- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kanneganti Chowdarayya
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from convictions in Sessions Case No. 22 of 1937 on the file of the learned Sessions Judge of Guntur. The appellant in C.A. No. 456 of 1937 was the 1st accused and the appellant in C.A. No. 465 of 1937 was the 2nd accused in that Sessions case. Four persons were tried on charges that the 1st accused kidnapped a minor boy from lawful guardianship with intent that he should be murdered (charged under S. 364 IPC) and that the 2nd, 3rd and 4th accused abetted this offence.
The Sessions Judge found the 1st accused guilty of an offence under S. 363 IPC (kidnapping from lawful guardianship), holding the specific allegation of intent to murder not proved. The 1st accused was sentenced to seven years rigorous imprisonment; the 2nd accused was convicted of abetment of the offence under S. 363 IPC and sentenced to five years rigorous imprisonment; the 3rd and 4th accused were acquitted. On appeal the higher court considered the facts and relevant legal questions, and ultimately allowed the appeal(s).
A notable factual feature is that the 1st accused was the biological father of the child alleged to have been kidnapped from the child's mother (P.W.1). The father had earlier instituted litigation against the mother challenging a prior compromise decree, alleging the child was illegitimate. The alleged taking of the child occurred on 11 April 1937. Identification evidence and a confession (Ex. C) by the 2nd accused were part of the prosecution case; the Sessions Judge rejected the confession as not shown to be voluntary.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the father of a child, who is in fact the child's civil father and thus in law entitled to custody, can be convicted of kidnapping from the lawful guardianship of the child's mother under S. 361/363 IPC when he procures the child from the mother's custody.
- Whether the confession (Ex. C) made by the 2nd accused to the Taluk Magistrate should have been admitted and relied upon, given the Sessions Judge's finding that proper precautions to ensure voluntariness were not observed.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- Counsel for the appellants argued that the evidence of P.W.s 1 to 5 (who described and identified the taking of the child) ought not to be accepted.
- Mr. Vepa (for the appellants) supported the Sessions Judge's rejection of the 2nd accused's confession (Ex. C), contending the Taluk Magistrate had not observed precautions to ensure voluntariness.
- The 1st accused contended he did not deny paternity ultimately and that the plaint in his suit had been lodged on the advice of his pleader's clerk (though the pleader testified otherwise).
Prosecution's Arguments
- The learned Public Prosecutor argued that the Sessions Judge was wrong to discard the 2nd accused's confession and that there were no proper reasons to suppose the confession was anything but voluntary.
- The Public Prosecutor also invited the court to infer an immoral or unlawful purpose for taking the child (specifically a motive to stifle any suit for partition on behalf of the child) and relied on prior authority (Mahendranath Chakravarti v. Emperor) to argue that the Exception to S. 361 would not protect the father if the act was for an immoral or unlawful purpose.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Saharali Mohammad v. Kamizuddin Mahammad (Rankin C.J.) | Interpreting the Explanation to S. 361 IPC: the section's explanation extends "lawful guardian" to include any person lawfully entrusted with care/custody, and consent of relatives may establish lawful guardianship; used to distinguish de facto custody from civil guardianship. | The court relied on Rankin C.J.'s reasoning to support the proposition that the Explanation to S. 361 cannot be used to convict a person who in fact is the civil guardian merely because another has de facto custody; this reasoning fortified the conclusion that the father's act did not amount to kidnapping under S. 361/363 IPC in the absence of proof of an immoral/unlawful purpose. |
| Mahendranath Chakravarti v. Emperor | Considered whether a father of an illegitimate child could be protected by the Exception to S. 361 when he took the child away to "hush up a scandal"; discussed burden on prosecution to show immoral/unlawful purpose. | The court noted the case but observed there was no decision on appeal; it cited Henderson J.'s observation that it is for the prosecution to prove the act was committed for an immoral or unlawful purpose. The court applied this allocation of burden (with reference to S. 105 Evidence Act) to find that the prosecution had not proved such a purpose here. |
| Emperor v. Sital Prasad (as cited in Saharali Mohammad) | Authority for the proposition that the Explanation to S. 361 cannot be used to convict a person who in fact is the civil guardian by setting up mere de facto guardianship against the civil guardian. | The court adopted this authority (as quoted in Saharali Mohammad) to support the conclusion that the father's position as civil guardian precludes convicting him under S. 361 simply because the mother had de facto custody. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in a step-by-step analysis grounded on the facts as found by the Sessions Judge and the text of S. 361 IPC and its Explanation:
- Fact-finding: The child had been in the custody of his mother (P.W.1) from birth for over three years; the mother was thereby a "lawful guardian" within the meaning of S. 361 by virtue of the Explanation (consent/acquiescence of the father to maternal custody).
