Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Panangipalli Suranna v. Katta Venakata Suryanarayana Jagapathiraju

Madras High Court
Aug 13, 1918
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute arises from the sale in execution of a decree for arrears of rent. Defendants 1 and 2 sued defendant 3 in a Revenue Court for arrears of rent, obtained a money decree and caused the holding to be sold in execution. The property was purchased by defendant 7. The plaintiff claimed to be a mortgagee under a registered mortgage deed dated 6 May 1910 and sued for a declaration that the sale in execution was subject to his mortgage. The District Munsif and the Subordinate Judge took opposite views: the District Munsif held the sale did not affect the prior mortgage (relying on Tariniprosad Roy v. Narayan Kumari), while the Subordinate Judge followed Calcutta High Court authorities (e.g., Royzuddin Sheik v. Kali Nath Mookerjee) and held the sale transferred the property free of encumbrance. The matter reached this Court on second appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the purchaser in execution of a decree for arrears of rent (obtained in a Revenue Court) takes the property subject to a prior mortgage held by the plaintiff, or takes free of that encumbrance.
  2. Whether the statutory charge for rent created by Section 5 of the Madras Estates Land Act is a "charge" within the meaning of Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act, thereby invoking the procedure in Order 34, Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure for enforcement of such charge.
  3. Whether a sale in execution of a Revenue Court decree for rent should have the same effect as a sale by the Collector under Chapter 6 of the Estates Land Act (i.e., pass title free of encumbrances except those preserved by Section 125 of the Estates Land Act), in view of Section 132 of the Estates Land Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The charge created by Section 5 of the Estates Land Act is a "charge" within the meaning of Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act; accordingly Order 34 of the CPC applies and a sale in execution of a simple money decree will not bind a mortgagee or prevent redemption.
  • Relying on observations of Petheram, C.J., in Tariniprosad Roy v. Narayan Kumari, the appellant argued that a sale in execution of a simple money-decree for rent has no greater effect than any other sale in execution of a money-decree, implying the mortgagee's rights should remain protected.
  • Counsel for the appellant also relied on general principles about adopting definitions in the Transfer of Property Act when construing other Acts (citing Narayana Ayyar v. Venkataramana Ayyar) to support reading the Estates Land Act charge as a Section 100 charge.

Respondents' Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' separate legal arguments beyond the positions reflected in the lower courts' findings and the authorities they followed (primarily the Calcutta High Court authorities holding that rent-charge is not a charge within Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act and that a Collector's sale or an equivalent sale passes title free of encumbrances except as reserved by Section 125).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Tariniprosad Roy v. Narayan Kumari Authority for the proposition (as used by the District Munsif) that a sale in execution of a decree for rent does not affect a prior mortgage; contains observations by Petheram, C.J., that form of action should not alter enforcement rights. The District Munsif relied on this case. The opinion records Petheram, C.J.'s observations but notes that other decisions dissent from them; the Court did not follow this case as deciding the present appeal in appellant's favour.
Royzuddin (Royzuddi) Sheik v. Kali Nath Mookerjee Calcutta High Court authority holding that the statutory charge for arrears of rent is not a "charge" within the meaning of Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act, and that a sale for arrears produces effect like a Collector's sale (title free of encumbrances except specified exceptions). The Subordinate Judge and this Court (both Judges who wrote) accepted the Calcutta High Court view and applied it to hold the purchaser in execution takes free of encumbrances except those preserved by Section 125 of the Estates Land Act.
Fotick Chunder Dey Sircar v. E. G. Foley Calcutta High Court decision that a charge for rent is not within the meaning of Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act. Accepted by Phillips, J., (and cited by Kumaraswami Sastri, J.) as supporting the conclusion that Section 100 is inapplicable to statutory rent-charges under the Estates Land Act.
Srimati Maharanee Dasya v. Harendra Lal Roy Authority noting there is no strict analogy between a charge for rent and a mortgage. Used to support the view that a statutory rent-charge is not equivalent to a mortgage for the purposes of Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act.
Gopi Nath Mahapatra v. Kashi Nath Reg. Decision holding that a purchaser in execution of a rent-decree had priority over a purchaser in execution of a mortgage decree. Referred to by Kumaraswami Sastri, J., to show judicial tendency to treat sale for arrears of rent as conferring priority similar to a Collector's sale.
Narayana Ayyar v. Venkataramana Ayyar Observations that where another Act uses words defined in the Transfer of Property Act, courts may adopt those definitions in the absence of repugnance (in context, Limitation Act interpretation). The appellant relied on these observations; the Court (Kumaraswami Sastri, J.) noted these observations are not an imperative rule of construction and did not allow them to determine that Section 100 applies to the statutory rent-charge.
Surbo Lal v. Wilson Case that dissents from the observations of Petheram, C.J., in Tariniprosad Roy. Cited as an example of judicial dissent from Tariniprosad Roy; used to justify not following Petheram, C.J.'s view.
Arthur Henry Forbes v. Maharaja Bahadur Singh S. Privy Council observation that Section 65 (Bengal Tenancy Act) is not well-worded and that the words about "rent being a first charge" appear to be an afterthought. Quoted to show the drafting difficulties with Section 65 and to support the proposition that analogous provisions in other tenancy/estates Acts should be read together rather than by relying solely on a single badly-worded clause.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds on two principal strands: (1) whether the statutory rent-charge created under the Estates Land Act is a "charge" within Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act (with the consequence that Order 34, Rule 14 CPC would apply), and (2) whether a sale in execution of a Revenue Court decree for arrears of rent must, by operation of Section 132 of the Estates Land Act, have the same effect as a Collector's sale under Chapter 6 (i.e., pass title free of encumbrances except those specified in Section 125).

