- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mohideen Imbrahim v. Mahomed Mura Levai Through His Agent Mahomed Mira Sahib
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff (referred to in parts of the opinion as the respondent) purchased immovable property at a court auction in execution of a decree obtained by the defendant (the decree-holder) in S.C. 219 of 1894. A third party subsequently brought a suit (O.S. No. 341 of 1905) asserting title to that land; that suit included the auction purchaser (plaintiff) and the decree-holder (defendant) as parties, and the third party's title was upheld. Following that decision the auction purchaser applied in the execution proceedings for repayment of the purchase-money but was advised that his remedy was by a separate suit. The purchaser then instituted S.C. 156 of 1910 against the judgment-creditor; the Subordinate Judge granted a decree for recovery of the purchase money. The petitioner (challenging that decree) raised two principal grounds: (1) that the suit was not maintainable and (2) that it was barred by limitation under Article 62 of Schedule I of the Limitation Act. The present opinion reviews those contentions and affirms the Subordinate Judge's decision, ultimately dismissing the petition with costs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the suit by the auction purchaser to recover the purchase money is maintainable (particularly in view of changes to the Civil Procedure Code from the Code of 1882 to the later Code).
- Whether the suit is barred by limitation, specifically Article 62 of Schedule I of the Limitation Act (i.e., whether limitation began to run from the date the money was received by the decree-holder or from the date the auction purchaser's right to sue accrued).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The present suit is not maintainable under the new Civil Procedure Code because the provisions that previously (under the Code of 1882 and earlier) gave the auction purchaser a substantive right to recover purchase money have been altered or omitted.
- The suit is barred by limitation: it is said to be a suit in the nature of "money had and received" and thus limitation would run from the date the money was received by the defendant (August 1905) under Article 62 of both the old and new Limitation Acts; relying on cases such as Kovvuri Basiva Reddi (Tallapragada Nagamma) and Ram Kumar Saha v. Ram Gour Saha.
Respondent's / Court-noted Arguments (as reflected in the opinion)
- Under Section 315 of the Civil Procedure Code of 1882 a court-auction purchaser acquired a right to sue the decree-holder to recover purchase money when it was found in a later suit that the judgment-debtor had no title to the property sold; in the present case that right accrued when the decree in O.S. No. 341 of 1905 was confirmed on appeal (21 January 1907).
- The events giving rise to the purchaser's right occurred while the old Code (Act XIV of 1882) was in force and the repeal by the new Code did not destroy rights already accrued (reliance on Section 6 of the General Clauses Act X of 1897 as noted in the opinion).
- The claim is a statutory right created under Section 315 as interpreted by earlier decisions; it is not a simple common-law claim for money had and received whereby limitation would necessarily begin to run from the date the money was paid.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Gurnshidawa v. Gangaya (1897) I.L.R. 22 B. 783 | Authority following earlier cases that under Section 315 (old Code) a court-auction purchaser could sue to recover purchase money where the judgment-debtor had no title. | Used to support the proposition that the plaintiff's right to sue accrued under the old Code and that such suits were maintainable. |
| Munnah Singh v. Gajadhar Singh (1883) I.L.R. 5 a. 577 | Earlier authority followed in the line of Section 315 decisions regarding auction purchasers' rights. | Followed as part of the consistent line of authority validating suits by auction purchasers under the old Code. |
| Pachappan / Pachayappan v. Narayana (1887) I.L.R. 11 M. 269 | Held that a suit to recover purchase-money was a proper procedure under provisions corresponding to Section 315; recognized the substantive right under the old Code. | Relied on to show that a substantive right to recover existed under the old Code and that this could be enforced by suit. |
