- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Indian Sugar Mills Co., Ltd., In Re
Young, J.:— The liquidator of the Union Indian Sugar Mills Co., Ltd. (in liquidation) has at his disposal a surplus after paying all the creditors of the company. It, therefore, became his duty to divide this pro rata among the shareholders. He naturally proposed to divide this money among those shareholders whose names appear upon the register of shareholders. The five applicants before me today, however, are not registered shareholders. They claim to hold the shares of one Lala Debi Datt as security for loans advanced to him. As security for those loans they took the share certificates and blank transfers. These transactions took place some time before the company went into liquidation. The mortgagees of the shares never took any steps to notify the company officially or to have their names registered as shareholders. They claim, however, that as Lala Debi Datt was the Managing Director of the company and as he himself personally pledged these shares to them, the company must therefore be said to have had notice of the pledging of the shares, and that thereafter the company had no lion upon the shares' in question. The liquidator claims that Lala Debi Datt was indebted to the company for a large sum of money; that under the articles of association the company has a, lien upon all the shares of members for debts owing by the members to the company, and that therefore that share of the surplus which would be due to Lala Debi Datt should not be distributed to the mortgagees of the shares, but should be distributed among the other shareholders.
The law upon this point is clear. A company has a lien upon the shares of its members for debts owing by the members to itself. If, however, a member pledges his shares to some third party as security for a loan, and the company has notice of the transaction, the company loses its lien for all debts owing by that member to the company subsequent to the knowledge of the company of the transaction. The question therefore arises in this case whether the knowledge of Debi Datt of the transaction of the pledging of these shares was the knowledge of the company. If it was, then only that amount of the debt owing by Debi Datt to the company before the pledging of the shares would be distributable among the other shareholders. On the other hand, if the knowledge of Debi Datt was not the knowledge of the company, then the whole amount which would go ordinarily to the applicants would be distributable among the other shareholders.
It is necessary to see in this case who Debi Datt was. It appeal's that Debi Datt was clearly the most important man in this company. He was the Managing Director, and under article 90 of the articles of association it was provided that “Lala Debi Datt shall be the permanent Managing Director of the company under these articles, until such time as the said Lala Debi Datt resigns the office of his own accord; he shall have all powers exercisable by the Directors of the company, either, in management of the affairs of the company or in raising or borrowing any sum or sums of money for the purpose of the company, and he shall not be subject to retirement either by rotation or otherwise.”
It will thus be seen that peculiar and extensive powers were given to Lala Debi Datt by the articles of association. He was by no means an ordinary Managing Director. Further, there is no doubt that he had knowledge of his own transaction in pledging the shares. Under circumstances somewhat similar to these this point of law has been considered in England in Rainford v. James Keith & Blackmark Co., Ltd.(1). It was there held that where three Directors had notice of a charge upon shares in their private or personal capacity, that was good notice to the company. Debi Datt in this case had the powers of the whole Board delegated to him and therefore this authority is applicable. In my opinion, the proposition might also be stated under the ordinary law of principal and agent. Notice to an agent is undoubtedly notice to the principal, and therefore notice to the company's agent would be notice to the company itself. The only exception to this rule would be when the agent is acting in fraud of his principal. Now in this case there is no doubt that Lala Debi Datt in his peculiar position must be held to be the agent of the company. There is equally no doubt that he had notice of the transaction in question. It must, therefore, be held that the company too had notice. This being the case, the lien of the company upon the shares of Lala Debi Datt for any debt due to the company by Lala Debi Datt goes after the date of knowledge of the charge upon the shares. The result will be that such money as Lala Debi Datt owed to the company in each case before the company had knowledge of the particular charge will be divided by the liquidator among the shareholders other than the shareholder who holds that particular charge upon the shares, provided the money owing to the company has not subsequently been paid by Lala Debi Datt. The mortgagees of these shares propose to apply to the court to have their names registered as the shareholders of the shares that are charged to them in place of Lala Debi Datt's name. When that is done and the court has ordered accordingly, the liquidator will pay to these shareholders their pro rata share of the surplus.
Alert