On the first strand the Court (both Phillips, J., and Kumaraswami Sastri, J.) concluded that the statutory charge for rent is not the type of "charge" contemplated by Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act. The textual and practical reasons given in the opinion include:

  • Section 100 refers expressly to security "for the payment of money"; a statutory rent-charge under the Estates Land Act may secure rent payable in kind as well as money, so Section 100's definition (focused on payment of money) is inapt when rent is not payable in money.
  • Where the Estate Land Act treats the rent-charge uniformly (whether rent payable in money or kind), it would be anomalous to hold that in some cases the statutory charge is a Section 100 charge and in others it is not.
  • Section 73 of the Transfer of Property Act (referenced in the opinion) and prior judicial authorities (Fotick Chunder Dey Sircar v. E.G. Foley; Royzuddi/Royzuddin Sheik v. Kali Nath Mookerjee) support the conclusion that a statutory rent-charge is not the same as the Section 100 "charge."
  • The practical consequences of treating the statutory rent-charge as a Section 100 charge (i.e., that a tenant could redeem the charge simply by paying arrears and thereby terminate its continuing operation as security) are inconsistent with the Estates Land Act's scheme, under which the charge continues as security for future rent.

On the second strand, the Court emphasised the statutory framework of the Estates Land Act:

  • Section 5 creates a first charge on the holding for rent. The Act provides several remedies for rent recovery: distraint and sale of movables (Section 77), sale through the Collector (Sections 111–131), and a suit in a Revenue Court under Section 77 with sale in execution of the decree.
  • Section 132 makes the provisions of Chapter 6 (which govern Collector sales for arrears) applicable, so far as may be, to the execution by a Revenue Court of any decree for arrears of rent. The Court read this provision as importing the effect of a Collector's sale — namely, that such sales pass the property free of all encumbrances except those preserved by Section 125.
  • Section 125 specifies the limited exceptions (rights/encumbrances) that survive a Collector's sale; the Court held that equivalents of these exceptions must also be respected in execution sales under Revenue Court decrees by virtue of Section 132.
  • Support for this construction was drawn from (a) the similarity of powers conferred on the Collector under Section 133 when executing a decree and when holding a Chapter 6 sale, and (b) existing case law and commentary (including Ameer Ali's commentary and Calcutta High Court decisions) treating a sale for arrears as conferring a purchaser title free of encumbrances except as reserved.

