Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vangaveiti Narayana And Another v. Madar Khan

Madras High Court
Feb 17, 1944
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary: Criminal Revision Cases Nos. 443 & 722 of 1943

Factual and Procedural Background

Both petitions arise from the same criminal proceeding, C.C. No. 13 of 1942 on the file of the Sub‑Magistrate of Jaggayyapeta. The petitioners (accused Nos. 1 and 2) were accused of committing criminal trespass on 62 acres and 57 cents of land (Survey No. 26 in T.D. No. 232, Siripuram village), allegedly in the possession of the zamindar of Munagala, on 26 July 1941 at about 7 a.m. When the complainant (an estate servant / the kotwal) obstructed ploughing, the accused allegedly threatened personal injury.

The accused were charged under provisions identified in the record (sections cited in the opinion include sections 352 and 447; the text also mentions acquittal in respect of an offence punishable under section 359 and conviction only for criminal trespass). The Sub‑Magistrate acquitted them on one count and convicted them for criminal trespass; the Sub‑Divisional Magistrate of Bezwada confirmed that conviction and sentence on appeal.

A civil background is central to the dispute: a prior civil suit (resulting in Exhibit A, decree of ejectment dated 8 May 1935) and execution proceedings led to delivery of possession of the disputed 62 acres 57 cents to the zamindar via court order and execution (delivery through Court on 15 June 1939, Exhibit C). The prosecution’s case was that the land, though delivered, lay fallow and the ryots' Association instigated members to occupy such uncultivated zamindar lands; accused Nos. 1 and 2 (brothers and active association members) were among those who took possession on 26 July 1941.

Evidence referred to in the record includes Exhibit VIII (a sale deed to the first accused dated 13 June 1941) and Exhibit IX (a cultivation account showing crop entries). The accused asserted prior possession and a purported purchase, but both trial and appellate courts rejected that version and found that the accused committed trespass.

Two separate revision petitions were filed: Criminal Revision Case No. 443 of 1943 challenging the appellate magistrate’s confirmation of conviction and sentence; and Criminal Revision Case No. 722 of 1943 to revise the Sub‑Magistrate’s order dated 7 April 1943 directing delivery of possession of the lands to the zamindar.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction for criminal trespass was sustainable on the evidence, specifically whether the prosecution proved that the accused entered the land with the requisite intent to "annoy, intimidate or insult" the person in possession (the zamindar).
  2. Whether the petitioners' asserted prior possession or rights over the land (including the sale deed dated 13 June 1941 and evidence of cultivation) were sufficient to negative criminal trespass.
  3. Whether the order directing delivery of possession (challenged in Criminal Revision Case No. 722 of 1943) complied with the time limits and procedure referred to in section 522 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and whether delivery to the zamindar rather than to the complainant was proper.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners/Appellants (accused Nos. 1 & 2)

  • Contended that not every physical entry constitutes criminal trespass; prosecution had not proven intention to annoy, intimidate or insult the zamindar.
  • Argued that the zamindar was not present at the time, so there could have been no intention to annoy him.
  • Claimed prior possession of the land (including a sale to the first accused under Exhibit VIII and prior occupation as a lessee) and relied on cultivation evidence to challenge the trespass finding.
  • In the challenge to the delivery order (Cr. Rev. No. 722/1943) they argued that under section 522 CrPC the order must be passed within one month of conviction; since the order dated 7‑4‑43 was much later, it was asserted to be invalid. They also contended delivery should not have been ordered to the zamindar because he was not the complainant.

Prosecution / Respondent

  • Asserted that the zamindar had obtained decree and delivery of possession by court (Exhibit A and Exhibit C), and remained in possession from the date of delivery (15 June 1939) up to the date of the alleged offence.
  • Presented evidence that the accused were active members of the ryots' Association and that the association pursued a programme of forcibly occupying lands not actually cultivated by the zamindar; the accused acted pursuant to that programme and therefore with intent to annoy or intimidate.
  • Maintained that the delivery order was valid: an initial order under section 522 was passed on 16 October 1942 (within one month of conviction) but was stayed by the appellate court; the later order of 7 April 1943 simply gave effect to that earlier order after the stay was vacated, and delivery to the zamindar was proper because the complainant acted as his agent (kotwal/estate servant) and the finding was dispossession by show of force.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vullappa v. Bheema Rao [1918] M.W.N 81; 41 Mad. 156 F.B Quoted by petitioners to support the submission that the prosecution must definitely prove an intention to insult or annoy the person in possession. The court considered this authority but did not accept that it precluded conviction where the person in possession was absent; the court instead relied on additional evidence and other authorities to find intent present in the facts of this case.
In the matter of the petition of Gobind Prasad Invoked (by petitioners) likewise to argue that intention to insult or annoy must be specifically proved. The court noted the submission but treated it together with the other authorities; it found that the association's conduct and witness evidence established intention despite the zamindar's absence.
Chinna Venkatesu v. Peda Kesamma [1931] M.W.N 182; Cr. 6; 54 Mad. 515 Establishes that criminal trespass can be committed even when the person in possession is absent, provided entry was with intent to annoy or intimidate. The court relied on this authority to reject the petitioners' argument that the zamindar's absence precluded intention; combined with testimonial evidence of association activity (P.W.1) and conduct, the court concluded intent to annoy or insult existed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a stepwise factual and legal analysis strictly on the evidence and the record:

