- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Rahisha Begum v. State Of M.P.
Judgment Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
This is an appeal under section 2(1) of the Madhya Pradesh Uchcha Nyayalaya (Khand Nyaypeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 against the order dated 4-10-2007 of the learned Writ Court which dismissed W.P. (S) No. 1290/04. The writ petition was filed under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking declaration that the order dated 6-8-2003 (Annex. P/1) was illegal and directing the respondents to grant family pension to the petitioner by counting the part of service rendered by her husband as a daily wager.
Facts admitted in the pleadings and record: the petitioner is the wife of Late Ashraf Khan, who died on 5-3-2002. The husband was employed as a driver from May 1980 as a full-time daily wager and was paid monthly from the contingency fund. His services were regularized by an order dated 31-12-1998 (Annex. P/2). The respondents denied family pension on the ground that the deceased employee did not complete the requisite period of qualifying service for pensionary benefits.
The learned Writ Court dismissed the petition relying on earlier decisions (including Shrikrishna Shrivastava and State of Rajasthan v. Kunji Raman) and on provisions of the M.P. Irrigation Department Work Charged and Contingency Paid Employees Recruitment and Conditions Service Rules, 1977 and the M.P. Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976 (referred to as the Pension Rules of 1976), holding that services prior to regularisation (31-12-1998) could not be counted for pension/gratuity and that the deceased had not completed the qualifying period under Rule 43 of the Pension Rules of 1976.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner (wife of Late Ashraf Khan) is entitled to family pension and gratuity by counting the deceased husband's period of service as a contingency-paid / daily wager employee (from May 1980) for the purpose of qualifying service.
- Which pension rules (M.P. Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976 vs. Madhya Pradesh (Work Charged and Contingency Paid Employees) Pension Rules, 1979) apply to the deceased's service and whether the 1976 Rules exclude work-charged / contingency-paid employees.
- Whether the admitted facts (employment from May 1980, payment from contingency fund, regularisation on 31-12-1998, death on 5-3-2002) result in the deceased having acquired the status of a "permanent employee" under the Pension Rules of 1979 and thereby qualifying for pensionary benefits.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The deceased was employed from May 1980 as a full-time daily wager and was paid monthly from the contingency fund; his services were regularised on 31-12-1998 (Annex. P/2).
- On the basis of Rule 2(c) and Rule 6 of the Pension Rules of 1979, a contingency-paid employee of this description would be deemed a "permanent employee" and qualifying service should be computed from the initial appointment date (May 1980).
- Reliance placed on the Supreme Court decision in Ram Kumar Agrawal v. State of M.P (1995 Supp (3) SCC 67) and on the Single Bench decision in Surendra Kumar Chaturvedi v. State of M.P (2005 (3) MPLJ 385) to support counting pre-regularisation service for pension entitlement.
Respondents' Arguments
- The deceased did not complete the requisite qualifying service after regularisation on 31-12-1998 and died on 5-3-2002; therefore the petitioner is not entitled to family pension or gratuity.
- The Pension Rules of 1976 apply; Rule 12 of the Pension Rules of 1976 pertains to qualifying service and, applying those provisions, the husband did not meet qualifying service requirements.
- The impugned order dismissing the writ petition was correctly founded on applicable precedents and the relevant pension rules.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shrikrishna Shrivastava v. State of M.P, 2003 (4) MPLJ 376 | Referenced by the learned Writ Court in support of dismissal (as recorded in the impugned order). | The Writ Court relied on this Division Bench decision in dismissing the writ petition; the appellate bench recorded that the Writ Court had relied upon it when passing the impugned order. |
| State of Rajasthan v. Kunji Raman, (1997) 2 SCC 517 : AIR 1997 SC 693 | Referenced by the learned Writ Court in its reasoning (as recorded in the impugned order). | The Writ Court relied on this Supreme Court decision in dismissing the writ petition; the appellate bench noted that the Writ Court had cited it. |
| Ram Kumar Agrawal v. State of M.P, 1995 Supp (3) SCC 67 | Interpreting the definition of "permanent employee" under the Pension Rules of 1979 and entitlement to pension on satisfying qualifying service. | The appellate court adopted an analogy from this decision (which held entitlement to pension where qualifying service was satisfied) to conclude that the deceased qualified for pensionary benefits and, accordingly, the petitioner was entitled to family pension and gratuity. |
| Surendra Kumar Chaturvedi v. State of M.P, 2005 (3) MPLJ 385 | Relied upon by appellant's counsel as supportive authority (single bench decision of this Court). | The appellate bench noted that the appellant relied on this decision; the court treated it as part of appellant's supporting authorities in the context of counting services for pension entitlement. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded through the following analytical steps, applying statutory definitions and admitted facts:
- Procedural posture: The appeal arose from dismissal of the writ petition; both parties' counsel were heard.
