- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Abdul Sac v. Sundara Mudaliar
Factual and Procedural Background
The case arises from execution proceedings related to a mortgage suit filed by the 1st respondent to enforce a mortgage and bring certain properties to sale. The original owner was Kaliappa Pillai, who left a widow and an adopted son, Ramaswami Pillai. Ramaswami released the suit properties to his adoptive mother in 1889, who sold them subsequently. The appellant purchased the property in 1909 and created a usufructuary mortgage in 1910. In 1917, the 1st respondent sued to enforce a mortgage executed by Ramaswami Pillai in 1906, involving multiple defendants including the appellant (2nd defendant) who claimed an independent title and contended he was not a necessary party. The District Munsif dismissed the suit against defendants 2 to 6 but gave a decree against the 1st defendant. Execution proceedings followed without notice to defendants 2 to 6, leading to disputes over possession and title. The District Munsif ruled that the plaintiff was not entitled to evict these defendants in execution, but the District Judge held that the title issues should have been investigated and that defendants 2 to 6 were parties under Section 47 of the Civil Procedure Code, barring a separate suit. The appellant contended that title questions could not be examined in execution and that defendants improperly impleaded should have been struck out rather than dismissed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether defendants 2 to 6, against whom the suit was dismissed for misjoinder, remain parties to the suit under Section 47 of the Civil Procedure Code for the purposes of execution proceedings.
- Whether the executing Court may consider the judgment and pleadings beyond the decree to determine party status under Section 47.
- The proper procedure when a party is improperly joined in a suit—whether to dismiss the suit as against them or to strike their name out under Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Code.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- Defendants 2 to 6 were improperly impleaded and the suit was dismissed against them; hence, they are not parties against whom a suit has been dismissed under Section 47.
- There is a distinction between dismissal on merits and dismissal due to misjoinder; the latter does not leave the party as a party to the suit for execution purposes.
- The question of title of the appellant and the 6th defendant could not be examined in execution proceedings.
Respondent's Arguments
- The construction of Section 47 in Krishnappa v. Periyaswami should not be adopted due to inconvenience to litigants and executing courts.
- The executing Court should only consider the decree itself, not the judgment or pleadings.
- There is no distinction between a defendant against whom the suit is dismissed due to abandonment and one dismissed due to misjoinder; both remain parties unless struck off.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Krishnappa v. Periyaswami | Parties exonerated due to misjoinder do not remain parties under Section 47; executing Court may consider judgment and pleadings beyond decree. | Adopted as the correct view; exonerated parties due to misjoinder are not parties for execution purposes. |
| Sethu Konar v. Ramaswami Konar | Exonerated parties remain parties if their names are not struck off the record; strict construction of Section 47. | Rejected as the narrow view; the Court favored the broader interpretation in Krishnappa. |
| Venkatapathi Naidu v. Subraya Mudali | Formal removal of a party's name from record is not determinative of party status under Section 47. | Supported the view that party status depends on nature of exoneration, not formal record removal. |
| Sannamma v. Radhabhayi | Where a suit is dismissed against a party due to plaintiff's election to abandon, that party is a defendant against whom suit has been dismissed under Section 47. | Distinguished from misjoinder cases; recognized as proper application of Section 47. |
| Ramaswami Sastrulu v. Kameswaramma | A party exonerated from suit by dismissal against him is a party under Section 47. | Distinguished since it was not a case of misjoinder; supported the need to strike out improperly joined parties. |
| Abdul Kasim v. Thambusami Pillai | Exonerated defendant remains party if name not removed from record. | Contrary view; rejected in favor of Krishnappa's reasoning. |
| U Kala v. Ma Hnin U | Followed Krishnappa and Sannamma; misjoined parties dismissed do not remain parties under Section 47. | Supported the broader view and proper procedure of striking out misjoined parties. |
| Linga Aiyar v. Lakshmanan Chettiar | Striking off a party's name is proper for misjoinder; dismissal is proper where plaintiff discontinues against a party. | Clarified correct procedure distinguishing misjoinder from abandonment cases. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed conflicting views regarding the status of parties dismissed from a suit due to misjoinder under Section 47 of the Civil Procedure Code. It emphasized that where a party is improperly joined and exonerated on that ground, that party does not remain a party to the suit for execution purposes. The Court rejected the narrow construction that focuses solely on whether the suit was dismissed against the party without considering the reason for dismissal. It held that the executing Court must consider the judgment and pleadings, not just the decree, to determine party status.
