Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Khondkar Mahomed Saleh v. Chandra Kumar Mukerji

Calcutta High Court
Feb 6, 1929
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit on a mortgage executed in 1902 in favour of the father of the respondent, Aswini Kumar Mukherjee. The mortgage bond's due date was 12 April 1904. The original mortgagee died in December 1905 leaving his son (the present respondent) as heir; the son was then a minor. A suit on the mortgage was instituted in 1906 and a preliminary decree passed on 30 November 1906. An order absolute under the then provisions of the Transfer of Property Act was made on 9 January 1907.

The plaintiff (the mortgagee) sought, among other relief, that, if sale of the mortgaged property did not satisfy the mortgage debt, the balance could be realised from the mortgagor personally. The mortgaged property was sold on 16 September 1908, purchased by the mortgagee for Rs. 831, whereas the decree (including costs) amounted to about Rs. 6,666, leaving a substantial balance.

The mortgagee attained majority on 23 September 1923. On 23 September 1924 he applied under Order 34, rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure for a personal decree against the mortgagor. The mortgagor pleaded that this application was barred by limitation. The learned Subordinate Judge overruled the limitation objection and decreed personal recovery of the balance (including interest), and the mortgagor appealed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Which Limitation Act governs the mortgagee's 1924 application for a personal decree arising from a mortgage whose mortgaged property was sold in 1908: the earlier Limitation Act (XV of 1877) or the Limitation Act (IX of 1908) that came into force on 1 January 1909?
  2. Whether the substitution in s.6 of the Limitation Act IX of 1908 (restricting the wording to “make an application for the execution of a decree”) operated retrospectively so as to affect a vested right of a minor to make an application after attaining majority under the earlier Act.
  3. Whether statutes of limitation are to be treated as matters of procedure (and therefore applicable to causes of action or rights accruing before the statute if the new law allows time to comply) or whether they can operate to take away vested substantive rights.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The law of limitation in force when the application was made (i.e., Limitation Act IX of 1908) should be applied. Under that Act the application for a personal decree fell within Art. 181 of the first schedule and carried a three-year limitation period starting from accrual of the right.
  • The right to apply accrued in September 1908 (time of sale), so the three-year period under the 1908 Act expired in September 1911, and the application made in September 1924 was therefore barred by limitation.
  • Relied on Lala Soni Ram v. Kanhaiya Lal and rules of construction supporting application of the law in force at the time of making the application, and cited authorities (e.g., Queen v. Leeds and Bradford Railway Co. and Towler v. Chatterton) on retrospective operation where commencement is suspended.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The earlier Limitation Act (XV of 1877) should apply: under s.7 of that Act a minor may make any application within the prescribed period after minority ceases, meaning the mortgagee could apply within three years after attaining majority (i.e., after 23 September 1923), and the 1924 application was thus in time.
  • The substitution effected by s.6 of the 1908 Act deprived the mortgagee of a vested right to apply after attaining majority; therefore the older law should govern as it preserves that vested procedural privilege.
  • Relied on precedent(s) and authorities interpreted to support the contention that the 1908 changes should not be applied so as to defeat vested rights.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pell v. Gregory (Full Bench) Held that an application for a personal decree under Order 34, r. 6 falls within Art. 181 of the first schedule of the Limitation Act (IX of 1908) with a three-year period. The court accepted the Full Bench's classification that the application falls under Art. 181 and that a three-year limitation applies under the 1908 Act.
Lala Soni Ram v. Kanhaiya Lal Authority relied on for the proposition that the law in force when an application is made should be applied; used to argue against retrospective application that impairs vested rights. The court considered the case but distinguished it: Lala Soni Ram was considered in context and the court concluded it did not prevent applying the 1908 Act here because the plaintiff had time under the new Act to make the application.
The Queen v. Leeds and Bradford Railway Company Discusses retrospective operation where an Act's operation is suspended for a time; held to have retrospective effect for antecedent damage where a grace period was provided. The court discussed the decision and reasoning but treated it as part of the general retrospective-operation jurisprudence; ultimately it did not change the conclusion that the 1908 Act (a procedural statute) applies here.
