- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramaswami Naicken v. Venkatasami Naicken
Factual and Procedural Background
The Full Bench decision in Arumugham Chetty v. Muthu Koundan (5) is treated as the governing authority. This Second Appeal was heard and, having regard to the Full Bench ruling and subsequent discussion of costs and intervening authorities, the court held that the second appeal fails and dismissed it. The learned Advocate-General appeared for the appellant but did not argue the second appeal on its merits; submissions focused on the question of costs in light of intervening authority. The court reviewed competing submissions on costs and allocated costs among parties, identifying the 1st defendant as primarily responsible for the litigation.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Second Appeal should be dismissed in light of the Full Bench decision in Arumugham Chetty v. Muthu Koundan (5).
- Whether the appellant should be directed to pay the respondents' (defendants') costs having regard to the Privy Council decision in Sahu Ram Chandra v. Bhup Singh (6) and the interpretation in Badagala Jogi Naidu v. Bendalatn Papiah Naidu (7) that a deed of mortgage cannot be relied on as an antecedent debt.
- How the court should exercise its discretion under Section 35 of the Civil Procedure Code in awarding or withholding costs where the legal position has changed or where the litigation arises from a contested state of law.
Arguments of the Parties
Advocate-General for the Appellant
- Did not argue the second appeal on its merits.
- Contended that because the appeal was filed after the Privy Council decision in Sahu Ram Chandra v. Bhup Singh (6) and relying on Badagala Jogi Naidu v. Bendalatn Papiah Naidu (7) (where Spencer and Krishnan, JJ., interpreted the Privy Council ruling to mean a deed of mortgage cannot be relied on as an antecedent debt), the court should not direct the appellant to pay the respondents' costs.
Mr. K. Srinivasa Aiyangar (opposing view)
- Argued that costs should follow the event unless there is misconduct by the successful party or it would be manifestly unjust to award costs to the successful party.
- Submitted that Section 35 of the Code of Civil Procedure gives broader discretion as to costs than the English Rule (p. 65, R. 1) applicable to jury trials.
- Relied on English and other authorities (Forster v. Farquhar; Walter v. Steinkopff; Cooper v. Whittingham; Kuppusami Chetty v. Raja of Kalahasti; Robinson v. Rosher; Sultan Harbour Improvement Company v. Hitchens) to show the discretionary refusal of costs is appropriate where the suit was based on a state of law later overruled or where judicial discretion is properly exercised.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Arumugham Chetty v. Muthu Koundan (5) | Full Bench decision treated as controlling authority on the matter. | The court relied on this Full Bench decision in holding that the Second Appeal fails and dismissing it. |
| Sahu Ram Chandra v. Bhup Singh (6) | Privy Council decision relied upon by the Advocate-General in argument on costs. | Referenced as an intervening authority relevant to whether a deed of mortgage can be relied on as an antecedent debt and thus relevant to the question of costs. |
| Badagala Jogi Naidu v. Bendalatn Papiah Naidu (7) | Interpretation by Spencer and Krishnan, JJ., of the Privy Council ruling to mean a deed of mortgage cannot be relied on as an antecedent debt. | Invoked by the Advocate-General to argue against directing the appellant to pay costs; considered by the court in assessing the appropriateness of awarding costs. |
| English Rule (p. 65, R. 1) | Rule as to actions tried by a jury which enjoins the judge to withhold costs from the successful party only for good cause shown. | Contrasted with Section 35 CPC to show the Indian provision gives broader discretion in awarding costs. |
| Forster v. Farquhar | Bowen, L.J.'s observation that depriving the successful party of costs does not require proving misconduct. | Used to show English jurisprudence has relaxed the strict rule against withholding costs and supports judicial discretion. |
| Walter v. Steinkopff | Mr. Justice North's statement that a judge's discretion as to costs is not removed merely because a bare legal question arises. | Relied on to demonstrate that discretion remains even on pure legal questions. |
| Cooper v. Whittingham | The strict rule enunciated by Jessel M.R. (regarding costs) has been practically abandoned in subsequent English cases. | Noted to support the view that rigid rules on costs have been relaxed. |
| Kuppusami Chetty v. Raja of Kalahasti | Judgment based on dictum of the Master of the Rolls which the court notes is no longer law in England. | Referenced to indicate prior reliance on an outdated English dictum and to justify flexible application of discretion under Section 35. |
| Robinson v. Rosher | Authority pointing out it can be sound discretion to refuse costs where a suit was based on a state of law since overruled. | Applied to justify refusal of costs where litigation was founded on a state of law later overruled by statute or superior tribunal. |
| Sultan Harbour Improvement Company v. Hitchens | Similar principle to Robinson v. Rosher about refusing costs where underlying law has been overruled. | Used alongside Robinson v. Rosher to support the court's exercise of discretion in respect of costs. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began from the Full Bench decision in Arumugham Chetty v. Muthu Koundan (5) and concluded the Second Appeal fails. On the question of costs the court considered the Advocate-General's submission invoking the Privy Council decision (Sahu Ram Chandra v. Bhup Singh (6)) and the interpretation in Badagala Jogi Naidu v. Bendalatn Papiah Naidu (7) that a deed of mortgage cannot be relied on as an antecedent debt. The court also considered counter-submissions that Section 35 CPC confers broad discretionary power to award or refuse costs and that English authorities demonstrate judicial discretion to refuse costs even absent misconduct.
