Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sami Ayyangar v. Venkataramana Ayyangar

Madras High Court
Oct 11, 1933
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerned the construction of entries in the Inam Register (Ex. 1) about a grant described in the Register and whether that grant was made to the temple (the deity) or to an individual (Venkatachala Ayyangar) and whether it was burdened with archaka service. Column 15 of the Register records the name of Rama Ayyangar (entered in the account of 1803 / fasli 1213) and Column 21 contains the note: “To be confirmed to the party in Column 16 as long as he continues the performance of the services.”

In 1906 the defendants' uncle (the then holder) was dismissed and another person was appointed who acted for about three years. The plaintiff was appointed archaka in 1909 and instituted the present suit within twelve years of his own appointment. The case reached this Court on second appeal. The Court considered (a) the proper construction of the Register entries, (b) whether the suit was barred by limitation given the defendants' possession, and (c) whether the archaka's legal position as a trustee (if any) affected the right to claim adverse title.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the grant recorded in the Inam Register was made to the deity (temple) or to the named individual (Venkatachala Ayyangar), and whether it was subject to a condition of performing archaka services.
  2. If the grant were construed as to the temple or to the office-holder, whether the plaintiff's suit was barred by limitation (specifically in light of adverse possession exceeding twelve years and Article 144 of the Limitation Act).
  3. Whether the archaka's legal position is that of a trustee (which would prevent him asserting adverse title until properly discharged) and, if so, whether that affects the validity of his dismissal and the limitation defence.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff contended that the period of limitation should run from his own appointment in 1909 and not from the dismissal of his predecessor, i.e., that adverse possession during the predecessor's tenure should not affect his right.
  • It was argued that the position of the Archaka was in law that of a trustee and, accordingly, an archaka could not be permitted to assert an adverse title until he had obtained a proper discharge from the trust. The plaintiff relied on authority (Srinivasa Moorthy v. Venkata Varada Aiyangar) to support this trustee contention and urged reconsideration of earlier cases on that basis.

Defendants' / Respondents' Arguments (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The register entries (in particular Column 21) were to be construed as confirming the grant to the named individual (Venkatachala Ayyangar) subject to the performance of archaka services, rather than to the deity.
  • The defendants and their predecessors had been in possession for over twelve years from the dismissal of the defendants' uncle (in 1906), and such possession was adverse, thereby barring the plaintiff's suit under Article 144 of the Limitation Act.
  • The dismissal of the predecessor was justified on the footing that he was a servant (not a trustee); if the archaka were treated as a trustee, his removal could only be by a court proceeding, but the court found dismissal justified on the servant footing—this supports the defendants' possession and title arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kuppuswami Mudaliar v. Samia Pillai Held that where the holder of a religious office (with lands attached) was dismissed but continued in possession and another was appointed, a suit brought more than twelve years from the date of dismissal was barred under Art. 144 of the Limitation Act. The Court held the present facts fell within this principle and that the plaintiff's suit was therefore barred.
Dhanushkotirayudu v. Vankayala Venkatarathnam Decided that a person in adverse possession of lands annexed to an office for over the statutory period acquires a prescriptive right as against the holder of the office and his successors; the question is inter partes and does not affect the Government's right to resume land. The decision was followed as supporting the conclusion that adverse possession over the statutory period confers a right against the office-holder and successors.
Subramania Gurukkal v. Ammakkannu Ammal Affirms the principle (noted in 38 M.L.J. 320) that where land forming part of emoluments of an office is alienated and the alienee is in possession for over twelve years claiming title as owner, he obtains an absolute and indefeasible right. Used to support the proposition that long adverse possession of lands attached to an office gives the possessor an absolute right.
38 M.L.J. 320 Authority for the principle that prolonged adverse possession of land attached to a temple office, where the possessor claims title as owner, results in an absolute and indefeasible right after the statutory period. Referred to as the underlying principle affirmed by Subramania Gurukkal; supports the limitation-based bar.
Jalandhar Thakur v. Jharula Das Authority cited by the Advocate-General (details not expanded in the opinion). The Court considered and distinguished this decision from the present facts and the other authorities relied on; it did not deal with it at length.
Chidambaram Chetti v. Minammal One of the decisions supporting the view that adverse possession of lands attached to an office can bar suits after the statutory period. Referred to as further support for the Court's conclusion on limitation and adverse possession.
Majavath Alli v. Mujafar Alli Another decision cited in support of the adverse-possession principle applied to office-attached lands. Cited as additional authority supporting the Court's view on limitation.
Srinivasa Moorthy v. Venkata Varada Aiyangar Authority relied upon for the proposition that an Archaka is a trustee and cannot assert an adverse title until properly discharged from the trust. Noted by the Court as the source of the trustee argument advanced by the plaintiff, but the Court rejected that argument on the facts here.
Nellaiyappa Pillai v. Thangama Nachiyar Principle that a trustee (or similar fiduciary incumbent of an office) could be removed only by the Court and in a properly instituted suit. Recognised by the Court as the legal rule if the archaka were a trustee; the Court observed that on that footing dismissal would be invalid, but the Court found dismissal justified on the alternative footing that the incumbent was a servant, not a trustee.
Narayana Ayyar v. Kumarasami Mudaliar Same general principle as Nellaiyappa Pillai regarding removal of a trustee/incumbent only by court proceedings. Referred to in the reasoning about the trustee position; again, the Court treated the trustee argument as inapplicable because dismissal was justified on the servant footing.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began with a textual construction of the Inam Register. While Column 15 and the use of words such as “Devadayam” introduced potential ambiguity, the Court placed decisive weight on the explicit terms of Column 21: “To be confirmed to the party in Column 16 as long as he continues the performance of the services.” The Court reasoned that if “the party” were understood to be the deity, the condition “as long as he continues the performance of the services” would be nonsensical because a deity cannot perform archaka services; the idea that the grant would be resumable on the deity failing to render the service would be absurd. Taken together with the historical fact that the land had been held continuously by the family of Venkatachala for at least two generations, the Court concluded the Register intended to confirm the grant in favour of the named individual (Venkatachala Ayyangar) subject to archaka service.