  1. Possession and Title Background: The court accepted the trial and appellate courts' findings that the zamindar had obtained a decree (Exhibit A) and that possession had been delivered by the Court (Exhibit C, delivery dated 15 June 1939 or references to 8 June 1939 in the opinion). The court found no reason to disturb that factual finding of zamindar possession prior to the alleged offence.
  2. Rejection of Prior Possession Claim: The accused's claim of prior possession (through Krishnamacharyulu or via the sale deed Exhibit VIII dated 13 June 1941) was considered and rejected. The court observed that Krishnamacharyulu had been a defendant in the civil suit and that a decree and delivery had been made against him; Exhibit VIII post‑dates or closely precedes the alleged incident and did not establish lawful prior possession. The trial and appellate courts' disbelief of the accused's alleged prior possession was affirmed.
  3. Analysis of Cultivation Evidence: Exhibit IX (cultivation account) showed crops in July and October; this was reconciled with the prosecution case that the accused ploughed on 26 July. The court accepted the trial courts' assessment that the karnam’s testimony of an inspection on 15 July was not credible and that description of the land as cultivated in July was compatible with a later ploughing of a portion at the end of July. The court also addressed an apparent inconsistency arising from P.W.2's cross‑examination (that a "major portion" had been ploughed) by noting re‑examination evidence clarifying that the accused ploughed about four acres and that three teams worked, making the physical possibility plausible.
  4. Intention to Annoy or Intimidate: The petitioners argued authorities requiring definite proof of intention to annoy or insult and pointed to the zamindar's absence. The court considered Vullappa v. Bheema Rao and the petition of Gobind Prasad (as cited by petitioners) but relied particularly on Chinna Venkatesu v. Peda Kesamma to emphasize that trespass with intent may be committed even when the possessor is absent. Critically, testimonial evidence (notably P.W.1 and P.W.6) established that the accused were active members of the ryots' Association and that the association pursued a programme to forcibly occupy zamindar lands; P.W.1 stated that the offence was committed under advice of association leaders. On this factual matrix the court concluded that the entry was with intent to annoy and insult the zamindar.
  5. Sentencing and Miscellaneous Points: The court found the sentence (fine of Rs. 30) not excessive in the circumstances. It also addressed procedural objections to the timing of the order for delivery under section 522 CrPC: the court held that the order under section 522 was in fact passed on 16 October 1942 (within one month) but its execution was stayed by the appellate court; the later order of 7 April 1943 merely implemented that earlier order after the stay was vacated and was not itself an untimely section 522 order.
  6. Delivery to Zamindar: As to the argument that delivery should not have been made to the zamindar because he was not the complainant, the court observed that the complainant (the kotwal) was an agent/servant of the zamindar and that the factual finding was that dispossession had occurred by show of force; hence delivery to the zamindar was proper.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Both Criminal Revision Case No. 443 of 1943 and Criminal Revision Petition No. 722 of 1943 are dismissed.

Direct consequences:

  • The convictions of accused Nos. 1 and 2 for criminal trespass, as confirmed by the appellate magistrate, are upheld.
  • The sentence imposed (fine of Rs. 30) is sustained as not excessive.
  • The order directing delivery of possession of the lands to the zamindar is upheld: the court treated the October 16, 1942 order as the operative section 522 order (passed within one month), its execution having been stayed during appeal; the April 7, 1943 order gave effect to that earlier order after the stay was vacated, and delivery to the zamindar was proper because the complainant acted as his agent and dispossession by show of force was found.

Broader legal significance: The opinion applies established case law about intent in criminal trespass (including that absence of the possessor does not preclude an intent to annoy or intimidate) to the specific facts of this dispute. The court affirmed the factual findings of possession, lack of lawful prior possession by the accused, and the association‑led character of the trespass. The opinion does not announce a novel legal principle or depart from the cited precedents; it resolves the petitions on the record before it.

