Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dina Nath Mitter Judgment-Debtor, v. Bejoy Krishna Das And Others Decree-Holders,

Calcutta High Court
May 29, 1903
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

By a decree dated 17 March 1888 in a suit to enforce a mortgage, the Court ordered the defendant to deposit Rs. 15,459-3 annas in Court (Rs. 14,595 claimed by the plaintiff and Rs. 864-3 costs) within six months, failing which the mortgaged property was to be realised by sale. The mortgaged property was put up for sale in 1888 and sold, the sale being completed on 22 February 1889. The decree was not fully satisfied; decree-holders proceeded against other properties of the judgment-debtor, which were sold for Rs. 1,450 and purchased by the decree-holders (sale taken on 20 May 1889 and confirmed 25 June). The benefit of the decree was assigned to predecessors of the present appellants. Assignees applied for further execution and other properties were attached. On 10 November 1896 the judgment-debtor objected that the decree did not permit proceedings against properties other than the mortgaged ones and that execution could not proceed unless a decree were obtained under sec. 90 of the Transfer of Property Act; the attachment remained but the execution was not proceeded with and no order was made on that objection. On 4 June 1898 the decree-holders applied for a decree under sec. 90 of the Transfer of Property Act; the Court below granted such a decree. The judgment-debtors have appealed against the making of that decree.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a supplemental decree under sec. 90 of the Transfer of Property Act ought to have been made in the circumstances of this case.
  2. Whether sec. 90 applies where the original decree is a personal decree against the mortgagor permitting execution against any of the mortgagor's properties other than those mortgaged.

Arguments of the Parties

Judgment-debtors' Arguments

  • The decree did not provide for decree-holders proceeding against properties other than the mortgaged ones; execution could not lawfully proceed against other properties unless a decree was obtained under sec. 90 of the Transfer of Property Act.

Decree-holders' Position

  • The decree-holders applied for a decree under sec. 90; the opinion does not record a detailed account of their legal arguments supporting that application.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court (Maclean, C.J.) held that sec. 90 of the Transfer of Property Act contemplates the making of a supplemental decree in the specific situation where the net proceeds of sale of the mortgaged property prove insufficient to pay the amount due on the mortgage for the time being. The section does not apply where the original decree is a personal decree against the mortgagor under which the mortgagee can, in execution, proceed against any property of the mortgagor other than that comprised in the mortgage. The Court reasoned that it is unreasonable to make a supplemental decree under sec. 90 when the decree-holder already has an existing personal decree enabling him to obtain the relief sought by executing against other properties. Because a decree under sec. 90 was not necessary in the circumstances, it ought not to have been made.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; ORDER OF THE COURT BELOW DISCHARGED.

Direct effect: the decree made under sec. 90 of the Transfer of Property Act by the Court below is set aside. Under the circumstances the Court ordered that no costs be awarded either in this Court or in the Court below. The opinion does not state any broader precedent beyond the application of sec. 90 to the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

Maclean, C.J:— By a decree, dated the 17th of March 1888, made in the present suit, which was a suit to enforce a mortgage, it was ordered:—“That the suit be decreed; that the Defendant do deposit the total amount of Rs. 15,459-3 annas in the Court, Rs. 14,595 being the amount claimed by the Plaintiff and Rs. 864-3 annas being the amount of costs, within six months' time from the date of the decree, ??? Defendant fails to deposit ??? the said time fixed, the ??? be realised by sale of the ??? mortgage; and if there ??? surplus sale-proceeds, it ??? turned to the judgment-debtor; ??? Defendant do pay to the ??? Rs. 14,595 under claim, and ??? on account of costs, in 5,459-3 together with interest ??? per annum from the date ??? of the suit until realization.

??? clear from the terms of that ??? there was a personal decree ??? Defendant for the payment ??? of Rs. 15,459 in all. The ??? was put up for sale on the 17th ??? 1888, and was sold for ??? the decree-holders being ??? and the sale was ??? on the 22nd of February 1889. ??? decree not having been fully satisfied, ??? decree-holders proceeded against ??? properties of the judgment-debtor, ??? those properties were sold for ??? 1,450 and the decree-holders ??? purchased them. The sale took ??? on the 20th of May 1889, and ??? confirmed on the 25th of June. ??? benefit of the decree was ??? assigned to the predecessors in ??? of the present Appellants. The assignees of the decree then applied for further execution of it against other properties of the judgment-debtor, and the same were attached. It is clear that these proceedings in execution could only have been taken, and were only taken, upon the footing that there was a personal decree against the judgment-debtor for the whole of the mortgage debt. On the 10th of November 1896, the judgment-debtor objected that the decree did not provide for the decree-holders proceeding against properties other than the mortgaged ones, and, that the execution could not proceed unless a decree were obtained under sec. 90 of the Transfer of Property Act. In consequence of that objection, the last execution proceedings were not proceeded with, though the attachment remained in force: no order apparently was made upon this objection raised by the judgment-debtor. On the 4th of June 1898, the present application was made by the decree-holders asking for a decree under sec. 90 of the Transfer of Property Act. The Court below made a decree under sec. 90, and the judgment-debtors, although they insisted that such a decree was necessary, have now appealed against its having been made.

The only question argued before us is whether that order ought to have been made. In my opinion, sec. 90 contemplates the making of a supplemental decree in the special case provided for by that section, namely, the nett proceeds of any sale of the mortgaged property proving insufficient to pay the amount due for the time being on the mortgage, and does not apply to a case where the original decree is a personal one against the mortgagor, under which the mortgagee can, in execution, proceed against any property of the mortgagor other than that comprised in the mortgage. It does not seem reasonable that a Court should make a supplemental decree under sec. 90, when the decree-holder can obtain all he wants by putting in force an existing decree in his favour, against the judgment-debtor. No order under sec. 90 was necessary, and, if not necessary, I do not think it ought to have been made.

The appeal, therefore, must be allowed and the order of the Court below discharged. But under the circumstances of the case we give no costs either in this Court or in the Court below.

Appeal allowed.