The Court then considered the alternative constructions (grant to the temple, or grant to the office-holder for the time being) and whether the suit would be within time under either construction. The Court held that, in either alternative, the defendants' long adverse possession (in particular possession for more than twelve years from the dismissal of their uncle in 1906) barred the plaintiff's suit under Article 144 of the Limitation Act. The Court applied precedents (notably Kuppuswami Mudaliar v. Samia Pillai and Dhanushkotirayudu v. Vankayala Venkatarathnam) establishing that adverse possession by a person in possession of lands annexed to an office for over the statutory period confers a prescriptive right as against the office-holder and successors.

The plaintiff's contention that time should run from his own appointment (in 1909) and not from the earlier dismissal was considered and overruled: the Court held that the possession of the person dismissed must be deemed adverse as against either the temple or the newly appointed archaka, so the statutory period had run.

The trustee argument (that the archaka was a trustee and therefore could not claim adverse title until discharged) was addressed. The plaintiff relied on Srinivasa Moorthy v. Venkata Varada Aiyangar and argued that earlier cases required reconsideration. The Court observed that this contention was in fact fatal to the plaintiff's case because the dismissal was justified on the footing that the incumbent was a servant and not a trustee. If the incumbent had been a trustee (in which case removal would require court proceedings—per Nellaiyappa Pillai and Narayana Ayyar), his dismissal would have been invalid and he would lawfully remain in possession; on that footing the plaintiff's suit would still fail. Thus the trustee argument did not assist the plaintiff.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The second appeal is allowed.

Consequences and immediate effects:

  • The decree of the Subordinate Judge is set aside.
  • The decree of the District Munsif is restored.
  • The plaintiff is directed to pay to the Government the Court-fee payable on the Memorandum of Appeal in the lower appellate Court.
  • The appeal is allowed with costs in this Court and in the lower appellate Court.

Broader implications: The opinion applies and reaffirms established principles concerning the construction of temple-office grants and the effect of long adverse possession on lands annexed to religious offices, relying on previous case law. The opinion does not state that it establishes a new precedent beyond applying those existing authorities.

N. R. R. Appeal allowed.
Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

On a construction of the entries in the Inam Register (Ex. 1), I am disposed to hold that the grant was not to the deity but was to Venkachala Ayyangar and that it was burdened with service. Column 15 of the Register shows that the name of Rama Ayyangar, Venkatachalla's father, was entered in the account of 1803 (fasli 1213). The use of the word “Devadayam” does not necessarily import that the grant was made to the temple, for the words, to which I attach great importance, are those that occur in Column 21. They are to the following effect:—

“To be confirmed to the party in Column 16 as long as he continues the performance of the services.”

