Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Lakshmi Ammal v. Sun Life Assurance Co. Of Canada

Madras High Court
Sep 26, 1933
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, a widow, filed a suit claiming a sum of Rs. 3210 under the Indian Married Women's Property Act (Act III of 1874) on the ground that a trust was created in her favor by her deceased husband's life insurance policy. The husband had insured his life in 1906 with the New York Life Insurance Company in Calcutta, which was later taken over by the defendants, Sun Life Assurance Company of Canada. The husband had obtained a loan against the policy and surrendered it in 1926. After his death in 1929, the plaintiff sought to recover the money from the defendants but was referred to the Official Trustee of Bengal and later to the Official Trustee of Madras, both of whom declined to proceed without funds from her. Consequently, she sued the defendant company as a pauper. The learned Chief Justice dismissed the suit on the ground that, assuming a cause of action existed, the plaintiff was not the proper person to institute the suit. The plaintiff appealed this decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff was the proper person to institute the suit for recovery of the money under the insurance policy.
  2. Whether a trust was created in favor of the plaintiff under Section 6 of the Indian Married Women's Property Act.
  3. Whether Section 59 of the Indian Trusts Act, 1882, entitled the plaintiff to institute the suit in the absence or impracticability of the trustee's execution of the trust.
  4. Whether the application of Section 6 of the Married Women's Property Act extends to a policy effected in 1906 by a Hindu husband.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • A trust was created in her favor under Section 6 of the Married Women's Property Act.
  • The Official Trustee of the Presidency where the insurance was effected is the proper person to enforce the trust, but since they declined to act without funds, she is entitled under Section 59 of the Indian Trusts Act to institute the suit herself.
  • In the special circumstances of the case, the plaintiff should be allowed to sue as the beneficiary.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The plaintiff is not the proper person to institute the suit; the Official Trustee of Bengal should enforce the trust.
  • Section 6 of the Married Women's Property Act does not apply to policies effected before 1923 by Hindu husbands, as per the view of the Calcutta High Court.
  • The Official Trustees have not disclaimed trusteeship; therefore, the plaintiff cannot rely on Section 59 of the Indian Trusts Act to sue directly.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Balamba v. Krishnayya Clarification that under Section 6 of the Married Women's Property Act, the person entitled to enforce the rights of the beneficiary is the trustee or, if none appointed, the Official Trustee. The court relied on this authority to affirm that the Official Trustee of Bengal is the proper party to institute the suit, not the plaintiff.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed whether the plaintiff was the proper party to institute the suit. It noted that under Section 6 of the Indian Married Women's Property Act, the sum secured by the policy is payable to the Official Trustee of the Presidency where the insurance office is located, who holds it upon the trusts expressed in the policy. The court observed that the Official Trustee of Bengal, where the policy was effected, is the proper person to enforce the trust. Although the plaintiff relied on Section 59 of the Indian Trusts Act to sue in the absence or impracticability of the trustee, the court found no evidence that the Official Trustee of Bengal or Madras had disclaimed trusteeship or that execution of the trust had become impracticable. Hence, the plaintiff could not rely on that provision.

Further, the court acknowledged the conflicting view of the Calcutta High Court that Section 6 does not apply to policies effected before 1923 by Hindu husbands, and thus it would be improper for the court sitting in Madras to declare a trust under this section for a policy effected in Calcutta in 1906. Consequently, the court upheld the dismissal of the suit on the ground that the plaintiff was not the proper person to institute the suit.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED THE APPEAL with costs.

The direct effect of this decision is that the plaintiff, as the beneficiary, is not entitled to institute the suit for recovery under the insurance policy; instead, the Official Trustee of Bengal is the proper party to enforce the trust. No new precedent was established, and the court refrained from deciding on the merits of the trust's existence under Section 6 of the Married Women's Property Act.

Show all summary ...

Madhavan Nair, J. — The plaintiff is the appellant. The question for determination in this appeal is whether the suit out of which this appeal arises was properly instituted by the plaintiff.

The plaintiff is a widow. In 1906 her husband insured his life for the benefit of his wife for a sum of Rs. 2000 with the New York Life Insurance Company whose office was situate in Calcutta. The business of the New York Life Insurance Company in India has since been taken over by the defendants, the Sun Life Assurance Company of Canada. The plaintiff's husband obtained a loan of Rs. 600 from the defendants and in 1926 he surrendered his policy receiving a sum of Rs. 700 and odd exercising an option reserved in his favour in the policy. In 1929 the plaintiff's husband died. She now claims to recover the money under the Indian Married Women's Property Act (Act III of 1874) on the ground that under S. 6 of the Act a trust has been created in her favour. In the present suit she asks for a declaration that a trust was created by her deceased husband and that she is the beneficiary thereunder and that the Official Trustee of Madras or such other fit and proper person be appointed to execute the trust and that a direction be given to him to pay her the sum of Rs. 3210.