Towler v. Chatterton Authority on construction as to whether an Act fixes a date before which actions must be brought (bearing on retrospective effect). The court examined the authority and related critical commentary; it noted the case's treatment but did not follow it to defeat application of the 1908 Act in the present facts.
Moon v. Durden Contains commentary (by Rolfe, B.) on prior decisions including Towler v. Chatterton; used to evaluate the correctness of retrospective constructions. The court discussed Rolfe, B.'s observations and used them in assessing the limits of retrospective application; it did not treat Moon v. Durden as preventing application of the 1908 Act here.
Wright v. Hale Statement that there is a distinction between enactments affecting vested rights and those affecting procedure. The court relied on this distinction to treat statutes of limitation as matters of procedure ordinarily applicable to matters brought after commencement.
Re: Athlumney (Wright, J.) Affirms the rule that statutes are not to operate retrospectively so as to impair existing rights, except in matters of procedure. The court cited this authority to support the general principle that procedural statutes may be applied retrospectively, and used it in assessing whether the 1908 Act affected a vested right.
Gopeshwar Pal v. Jiban Chandra Chandra (Special Bench) Held that an amendment to a limitation provision should not be construed to deprive persons of a vested right to sue where compliance with the new provision would be impossible; distinguishes cases where compliance remained possible. The court discussed this Special Bench as identifying an exception: where compliance with the new law was impossible, the amendment would not apply. The court found the exception inapplicable here because the mortgagee had time under the 1908 Act to apply.
Promotha Nath Pal Chowdhury v. Mohini Mohan Pal Chowdhury Held that an amendment (sec. 66, C.P.C., 1908) which withdrew a subsisting right of suit could not be given retrospective effect as it took away a vested right. The court distinguished this case as factually different: there the amendment removed a subsisting right to sue; the present case involved limitation (a procedural change) and the plaintiff could have complied under the new Act.
Fazl Karim v. Annada Mohan Roy Involved a judgment-debtor's application to set aside an auction sale and the interplay of the 1877 and 1908 Limitation Acts; decided before Lala Soni Ram. The court treated the case as distinguishable and not controlling here; noted that the judgment-debtor had an opportunity under the 1908 Act before its commencement but did not avail himself of it.
Shaik Sadi Ali v. Shaikh Dalimuddin Following Colonial Sugar, holds that the right of appeal is a substantive right which cannot be taken away without express provision. The court observed that this and similar cases dealt with substantive rights (e.g., appeals) and thus were not pertinent to the present procedural/limitation question.
Colonial Sugar Refining Co. v. Irving Authority for the proposition that a right of appeal is substantive and cannot be removed without explicit legislative provision. The court cited it to show the distinction between substantive rights (to which the cited authorities apply) and procedural matters such as limitation statutes (the main issue here).
Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. v. Income Tax Commissioner, Delhi Judicial Committee decision treating certain rights (e.g., appeals) as substantive. The court relied on this as an example of cases concerning substantive rights, which are distinguishable from procedural limitation rules at issue in the present appeal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by identifying the chronological and legal facts: the mortgage debt became due in 1904; the sale occurred in September 1908; the mortgagee was a minor until 23 September 1923; the application for personal decree was filed on 23 September 1924.

The core analytical question was whether the Limitation Act IX of 1908 (which came into operation 1 January 1909) altered the earlier privilege under Act XV of 1877 that allowed a minor, after attaining majority, to make certain applications within a prescribed period. Section 6 of the 1908 Act narrowed the language (substituting “make an application for the execution of a decree”), which led to the parties' dispute whether that change took away a vested right to apply after attaining majority.

The court reviewed authorities on retrospective operation and distinguished substantive rights from procedural rules. It cited authorities (Wright v. Hale; Re: Athlumney) supporting the settled principle that statutes affecting procedure (including limitation statutes) are ordinarily not regarded as impairing vested rights and may be applied to matters after their commencement.