The Court further held that the proper procedural step when a party is improperly joined is to strike out the party's name under Order 1 Rule 10(2), rather than dismiss the suit as against them. Dismissing the suit against such a party without striking out their name places them in a worse position than if the correct procedure had been followed. The Court found the reasoning in Krishnappa v. Periyaswami persuasive and consistent with legal principles, while the contrary view in Sethu Konar v. Ramaswami Konar was rejected.
The Court also addressed the respondent's concerns about inconvenience, concluding that it is the Court's duty to examine the judgment and pleadings. The distinction between dismissal due to abandonment and dismissal due to misjoinder was clarified, emphasizing that the latter involves parties who should never have been joined.
Holding and Implications
The Court allowed the appeal with costs, holding that defendants improperly joined and exonerated on the ground of misjoinder do not remain parties to the suit for the purposes of Section 47 of the Civil Procedure Code. The Court ordered that the proper procedure is to strike out the names of improperly joined parties rather than dismiss the suit against them.
The decision clarifies the procedural requirements in cases of misjoinder, ensuring that execution proceedings do not involve parties who were never properly before the Court. It also underscores the obligation of trial courts to strike out improperly joined parties promptly. No broader precedent beyond the parties to this case was established.
Sir H. O. C. Beasley, Kt., C.J — This case has been referred to us by our brother Jackson, J., because the question for decision by us has been the subject of conflicting decisions in Krishnappa v. Periyaswami and Sethu Konar v. Ramaswami Konar .
The question before us arises out of proceedings in execution. The 2nd defendant in O. S. No. 348 of 1917 on the file of the 2nd Additional District Munsif's Court of Madura is the appellant here. The facts of the case may be briefly stated as follows. One Kaliappa Pillai was the original owner of the properties, the subject-matter of the suit. He left a widow and an adopted son Ramaswami Pillai. In 1889 the latter released the suit properties in favour of his adoptive mother. She sold the property in 1894 and between that date and 1909 there were different purchasers. In 1909 the appellant became the purchaser of the property and created a usufructuary mortgage in 1910 in favour of the 6th defendant. In 1906 Ramaswami Pillai executed a mortgage of some of the properties which mortgage was assigned to the present 1st respondent. In 1917 the 1st respondent filed a suit to enforce the mortgage and bring the properties to sale. Ramaswami's son was the 1st defendant and defendants 2 to 5 were impleaded in that suit and also the 6th defendant the usufructuary mortgagee. In that suit the 1st defendant was ex parte. The 2nd defendant claimed a title paramount by purchase and pleaded that he was not a necessary party to the suit. The District Munsif dismissed the suit as against defendants 2 to 6 but gave a decree against the 1st defendant. In his judgment he states as follows:
“2nd defendant claims an independent title. He has endorsed on the plaint that he does not derive his title from the mortgagor but quite independently of him. Therefore he is not a necessary party to the suit. The suit must be therefore dismissed with costs against defendants 2 to 6. Plaintiffs will get a decree against the other defendants in the suit.”
In the decree also the suit was dismissed as against defendants 2 to 6. An execution petition was then presented by the plaintiff to bring the property to sale. No notice was given to the other defendants. He dispossessed the 6th defendant who was then in possession of the property. The appellant then presented an application to put the 6th defendant in possession of the property. The 1st respondent disputed the appellant's title on the merits and put him to proof of all the sales and purchases. The District Munsif held that the plaintiff (1st respondent) was not entitled to evict the defendants. In his order the District Munsif stated:
“The plaintiff is not entitled in execution of this decree to evict the 6th defendant or defendants 2 to 5 “.
The 1st respondent appealed to the District Judge at Madura who held that the question of title as between the 1st respondent and defendants 2 to 6 should have been investigated and that since the defendants 2 to 6 were parties to the suit, the 1st respondent was barred by Sect. 47, Civil Procedure Code, from instituting a separate suit, but that the application under Sect. 47 of the Civil Procedure Code could have been treated as a suit if the learned District Munsif considered it sufficiently complicated. The appellant's contention here is that the question of his title and the 6th defendant's title was not a matter which could be gone into in the execution proceedings.