On these bases the Court concluded (consistently with the Calcutta High Court authorities it accepted) that a statutory rent-charge under the Estates Land Act is not a Section 100 charge, Order 34, Rule 14 CPC is inapplicable, and a sale in execution of a Revenue Court decree for arrears of rent passes the property free from encumbrances except those specifically retained by Section 125 of the Estates Land Act.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

APPEAL DISMISSED. The second appeal is dismissed with costs.

Direct effect on the parties:

  • The purchaser in execution (defendant 7) takes the property free of the plaintiff's prior registered mortgage, subject only to the specific exceptions preserved by Section 125 of the Estates Land Act.
  • The plaintiff's claim for a declaration that the sale in execution was subject to his mortgage therefore fails.

Broader implications: The Court accepted the view (expressed in Calcutta High Court decisions cited in the opinion) that statutory rent-charges under the Estates Land Act are not "charges" within Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act and that a sale in execution of a Revenue Court decree for arrears of rent, by virtue of Section 132, has the same effect as a Collector's sale under Chapter 6 — namely, passing title free of encumbrances except those specified in Section 125. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal doctrine beyond applying these statutory provisions and existing authorities to the facts before it.

Disposition: Second appeal dismissed with costs.

Prepared from the text of the provided opinion. No information has been added beyond what appears in that opinion.

Show all summary ...

Phillips, J.:— The plaint properties were sold to defendant 7 in execution of a decree for rent due upon them, and the sole question for decision is whether the purchase by defendant 7 is subject to plaintiff's mortgage on the properties or not. The two lower Courts have taken opposite views, the District Munsif holding, on the strength of the ruling in Tariniprosad Roy v. Narayan Kumari(1), that a sale in execution of a decree for rent did not affect a prior mortgage, while the Subordinate Judge, following the opinion of the Calcutta High Court in Royzuddin Sheik v. Kali Nath Mookerjee(2), that the statutory charge upon the land for arrears of rent was not a charge within the meaning of Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act, held that the sale transferred the property free of encumbrance.

2. Under Section 5 of the Madras Estates Land Act, a first charge is created upon the land for rent, but the-provision in Section 65 of the Ben. Ten. Act, that the land can be sold in execution of a decree for rent finds no place in the Madras Act, under which a landlord may sue for his rent or distrain moveable property (S. 77) or sell the land through the Collector (S 111). The question is whether having obtained a money decree, the property can be brought to sale in execution with the same result as would follow from a sale effected by the Collector. If the charge upon the land is a charge within the meaning of Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act, the provisions of O. 34, R. 14 of the CPC, clearly forbid the sale of the property except by instituting a suit for sale in enforcement of the charge. Under Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act:

“Where immovable property of one person is by act of parties or operation of law made security for the payment of money to another, and the transaction does not amount to a mortgage, the latter person is said to have a charge on the property and all the provisions hereinbefore contained as to a mortgagor, shall, so far as may be, apply to the owner of such property.”

3. If we apply this section, the owner of the property, i.e the tenant whose holding is security for the rent, is treated as being in the position of a mortgagor, and has the rights of a mortgagor, under Ss. 60 and 61, to redeem the charge, but under the Estates Land Act a tenant cannot get rid of the charge upon his holding by paying the rent for the charge continues as security for rent to be paid here after. It may also be noted that, where rent is payable in kind, the charge for arrears of rent cannot come within the definition in S. 100 which refers only to payment of money, and it would be most anomalous that a charge created by statute should be a charge within the meaning of S. 100 in some cases, but not so in others. The Estates Land Act treats the charge as being of the same nature in all cases, and creates no distinction between the charge where rent is payable in kind and the charge where rent is payable in money. Section 73 of the Transfer of Property Act, would also seem to indicate that a charge for rent is not of the nature contemplated in S. 100. I would therefore accept the view of the Calcutta High Court expressed in Fotick Chunder Dey Sircar v. E.G Foley(3) and Rhozuddi Sheikh v. Kali Nath Mookerjee that a charge for rent is not within the meaning of Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act. In this view O. 34, R. 14 is inapplicable to the present case. There is however another aspect of the case which has to be considered. Under the decree for rent the property can be brought to sale, but if the decree were merely for money due on a debt, the sale would not have the effect of passing the property free of encumbrance, and it is difficult to see how the fact that the debt is a debt for rent can affect the case when the decree is passed by a civil Court. In the present case however we are not concerned with a civil Curt's decree, because the rent decree was obtained in a Revenue Court and under Section 132 of the Estates Land Act the provisions of Ch. 6 relating to sale by a Collector for arrears of rent are made applicable to the execution of a decree of a Revenue Court for arrears of rent. A sale by a Collector under Ch. 6 passes the property free of all encumbrances except those specified in S. 125, and consequently by virtue of S. 132 a sale in execution must do the same. This view is also supported by the fact that under S. 133 the Collector has certain powers given to him both in executing a decree for arrears by sale and in holding a sale for default under Ch. 6, no distinction being drawn between the two sales. Although Section 65 of the Ben. Ten. Act is not specifically re-enacted in the Madras Act, S. 132 of the latter leads to the same result, and I must hold that a sale in execution of a decree for rent in a Revenue Court passes the property to the purchaser free of all encumbrances except those specified in S. 125. This second appeal is accordingly dismissed with costs.