| Nilakanta v. Imam Sahib (cited variously: 1882/1892) I.L.R. 16 M. 361 (appears multiple times) | Authority for (a) the proposition that Article 120 (limitation) applies to suits under Section 315 of the old Code and (b) that a substantive right to sue accrues "when the right to sue accrues". | Key authority relied upon by the court to hold that Article 62 did not apply and that Article 120 (or the corresponding article in the Limitation Act) was the appropriate measure for such statutory rights; held analogous to the present case. |
| Ram Kunwar / Ram Kumar Shaha v. Ram Gour Saha (1909) I.L.R. 37 C. 67 | Case relied upon by the petitioner regarding limitation (tendency to apply Article 62 in some contexts). | Cited by the petitioner for the limitation argument; the court distinguished or disagreed with the view taken there for the present category of statutory claims arising under Section 315. |
| Kovvuri Hasana / Kovvuri Basiva Beddi v. Tallapragad / Tallapragada Nagamma (1911) I.L.R. 35 M. 39 | Case relied upon by petitioner as authority applying limitation (Article 62) in related kinds of recovery claims; mentioned as a case of private sale in the opinion. | Cited by petitioner; the court examined and distinguished it on the basis that the cause of action under Section 315 arises when it is found the judgment-debtor had no saleable interest, not when money was paid. |
| Hanuman Kamat v. Hanuman Mandur (1891) I.L.R. 19 C. 123 | Privy Council authority on limitation: that Article 62 or Article 97 would apply depending on whether consideration failed originally or subsequently; starting point is when cause of action occurred. | Invoked to support the principle that limitation must be measured from the time the cause of action arose (i.e., when the purchaser's substantive right to sue arose) rather than the date of payment. |
| Dorat Ali Khan v. The Executors Khajhee Moheeooddeen (1878) I.L.R. 3 C. 806 | Explains that sales by sheriff in India are governed by law relating to chattels; buyer at sheriff's sale acquires only the judgment-debtor's interest and there is no implied warranty of title. | Used to trace the historical background and distinguish between consequences of private sales and sales in execution; helped explain earlier rule that a purchaser could not recover money in certain sheriff-sale contexts. |
| Chapman v. Speller (1850) 14 Q.B. 621 | English authority that purchaser at a sheriff's sale could not recover purchase-money because the sale transfers only whatever interest the judgment-debtor had; no failure of consideration. | Relied on as part of the historical survey explaining why older authorities sometimes denied recovery to auction purchasers (particularly in cases involving sale of movables). |
| Soudamani Chowdranee v. Kishen Kishore Peddar (1869) 12 W.R.F.B. Rulings p. 8 | Attempt to recover purchase-money under Regulation VII of 1825; Full Bench negated the purchaser's claimed right in certain circumstances and interpreted provisions of earlier Codes. | Referred to in the historical discussion to show the development of law leading up to the Act X of 1877 and Act XIV of 1882 and how statutory language evolved. |
| Bam Kumar Saha v. Ram Gour Shahad (1909) I.L.R. 37 C. 67 | Decision reaffirming that a suit to recover purchase-money was a proper procedure under provisions corresponding to Section 315. | Reinforced the proposition that, under the old Code, suit was an appropriate remedy for the auction purchaser. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in two main analytical stages corresponding to the two principal contentions raised.
(1) Maintainability
- The court accepted the factual chronology: the auction purchase, the third-party suit (O.S. No. 341 of 1905) and its final confirmation on appeal (21 January 1907) all occurred while the Civil Procedure Code of 1882 (Act XIV of 1882) was in force.
- Under Section 315 of the old Code a purchaser at a court auction acquired a substantive right to recover the purchase money where it was found that the judgment-debtor had no saleable interest. The court cited a line of authorities supporting that proposition (including Nilakanta, Pachappan, and others).
- Although the new Civil Procedure Code (Act V of 1908) altered the execution provisions (notably Order XXI Rules 66, 90–93) and removed language that had been construed as creating a substantive right to recover purchase money, those statutory changes did not operate retrospectively to extinguish rights that had already accrued under the old Code.
- The court relied on Section 6 of the General Clauses Act X of 1897 (as invoked in the opinion) to conclude that the right accrued under the old Code was preserved despite the repeal and replacement of that Code by the new Code coming into force on 1 January 1909.