After the death of her husband the plaintiff approached the defendants for the recovery of the amount alleged to be due to her under the insurance policy effected by her husband. She was referred by them to the Official Trustee of Bengal. Having regard to the decisions of the Calcutta High Court the view of which I may say is different to the view of our own Court he felt a doubt whether since the policy was effected in the year 1906, the Married Women's Property Act would apply and wrote to her saying that he was prepared to proceed with the matter of recovering the money from the company only if he was supplied with funds by her. She then applied to the Official Trustee of Madras. He also gave her a similar reply. Being thus defeated in her endeavours to get the money under the policy, she sued the defendant company as a pauper. Various issues were settled in the case. The learned Chief Justice dismissed the suit on the ground that assuming that she has a cause of action, which was not decided, she was not the proper person to institute the suit.

In appeal it is argued before us that that decision is wrong and that in the circumstances of the case she is the proper person to institute the suit. The contention of the plaintiff is that a trust has been created in her favour by force of S. 6 of the Married Women's Property Act. The second paragraph of that section says “When the sum secured by the policy becomes payable, it shall, unless special trustees are duly appointed to receive and hold the same, be paid to the Official Trustee of the Presidency in which the office at which the insurance was effected is situate, and shall be received and held by him upon the trusts expressed in the policy, or such of them as are then existing.” This section lays down the machinery for recovering, if a trust is created in favour of the wife, the money covered by the trust, and having regard to the words of the Section it seems that the Official Trustee of the Presidency in which the office at which the insurance was effected is situate is the proper person to enforce the trust. In Balamba v. Krishnayya (1) It was pointed out, though the question did not directly arise for decision in that case, by Sir Arnold White, C. J., that under S. 6 “the person entitled to enforce the rights of the beneficiary is the trustee, if a trustee has been appointed, and if no special trustee has been appointed the Official Trustee, to whom the money is payable.” Having regard to the fact that in this case the contract was entered into by the plaintiff's husband with the New York Life Insurance Company at Calcutta, it would appear that the proper person to institute the suit would be the Official trustee of Bengal. Reliance is placed upon S. 59 of the Indian Trusts Act, II of 1882, in support of the contention that in the special circumstances of this case the plaintiff is entitled to institute a suit even though ordinarily it may be the Official Trustee of the Presidency in which the office at which the insurance was effected is situate, who would be the proper person to institute the suit. S. 59 runs as follows:—“When no trustees are appointed or all the trustees die, disclaim, or are discharged, or where for any other reason the execution of a trust by the trustee is or becomes inpracticable, the beneficiary may institute a suit for the execution of the trust, and the trust shall, so far as may be possible, be executed by the Court until the appointment of a trustee or new trustees.” It is not said in this case that the Official Trustee of Bengal has declined to act though he asks the plaintiff to provide him with funds before taking the necessary proceedings; nor has the Official Trustee of Madras declined to take proceedings if it is the case of the plaintiff that the cause of action arose in Madras. We have not been shown that the execution of the trust has become impracticable. In these circumstances the plaintiff is not entitled to rely on S. 59 of the Indian Trusts Act to institute a suit in her name for the enforcement of the trust. This was the view of the learned Chief Justice and it seems to me that that view is correct. The case as pointed out by the learned Chief Justice is an unfortunate one for the plaintiff but as she is not the proper person to institute the suit the only order that can be passed by this Court is that the suit should be dismissed.

If the plaintiff could institute the suit and if the cause of action can be said to have arisen in Madras, then according to the decisions of the Madras High Court she would succeed in getting a decision in her favour that a trust has come into existence by force of S. 6 of the Married Women's Property Act; but in the present case we are not called upon to consider the merits of the case, as the suit has to be dismissed as the plaintiff is not the proper person to institute it.

The appeal is dismissed with costs.

Reilly, J:—In my opinion also we cannot differ from the learned Chief Justice's view that, if the policy in question is, as the Plaintiff maintains, one to which S. 6 of the Married Women's Property Act applies, the person to sue on it on behalf of the plaintiff is the Official Trustee of Bengal, unless he has disclaimed trusteeship in the matter.

In my opinion there is another reason also why the plaintiff's suit in this Court must be dismissed. She sues for a declaration that a trust was created by her husband, Gopalaswami Nayudu, in respect of the policy on his life and that she is the sole beneficiary thereunder. The contract under that policy was that the insurance company should pay the amount of the insurance at their office in Calcutta. The policy was taken out in 1906. We are aware that it is the view of the Calcutta High Court, contrary to the view of this Court, that S. 6 of the Married Women's Property Act does not apply to a policy taken out by a Hindu husband before 1923, and knowing that, I think, it would be clearly improper for this Court to make such a declaration as the plaintiff asks for in respect of this particular policy merely because she chooses to bring her suit in Madras instead of Calcutta.

I agree that this appeal should be dismissed with costs.

N. R. R.Appeal dismissed.