The question is whether defendants 2 to 6 in the suit are, under the provisions of Sect. 47 of the Civil Procedure Code, defendants against whom a suit has been dismissed and therefore parties to the suit. The contention of the appellant is that as the defendants were held not to have been properly impleaded in the suit and the suit on that ground was dismissed as against them they are not defendants against whom a suit has been dismissed as is provided in Sect. 47 of the Civil Procedure Code and that there is a distinction between the dismissal of a suit on its merits and a dismissal through mis-joinder of parties. Two views upon this matter have been taken. There is the broad view of the section taken in Krishnappa v. Periaswami and the narrow view of it in Sethu Konar v. Ramaswami Konar . Before proceeding to deal with the cases upon this point, reference must be made to O. 1 R. 10 (2) Sch. I of the Civil Procedure Code which provides that the Court may at any stage of the proceedings order the name of any party improperly joined to be struck out. The District Munsif having found that defendants 2 to 6 had been improperly impleaded in the suit should have ordered their names to be struck out instead of dismissing the suit as against them. The broad view of Sect. 47 of the Civil Procedure Code is that it is proper for the Court in execution proceedings to consider not only the decree itself but the judgment and the pleadings and see whether upon the facts of the case the parties, although the suit was dismissed as against them, really remained parties to the suit. The narrow view of the section is that it is not appropriate to the executing Court to consider anything else but the fact that the suit was dismissed as against the defendants—no matter what the reasons were for such dismissal. That of course is placing the strictest and narrowest construction on Sect 47. In Krishnappa v. Periyaswami , Ayling and Kumaraswami Sastri, JJ., held that where a party to a mortgage suit, who sets up a title adverse to both the mortgagor and the mortgagee, has been exonerated from the suit on the ground of misjoinder and his claim has not been adjudicated upon in the suit he does not remain a party to the suit for the purposes of Sect. 47 of of the Civil Procedure Code. The order of the Judge in the trial Court was an order exonerating the defendant with costs as he was an unnecessary party to the suit. It was argued in the appeal that notwithstanding this exoneration, he still continued to be a party to the suit and that the lower appellate Court should have gone into the question of his title. On page 966 in the judgment of the High Court it is stated:
“The exoneration in the present case having been on the ground of misjoinder we are of opinion that the party whose claim was not adjudicated upon does not remain a party to the suit for the purpose of Sect. 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Exoneration from the suit may be due to various causes and the question whether a party remains on record for the purpose of Sect 47 in spite of such exoneration will depend upon the nature and scope of the order having regard to the pleadings and the reason which led to such dismissal or exoneration. To hold that in cases of misjoinder (and consequent refusal of the Court to adjudicate upon the particular matters in contest the party whose claim was not adjudicated upon and who was exonerated remains a party to the suit would lead to the anomaly that the Court would be bound in execution proceedings to decide the very questions which it refused to determine in the suit.”
And again at Page 968:
“As pointed out in Venkatapathi Naidu v. Subraya Mudali , the mere fact that the name of the exonerated party is not formally removed from the record pursuant to the order exonerating him would not affect the question as to whether he remains a party.”
The case was referred to in Sannamma v. Radhabhayi a decision of a Full Bench which held that where a person has been properly impleaded as one of the defendants in a suit but the suit is dismissed as against him an account of the plaintiff's election to abandon his case so far as it affected that defendant, such a person is a defendant against whom a suit has been dismissed within Sect. 47, Civil Procedure Code.
On page 424 Sir John Wallis, C.J, states:
“The case which came before the Court in Krishnappa v. Periaswami , of a misjoinder of causes of action and of the plaintiff being required to proceed with one cause of action only and the suit being dismissed as against the defendants who had been joined in respect of the other causes of action only, may possibly stand on a different footing, as to hold that the cause of action which the Court was prohibited from trying may be gone into in execution by virtue of Sect. 47, goes far to defeat the prohibition of joinder, and such a construction of Sect. 47 should therefore be avoided if it is possible to do so. As that question is not before us, I express no opinion upon it, and will only say that the proper course in these cases appears to be for the Court to exercise the power, which it now has under O. 1, R. 10 (2) of ordering at any stage of the proceedings, the name of defendant improperly joined to be struck out, instead of dismissing the suit as against him. That will, as held by the Full Bench in Ramaswami Sastrulu v. Kameswaramma have the effect of taking him out of the operation of Sect. 47 which ought not to apply to him fleeing that he has no real concern with the suit.”
Although Sir John Wallis does not definitely decide the point, it is obvious that he approved of the spirit of Krishnappa v. Periyaswami and he certainly has given very strong reasons for holding that the Bench in that case took the correct view.
