Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M.R.P.R.S. Shanmuganatha Chettiar v. K. Srinivasa Ayyar

Madras High Court
Mar 22, 1916
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Subordinate Judge of Coimbatore found that the execution of certain promissory notes and payment of consideration for them were proved. The notes were executed by the first defendant (who is described as the father of defendants Nos. 2, 3 and 4) and by the fifth defendant. Defendants Nos. 5, 6 and 7 are brothers and members of a joint Hindu family; the text states they had nothing to do with the first defendant except in relation to this business.

The evidence established a joint business in rice and tobacco carried on by defendants Nos. 1, 5 and 6. The trial court (Subordinate Judge) entered a decree that, among other things, awarded interest on Rs. 7,000 from the date of the suit. This opinion records appellate consideration of (a) whether the seventh defendant was a partner and thus liable, (b) whether the sixth defendant (who did not execute the promissory notes) could be held liable, and (c) the correct basis for calculating interest and costs. The appellate court modified the decree by excluding the seventh defendant's liability, recalculating interest to exclude interest taken in advance, and allocating costs between the parties.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the seventh defendant was a partner in the joint business carried on by defendants Nos. 1, 5 and 6 and therefore liable on the promissory notes.
  2. Whether the sixth defendant, who did not execute the promissory notes and where the notes do not purport to have been executed on behalf of the firm, can nonetheless be held liable for the debt incurred for the partnership business.
  3. Whether the existence of promissory notes (executed contemporaneously with the advance) prevents a suit on the antecedent debt or merges the debt into the negotiable instrument such that liability can be enforced only on the note.
  4. The correct calculation of interest where the principal sum includes an amount described as "interest taken in advance."

Arguments of the Parties

Sixth Defendant's Arguments

  • The sixth defendant contended that because he did not execute the promissory notes and the notes do not purport to have been executed on behalf of the firm, he could not be held liable in the present action.
  • The argument advanced that the present suit is on the promissory notes and not for recovery of the debt evidenced by those notes; where money is borrowed on a promissory note, the debt becomes merged in the note and an action would lie only on the note unless there is evidence of an intention that defendants should be liable on the original obligation as well.
  • Strong reliance was placed (for this contention) on the decisions in Somasundaram v. Krishnamurthi and Muthu Sastrigal v. Visvanatha Pandhara Sannadhi.

Plaintiffs' Evidence (as summarized in the opinion)

  • The plaintiffs' first witness sought to show that the seventh defendant was interested in the joint trade.
  • The plaintiffs' second witness was the first defendant, who stated distinctly that the seventh defendant was not a partner; the court describes this witness as not being prejudiced in favour of the seventh defendant and as having knowledge as to who the partners were.

Respondents' Pleader on Interest

  • Mr. T. E. Ramachandra Ayyar, the learned pleader for the respondents, pointed out that the Subordinate Judge allowed interest on Rs. 7,000 from the date of institution of the suit, whereas that sum included Rs. 167-8-0 described as interest taken in advance; he argued interest should be allowed only on Rs. 6,832-8-0 from the date of the suit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Somasundaram v. Krishnamurthi Relied upon by respondents' counsel to support the proposition that where money is borrowed on a promissory note the debt becomes merged in the note and an action can lie only on the note. The court observed that it was not entirely clear that the judges in that case intended to lay down the broad proposition urged by respondents; the opinion did not accept Somasundaram as decisive against holding a partner liable for a partnership debt simply because another partner executed a note.
Muthu Sastrigal v. Visvanatha Pandhara Sannadhi Relied upon in support of the merger argument; the decision (by Sadasiva Ayyar and Spencer, JJ.) was based mainly on provisions of section 91 of the Indian Evidence Act because the promissory note in that case was inadmissible (it was unstamped). The court noted that in that case the promissory note was inadmissible and therefore the suit (which was based on the note) failed; the court distinguished that factual situation from the present one where the note was admissible and there was no contention that the debt had been intended to merge into the note.
Karmali Abdulla v. Karimji Jiwanji (Privy Council) Illustrates that a partner who did not draw or sign a bill or note may nonetheless be liable where the money raised by the instrument was required for and utilized in the partnership business; the decision treats the matter not as purely liability on the bill but as liability arising from partnership obligations. The court treated this decision as concluding that a partner can be liable for partnership debts even though he did not execute the bill or note, where the money was raised for partnership purposes. The opinion relies on this authority to reject the sixth defendant's contention that non-execution of the notes absolved him of liability.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a structured factual and legal analysis:

  1. Factual findings of the Subordinate Judge — execution of the promissory notes and payment of consideration — were accepted as proved. The court recognised a joint business in rice and tobacco carried on by defendants Nos. 1, 5 and 6.
  2. On the seventh defendant's liability, the court examined documentary and testimonial evidence relied upon by the Subordinate Judge (notably Exhibits W and R and plaintiffs' witness testimony). It found that Exhibits W and R did not establish that the seventh defendant was a partner: Exhibit W "does not prove anything of the kind" and Exhibit R "apparently refers to some business other than the one" in the suit. The plaintiffs' first witness tried to show interest by the seventh defendant, but the first defendant (the plaintiffs' second witness) unequivocally stated that the seventh defendant was not a partner. Given the conflict and the first defendant's authoritative testimony on who the partners were, the court held the evidence insufficient to make out that the seventh defendant was interested in the business carried on by defendants Nos. 1, 5 and 6. Consequently, seventh defendant was not liable.
  3. On the sixth defendant's liability, the court tested the argument that a promissory note executed contemporaneously with an advance necessarily merged the debt and prevented a suit on the original obligation. The court rejected the absolute form of that contention:
    • It observed that Muthu Sastrigal concerned an inadmissible (unstamped) promissory note and therefore the suit failed on evidentiary grounds under section 91 of the Indian Evidence Act; that factual circumstance does not govern the present case.
    • It found Somasundaram to be unclear on whether it supported the broad proposition urged for the respondents, and expressed that the contention would lead to an untenable result (i.e., that a firm would escape liability simply because one partner executed a note).
    • Relying on the Privy Council decision in Karmali Abdulla v. Karimji Jiwanji, the court accepted the proposition that where money is raised and used for partnership business, a partner who did not execute the instrument may nonetheless be liable for the debt. The Privy Council treated the question not purely as one of liability on the instrument but as one of partnership liability for debts properly incurred.
    • The court noted that it is open to parties to show an intention that the debt be merged into the negotiable instrument, but observed that no such case was advanced here.
    On that basis the court held that the sixth defendant's liability was made out despite his not signing the promissory notes.
  4. On interest, the court accepted the submission that the Subordinate Judge had allowed interest on Rs. 7,000 from the date of institution of the suit whereas that sum included Rs. 167-8-0 described in the record as interest taken in advance. The court held that interest should be allowed only on Rs. 6,832-8-0 (i.e., Rs. 7,000 minus Rs. 167-8-0) from the date of the suit, and ordered modification of the decree accordingly.
  5. On costs, the court allocated costs such that the sixth defendant would bear the costs of the appellants and the appellants would pay the costs of the seventh defendant (language drawn from the opinion).

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • The seventh defendant is not liable — the evidence did not show he was a partner or otherwise interested in the joint business carried on by defendants Nos. 1, 5 and 6.
  • The sixth defendant is liable — notwithstanding that he did not execute the promissory notes, he was held liable for the partnership debt because the money was raised for and used in the partnership business and there was no evidence that the parties intended the debt to be merged in the notes.
  • The decree of the Lower Court is modified by (a) declaring the seventh defendant not liable, and (b) recalculating interest so that interest is allowed only on Rs. 6,832-8-0 from the date of the suit (i.e., excluding Rs. 167-8-0 which represented interest taken in advance).
  • Costs: The sixth defendant will bear the costs of the appellants, and the appellants will pay the costs of the seventh defendant.

