- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Gora Chand Haldar v. Prafulla Kumar Roy
Walmsley, J.:— This Reference is made in a first appeal from an order. The necessary facts are given in the Order of Reference, and need not be repeated.
The question propounded is in these words: “Where a decree, having been passed by a Court having no jurisdiction to pass it, is void, and a nullity, is the execution Court competent to question its validity and refuse to execute it?”
The learned Judges who made the Reference are satisfied that the decree under consideration was made by a Court that had no jurisdiction to make it, and that in consequence it is void and a nullity. It is not open to us, therefore, to consider any of the questions involved in that finding. We have to start by accepting the proposition that the Court that made the decree had no jurisdiction to make it, and by that expression is meant that the Court had not such territorial jurisdiction as would authorize it to make the decree, and not that having jurisdiction it exercised it erroneously. This distinction is of great, importance, for, with all respect, I venture to think that the apparent conflict in reported cases is largely due to failure to keep this distinction clearly in view. It would be tedious to examine the numerous, decisions in detail, and it would not lead to any useful result. I think it may be said, that the correct, view, and the view for which there is a strong, current of authority, is that where the decree presented for execution was made by a Court which apparently had not jurisdiction, whether pecuniary or territorial or in respect of the judgment-debtor's-person, to make the decree, the executing Court is entitled to refuse to execute it on the ground that it was made without jurisdiction. Within these narrow limits I think that the executing Court is authorized, to question the validity of a decree.
As the question arises in a first appeal, we must return the case for final adjudication by the Bench which referred it, with the statement that our answer to the question propounded is in the affirmative.
C.C Ghose, J.:— I agree.
Suhrawardy, J.:— I agree.
B.B Ghose, J.:— I agree.
Duval, J.:— I agree.
S.M
Alert