- Statutory language: The court noted that S. 361 defines "whoever takes or entices" as kidnapping and that the word "whoever" would on its face include the father.
- Exception analysis: The Exception to S. 361 exempts "any person who in good faith believes himself to be the father of an illegitimate child, or who in good faith believes himself to be entitled to the lawful custody of such child, unless such act is committed for an immoral or unlawful purpose." The court reasoned that if a person who merely believes himself to be entitled is exempted (absent immoral/unlawful purpose), then a person who in fact is the father (and therefore in law entitled) is a fortiori within that exception unless an immoral or unlawful purpose is proved.
- Burden of proof: The court recognized the prosecutorial burden to show that the act was done for an immoral or unlawful purpose (drawing on observations in Mahendranath Chakravarti and S. 105 Evidence Act principles). The Exception's wording and the authorities cited lead the court to place on the prosecution the task of proving such purpose once the facts show the actor to be the child's father.
- Application to the present facts: The Sessions Judge had specifically held that the charge that the father kidnapped the child to have him murdered was not proved. No other unlawful or immoral purpose was established by the prosecution evidence. In the absence of proof of such a purpose, the father's deceitful procurement of the child from the mother's custody did not amount to an offence under S. 361 IPC (and therefore the conviction under S. 363 IPC could not stand).
- Confession issue: Although there was a confession (Ex. C) by the 2nd accused which the Sessions Judge had rejected for lack of proper precautions to ensure voluntariness, the appellate court observed there was no necessity to discuss the admissibility of that confession at length because other evidence was, in the court's view, sufficient to establish the facts relied on; ultimately, however, the decisional outcome turned on the legal effect of the father's status and the absence of proof of an immoral or unlawful purpose.
- Reliance on precedent: The court explicitly relied on the reasoning in Saharali Mohammad (and the authority quoted therein) to support the legal conclusion that a civil guardian cannot be convicted on the basis that another's de facto guardianship is set up against him.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeals are allowed; the convictions and sentences of the appellants in C.A. No. 456 of 1937 and C.A. No. 465 of 1937 are set aside and both appellants are acquitted.
The judgment directed that the appellants, who had been released on bail, have their bail bonds cancelled. The court's conclusion rested on (i) the factual finding that the 1st accused was the child's father and thus entitled in law to custody, (ii) the Exception to S. 361 IPC protecting such a person unless the act was committed for an immoral or unlawful purpose, and (iii) the prosecution's failure to prove any such immoral or unlawful purpose.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The appellants' convictions under S. 363 IPC (and abetment) were set aside and both appellants were acquitted; their bail bonds were ordered cancelled.
- Broader impact: The opinion does not articulate or declare a broader novel precedent beyond applying established principles; its decision rested on statutory interpretation of S. 361's Exception and on applying existing authorities to the facts. The opinion emphasized that, in the absence of proof of an immoral or unlawful purpose, a biological/civil father who is in law entitled to custody cannot be convicted under S. 361/363 merely because the child's mother had de facto custody.
Appeal allowed.
N.R.R
JUDGMENT
This is a case of an unusual kind. In fact I am informed that it is the first case of its kind. The appellant in C.A No. 456 of 1937 was the 1st accused and the appellant in C.A No. 465 of 1937 was the 2nd accused in S.C 22 of 1937 on the file of the learned Sessions Judge of Guntur. Along with them two Muhammadans were tried and the charges upon which they were put up for trial were that the 1st accused kidnapped a minor boy from lawful guardianship with intent that he should be murdered (S. 364 Indian Penal Code). The 2nd, 3rd and 4th accused were charged with abetment of this offence. The learned Sessions Judge found the 1st accused guilty of an offence under S. 363 Indian Penal Code holding it not proved that the kidnapping was in order that the little boy might be murdered. The 1st accused has been sentenced to 7 years rigorous imprisonment. The 2nd accused was convicted of abetment of the offence under S. 363 Indian Penal Code, and sentenced to 5 years rigorous imprisonment. The 3rd and 4th accused were acquitted.