Implications: The decision applies the principle (supported by the Privy Council authority cited) that a partner may be held liable for partnership debts incurred for and used in the partnership business even if he did not execute the instrument (bill or promissory note) used to raise the money, unless there is evidence the parties intended the debt to merge into the instrument. The opinion does not assert that it is laying down a new general precedent beyond its application of cited authorities; the practical consequences are the reallocation of liability, modification of interest computation, and specific costs orders between the parties in this case.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Abdur Rahim, J.:— The learned Subordinate Judge of Coimbatore has found that the execution of the promissory notes in question has been proved and also that consideration was paid for them. These notes were executed by the first defendant father of defendants Nos. 2, 3 and 4, and by the fifth defendant. Defendants Nos. 5, 6 and 7 are brothers and members of a joint Hindu family. They have nothing to do with the first defendant except so far as this business is concerned.

There can be no doubt that there was a joint business carried on in rice and tobacco by the defendants Nos. 1, 5 and 6. But so far as the liability of the seventh defendant goes, the evidence does not show with sufficient clearness that he was a partner in the joint business carried on by the defendants Nos. 1, 5 and 6, Exhibit W which was relied on by the Subordinate Judge in order to make out that the seventh defendant; was a partner does not prove anything of the kind. Nor does Exhibit R. Exhibit R apparently refers to some business other than the one which is under consideration in this suit. Then we have the evidence of the plaintiffs' first witness with regard to the liability of the seventh defendant. No doubt, he seeks to make out that the seventh defendant was interested in the joint trade in question. On the other hand, the plaintiffs' second witness, who was the first defendant and who cannot be said to be prejudiced in any way in favour of the seventh defendant and whose knowledge as to who were the partners cannot be disputed, distinctly states that the seventh defendant was not a partner. It must be held that the evidence does not make out that the seventh defendant was interested in the business carried on by the defendants Nos. 1, 5 and 6.

The fifth defendant's liability cannot be disputed because he was one of the two executants of the promissory notes. It is strongly contended on behalf of the sixth defendant that inasmuch as he did not execute the promissory notes, and these notes do not purport to have been executed on behalf of the firm so as to make the firm liable, he cannot be held liable in this action at all. It is argued that the present suit is on the promissory notes and not for recovery of the debt evidenced by those notes. The position taken up is this:—that where money is borrowed on a promissory note, it should be held that the debt became merged in the promissory note and a suit would lie only on the note, at any rate, unless there is evidence of intention that the defendants were to be liable for the debt as well. Strong reliance is placed in support of this contention on Somasundaram v. Krishnamurthi(1) and Muthu Sastrigal v. Visvanatha Pandhara Sannadhi(2). As regards the latter case which is a decision of Sadasiva Ayyar and Spencer, JJ., the learned Judges (at least Sadasiva Ayyar, J.), based the decision mainly on the provisions of section 91 of the Indian Evidence Act. The promissory note on which action was brought in that case, was inadmissible in evidence as it was an unstamped note. The view taken by the learned Judges was that as the suit was based on the note and that was inadmissible in evidence, the suit must fail. In that case, there was no question of the liability of the partners on account of the debt evidenced by the promissory note. In Somasundaram v. Krishnamurthi that question did arise. It does not seem quite clear whether the learned Judges, Subrahmanya Ayyar, J., and the present Chief Justice intended to lay down that, if the suit was so framed as to make the defendants liable on their original obligation for the debt, the action could not be maintained because of the existence of the promissory note. The proposition contended for on behalf of the respondents amounts to nothing less than this; that if a member of a firm who is authorized to borrow money borrows it and executes a promissory note, the firm will not be held liable for the debt at all, though it would be liable if he had not executed the note. This is prima facie untenable and I think the matter is concluded by a recent decision of the Privy Council—Karmali Abdulla v. Karimji Jiwanji. In that case, each of the two partners who were found to have been carrying on a joint venture drew bills of exchange for his share and the plaintiff who accepted those bills afterwards sought to make the partner who did not execute the bill in question, also liable. The High Court of Bombay in reversing the decision of the trial Judge, pointed out that the suit was not based on the bill, but their Lordships held that it was erroneous to treat the question as purely a question of liability on the bill. Then, having found that, as a matter of fact, there existed the relationship of partners between the two defendants and that the money which was paid on the bill, was required and utilized in the partnership business, they held that the partner who did not draw the bill, was also liable.