I will now turn to Sethu Konar v. Ramaswami Konar where a Bench of this Court took the opposite view to that taken in Krishnappa v. Periyaswami . That was a suit for sale on mortgage and a person claimed the property by a title paramount to that of the mortgagor and he was joined as a defendant. But the final decree merely stated that he was exonerated without removing his name from the record and it was held that he should be considered as continuing to be a party to the suit. The reason for deciding this case in that way was that the Bench considered that the ground on which a party is exonerated from the suit can never determine whether he continues or ceases to be a party but will depend entirely upon whether his name has been struck off from or retained on the record. This of course is applying Sect. 47 in its strictest sense. Another case on this point is Linga Aiyar v. Lakshmanan Chettiar (4) a decision of Odgers and Viswanatha Sastri JJ. The 2nd defendant in that suit had his name by consent struck off by the District Munsif but his name was retained in the cause title in the decree which was finally drawn up and it was held that in spite of his name being struck off, he was a party to the suit within the meaning of Sect. 47 and the explanation thereto but it was stated that striking out is the proper procedure to be employed in the case of misjoinder, that in any other case the proper course is dismissal and that striking off the name is not appropriate to a case of a party against whom the plaintiff does not wish to proceed further. In that case there was no question of a misjoinder of parties as the defendant was properly impleaded in the suit. Another case directly in point is U Kala v. Ma Hnin U and One and there Krishnappa v. Periyaswami and Sannamma v. Radhabhayi were followed; and it was held that where a suit is dismissed against a person on the ground that he was wrongly joined as a party having no real concern with the suit, such a person does not remain a party to the suit for the purpose of Sect. 47 of the Civil Procedure Code and that a more appropriate way, in case of misjoinder, is to strike out the name of the party under O. 1, R. 10 (2), of the Code, so as to take him out of the operation of Sect. 47. The contrary view was taken in Abdul Kasim v. Thambusami Pillai .
There a defendant was exonerated by the decree in the suit with the result that the suit was dismissed as against him but his name was not actually removed from the record and it was held that he did not cease to be a party to the suit on that account. That was a decision of a Bench consisting of Oldfield and Krishnan, JJ. This case was referred to in Krishnappa v. Periyaswami . No reason for the exoneration of the defendant is given either in the statement of the facts of the case or in the judgment which is a very short one. In Venkataswami v. Chidambaram (5) it was held that a defendant whose name appears in the decree without having been struck off previously from the record is a party within the provisions of Sect. 47 of the Civil Procedure Code. There the 4th defendant set up a title adverse to both the mortgagor and the mortgagee and was held not to be a necessary party and ordered to be struck out of the suit. The order was: “4th defendant is not a necessary party and is exonerated with costs”. The Bench consisting of Sadasiva Aiyar and Phillips, JJ., thought that Sect. 47 was perfectly plain in its terms. In Ramaswami Sastrulu v. Kameswaramma (6), it was held that a party defendant exonerated from the suit, the suit being dismissed against him, is a party to the suit. This case also was referred to in Krishnappa v. Periyaswami but was held distinguishable because it did not appear to be a case of exoneration of a party by reason of misjoinder of causes of action.
Mr. Srinivasagopalachari in the course of his argument on behalf of the respondent contended that the construction placed upon Sect. 47 of the Civil Procedure Code in Krishnappa v. Periyaswami ought not to be placed upon it because of the inconvenience it would cause to the litigant public and those who have to advise them and because it would put an unreasonable burden upon the executing Court if that Court had to consider not only the decree but the judgment and the pleadings in the suit instead of merely taking the decree itself. I can see no force in this latter contention as it is the duty of a Court not only to refer to the decree but also the judgment and the pleadings. In the case before us no inconvenience could have been occasioned by this procedure because the judgment of the District Munsif upon this point is contained in a very few lines. He further contended that there can be no distinction between the case of a defendant against whom the plaintiff abandons his claim and the suit is accordingly dismissed as against him and a person who has the suit dismissed against him on account of misjoinder. In my view, the two cases are quite different. In the former case he may be a proper party to the suit but yet the plaintiff either does not wish to take a decree against him or feels that he is unable to prove his claim and he is not a person to whom O. 1, R. 10 (2) applies. In the latter case on the other hand, he is a person who ought never to have been made a party to the suit at all and not having been properly impleaded, the plain duty of the Court is to strike his name out. If the respondent's contention is correct, then it means that, although the appellant ought not to have been made a party to the suit and the District Munsif held that he had been improperly impleaded and instead of striking his name out adopted the wrong procedure in dismissing the suit as against him, he is to be placed in a worse position than a party in respect of whom the Court does adopt the correct procedure. It seems to me to be a contradiction to say that a person who is held at the trial of the suit not to be a proper party to the suit remains still a party to the suit. I am clearly of the opinion that Krishnappa v. Periyaswami was correctly decided and the appeal to the lower Appellate Court was incomplete. The appeal must accordingly be allowed with costs.
I cannot leave this case without pointing out that it is the duty of the trial Judge to strike out the name of a party improperly impleaded. It is quite wrong procedure to dismiss the suit as against him.
Anantakrishna Ayyar, J.—-I agree.
Curgenven, J.—I agree.
N. R. R.Appeal allowed.
Alert