The court examined the Special Bench decision in Gopeshwar Pal as articulating a limited exception: if an amendment makes compliance impossible and thus would deprive a person of a vested right to sue, the amendment should not be applied retrospectively. Applying that test to the present facts, the court found that the mortgagee had a real opportunity to make his application under the 1908 Act: the right accrued in September 1908 and the three-year period under the new Act would have expired in September 1911 — giving the mortgagee roughly two years and nine months from the passage of the 1908 Act to apply.

Because compliance under the new Act was possible (i.e., the new limitation period did not make it impossible for the mortgagee to act), the court held the 1908 Act applied. The court further considered and distinguished other precedents relied upon by the parties (including those concerning substantive rights such as appeals), concluding they were not applicable to a procedural/limitation question.

On that basis the court concluded that the rule of limitation applicable to the present case is that laid down by Act IX of 1908, and, accordingly, the 1924 application was time-barred under the 1908 Act.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Appeal allowed; the judgment and decree of the Subordinate Judge are set aside and the mortgagee's application is dismissed.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The decree made by the learned Subordinate Judge awarding a personal decree against the mortgagor is set aside.
  • The mortgagee's application for a personal decree (filed on 23 September 1924) is dismissed as barred by the Limitation Act (IX of 1908) as applied by the court.
  • Costs were ordered against the mortgagee in both Courts.

Broader implications:

  • The court applied the principle that statutes of limitation are procedural and, where the amended limitation period still left the claimant an opportunity to comply after the amendment, the new limitation law (Limitation Act IX of 1908) governs applications made after its commencement.
  • The opinion distinguished cases concerning substantive rights (e.g., right of appeal) from procedural limitation rules and applied the settled distinction in reaching its conclusion.

The opinion does not state that it establishes any novel binding precedent beyond applying established principles to the facts: its effect is the reversal of the Subordinate Judge's order and dismissal of the application on limitation grounds.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—

B.B Ghose, J.:— This is an appeal by the original Defendant mortgagor in a suit brought on a mortgage which was executed in 1902 in favour of the father of the present Respondent one Aswini Kumar Mukherjee. The due date under the bond for payment of the mortgage money was 12th April 1904. The original mortgagee died in December 1905, leaving his son the present Respondent his only heir who was then a minor. A suit was brought on the mortgage in 1906 and a preliminary decree was passed on the 30th November 1906. An order absolute was made under the repealed provisions of the Transfer of Property Act on the 9th January 1907. In the suit the Plaintiff who was represented by his guardian ad litem prayed, amongst other things, that in case the entire amount of the mortgage be not fully satisfied by the sale of the mortgage properties, then the balance might be realised from the Defendant's other moveables and immoveables as well as from his person. According to the usual practice then prevailing, the decree was made for realisation of the mortgage money in the first instance out of the mortgage property, leaving it to the mortgagee to apply for a further decree against the person of the mortgagor if by the sale of the mortgaged property the entire money was not realised. The mortgaged property was sold on the 16th September 1908 and it was purchased by the mortgagee for Rs. 831. The mortgage decree including all costs was for Rs. 6,666 odd and therefore a considerable sum remained due as balance of the mortgage money. The mortgagee attained majority on the 23rd September 1923 and an application was made under Or. 34, r. 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure on 23rd September 1924 for a personal decree against the mortgagor. The mortgagor pleaded that this application was barred by limitation. The learned Subordinate Judge has overruled that objection and made a decree against the mortgagor personally for the balance of the money due, together with interest which amounted to Rs. 13,284-6-9 pies. The Defendant mortgagor has appealed against that decree and his contention is that the Plaintiff's application should be dismissed on the ground that it was barred by limitation.