Kumaraswami Sastri, J.:— The plaintiff is the appellant. Defendants 1 and 2 filed a suit in the Revenue Court against defendant 3 for arrears of rent, got a money-decree and in execution sold the holding. The plaintiff who claimed to be a mortgagee under a registered deed of mortgage, dated 6th May 1910, sued for a declaration that the sale in execution was subject to his mortgage. The District Munsif was of opinion that inasmuch as the sale was in execution of a simple money, decree, the decree-holders must be presumed to have given up their lien on the holding conferred by Section 5 of the Estates Land Act, and passed a decree in favour of the plaintiff. On appeal the Subordinate Judge reversed the decree and held that the charge was not affected by the form of the decree. It is argued for the appellant that the charge created by Section 5 of the Estates Land Act, is a charge within the meaning of Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act, so as to attract to it the provisions of O. 34 of the CPC, and that consequently the sale of the property charged in execution of a simple money decree will not bind a mortgagee or prevent him from redeeming. It is also argued on the strength of the observations of Petherano, C.J, in Tariniprosad Roy v. Narayan Kumari that the sale in execution of a simple money-decree for rent would have no higher effect than any other sale in execution of a money-decree. As regards the first contention I do not think that rent due by a tenant to his landlord which may be payable either in kind or in money can be said to be a charge within the meaning of Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act, which expressly refers to the security being only for the payment of money. It is extremely unlikely that the legislature intended that landlords who receive their rent in kind should be on a different footing from those who receive the rent in money and that while the former are untrammelled by the provisions of O. 34 of the CPC, the latter are bound by them.

4. In Srimati Maharanee Dasya v. Harendra Lal Roy(4) it was pointed out that there was no strict analogy between a charge for rent and a mortgage. In Fotick Chunder Dey Sircar v. E.G Foley it was hold that rent due by a tenant, which by virtue of Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, was a charge on the holding, was not a charge within the meaning of Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act and a similar view was taken by Mookerjee, J., in Royzuddi Sheik v. Kali Nath Mookerjee. In Gopi Nath Mahapatra v. Kashi Nath Reg(5) the purchaser in execution of a rent-decree was held to have priority over a purchaser in execution of a mortgage decree; and reference was made to Section 73 of the Transfer of Property Act, which enacts that where property is sold for arrears of rent, the mortgagee is entitled to enforce his mortgage against the surplus sale proceeds. Reliance has been placed by the appellant's vakil on the observations in Narayana Ayyar v. Venkataramana Ayyar(6), to the effect that in construing the words “mortgage” and “charge” for the purpose of the Limitation Act, the definitions of the Transfer of Property Act should be applied in the absence of any definition in the Limitation Act. These observations do not lay down an imperative rule of construction, but only indicate that in the absence of any repugnance, Courts will adopt the definition in a substantive enactment, when they have to construe other Acts where the same words are used. The fact that rent is not necessarily payable in money renders the definition of a charge in Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act, inapplicable. I think the view taken by the Calcutta High Court is sound and see no reason to differ from the decisions above referred to.