N.T.R
Show all summary ...

Both these arise out of the same case, C.C No. 13 of 1942 on the file of the Sub Magistrate of Jaggayyapeta. The charge against the petitioners, who were accused Nos. 1 and 2 in the case, was that they committed criminal trespass over 62 acres and 57 cents of land in S. No. 26 in T.D No. 232 in Siripuram village in the possession of the zamindar of Munagala on the 26th of July 1941 at about 7 a.m When the complainant, an estate servant, obstructed the accused from ploughing the land, they threatened to cause personal injuries if he interfered. They were charged with offences punishable under sections 352 and 447: but they were acquitted in respect of the offence punishable under section 359 and convicted only for criminal trespass. The matter was taken in appeal to the Sub Divisional Magistrate of Bezwada, who confirmed the conviction and sentence. On the 16th of October 1942, the Sub Magistrate of Jaggayapeta passed an order directing the delivery of the land trespassed to the Zamiadar of Munagala. During the pendency of the appeal, the proceedings were stayed and after the appeal was disposed of and the stay was vacated, an order was passed on the 7th April 1943 directing the delivery of possession of the lands as per the original order. Criminal Revision Case No. 443 of 1943 is against the order of the appellate Magistrate confirming the conviction and sentence, while Criminal Revision Case No. 722 of 1943 is for revising the order of the Sub Magistrate dated 7-4-43 directing the delivery of possession of lands to the zamindar.

The property in dispute measuring 62 acres and 57 cents in extent was the subject matter of a litigation between the Government, an inamdar and the zamindar of Munagala. At the time or the survey, the entire survey field No. 26 measuring 73 acres 18 cents was surveyed as if it was an inam land, but the registered extent of the inam was only 10 acres 61 cents. So the suit was filed for the establishment of the zamindar's rights both in the melwaram and kudiwaram in the 62 acres 57 cents excluding the 10 acres 61 cents, which alone was inam, and for recovery of possession of the same. There was also an alternative prayer that in case the defendants should be considered to have acquired a kudivaram right in the land for the establishment of the plaintiff's melwaram right and for an injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with the said melwaram right of the plaintiff. The Government represented by the Secretary of State for India in Council was the first defendant in the suit. There were five other defendants. The suit was decreed in respect of both the melwaram and kudivaram rights and a decree in ejectment in respect of 62 acres 57 cents was passed, vide Exhibit A. That was on the 8th May 1935. Proceedings in execution were taken and the property was delivered through Court to the zamindar on the 15th of June 1939, Vide Exhibit C. On that date the amin went to the village, marked off the 62 acres 57 cents as shown in a plan attached to the delivery receipt and delivered possession of that land to the agent of the zamindar after removing it from the possession of the defendants. The prosecution case was that after that, the land was lying fallow. There were disputes between the ryots and the zamindar. The ryots' Association wanted the ryots to take possession of the lands which were not actually occupied by the zamindar. In pursuance of this programme of the association these lands were taken possession of by the accused on the 26th July 1941. There were originally seven accused in this case. Of them accused Nos. 1 and 2 are brothers and were the active members of the ryots' association. The other accused were their farm servants. They were acquitted and accused Nos. 1 and 2 alone were convicted and sentenced as stated above. P.W 1, an estate clerk, and P.W 6, who took possession of the land on behalf of the estate were examined to prove that the zamindar of Munagala obtained a decree and also possession of the property in dispute through Court. P.W 2, the kotwal of Siripuram village and a servant of the zamindar was the complainant and he stated that when he found the accused attempting to plough the land he obstructed them. He was necked out by the third accused at the instigation of the first accused and the others abused him in foul language. He reported the matter to the estate authorities and again went to the land with some others. He found the accused actually ploughing it. They refused to heed their words when they were asked to give up ploughing the land and get away. The Village Munsif, P.W 3 and P.W 4, who went with P.W 2, corroborated his version. The accused's version was that they have been in possession of the land prior to the date of offence and denied the trespass. They attempted to show that the entire 73 acres 18 cents had belonged to the inamdar in various shares. The first accused's case was that he purchased the share of one Krishnamacharyulu under Exhibit VIII and that even prior to the same he was in possession as a lessee. Both the courts found that the alleged prior possession of the accused was not true and they committed trespass into the land and found them guilty of trespass.