- Primary legal question identified: whether the Pension Rules of 1976 apply to the deceased or whether the Pension Rules of 1979 govern his service, and whether his service qualifies him as a "permanent employee" for pensionary benefits.
- Interpretation of the Pension Rules of 1976: The court examined Rule 2 of the Pension Rules of 1976 (particularly Rule (ii)(a)) and concluded that the 1976 Rules are not applicable to a person employed in a work-charged establishment; thus the respondents' submission that the 1976 Rules applied was rejected on the basis of the rules' own exclusion clauses as interpreted by the court.
- Examination of the Pension Rules of 1979: The court closely analyzed Rule 2 of the Pension Rules of 1979, which defines "Contingency paid employee", "Work-charged employee" and "Permanent employee" (including the proviso adjusting the length of service for those attaining superannuation on or after 1-4-1981).
- Assessment of admitted facts: The pleadings (para 5(4)) and the respondents' return admitted that the deceased was employed full-time from May 1980 as a daily-rated employee, paid monthly from the contingency fund, and that his services were regularised on 31-12-1998. The court treated these admissions as establishing the factual foundation for pension entitlement analysis.
- Application of the definition of "permanent employee": On the admitted facts and the 1979 Rules' definitions, the court concluded that the deceased had qualified as a "permanent employee" under clause 2(c) of the Pension Rules of 1979 prior to his death on 5-3-2002.
- Use of judicial precedent by analogy: The court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Ram Kumar Agrawal (1995 Supp (3) SCC 67), which addressed entitlement to pension where qualifying service was satisfied. The bench adopted an analogous approach to hold that, given the reduction in qualifying service (from ten to six years) effected by a government circular (referred to in the judgment), the deceased had met the qualifying period for pension.
- Conclusion from analysis: Because the deceased qualified for pension under the 1979 Rules and the admitted facts, the petitioner (as wife) is entitled to family pension and gratuity. The appellate court therefore allowed the appeal, set aside the impugned order dated 4-10-2007, and directed payment of the benefits.
- Costs and incidental directions: The court additionally awarded exemplary costs of Rs. 10,000 and counsel fee of Rs. 2,000 to the petitioner, directing that family pension, gratuity and the quantified costs be paid within two months.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appellate court allowed the appeal and set aside the impugned order dated 4-10-2007. The core ruling is summarized as:
APPEAL ALLOWED.
Consequences and direct effects:
- The respondents are directed to pay the petitioner (wife of Late Ashraf Khan) the family pension and the gratuity of her husband.
- The respondents are directed to pay exemplary costs of Rs. 10,000 (Rupees Ten Thousand) and counsel fee of Rs. 2,000 (Rupees Two Thousand) to the petitioner, together with the family pension and gratuity, within two months.
The opinion does not purport to set out broader or novel precedent beyond the application of the Pension Rules of 1979 to the admitted facts of this case and the analogical use of Ram Kumar Agrawal. The decision's practical effect is to grant the relief sought by the petitioner in the present proceedings.
List of cases referred: 1. Shrikrishna Shrivastava v. State of M.P, 2003 (4) MPLJ 376 (Para 5) 2. State Of Rajasthan v. Kunji Raman., (1997) 2 SCC 517 : AIR 1997 SC 693 (Para 5) 3. Rani Kumar Agrawal v. State of M.P, 1995 Supp (3) SCC 67 (Paras 7, 12) 4. Surendra Kumar Chaturvedi v. State of M.P, 2005 (3) MPLJ 385 (Para 7)
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
A.K Shrivastava, J.:— This appeal has been filed under section 2(1) of Madhya Pradesh Uchcha Nyayalaya (Khand Nyaypeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 against the order dated 4-10-2007 passed by learned Writ Court in W.P (S) No. 1290/04 dismissing the writ petition filed by the appellant/writ petitioner.
2. The writ petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India before the learned Writ Court seeking following reliefs which reads thus:
“(a) That, order dated 6-8-2003 Annex. P/1 may kindly be declare illegal and respondents may kindly be directed to grant family pension to the petitioner by counting the part of service which petitioner's husband rendered as daily wager in employment.
(b) That, any other relief which this Hon'ble High Court may deem fit with cost of the petition.”