- Therefore the court held the present suit to be maintainable because the plaintiff's right had accrued while the old Code was in effect and was not taken away by the new Code.
(2) Limitation
- The petitioner argued that limitation under Article 62 should apply, treating the action as one for money had and received such that limitation would run from the date the money was received by the decree-holder (August 1905).
- The court rejected that approach for two principal reasons expressed in the opinion:
- On principle, an article of limitation cannot be applied to bar a right before that right has come into existence. The substantive right to sue under Section 315 comes into existence when it is found that the judgment-debtor had no saleable interest (i.e., when the third-party suit establishes that fact), not at the time the purchase money was paid.
- The claim is a statutory right created under Section 315 (as interpreted by earlier authorities), not a pure common-law action for money had and received; therefore the proper starting point for limitation is when the right of action accrues.
- The court found (following Nilakanta and related authorities) that Article 120 (or the article appropriate to suits where the right accrues at a later date) rather than Article 62 was the apt measure; consequently the plaintiff's suit instituted in January 1910 was within time.
- The court also addressed and distinguished decisions cited by the petitioner (e.g., Kovvuri and Ram Kumar Saha), observing that those cases either involved private sale contexts or did not consider the special nature of a Section 315 claim arising from court auction sales.
Additional statutory/interpretive analysis noted by the court:
- The court surveyed the historical development of execution law (from Act VIII of 1859 through Act X of 1877 and Act XIV of 1882 to the new Code) to explain why earlier decisions recognized a substantive right under the old Code while the new Code's Order XXI provides a different remedial scheme (requiring applications before confirmation of sale and substituting "order for repayment" language rather than an express substantive entitlement).
- Although the court acknowledged that the new Code's procedure could work hardship on auction purchasers who are unaware of defects in title before confirmation, it emphasized that these are legislative choices and that the Legislature had thus altered the substantive law for future cases; but rights already accrued under the old Code survived repeal and replacement.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court dismissed the petition and ordered costs. The court held that (a) the suit by the auction purchaser was maintainable because his substantive right to sue had accrued under Section 315 of the Civil Procedure Code of 1882 prior to the coming into force of the new Code, and (b) the suit was not barred by limitation, Article 62 being inapplicable because the cause of action arose when it was found that the judgment-debtor had no saleable interest (i.e., when the third-party decree was confirmed), not when the purchase-money was paid.
Implications: The direct effect is that the Subordinate Judge's decree in favor of the auction purchaser is upheld and the petition challenging that decree is dismissed with costs. The court noted the legislative alteration in the new Civil Procedure Code (Order XXI rules) which curtailed the previously recognized substantive right for future cases, but it preserved accrued rights under the old Code; the opinion does not purport to create a broader new precedent beyond affirming the application of established authorities to the facts before the court.
1. The facts of the case are sufficiently set forth in the judgment of the Subordinate Judge : and his decision appears to me to be correct. Two points are argued on behalf of the petitioner, (1) that the present suit is not maintainable and (2) that it is barred by Article 62 of Schedule I of the Limitation Act.
2. As regards the first point, the Court auction under which plaintiff (Respondent) purchased the property, the filing of O.S. No. 341 of 05 to declare the title of a third person other than the Judgment-debtor and the final decision of that suit, all took place, while thfe old Civil Procedure Code (Act XIV of 1882) was in force. It has been repaatedly held that under section 315 of that act a suit by a Court auction purchaser to recover the sale price from the decree-holder would lie where it was found on a suit brought by a third party that the judgment-debtor has no title whatever to the property sold in Court auction (vide Gurnshidawa v. Gangaya (1897) I.L.R. 22 B. 783 following Munnah Singh v. Gajadhar Singh (1883) I.L.R. 5. a. 577 Pachappan v. Narayana (1887) I.L.R. 11 M. 269 and Nilakanta v. Imam Sahib (1892) I.L.R. 16 M. 361) Plaintiff's right of suit accrued on 21st January 1907, when the decree in O.S. No. 341 of 05 was confirmed on appeal it does not appear that he ever obtained possession of the property purchased. Whether a similar right of suit exists under the present code is a point on which it is unnecessary to express an opinion, though I should be loth to hold that it did not. But I certainly do not find anything in the present code which would have the effect of taking away the right of suit which had accrued to the plaintiff before it came into force. I therefore hold the present suit to be maintainable.