It is urged before me that it is not all trespass that would amount to criminal trespass and that there is nothing in this case to indicate that the trespass was caused with the intent to annoy, intimidate or insult the zamindar. The prosecution case was that the petitioners were members of the ryots' association and it was with a view to annoy, intimidate and insult the zamindar that all lands not cultivated and in the possession of the zamindar were sought to be trespassed upon by the ryots and that is how the appellants came to trespass upon this land. Both the courts have found that the appellants entered into the land with intent to annoy, intimidate and insult the zamindar who was in possession of the land. I do not think there are any grounds for differing from the findings of the two Courts that the zamindar was in possession of the lands from the date of the delivery on 8th June 1939 and prior to the date of occurrence and that the petitioners trespassed upon them. The version that they were in possession before the date of offence is not one that could be accepted. Krishnamacharyulu, through whom the first accused in this case claims a right to the property, was a party to the suit O.S 659 of 1934 on the file of the District Munsif's Court of Bezwada. That suit was not only in respect of the melwaram right but also in respect of the kudivaram right and Krishnamacharyulu was the fourth defendant in that suit and a decree in ejectment was passed. Exhibit C shows that there was a delivery of possession on 8th June 1939. Exhibit VIII, a sale deed to the first accused, is dated 13th June 1941, a few days prior to the alleged date of occurrence. Exhibit IX, the cultivation account, no doubt shows that there were crops of ground-nuts, sajja and anumulu in July and jonna in October on that land. But then if the trespass was at the end of July and it is stated by the prosecution that the petitioners cultivated the land after ploughing it on the 26th July there was nothing wrong in the karnam describing the land as having been cultivated in July. The karnam's evidence on this point that he inspected the land on the 15th July was not believed by the two Courts and I see no reason to differ from those findings.

It is next urged that P.W 2 in cross-examination stated that a major portion of the land was ploughed when he went near the field. From this it was sought to be inferred that it would not have been possible to have ploughed a major portion of the 62 acres odd on the morning of the date of occurrence itself. But then it was elicited in re-examination that the accused ploughed about 4 acres and if in cross examination by a major portion of land was meant the 4 acres that was ploughed it must have been possible to plough a major portion of the four acres on the morning of the date of occurrence, as the evidence itself was to the effect that it was not one team but three teams that entered the land to plough.

It is urged for the petitioners on the strength of the observations in Vullappa v. Bheema Rao [1918] M.W.N 81; 41 Mad. 156 F.B, and In the matter of the petition of Gobind Prasad2 that the prosecution will have to prove definitely that there was an intention to insult or annoy the zamindar. It was further stated that the zamindar was not present then and there could have been no intention to annoy him. But as pointed out in Chinna Venkatesu v. Peda Kesamma 3 [1931] M.W.N 182; Cr. 6; 54 Mad. 515 an offence of criminal trespass could be committed even when the person in possession of the property is absent, provided the entering into or upon the property was done with intent to annoy or intimidate. In this case there is evidence that the appellants were active members of the ryots association; vide the evidence of P.W 1. There was an agitation by the association to highhandedly take possession of the land which was the subject matter of the case and also other similar lands when this offence was committed. P.W 1 stated that this offence was committed under the advice of the leaders of the ryots' association. It is therefore clear that when the object of the association was to take possession of the lands in the possession of the zamindar in a highhanded manner, the trespass must have been with intent to annoy and insult him and the mere fact that he was not present would not indicate that there could have been no intent to annoy or insult. A man need not necessarily be insulted by acts done in his presence. I therefore find that the petitioners were rightly convicted. The sentence of a fine of Rs. 30 cannot at all be said to be excessive. Criminal Revision Case No. 443 of 1943 is accordingly dismissed.

With regard to the other petition, namely, Criminal Revision Case No. 722 of 1943, it is said that under section 522 of the Code of criminal Procedure, the order must be passed within one month. The judgment in the case convicting the accused was delivered on the 28th September 1942 by the Sub Magistrate of Jaggayyapeta. Since the order sought to be revised was passed on 7-4-43 it is stated that this is invalid. Further it is contended that the order directing the delivery to the zamindar and not to the complainant was invalid. The order directing delivery was first passed on the 16th October 194a within one month from the date of the conviction, but the execution of that order was stayed under the orders of the appellate court and it was only after the appellate court dismissed the appeal and the stay order was vacated, the order could be executed and that is how the second order came to be passed on 7-4-43. The order dated 7-4-43 is not the order passed under section 522 of the Code. That order was passed on the 16th October 1942 itself. Only it was given effect to later, since till then there was a stay by the appellate Court.

The next contention is that the delivery should not have been ordered to be made to the zamindar since he was not the complainant. But then the complainant was the kotwal, the agent of the zamindar and the finding was that the zamindar was dispossessed of the land by show of force. In these circumstances the order was rightly made. Criminal Revision Petition No. 722 of 1943 is also dismissed.

N.T.R