3. As per the case of writ petitioner/appellant, the petitioner is the wife of Late Ashraf Khan, who was serving on the post of Driver in the office of the respondents and had died on 5-3-2002 and after the death of her husband, the petitioner submitted an application for seeking the benefit of family pension and other service benefits. However, the respondents vide letter dated 6-8-2003 informed the reasons and denied the benefit of pension and other service benefits to her on the ground that the deceased employee did not complete the requisite period of qualifying service for allowing the family pensionary benefits to the writ petitioner. A copy of the order of the Executive Engineer in that regard dated 6-8-2003 has been placed as Annexure P/1 before the learned Writ Court.
4. The respondents filed their return and took a stand that because the husband of the writ petitioner did not qualify the requisite service for obtaining the pension, therefore, she is not entitled for any family pension or other service benefits.
5. The learned Writ Court by the impugned order dated 4-10-2007 has dismissed the writ petition holding that in the light of the decision of the Division Bench Shrikrishna Shrivastava v. State of M.P, 2003 (4) MPLJ 376 and in view of the decision of the Supreme Court State Of Rajasthan v. Kunji Raman., (1997) 2 SCC 517 : AIR 1997 SC 693 and per the provisions of M.P Irrigation Department Work Charged and Contingency Paid Employees Recruitment and Conditions Service Rules, 1977 as well as M.P Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976 (in short “the Pension Rules of 1976”) since the husband of the writ petitioner was engaged as daily wager was not entitled to count his services prior to regularization order viz. 31-12-1998 for the purpose of pension and gratuity and further held that the husband of the petitioner since did not complete five years and ten years of qualifying service as per Rule 43 of the Pension Rules of 1976, hence, the writ petitioner is not entitled for the family pension and gratuity after the death of her husband.
6. We have heard Shri S.K Sharma, learned counsel for appellant and Shri M.P.S Raghuvanshi, learned Additional Advocate General for respondents/State.
7. S.K Sharma, learned counsel for appellant by inviting our attention to para 5(4) of the writ petition has contended that the husband of the petitioner died on 5-3-2002 and further it has been contended by him that the services of the husband of the petitioner were regularized on 31-12-1998 and in this regard he has invited our attention to Annexure P/2. In para 5(4) of the writ petition it is pleaded that the husband of the petitioner Ashraf Khan was an employee in the respondents-department from May, 1980 as a driver for full time in the office as daily wager and has been paid monthly amount in lieu of salary from the contingency fund and his services were regularized vide order dated 31-12-1998. Hence, the appellant/writ petitioner is entitled for family pension. The husband of the appellant/writ petitioner would be deemed to be a ‘permanent employee’ as envisaged under Rule 2(c) of Madhya Pradesh (Work Charged and Contingency Paid Employees) Pension Rules, 1979 (for brevity “the Pension Rules of 1979”) and if that would be the position since appellant's husband was appointed in May, 1980 as a driver for full time in the office as daily wager and was paid monthly amount in lieu of the salary from contingency fund, therefore, the qualifying services would be computed from the date of his initial appointment viz. May, 1980 vis-à-vis to Rule 2(c) and Rule 6 of the Pension Rules of 1979. In support of his contention learned counsel has put emphasis on the decision of the Supreme Court Ram Kumar Agrawal v. State of M.P, 1995 Supp (3) SCC 67. Learned counsel has also placed heavy reliance on the Single Bench decision of this Court Surendra Kumar Chaturvedi v. State of M.P, 2005 (3) MPLJ 385.
8. On the other hand Shri M.P.S Raghuvanshi, learned Additional Advocate General argued in support of the impugned order and submitted that since the husband of the writ petitioner did not qualify the qualifying service after his regularisation from 31-12-1998 and he breathed his last on 5-3-2002, therefore, the petitioner who is wife of the deceased employee is not entitled for family pension. Learned Additional Advocate General further submitted that Rule 12 of the Pension Rules of 1976 pertains to qualifying service and the same is applicable on the petitioner and if the case of the writ petitioner is judged from any angle, since the husband of the writ petitioner did not qualify the qualifying service, she is not entitled for family pension and other pensionary benefits, and therefore, rightly the writ petition has been dismissed.
9. Having heard learned counsel for the parties, we are of the considered view that this appeal deserves to be allowed.
10. We do not find any merit in the contention of the learned Additional Advocate General that the Pension Rules of 1976 are applicable in the case of the employees whose services are governed by the Pension Rules of 1979. On bare perusal of Rule 2 of the Pension Rules 1976 which speaks about the application of the said Rules and particularly Rule (ii)(a) we find that the Pension Rules of 1976 are not applicable to a person employed in a work charged establishment. Looking to the definition clause of the Pension Rules of 1979 we find that what is the meaning of “Contingency paid employee”, “Work-charged employee” and “Permanent employee” has been defined in Rule 2 of the Pension Rules of 1979 and we would like to apt to quote the same, which reads thus:—
“(a) “Contingency paid employee” means a person employed for full time in an office or establishment and who is paid on monthly basis and whose pay is charged to office contingencies excluding the employees who are employed for certain period only in a year.