5. On the second question I am of opinion that a sale in execution of a money-decree for rent in a suit under Section 77 of the Estates Land Act, passes title free from all encumbrances, except when the encumbrance falls within S. 125 of the Act. S. 5 declares that the rent of raiyati land together with any interest which may be due in respect thereof shall be a first charge on the holding. Under the Act the landlord can recover the rent due in these ways: (1) by distraint and sale of moveable property; (2) by a sale through the Collector; and (3) by a suit under S. 77 of the Act in a Revenue Court and sale in execution of the decree passed therein. So far as distraint and sale by the Collector are concerned, there can be little doubt that the sale would confer a title on the purchaser free from all encumbrances except such as are contemplated in S. 125, and there seems to be no reason why the intervention of a decree for rent should make any difference if the provisions of O. 34 of the CPC, do not apply. The following observations of Mr. Ameer Ali in his commentaries on Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, when dealing with Tariniprosad Roy v. Narayan Kumari are in point:

“There is no warrant in the provisions of the Act for holding that a difference in the form of the action would alter the rights of the landlord relating to the enforcement of his decree for arrears of rent. If the suit is for rest and the decree is for rent, the absence of a declaration in the ordering part of the decree that the decretal amount is a charge on the tenure or holding would not, it is submitted, alter the character of the decree, the effect of which under the law is to make the rent a first charge on the tenure or holding in respect of which the arrears are claimed.”

6. The observations of Petheram, C.J, in Tariniprosad Roy v. Naiayan Kumari are dissented from in Surbo Lal v. Wilson(7) and in Royzuddi Sheik v. Kali Nath Mookerjee(8). Mookerjee, J., was of opinion that the consequence which follows from the provision that rent is a first charge upon an under tenure is that a sale, held in execution of a decree for arrears of rent produces the effect described in Ch. 14, Bengal Tenancy Act, which refers to sales for arrears under a decree and which provides for a title free from all except certain specified encumbrances to the purchaser.

7. It has been argued for the appellant that, as there is no section in the Estates. Land Act similar to Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, the decisions above referred to-have no application. S. 65 provides that where a tenant is a permanent tenure-holder or a raiyat, holding at fixed rates or an occupancy raiyat, he shall not be liable to ejectment for arrears of rent, but his tenure or holding shall be liable to sale in execution of a decree for the rent thereof, and the rent shall be a first charge thereon. As observed by the Privy Council in Arthur Henry Forbes v. Maharaja Bahadur Singh S. 65 is not a happily worded section and the clause refers to “rent being a first charge” and the words

“seem from their collocation to have been inserted as an after thought without sufficient consideration of their applicability to the rest of the provisions contained in the section.”

8. The Estates Land Act contains provisions in different sections which, in effect, reproduce all the provisions of Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. Section 5 of the Estates Land Act, provides that rent due by a raiyat shall be a first charge. S. 6 gives a raiyat rights of permanent occupancy. S. 77 gives the landlord the right to recover arrears of rent in a Revenue Court, and S. 132 provides that the provisions of Ch. 6 shall be applicable, so far as may be, to the execution by a Revenue Court of any decree for arrears of rent. It will thus be seen that the absence of any separate section like Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, makes really no difference in the scheme of the Estates Land Act land does not render the reasoning adopted by the learned Judges of the Calcutta High Court inapplicable. Sections 111 to 131 relate to sales by the Collector on the application of the landlord to whom rent is due, and S. 125 enacts that the purchaser will only take the holding subject to:

“any right or interest which the raiyat has created therein with the landlord's permission in writing registered and subject to any encumbrances created before the passing of the Act.”

9. It seems to me that the combined effect of Ss. 125 and 132 is to give the same rights to a purchaser in execution of a decree for rent, there being nothing in the Act repugnant to such a construction. I am therefore of opinion that the purchaser in execution of a decree for rent gets the properties free from encumbrances, except such as are specially reserved by the provisions of the Estates Land Act. The second appeal fails and is dismissed with costs.

S.N/R.K

10. Appeal dismissed.