3. As regards the question of limitation Nilakanta v. Imam Sahib (1892) I.L.R. 16 M. 361 is authority for holding that Article 120 applies to suits brought under section 315 of the old code. The petitioner relies on the cases reported in Ram Kunwar Saha v. Ram Gour Saha (1909) I.L.R. 37 C. 67, Kovvuri Hasana Reddi v. Tallapragad Nayanna (1911) I.L.R. 35 M. 39. The latter of these was a case of private sale and though the Calcutta case was one of court sale the decision followed that in an earlier case of private sale, Hanuman Kamat v. Hanuman Mandur (1891) I.L.R. 19 C. 123 and the question of whether a suit under Section 315 should be distinguished was not considered. I hold that the suit is not time barred.
4. The petition must therefore be dismissed with costs.
Napier J.
5. This is a suit to recover from the defendant money paid on the purchase at a court auction in execution proceedings of certain property. The defendant was the decree-holder in S.C. 219 of 1894. In execution of his decree he brought certain lands to sale as belonging to his judgment-debtor and the plaintiff purchased them. Subsequently a third party brought a suit to establish his title to the land making the plaintiff and the defendant in this suit parties and his title was upheld. The plaintiff then applied in execution proceedings for refund of his money, but the court held that his remedy was by a suit. He accordingly instituted S.C. 156 of 1910 against the judgment-creditor and the Subordinate Judge gave him a decree.
6. It is contended in this Court that no suit lies. It is admitted that under Section 315 of Civil Procedure Code of 1882 the purchaser would be entitled to receive back his purchase money; but it is argued that under the present Code no such right exists and his rights are governed by the Code.
7. It is necessary to examine the history of this claim. It has been laid down by the Privy Council in Dorat AH Khan v. The executors Khajhee Moheeooddeen (1878) I.L.R. 3 C. 806 that as in India moveable and immoveable property are alike capable of being seized and sold under the writ of fieri facias the responsibility of the sheriff in respect of sales here is governed by the law relating to chattels rather than by that relating to the sale of real property, It is clear that where the property seized was personal estate and it was sold by the sheriff no suit lay either against the sheriff or the judgment-creditor who had received the purchase money to recover it when the property had been recovered from the purchaser by a person claiming title the principle being that a sale by the sheriff was not a sale in market overt the purchaser acquiring thereby only what the judgment-creditor had a right to sell, namely, the precise interest and no more which the judgment-debtor possessed in the goods and that there was no warranty of title implied in a sale by the Sheriff (vide Halsbury's Laws of England Vol. XIV, paragraph 113). This is on the authority of Chapman v. Speller (1850) 14 Q.B. 621, which was a claim for money had and received by the purchaser at a sheriff's sale against the vendor of the goods. The court held that the true consideration was not the property sold but the assignment of the right of the judgment-debtor whatever it was and that therefore there had not been a failure of consideration and accordingly the auction purchaser could not recover. It is clear from the decision of the Privy Council that that law applies in India apart from the statute. An attempt was made in Soudamani Chowdranee v. Kishen Kishore Peddar (1869) 12 W.R.F.B. Rulings p. 8 to recover money paid in the like circumstances under the provisions of Regulation VII of 1825 but the Court negatived the right and in so doing considered also the language of Act VIII of 1859 the first Civil Procedure Code. Section 249 of that Act provided that the proclamation should declare that the sale extended only to the right title and interest of the defendant in the property. Sections 256 and 257 provided for circumstances under which sales might be set aside on the ground of material irregularity in the conduct of the sale. Section 258 provided that where the sale of immoveale property was set aside the purchaser should be entitled to receive back his purchase money and it was argued that this section applied where the property was recovered by a third party. The Full Bench negatived this view and held that it only applied where the sale of the immoveable property was set aside for irregularity under the previous sections. The Court laid down that a purchaser at a sale in auction knows that no one guarantees him that the judgment-debtor had a good title, that he purchased the property with his eyes wide open and regulates the price which he bids with reference to the risk. The law was materially altered by act x of 1877, the provisions of which are re-produced in this respect in act xiv of 1882. The proclamation under section 287 of that act did not state that all that was sold was the right, title and interest of the judgment-debtor. Further it purports to give a great deal of information about the property and especially requires to be stated the incumbrances to which the property is liable and every other thing which the Court considers material for the purchaser to know in order to Judge of the nature and value of the property. Section 311 corresponds with Section 256 of the Code of 1859 in allowing an application to the Court to set aside the sale on the ground of material irregularity. Section 312 corresponds with Section 257 and is the procedure section with reference to the above. Then comes an entirely new Section 313 entitling the purchaser to apply to the Court to set aside the sale on the ground that the person whose property purported to be sold had no saleable interest therein under Section 315 which embodies Section 258 of the Code of 1859 includes among the circumstances under which the purchaser was entitled to receive back his purchase money this new circumstance
