Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mulraju Lakshmi Venkayamma Rao Bahadur v. Venkatadri Appa Rao Bahadur And Others

Madras High Court
Mar 22, 1915
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

1. It is argued for the petitioner that as our decree did not affirm the decision of the lower Court, and as the value of the contemplated appeal to the Privy Council is over ten thousand rupees, leave ought to be granted under Section 110 of the CPC, and O. 45, R. 3(1).

2. We see no sufficient reason to dissent from the view of the Calcutta High Court [See Rajah Sreenath Roy v. Secretary of State for India(1)], that where as regards the subject-matter of the proposed appeal the High Court has affirmed the decree of the Court of first instance (though it made some modifications in that decree in the appellant's favour as regards another portion of the plaintiff's claim) leave to appeal to the Privy Council ought not to be granted unless the proposed appeal involved some substantial question of law (last paragraph of Section 110 of the CPC).

3. There seems to be no “substantial question” of law involved in the proposed appeal.

4. It is, of course, possible by the expenditure of much ingenuity to formulate in the appeal grounds some questions of law as arising on the facts or on the reasons given for the decisions on certain facts, but the questions so formulated in this case are not “sustainable” questions even taken at their highest [See Gafur Khan v. Secretary of State(2) as to a substantial question of law having to be involved.”]

5. The decision in this case does not (in the language of a recent decision) involve any legal question “of general importance,” does not affect any large body of persons and does not “threaten the religious or civil rights of any class of the community.”

6. Assuming that in the judgment of this Court, some documents have been misconstrued, the conclusions on the facts are not based on those documents alone or even mainly.

7. The principle underlying their Lordships' decision in Ravi Veeraraghavulu v. Bomma Devara Venkata(3) seems to me to imply that such misconstruction of a portion of the evidence relating to particular facts cannot be treated as a “substantial” question of law.

8. We would, therefore, refuse the certificate applied for with one set of costs.

S.N/R.K

9. Certificate refused.