The remarkable feature of this case is that the first accused is the father of the boy whom he is said to have kidnapped from the keeping of the boy's mother (P.W 1). P.W 1 and the 1st accused were married several years ago and according to P.W 1 her husband deserted her. She filed a suit for maintenance and this was compromised on terms by which the 1st accused gave her some land to defray her costs and some additional land for her maintenance. This compromise took place on the 19th July 1933, and in 1936 P.W 1 put the decree in execution and got delivery of the lands. In the meanwhile in 1935 the 1st accused had filed a suit in the Court of the District Munsif, Guntur, to set aside the compromise entered into in July 1933, on the ground that it had been obtained by fraud. A copy of the plaint has been filed as Ex-L and it shows that the 1st accused alleged that his marriage with P.W 1 had never been consummated, that her child was illegitimate, and that she was actually pregnant as the result of adulterous intercourse at the time the compromise took place. The plaint was dated the 22nd November 1935. In that it is alleged that P.W 1's son was born on the 2nd January 1934.
In these circumstances on the 11th April 1937 it was alleged that the 1st accused with the help of the other three kidnapped his own son from the guardianship of the little boy's mother. Learned Counsel for the appellants has argued that the evidence of P.Ws 1 to 5 who speak to the kidnapping, ought not to be accepted. P.W 1 is the mother of the child; P.W 2 is a woman with whom P.W 1 was lodging while she was in Guntur for the purposes of her litigation: P.W 3 is another woman who was lodging in the same house, and P.Ws 4 and 5 are boys aged 13 and 11 respectively who were employed in sweet-meat shops in Guntur. The boys described how the second accused picked up the child in front of their shops, took him down a side lane and handed him over to the 1st accused. These two boys picked out the 1st and 2nd accused at an identification parade which was held on the 12th April, and there is really no reason for rejecting their evidence. In addition to this there was a confession (Ex. C) made by the 2nd accused to the Taluk Magistrate, Guntur, on the 17th April. The learned Sessions Judge discarded this confession on the ground that the Taluk Magistrate had not in spirit observed the proper precautions to ensure that the confession should be voluntary. Mr. Vepa who appears for the appellants contends that the learned Sessions Judge was right. The learned Public Prosecutor on the other hand contends that the learned Sessions Judge was wrong, and that there are no proper reasons for supposing the 2nd accused's confession to have been anything but voluntary. I do not see any necessity to discuss this question at length, because I am satisfied, as the learned Sessions Judge was, that the other evidence in the case is sufficient to establish the fact.
The facts proved therefore are that the little boy (the son of the 1st accused and P.W 1), who had been brought up by his mother from the date of his birth, and who was in her keeping on the 11th April 1937, was taken from her keeping by the 2nd accused who handed him over to the 1st accused, and who must of course have been acting under instructions from the 1st accused. The 1st accused does not now deny the paternity of the child. He alleges that he was ill-advised when he filed his suit against his wife. He says that the plaint was not drafted on his own instructions but on the advice of his pleader's clerk. This is not of course true. The pleader was examined as P.W 12 and he testified that the plaint (Ex. L) was prepared in accordance with the instructions of the 1st accused. His evidence is no doubt true. The interesting question which arises is whether in these circumstances the 1st accused can be held guilty of an offence under S. 363 Indian Penal Code. I am told that there is as yet no record of any case in which a father has been convicted of kidnapping his own child from the guardianship of the child's mother. I have therefore to decide the matter as well as I can without the assistance of any reported cases.
There is no doubt of course that P.W 1, the mother of the child, was on the 11th April 1937 the lawful guardian of the child for the purposes of S. 361 Indian Penal Code. The parties being Hindus, the father is the lawful guardian, whose rights of guardianship, until they are taken away by a decree of a competent Court or surrendered by himself, are paramount to those of any other person. The father having acquiesced in the retention by the mother of the custody of this child from the date of his birth for over 3 years and 3 months, the mother clearly comes within the meaning of the Explanation to S. 361 Indian Penal Code. It was observed by Rankin C.J in Saharali Mohammad v. Kamizuddin Mahammad(1).
“I do not doubt at all that the explanation to S. 361 was intended to extend the meaning of the words ‘lawful guardian’ beyond their ordinary scope. It is extended to include any person lawfully entrusted with the care or custody of such minor or other person. I do not doubt either that, where, by consent of the relatives, a minor has been allowed to be in the custody of a particular relative, the definition given by the section will be satisfied. In such a case, there may be no definite transaction of entrustment, but the consent of the relatives would be quite sufficient to make the guardianship lawful guardianship.”