This question raises an interesting point of law which does not seem to have been directly decided by any reported case. The point arises in this way. Under the Limitation Act XV of 1877 the Plaintiff would be entitled to maintain his application for a personal decree after the attainment of majority within the period of limitation prescribed therein. Under sec. 7 of that Act a minor might make any application within the prescribed period after the disability of minority had ceased. The new Limitation Act (Act IX of 1908) was passed in August 1908 and it came into operation on the 1st January 1909. Under sec. 6 of that Act, which replaced sec. 7 of Act XV of 1877, instead of the words “make any application” the words “make an application for the execution of a decree” were substituted, the result of which is that under the Limitation Act now in force the application for a personal decree against the mortgagor under Or. 34, r. 6, C.P.C, would not fall within the provisions of sec. 6, or, in other words, the privilege of making the application after the disability of minority has ceased was taken away and a minor must now make such an application within the period prescribed under the first schedule of the Limitation Act. It has been held by a Full Bench of this Court in the case of Pell v. Gregory (1) that such an application falls within Art. 181 of the first schedule of the Limitation Act (IX of 1908) and, therefore, the period of limitation is three years from the time when the right to apply accrued. The contention of the Appellant is that in this case the right to apply accrued in September 1908. The law of limitation now in force should be applied in the present case and it should, therefore, be held that the application made in September 1924 is barred by the rule of limitation. It is contended, on the other hand, on behalf of the Respondent, as was held by the learned Subordinate Judge, that the Limitation Act (XV of 1877) should apply to this case and although the right to make an application accrued in September 1908 as the mortgagee was under the disability of minority till 23rd September 1923, he was entitled to make the application within three years from that date. And as the application was made within that period, it was within time and the learned Subordinate Judge was right in making the decree. The question, therefore, is what law of limitation should be applied to the present application. It is argued on behalf of the Appellant that the rule of limitation should be applied according to the law in force at the time when the application was made and the learned Advocate relies upon the case of Lala Soni Ram v. Kanhaiya Lal in support of his proposition. He contends that the Subordinate Judge was wrong in holding that the Act of 1908 affected any vested right of the Plaintiff and, therefore, his conclusion that the Limitation Act of 1877 was applicable is erroneous. Reliance has been placed with regard to the rule of construction as to the retrospective operation of statutes to the cases of The Queen v. Leeds and Bradford Railway Company and Towler v. Chatterton in support of the contention that the Act of 1908 should be given what is called “retrospective operation.” In the case of The Queen v. Leeds and Bradford Railway Company an Act was passed which came into operation six weeks after its passing by which it was enacted that awards for compensation made under the Lands Clauses Act must be applied for and obtained within six months from the time when the damage was done to any property. The question arose whether the Act had a retrospective operation and was to apply to cases of damage done before its passing. The Court decided that it was retrospective, and Lord Campbell, C.J, in giving judgment observed: “If the Act had come into operation immediately after the time of its being passed, the hardship would have been so great that we might have inferred an intention on the part of the legislature not to give it a retrospective operation, but when we see that it contains a provision suspending its operation for six weeks, that must be taken as an intimation that the legislature has provided that as the period of time within which proceedings respecting antecedent damage or injuries might be taken before the proper tribunal…. A certain time was allowed before the Act was to come into operation, and that removes all difficulty. The case of Towler v. Chatterton is strongly in point.” It is stated in a well-known text book, Craies on “Statute Law,” at page 334 that the case of Towler v. Chatterton was, amongst other cases, commented upon somewhat adversely by Rolfe, B in an elaborate judgment in Moon v. Durden . But notwithstanding these criticisms, Towler v. Chatterton was followed in The Queen v. Leeds and Bradford Railway Company . This observation does not seem to be accurate, as would appear from a report of the judgment of Rolfe, B in the case of Moon v. Durden . There the learned Baron commented adversely upon two nisi prius decisions which were cited before him in support of the contention that a certain Act as regards wagering contracts should be given retrospective effect. But speaking of the decision in Towler v. Chatterton the earned Baron makes the following observations:— “Whether the decision in Towler v. Chatterton was correct, would depend on whether the true meaning of the 10th section was to fix a date before which all actions must be brought, or a date beyond which no parole promise should be sufficient to take a case out of the operation of the statute of limitations. The Court of Common Pleas adopted the former construction. Neither construction would do injustice by infringing the rule which in general makes all statutes prospective in their operation, and the Court of Common Pleas may have been right in their view of the statute, at all events, it is immaterial, in the present case, to discuss that point.” In the present case the question really is whether the Limitation Act (IX of 1908) affects a vested right as to making application, by the alteration made by sec. 6 in the previous law contained in sec. 7 of Act XV of 1877. It is a settled principle that, there is no vested right in procedure or costs. In Wright v. Hale (6), Pollock, C.B, observed, that there is a considerable difference between new enactments which affect vested rights and those which merely affect the procedure in Courts. In Re: Athlumney (7), Wright, J., says:— “Perhaps no rule of construction is more firmly established than this—that a retrospective operation is not to be given to a