"when it is found that the judgment-debtor had no saleable interest in the property purported to be sold and the purchaser for that reason is deprived of it."It is to be noted that the procedure by which the money is to be recovered is not stated in this section and it has accordingly been held that these sections give a substantial right to recover money paid to a judgment-creditor which may be exercised either by suit or by petition in execution proceedings. This was expressly decided in Pachayappan v. Narayanan ( 1887) I.L.R. 11 M. 269 where a suit to recover the money was held to be a proper procedure following Nilakanta v. Imam Sahib ( 1882) I.L.R. 16 m. 361 and has been lately re-affirmed in Bam Kumar Saha v. Ram Gour Shahad ( 1909) I.L.R. 37. C. 67 where the procedure was likewise by a suit.
8. We now come to the new Civil Procudure Code. Execution is dealt with in Part II of the Code Sections 36 to 74 and in order XXI. The sections of the Code contain no provision dealing with this question. Order XXI Rule 66 in like manner as Section 287 of the Code of 1882 does not contain the provision embodied in Section 249 of the the Code of 1859 that the proclamation should specifically state that only the right, title and interest of the judgment-debtor shall be sold and is practically in the same terms as Section 287 of the Code of 1882. Order XXI, Rule 90 embodies Section 311 of the old Code but gives the power to apply to the Court to set aside the sale on the ground of fraud in publishing and conducting it as well as on the ground of material irregularity. Rule 91 corresponds with Section 313 and empowers the purchaser to apply to the Court to have the sale set aside on the ground that the judgment-debtor had no saleable interest in the property sold and Rule 92 provides that where an application is made under Rule 91 and is allowed, the Court shall make an order setting aside the sale and unless such an application is' made and allowed or an application to set aside on the ground of irregularity or fraud, the Court shall make an order confirming the sale and thereupon the sale shall become absolute. Then Rule 93 provides that where the sale is set aside for any of the above reasons the purchaser shall be entitled to an order for re-payment of his purchase money against any person to whom it has been paid. Now the language differs very considerably from section 315 of the old code. section 315 provided that, where the sale was set aside under the corresponding sections, the purchaser should be "entitled to receive hack "his purchase money and also where it is found that the judgment-debtor had no saleable interest in the property." This last provision is entirely omitted in Order XXI R 93 and the words "the purchaser shall be entitled to receive back his purchase mone.3"'' are altered into the words "The purchaser shall be entitled to an order for repayment of his purchase money," The omitted words in Section 315 were the basis of the decisions in the cases above referred to, that a substantive right to receive back the purchase money was conferred upon the purchaser. This second substituted and limited right must be exercised before the sale is confirmed and when no such application is made the sale becomes absolute on the order of confirmation. It cannot of course be contended that these words can pass to an auction-purchaser property to which judgment-debtor had no title. It necessarily follows therefore that what is confirmed on the sale becoming absolute is only the right, title and interest of the judgment-debtor even though the notice to that effect is not inserted in the proclamation as it was under the Code of 1859. It is contended that this procedure works great hardship on an auction purchaser; for he may have no knowledge of the want of title in the judgment-debtor and may, therefore, not apply under Order XXI, Rule 91 and that the real owner of the property may not bring his suit either for declaration or to recover possession until sometime after the confirmation of the sale in which circumstances the auction purchaser has no remedy. This is so; but the Legislature must be assumed to have had knowledge of the decisions that those words created a substantive right and of the results of the alteration made in the law. The right is no longer a substantive right entitling the auction purchaser to recover his money, but a right to get an order in execution proceedings for re-payment if he discovers the absence of interest before the confirmation of sale.
