amount of Rs. 14,02,94,627/- (Rupees Fourteen Crores Two Lakhs Ninety Four Thousand Six Hundred And Twenty Seven Only) outstanding as on December 31, 2010 being the aggregate of the amounts inclusive of interest due and payable by and demanded of the Company in respect of all the financial assistance availed by the Company. Annexed and marked as Annexure “C” is the detail of the outstanding amounts payable as on December 31, 2010.” (Emphasis supplied)

13. In view of the aforesaid categorical averments in the notice dated 31.12.2000 issued by the first respondent, making it clear that the debt has been classified as NPA and requiring the petitioner to discharge the liability, in our considered opinion, the first respondent had duly complied with the requirement of the notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act. As a result the petitioner's contention that there is no compliance of statutory requirement about NPA in the notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act cannot be accepted.

14. Accordingly, we find no merit in this petition. The petition fails and is hereby dismissed.

15. No orders as to the costs.