- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
K.K Subbier v. K.M.S Lakshmana Iyer And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
A sabha of the Sourashtra community was registered as a society. The directors of this society sanctioned a loan to the 2nd accused, who was also a director, for a period of one year, in contravention of the provisions of Section 86(d) of the Companies Act. Before the loan period expired, the complainant, himself a director, requested the fellow directors to cancel the loan resolution, but they refused, citing that the loan period had not yet elapsed. The complainant then filed a complaint in the Court of the City First Class Magistrate of Madura under Section 86(d) of the Companies Act against the directors who supported the second resolution. The Magistrate summoned witnesses but acquitted all accused on a reading of the complaint, holding that the offence was committed at the time of the first resolution sanctioning the loan in 1939 and that the accused in the second resolution were not guilty.
The complainant appealed to the Sessions Judge, who referred the matter to this Court, opining that the 2nd accused was guilty of abetting the offence by receiving the loan. Additionally, the complainant filed a revision petition against the acquittal of the 1st accused, who was a party to the first resolution. The Registrar of Joint Stock Companies was approached but declined to intervene, referring the complainant to criminal courts.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the directors who passed the second resolution sanctioning the loan, after the complainant’s request to cancel it, committed an offence under Section 86(d) of the Companies Act.
- Whether the 2nd accused was guilty of abetting the offence by receiving the loan.
- The legality of the City Magistrate’s acquittal of the accused without examining witnesses.
- The appropriateness of intervention by this Court or the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies in the matter.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| In re Varadarajulu Naidu | Condemnation of acquitting accused without examining witnesses under the Code of Criminal Procedure | The Court noted that although the City Magistrate acquitted the accused without examining witnesses, this practice was condemned by Lakshmana Rao, J. in this precedent, indicating procedural impropriety. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court acknowledged that the sanctioning of the loan to a director contravened Section 86(d) of the Companies Act, and that both the first and second resolutions were wrongful. When the directors were made aware of the illegality during the second resolution, they should have acted to terminate the loan. Despite the complainant possibly having personal motives, his actions were justified. The Court criticized the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies for not intervening or advising the directors to prevent recurrence of such illegality. However, the Court found no necessity to intervene or punish the accused for the 1939 offence, especially since the loan had been repaid and no fresh breach had occurred. Regarding the procedural issue, the Court observed that the City Magistrate’s acquittal without examining witnesses was improper, as the Code of Criminal Procedure does not permit such action, and this was supported by precedent. Nevertheless, the Court did not find it necessary to delve deeply into this procedural impropriety.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED
The Court dismissed the petition, effectively upholding the acquittal of the accused. The decision means no further punishment or intervention will be undertaken by the Court in this matter. The loan having been repaid and no new offence having been committed, there is no ongoing breach under Section 86(d) of the Companies Act. The opinion does not establish any new legal precedent but underscores the procedural impropriety of acquitting accused without examining witnesses and the importance of regulatory bodies taking appropriate action in such matters.
A sabha of the Sourashtra community was registered as a society. In contravention of the provisions of S. 86(d) of the Companies Act, the directors sanctioned a loan to the 2nd accused—who was a director—for a period of one year. Before that year had terminated, the present complainant, who is one of the directors, moved his fellow directors to cancel the earlier resolution. They refused to do this and resolved that as the year for which the loan was made had not then elapsed, they would not interfere. The complainant thereupon filed a complaint in the Court of the City First Class Magistrate of Madura under S. 86(d) of the Companies Act against the present directors, who were parties to the second resolution. The Magistrate summoned witnesses; but before he had taken their evidence he acquitted all the accused on a reading of the complaint; for he was of opinion that no offence had been committed by the present directors in passing the second resolution. The offence was committed when the loan was made as a result of the resolution passed in 1939 and the persons who were guilty of the offence were those who were parties to the first resolution.
The complainant approached the Sessions Judge, who has referred the matter to this Court, expressing the opinion that the 2nd accused was guilty of abetting the offence by receiving the loan himself.
The complainant has also filed a revision petition in this Court against the acquittal of the 1st accused, who is said to have been a party to the first resolution.
It appears that the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies was approached in this matter; but he refused to intervene and referred the complainant to a criminal Court. There can be no doubt that the parties to both the resolutions acted wrongly. There was undoubtedly a contravention of the provisions of S. 86(d) of the Companies Act in sanctioning a loan to a director and when the attention of the directors on the second occasion was drawn to this, they should have taken steps at once to see that the illegal loan was terminated. Even if the complainant was prompted by personal motives, he was justified in his conduct. I also think that the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies should have taken action in the matter and at least have told the directors that they should see that such an illegality was not committed again and that they should take steps to end it. However, I do not think that it is necessary to intervene in this matter at the instance of a private party and to punish the various accused for something that was done in 1939, especially as the loan has been repaid and no fresh breach under this section seems to have been committed.
It is contended that the City Magistrate acted illegally in acquitting the accused without hearing the complainant's evidence. I have not thought it necessary to examine the authorities bearing on that point; but it may be pointed out that the Code of Criminal Procedure makes no provision for the acquittal of accused persons without examining witnesses. Lakshmana Rao, J. condemned the practice in In re Varadarajulu Naidu(1).
The petition is dismissed.
Petition dismissed.
N.R.R
Alert