9. This being the law on the subject, it remains to ascertain the appellant's position. He purchased the property in August 1903; the suit by the stranger was brought in the same year,, decreed on 13--3--06 and confirmed on appeal on 21--1--07. The Code of 1882 was in force than and accordingly there then accrued to the auction purchaser a right to recover the money by suit. By virtue of Section 6 of the General Clauses Act X of 1897 the repeal of the Code of 1882 by the New code, act v of of 1908 which came into force on the 1st of January 09 did not affect the right acquired under that enactment and it continued in him though his right to exercise it would in time become barred by limitation. He brought his suit to enforce this right in January 1910 and it is next contended that this suit is one for money had and received by the defendant for plaintiff's use, in which case limitation begins to run from the date when the money is received, i.e., August 1905 under Article 62 of both the old nnd the New Limitation Acts and that therefore his suit is barred. Reliance is placed upon Kovvuri Basiva Beddi v. Tallapragada Nagamma (1911) I.L.R. 35 M. 39 Ramlmmar Shaha v. Ram Gour Shaha (1909) I.L.R. 37 C. 67. Apart from the cases there is one answer which must on principle be fatal to this contention which is this : that no article can apply which would make the right to sue liable to be barred before it has come into existence; and if this contention were correct, that could easily occur in a suit of this nature. The substantive right comes into existence under Section 315 when it is found that the judgment-debtor has no saleable interest. The true owner of the land might conceivably not bring his suit for ten years after the auction purchase and the cause of action would not arise till then. How could the suit on this cause of action have been barred seven years before it came into existence? A further answer is that this is not a suit at Common Law for money had and received to the plaintiff's use but a suit on a statutory right. In the case of a suit to recover purchase money paid for property bought at a private sale the case of Haniunan Kamat v. Hamiman Man lur (1891) I.L.R. 19 C. 123 decided by the Privy Council is an authority for the proposition that Article 62 or Article 97 would apply according as whether the consideration failed originally or subsequently, that is to say, the starting point is the time at which the cause of action occurred and this case has been followed in Kovvuri Basiva Beddi v. Tallapra ada Nagamma (1911) I.L.R. 35 M. 39. As pointed out above, the cause of action in the present case did not arise when the money was actually paid as in the case of a sale by private contract when title is warranted, but on the date when it was found that the judgment-debtor had no saleable interest. This distinction has not been noted by the learned Judges who decided the case of Ram Kumar Shaha v. Ham Gour Shaha (1909) I.L.R. 37 C. 67 and I am unable to agree, with the view they took. There is a clear authority for the view that Article 62 does not apply in Nilakanta v. Imam Sahib (1892) I.L.R. 16 M. 301 a case on all fours with this. The court held that Article 120 was the appropriate article and undoubtedly the language is most apt with regard to the starting point "when the right to sue accrues." I agree with the view of the learned udges in that case and it follows that this suit is in time and therefore the petition must be dismissed with costs.
Alert