(b) “Work-charged employee” means a person employed upon the actual execution, as distinct from general supervision of a specified work or upon subordinate supervision of the departmental labour, store, running and repairs of electrical equipment and machinery in connection with such work, excluding the daily paid labour and muster-roll employee employed on the work.
(c) “Permanent employee” means a contingency paid employee or a work-charged employee who has completed fifteen years of service or more on or after the 1st January, 1974;
Provided that in respect of a contingency paid employee or a workcharged employee who has attained the age of superannuation on or after the First April, 1981, permanent employee means an employee who has completed 10 years of service on or after the 1st January, 1974.”
If we analyze the definition of “Contingency paid employee” in a broader spectrum, according to us, it will include a person employed for full time in an office or establishment and who is paid on monthly basis and whose pay is charge to office contingencies excluding the employees who are employed for certain period only in a year.
11. At this juncture, we would like to go through the pleadings of the writ petitioner as envisaged in para 5(4) of the writ petition which reads thus:
“5(4) That, it is true that husband of the petitioner late Shri Ashraf Khan on the need of Driver in the office of respondents has been employed on May, 1980 for full time in the office as daily wagers and has been paid monthly amount in lieu of Salary from the contingent fund and late Shri Ashraf Khan continue worked in the office of respondents and lastly respondents constituted a departmental committee and regularised the services of petitioner's husband vide order dated 31-12-1998. A copy of order dated 31-12-1998 is enclosed Annex. P/2 in this order petitioner's husband name is find place at Sr. No. 021.”
In very specific term the pleading of the writ petitioner is that her husband Late Ashraf Khan on account of the need of the driver in the office of the respondents, was employed in May, 1980 for full time in the office as daily wager and was paid monthly amount in lieu of salary from the contingency fund and his services were regularised on 31-12-1998. All the facts pleaded in para 5(4) of the writ petition have been admitted by the respondents in the return filed by them. Hence, it is no more in dispute, rather it is an admitted position, that the husband of the writ petitioner namely Ashraf Khan was a driver in the office of respondents and was employed in May, 1980 as daily rated employee for full time in the office and was paid monthly amount in lieu of the salary from the contingency fund and if that would be the position, according to us, since the petitioner's husband qualified the qualifying service as “permanent employee” as per the definition clause 2(c) of the Pension Rules of 1979 before he died on 5-3-2002. Hence, the writ petitioner is entitled for the family pension and gratuity.
12. The Supreme Court in Ram Kumar Agrawal (supra), though it was a case of voluntary retirement wherein the pension was sought, by considering the definition of “permanent employee” of the Pension Rules of 1979 in para 2 has held that the employee Ram Kumar Agarwal is entitled for pension since he qualified the qualifying services of 20 years as he served out for 21 years at the time when he was voluntarily retired. Adopting the analogy of the Supreme Court since the qualifying services which was 10 years earlier, but which has been reduced to six years by the circular of the Government, according to us, the husband of the writ petitioner qualified the qualifying services for obtaining the pension before his death, and hence, the writ petitioner being his wife is entitled for the family pension. At this juncture we would like to quote the circular of the Government by which the qualifying services has been reduced from ten years to six years which reads thus:
13. In this view of the matter, according to us, the writ petitioner is entitled for the relief of family pension as well as gratuity as prayed by her in the writ petition. Hence, by setting aside the impugned order 4-10-2007 passed by the learned Writ Court, we hereby allow the appeal of the appellant/writ petitioner and direct the respondents to pay her family pension as well as the gratuity of her husband Late Shri Ashraf Khan.
14. Since the husband of the appellant/writ petitioner was a low paid employee and on account of windfall on the head of the writ petitioner she became widow on account of death of her husband and a widow of a very low paid employee has been denied by the reliefs, which she is otherwise entitled for, therefore, we are of the view that she is entitled for exemplary costs which we quantify Rs. 10,000/- (Rupees Ten Thousand). This appeal is accordingly allowed with costs. Counsel fee Rs. 2,000/- (Rupees Two Thousand). Let the exemplary cost of Rs. 10,000/- and costs of writ petition as well as this appeal shall be paid to the writ petitioner along with payment of family pension and gratuity within two months.
Appeal allowed.
Alert