The court reasoned that the principles from the cited English and other authorities (Forster v. Farquhar; Walter v. Steinkopff; Cooper v. Whittingham; Robinson v. Rosher; Sultan Harbour Improvement Company v. Hitchens) show that rigid rules about costs have been relaxed and that refusal of costs can be appropriate where litigation was founded on a state of law later overruled. It held these principles are deducible a fortiori from the language of Section 35 CPC.
Applying these principles to the facts, the court found the 1st defendant was responsible for instigating the litigation; neither the plaintiffs nor the other defendants were culpable. The court also noted that, had the Divisional Bench judgment stood, the appellants might have succeeded — a consideration relevant to apportionment of costs. Balancing these factors, the court concluded it would be inappropriate to make the appellant pay the defendants' costs and that the 1st defendant should pay the costs of the other defendants in this Court.
Holding and Implications
Second Appeal dismissed.
Direct effects:
- The Second Appeal is dismissed.
- The appellant is not ordered to pay the costs of the defendants in this Court.
- The 1st defendant is directed to pay the costs of the other defendants in this Court.
The opinion does not purport to establish a new binding precedent beyond applying Section 35 CPC and the cited authorities to the allocation of costs in these circumstances; its effect is the allocation of costs as above between the parties to this appeal.
Following the Full Bench decision in Arumugham Chetty v. Muthu Koundan(5), we hold that this Second Appeal fails and dismiss it. The learned Advocate-General who appeared for the appellant did not argue the second appeal, but contended that as it was filed after the Privy Council decision (Sahu Ram Chandra v. Bhup Singh(6)) and on the strength of Badagala Jogi Naidu v. Bendalatn Papiah Naidu(7), in which Spencer and Krishnan, JJ., interpreted the Privy Council ruling to mean that a deed of mortgage cannot be relied on as an antecedent debt, this court should not direct the appellant to pay the respondent's costs. Mr. K. Srinivasa Aiyangar on the other hand contended that Unless there was misconduct on the part of the successful party or unless it would be manifestly unjust on the merits of the case to visit the defeated party with costs, costs should follow the event. There can be no doubt that the rule enunciated in Sect. 35 of the Code of Civil Procedure as to costs is wider than the English Rule (p. 65, R. 1), as to actions tried by a Jury which enjoins on the Judge to withhold costs from the successful party only for good cause shown. Even under the English Rule, Bowen, L.J, pointed out that in order to deprive the successful party of his costs it is not necessary to prove that the successful party has been guilty of misconduct. See Forster v. Farquhar. Mr. Justice North in Walter v. Steinkopff, said that the discretion of the presiding Judge is not taken away because he has to decide a bare legal question. The strict rule which was enunciated by Jessel M. R. in Cooper v. Whittingham, has been practically abandoned in these two cases. Mr. Justice Subramania Aiyar, in Kuppusami Chetty v. Raja of Kalahasti, has based his judgment on the dictum of the Master of the Rolls which is no longer law in England. Further, for the present case, there is direct authority of Robinson v. Rosher, and Sultan Harbour Improvement Company v. Hitchens, wherein it has been pointed out that it would be a sound exercise of discretion to refuse costs where a suit was based on a state of law, which has since been overruled either by an Act of Parliament or by a superior tribunal. In our opinion, the above principles are deducible a fortiori from the language of Sect. 35 of the Civil Procedure Code.
Under the Indian Law it can safely be stated that the discretion of the Court as to the award of costs so long as it is judicially exercised, should not be bound down by any artificial rules. A great deal must depend upon the facts of each case and upon its presentation by the party and upon circumstances and authorities which were pre-existing before the suit was launched. In the present case, 1st defendant has been responsible for the whole of the litigation; neither the plaintiffs nor the other defendants have been guilty of any act of commission or omission which can be charged against them. If the judgment of the Divisional Bench had stood, the appellants might have succeeded. That is a consideration which cannot altogether be ignored in apportioning costs. Taking all these circumstances into consideration, we think the appellant should not be made to pay the costs of defendants. We further think the 1st defendant who is the fans et origo of all the trouble should be directed to pay the costs, of the other defendants in this Court.
S. S.Appeal dismissed.
Alert