Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Abdul Gani Saheb, In Re

Madras High Court
Aug 20, 1936
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

This is a jail appeal in which notice has been ordered to issue by my brother Burn, J. on the ground that the sentence appeared to be excessive. The appellant was convicted as a result of the unanimous verdict of the jury to the effect that he was guilty of theft, after a trial conducted before the Sessions Judge of South Arcot.

[Portion of the judgment omitted as not being necessary for this report.]

As regards the question of sentence, the learned Judge does not give any particular reason for imposing a sentence of six years' rigorous imprisonment under section 379 read with section 75, Indian Penal Code. The prosecution case is that the property stolen in this case was a cow worth about Rs. 50. For an offence of this nature, if committed by a casual offender for the first time, the ordinary sentence would certainly not exceed six months' imprisonment. The question is whether an old offender, whose previous conviction was in 1929 and whose previous sentence was five years' rigorous imprisonment should now necessarily be given six years' imprisonment. There seems to be an idea prevalent in the minds of some Judges that there is a rule that the sentence on an old offender should always be at least a little more severe than the sentence just previous. This so-called rule cannot be supported by any good reason. It may be an excellent rule of thumb, but I do not think, in imposing sentences, such a rule can be safely followed in the interests of the proper administration of criminal justice. While the sentences imposed on criminals should be adequate to the offence, there is every reason why they should not be excessive. Apart from the injustice to the offender which an excessive sentence entails, such a sentence tends to undermine public confidence in the administration of criminal justice. In the absence of any reasons for imposing a sentence of six years' rigorous imprisonment in this case, and in view of the nature and value of the stolen property, I am of opinion that the sentence imposed by the learned Sessions Judge is far too severe. The sentence is therefore reduced to three years' rigorous imprisonment. The order directing the appellant to give information of his residence and change of residence to the police for a period of three years after the expiration of the sentence will stand. The conviction is confirmed and the substantive sentence is reduced to three years' rigorous imprisonment.

V.V.C