statute so as to impair an existing right or obligation, otherwise than as regards a matter of procedure, unless that effect cannot be avoided without doing violence to the language of the enactment.” After citing a large number of authorities in support of the proposition, the learned Judge observes at page 553: “one exception to the general rule has sometimes been suggested, namely, that where, as here, the commencement of the operation of an Act is suspended for a time, this is an indication that no further restriction upon retrospective operation is intended. But this exception seems never to have been suggested except in relation to statutes affecting procedure, such a statutes of limitation, and even in relation to them it is questioned in Moon v. Durden .” I have pointed out above from the judgment of Rolfe, B., in Moor v. Durden that the learned Baron did not actually disapprove of the law laid down in Towler v. Chatterton . I may also state here in passing that two other learned Barons who constituted the Court of Exchequer with Rolfe, B. did not say anything with regard to this question. The question, therefore, is whether the Limitation Act of 1908 affected any vested right or it was merely a law affecting procedure. It is clear from the observations of Wright, J., that statutes of limitation cannot be considered as anything else than matters relating to procedure and ordinarily such statutes have their operation from the date fixed in the statutes and govern all matters brought before the Court after the commencement of the operation of the statute. There is, however, one exception which has been pointed out in the case of Gopeshwar Pal v. Jiban Chandra Chandra decided by a Special Bench of this Court. There the period of limitation under the third schedule of the Bengal Tenancy Act was amended in such a way as to take away the rights of certain persons to bring a suit within the period of limitation prescribed by the Act before the amendment came into operation. The learned Judges observed as follows:— “Here the Plaintiff at the time when the amending Act was passed had a vested right of suit, and we see nothing in the Act as amended that demands the construction that the Plaintiff was thereby deprived of a right of suit vested in him at the date of the passing of the amending Act. It is not (in our opinion) even a fair reading of sec. 184 and the third schedule of the Bengal Tenancy Act, as amended, to hold that it was intended to impose an impossible condition under pain of the forfeiture of a vested right, and we can only construe the amendment as not applying to cases where its provisions cannot be obeyed. The law as amended may regulate the procedure in suits in which the Plaintiff could comply with its provisions, but cannot (in our opinion) govern suits where such compliance was from the first impossible. The effect is to regulate, not to confiscate. There are thus two positions; where in accordance with its provisions a suit could be brought after the passing of the amendment, it may be that the amendment would apply, but where it could not, then the amendment would have no application.” Then dealing with the case of Lala Soni Ram v. Kanhaiya Lal , the learned Judges say that case applies where it was possible for the Plaintiff to bring a suit in accordance with the provisions of the new Limitation Act after the passing of the amendment and there the amendment would apply. Now, applying this rule to the present case there cannot be any doubt that the Plaintiff might have made his application within the period of limitation prescribed under Act IX of 1908. The time when the right accrued was September 1908 and three years would expire in September 1911. Therefore, the mortgagee had about two years nine months' time after the passing of the Act of 1908 to make his application and hence there was no hardship which was discussed in the cases of Towler v. Chatterton and The Queen v. Leeds and Bradford Railway Company . It is not necessary, in this case, to lay any stress upon the fact that the Limitation Act of 1908 was passed in August 1908 and it was to come into operation on the 1st January 1909. That fact might have been important, if the position of the Plaintiff was such that he would have no time under the new law to make any application after the Act came into operation. But as a matter of fact, as I have already pointed out, he had two years nine months under the new law within which he could make his application. Therefore, in my judgment, it cannot be doubted that the rule of limitation applicable to the present case should be that laid down by Act IX of 1908. Reliance has been placed by the Respondent on the case of Promotha Nath Pal Chowdhury v. Mohini Mohan Pal Chowdhury (9) and particularly on the observations in the judgment at 469 in support of the contention that the old law of limitation (Act XV of 1877) should apply to the present case. That is, however, a case quite different from the present. There the Plaintiff had brought a suit against an assignee of a purchaser at an auction sale. Such a suit was not prohibited under the Civil Procedure Code of 1882. The Plaintiff had a subsisting right to sue such an assignee. Under sec. 66 of the Code of Civil Procedure of 1908 such a suit is not maintainable. The learned Judges held that sec. 66 of the Code had no retrospective operation as it actually took away a right of suit which is a vested right. Reliance has also been placed on the case of Fazl Karim v. Annada Mohan Roy . There a judgment-debtor made an application for setting aside an auction sale. The sale was held in 1903 when the old Limitation Act (XV of 1877) was in operation. He had a right to make his application within three years after the attainment of majority under that Act. But under the Limitation Act of 1908 he would have to apply within three years of the accrual of the right to make the application. The judgment-debtor made his application in January 1909 when he was still a minor. That case was decided before the decision of the Judicial Committee in Lala Soni Ram v. Kanhaiya Lal . The judgment-debtor could have made his application after the passing of the Limitation Act of 1908 and before it came into operation in January 1909, but he did not do so. He did not avail himself of the opportunity. This case does not fall within the exception formulated in the Special Bench case of Gopeshwar Pal v. Jiban Chandra Chandra referred to above. In my opinion that case should be considered as no longer law after the decision of the cases referred to above.