Therefore what we have proved in this case is that the child was in the keeping of his mother who was a lawful guardian within the meaning of S. 361 Indian Penal Code, and that the child was taken or enticed away out of her keeping. S. 361 says that
“whoever takes or entices……is said to kidnap”
and there can be no doubt that the word “whoever” will include P.W 1's husband. But this is not quite sufficient. The Exception to S. 361 states as follows:
“This section does not extend to the act of any person who in good faith believes himself to be the father of an illegitimate child, or who in good faith believes himself to be entitled to the lawful custody of such child, unless such act is committed for an immoral or unlawful purpose.”
Now, if a person who in good faith believes himself to be entitled to the lawful custody of a child cannot commit an offence under S. 361 Indian Penal Code, it seems to follow a fortiori that a person who is in fact the father of the child, and therefore in law entitled to the lawful custody of the child cannot come within the scope of S. 361 Indian Penal Code. In this case it can be said on behalf of the 1st accused that he did not merely in good faith believe himself to be entitled to the lawful custody of his child, but that he was beyond the possibility of any challenge entitled to the lawful custody of the child, and that therefore his act in taking the child from the keeping of his mother could not amount to an offence of kidnapping from lawful guardianship.
I think this contention is correct. The learned Public Prosecutor has drawn my attention to the final words of the Exception to S. 361 Indian Penal Code.
“Uness such act is committed for an immoral or unlawful purpose.”
He points out that according to the finding of the learned Sessions Judge, the 1st accused had a strong motive to get the child away from his mother in order to stifle any suit for partition on behalf of the child. The learned Public Prosecutor suggests that this is an immoral or unlawful purpose, and invites my attention to the case reported in Mahendranath Chakravarti v. Emperor. That was a case in which the father of an illegitimate child was said to have taken the child away from its mother at the age of 10 days, in order to hush up a scandal. It was held that in such circumstances the father of the illegitimate child might not be protected by the Exception to S. 361 Indian Penal Code. There was, however, no decision in the case, the appeal being remanded for re-hearing, but I notice that in the judgment of Henderson, J. it is observed that it is for the prosecution to show that the act was committed for an immoral or unlawful purpose. By S. 105 of the Evidence Act it is of course the duty of the accused to show that his offence falls within any of the exceptions in the Indian Penal Code; but where it appears from the prosecution evidence itself that the act falls within the Exception, the accused will clearly be relieved of that burden. In this case the Exception itself states that S. 361 does not extend to the act of a person who in good faith believes himself to be entitled to the lawful custody of the child, unless such act is committed for an immoral or unlawful purpose; and that, as Henderson, J. observes, lays upon the prosecution the burden of proving that the act was committed for an immoral or unlawful purpose. In the present case it cannot be said that the prosecution has established that the act of the 1st accused was committed for an immoral or unlawful purpose. The charge against the 1st accused was that he had caused this child to be kidnapped in order that he might be murdered but the learned Sessions Judge has expressly found that charge was not established. No other object was attributed to the 1st accused and it is not in my opinion justifiable to say that even though he has not been proved to have intended to murder the child, yet he must have had some other unlawful or immoral purpose.
In the absence of proof of the purpose for which the accused caused the child to be taken away from the keeping of his mother, all that we have proved is that the father of the child by deceitful means got the child from the keeping of his mother to his own. This in my judgment is not an offence under S. 361 Indian Penal Code and I am fortified in this opinion by the reasoning of Rankin C.J in the case in Saharali Mohammad v. Kamizuddin Mohammed. The learned Chief Justice quoted with approval the decision in Emperor… v. Sital Prasad…Accused.(2) as authority for the proposition that
“the explanation to S. 361 cannot be used to mean that, as against a person who, in fact, is the civil guardian of the minor, mere de facto guardianship can be set up so as to convict the real civil guardian of an offence under S. 361.”
I therefore find that the appellant in C.A No. 456 of 1937 has been wrongly convicted of an offence under S. 363 Indian Penal Code. I set aside the conviction and acquit him. The conviction of the appellant in C.A No. 465 of 1937 also for abetment must be set aside for the same reason. He is also acquitted. The appellants have been released on bail and I direct that their bail bonds be cancelled.
Appeal allowed.
N.R.R
Alert