The question whether the grant is to an institution represented by its manager or to a named individual who fills a certain character, is often a difficult one. In this case the “present owner” is stated to be “Kalyana Ramaswami Archaka Venkatachala Ayyan”, (Kalyana Ramaswami being the name of the deity). Whatever ambiguity may attach to these words, Column 21, to which I have referred, is explicit and unequivocal. If “the party” referred to in that column be understood to be the deity, what would be the result? The condition of the performing of the services cannot possibly refer to the deity and the idea of the grant being resumable on the deity failing to render the archaka service, would of course be absurd. The Inam Register shows that the land was continuously held at least for two generations by the family of Venkatachala, and the intention was no doubt to confirm the grant in his favour burdened with archaka service. This view involves the negation of the plaintiff's right and his suit must fail.

If a view different from what I have expressed, is taken of the grant, the question arises whether the suit is within time. Supposing the grant is construed as one to the temple, the income to be utilised for the remuneration of the Archaka, (that is one construction), or supposing again that the grant is regarded as one made to the office-holder for the time being, (this is the other construction), in either case I am clearly of the opinion that the suit is barred. Whether right to the property vests in the temple or in the newly appointed Archaka the possession of the person dismissed must be deemed adverse. The defendants have been in possession for more than 12 years from the date of the dismissal of their uncle, and the suit is therefore barred. The facts of the present case clearly bring it within the principle of Kuppuswami Mudaliar v. Samia Pillai (1). There too the holder of a religious office, to which certain lands were attached, was dismissed but continued in possession of the property, although another person was appointed to the office. It was held that the suit brought more than 12 years from the date of the dismissal was barred under Art. 144 of the Limitation Act. The learned Judges in that case followed Dhanushkotirayudu v. Vankayala Venkatarathnam . It was there decided that a person in adverse possession of lands annexed to the office of Karnam for over the statutory period, acquires a prescriptive right to the lands as against the holder of the office and his successors. As observed in that case, the question is one between the parties inter se and does not concern the right of the Government to resume the land. I may also refer to Subramania Gurukkal v. Ammakkannu Ammal (2), which affirms the principle laid down in 38 M.L.J 320. Where lands forming part of the emoluments of an office in a temple were alienated and the alienee was in possession for over 12 years claiming title as owner, it was held that he got an absolute and indefeasible right to the property. The decision relied on by the learned Advocate-General, Jalandhar Thakur v. Jharula Das (3), has been considered and distinguished in each of the three cases to which I have referred and I need not therefore deal with it at any length. The facts of the present case are these. In 1906 the defendants' uncle was dismissed and another was appointed in his place, who acted for about 3 years. The plaintiff was then appointed archaka in 1909 and the present suit was instituted within 12 years from the plaintiff's appointment. It is contended for him that he is not affected by the adverse possession during the period of his predecessor's office and that time runs from the date of his own appointment. This contention must be overruled. Two more cases may be referred to as supporting the view I have taken: Chidambaram Chetti v. Minammal (4) and Majavath Alli v. Mujafar Alli (5).

It is next argued that the position of the Archaka is in law that of a trustee and that he cannot be permitted to assert an adverse title until he has obtaind a proper discharge from the trust: Srinivasa Moorthy v. Venkata Varada Aiyangar (6). It is further urged that this question not having been raised or considered in the cases to which I have referred above, they require reconsideration. This contention, I must remark, is fatal to the plaintiff's case; for the dismissal of the Archaka is justified on the footing that he was a servant and not a trustee. If he was a trustee (I suppose what is meant is, that he was the trustee of a kattalai or a minor endowment) he could be removed only by the Court and in a properly instituted suit: Nellaiyappa Pillai v. Thangama Nachiyar (7) and Narayana Ayyar v. Kumarasami Mudaliar (8). On the footing of his being a trustee therefore, his dismissal is invalid and of no effect, and if that be so, he is lawfully in possession of the property and the plaintiff's suit must on that ground fail.

In the result, the second appeal is allowed with costs in this and in the lower appellate Court; the decree of the Subordinate Judge is set aside and that if the District Munsif is restored. The plaintiff is also directed to pay to the Government, the Court-fee payable on the Memorandum of Appeal in the lower appellate Court.

N. R. R.Appeal allowed.