Reliance was next placed on the Special Bench case of Shaik Sadi Ali v. Shaikh Dalimuddin (11), where it was held, following the well-known case of Colonial Sugar Refining Co. v. Irving (12) that a right of appeal is a substantive right which could not be taken away without an express provision for it. This was also held to be so in the case of Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. v. Income Tax Commissioner, Delhi (13) decided by their Lordships of the Judicial Committee. Those cases dealt with a substantive right and not with a question of procedure such as limitation of suits and have no bearing on the question before us. The real position in the present case is as summarised in Maxwell's “Interpretation of Statute,” 6th edition at page 399 while dealing with the cases of Towler v. Chatterton and The Queen v. Leeds and Bradford Railway Co. . The learned author says: “In both of the above cases, however, the construction, though fatal to the enforcement of a vested right, by shortening the time for enforcing it, did not in terms take away any such right; and in both it seems to fall within the general principle that the presumption against a retrospective construction has no application to enactments which affect only the procedure and practice of the Courts, even where the alteration which the statute makes has been disadvantageous to one of the parties. Although to make a law for punishing that which, at the time when it was done, was not punishable, is contrary to sound principle, a law which merely alters the procedure may, with perfect propriety, be made applicable to past as well as future transactions; and no secondary meaning is to be sought for an enactment of such a kind. No person has a vested right in any course of procedure.” What the enactment of 1908 did was to cut down the period within which the infant was entitled to exercise his vested right and did not as a matter of fact take away that right.

On these grounds I am of opinion that the appeal must be allowed, the judgment and decree of the learned Subordinate Judge set aside and the application of the mortgagee dismissed with costs in both the Courts.

Panton, J.:— I agree.

P.C