It is true that the question whether, the bills having been drawn and accepted, the suit could be maintained against a partner who did not take any part in drawing the bill, was not discussed before the Board; but the decision could not be explained unless the Judicial Committee were of opinion that although the person sought to be made liable was not the drawer of the bill, still he was liable because the money was raised for and used in the partnership business. Apparently no contention was raised to the contrary apparently because no question could be raised with any chance of success as to the liability of a partner for a debt properly incurred on behalf of the partnership simply because a promissory note had been executed for the debt. There is no doubt so far as it appears from the authorities referred to at the bar, that where there exists an antecedent debt and a promissory note is executed for such a debt, a suit on the promissory note failing, an action on the debt would lie. The whole contention is that because the advance of money and the execution of the promissory note were simultaneous, a suit would lie only on the promissory note and not on the debt evidenced by it. There seams to be nothing in reason in support of such a distinction. It may be open to the parties to show that it was intended that the debt should become merged in the negotiable instrument executed for it. But no such case was sought to be made here. I think therefore that the sixth defendant's liability is made out. It is pointed out by Mr. T.E Ramachandra Ayyar the learned pleader for the respondents, that the Subordinate Judge has allowed interest on Rs. 7,000, the principal amount borrowed on the promissory notes from the date of the institution of the suit, while that sum, as a matter of fact, included Rs. 167-8-0, the amount of interest taken in advance, Interest therefore ought to be allowed only on Rs. 6,832-8-0 from the date of the suit instead of on Rs. 7,000. The decree of the Lower Court will be modified by declaring that the seventh defendant is not liable and by calculating the interest payable in the manner I have indicated. The sixth defendant will bear the coats of the appellants and the appellants will pay the costs of the seventh defendant.

Srinivasa Ayyangar, J.:— I agree. There is a distinction between liability on the bill or the note and liability on the consideration for the bill or the note. This is clearly brought out in cases in England where an infant executes a note or gives a bill for what are called necessaries. In these cases, he is not liable on the bill or the note, but is liable for the consideration which he gets in the shape of necessaries. If the bill or note is endorsed, the endorses cannot recover anything, because the endorsement does not pass title to the consideration, but only to the bill or the note. That is one illustration.

So far as I am able to see, there is absolutely nothing in the Negotiable Instruments Act to prevent A from promising to pay B's debt or from promising to be jointly liable along with B either as a partner or otherwise, so that in cases of partnership; where one partner borrows for the benefit of the joint trade, the other partner agrees to make himself liable for the debt, though he may not be liable on the bill or the note which was executed by the other partner unless, of course, his signature appears on the face of the bill either as signed by him or his agent duly authorized to sign his name. Unless therefore there is any particular restriction, express or implied, in respect of any liability to be incurred by one partner with regard to a bill or promissory note which may be executed by the other partner, I really do not see how he can escape liability for a partnership debt. If, no doubt, the bill or note is endorsed to a third party, it may be that the endorsee will not be able to bring an action on that bill or note against the other partner or even on the debt against the other party. Except for that difference, the debt is certainly payable by the partner who did not sign the bill. That distinction is clearly brought out in a recent decision of the Privy Council in Karmali Abdulla v. Karimji Jiwanji. In that case, the first defendant firm and second defendant firm were found upon a construction of the agreement; between them and from other evidences, to be partners in a certain sugar trade. The plaintiff was financing that trade, and the arrangement was that the bills drawn either by the first defendant firm or the second defendant firm with respect to the sugar shipped by them, should be honoured by the plaintiff by accepting them. By so accepting those bills, if they were issued by the second defendant firm, the second defendant firm will be liable and if issued by the first defendant firm, that will be liable on the bills. It so happened in that case that the bills which were drawn by the first defendant firm had all been retired while those drawn by the second defendant firm had not beer, and the second defendant firm had become insolvent. The first defendant firm made itself liable for the debts borrowed by the second defendant firm for the purpose of the partnership transactions. In these circumstances, an action was brought to recover the balance due on these acceptances by the plaintiff on behalf of the second defendant firm of bills drawn by it after crediting the value of the goods sent along with the bills. The suit as against the first defendant firm was put in as an action for the balance of the debt; it is called an action of accounting against it in the course of the judgment. The first defendant firm was held liable for the money due on account of the acceptance by the plaintiff of the bills drawn by the second defendant firm.

N.R