Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner Of Service Tax v. Sgs India Pvt. Ltd.

Bombay High Court
Apr 23, 2014
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Opinion — S.C. Dharmadhikari, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal under Section 35G of the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with Section 83 of the Finance Act, 1994 was directed against the order of the Central Excise Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, Mumbai dated 10 February 2011 which set aside the order of the Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai dated 18 July 2007.

The respondent was a testing and certification agency providing Technical Inspection and Certification Agency (TICA) and Technical Testing and Analysis Agency (TTAA) services in India for goods imported by customers located abroad. The respondent received consideration in convertible foreign exchange.

Relevant administrative measures include: Notification No. S.T. 1 dated 9 April 1999 (exempting certain services where payment received in convertible foreign exchange), rescission of that notification by Notification No. 2/2003 dated 1 March 2003, a Circular of the Central Board of Excise and Customs dated 25 April 2003 clarifying that service tax is a destination-based consumption tax and that export of services would remain tax-free, and Notification No. 21/2003-S.T. dated 20 November 2003 (exempting certain services where payment received in India in convertible foreign exchange).

On 6 January 2006 the Directorate General of Central Excise Intelligence issued a show cause notice alleging that the respondent's services were performed in India (tests and reports prepared in India) and therefore not export of services; a demand of Rs. 82,16,553 was raised for the period 1 July 2003 to 19 November 2003. The Commissioner confirmed the demand and imposed penalty by an order dated 18 July 2007. The respondent appealed to the CESTAT, which allowed the appeal and set aside the Commissioner’s order. The present appeal challenges the Tribunal's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the services provided by the respondent (testing, inspection and certification conducted in India but the reports delivered to foreign clients) constituted "export of services" and were therefore not taxable under Service Tax law for the interregnum period 1 July 2003 to 19 November 2003.
  2. Whether the Circular dated 25 April 2003 and the later Notification No. 21/2003-S.T. applied to the respondent's services and excluded them from Service Tax liability despite the rescission of the earlier exemption notification.
  3. Whether the Tribunal erred in setting aside the Commissioner’s order confirming demand and penalty for the stated period — i.e., whether the Tribunal's interference was legally justified.
  4. Whether the demand raised by the department for the relevant period was time-barred.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Revenue's) Arguments — Mr. P.S. Jetly

  • The interregnum period (1 July 2003 to 19 November 2003) lacked the exemption claimed by the respondent, so service tax liability existed for that period and the Commissioner’s demand should have been confirmed.
  • The Circular dated 25 April 2003 is not applicable to the respondent's services; its paragraph 3 (and related conditions) do not apply to the facts of this case.
  • Service tax is destination-based only for exports; but services performed and consumed in India (testing performed and certificates issued in India) are not exports and are therefore taxable.
  • No inter-sectoral credit is allowed; services provided in India for the manufacture of goods ultimately exported do not attract exemption for the service-provider in the manner claimed.
  • Because the exporter is based in India and the services (testing/certification) were performed in India on goods originating in India, the respondent is not entitled to the exemption.

Respondent's (Assessee's) Arguments — Mr. Sridharan

  • The services rendered were covered by the exemption regime or were not taxable at all; even if an exemption notification was withdrawn briefly, export of services remained outside the Service Tax net by operation of law and administrative clarification.
  • Service tax is a destination-based consumption tax; export of services is not taxable and administrative circulars and the Finance Minister's parliamentary statement clarified the non-taxability of exported services after withdrawal of the earlier notification.
  • The place of provision (or consumption) of services determines taxability; in absence of a statutory place-of-provision rule, the administrative guidance and purposive construction should be applied to treat the services as exported.
  • Reliance on statutory structure: Section 65(105) (definition of taxable services) and Section 66 (charging provision) make the taxable event the provision of services and the territorial reach is governed by Section 64 — so tax applies only if the taxable event occurs in India.
  • Industry apprehension was addressed by Circular dated 25 April 2003 and the Finance Minister's speech; export of services remained tax-free. The CESTAT decisions cited by the Tribunal (B.A. Research and KSH International) support the respondent's position.
  • There was no suppression of facts; the demand (raised in January 2006 for liability in 2003) is time-barred and barred by limitation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
The Bengal Immunity Company Limited v. The State of Bihar and Ors. (1995) 6 STC 446 (SC) That the situs of an intangible concept (like a sale/service) can only be fixed notionally by artificial rules laid down by legislature or judges; place of provision must be determined by law or judicial rule. The Court cited this authority to support the submission that place of provision/consumption matters and must be determined by legal rules; it underpins the analysis of whether the taxable event occurred in India.
20th Century Finance Corporation Ltd. and Anr. v. State of Maharashtra (2000) 119 STC 182 (SC) Similar principle: situs of sale (or analogous intangible transactions) can only be fixed by legislature or judge-made law; no settled principle exists for determining situs. The Court relied on this statement to reinforce that place-of-provision issues require legal determination and that administrative guidance may inform that determination in absence of statutory provision.
Popatlal Shah v. The State of Madras (1953) 4 STC 188 (SC) Rejects the contention that a legislature cannot tax transactions concluded outside its territory provided there is sufficient territorial nexus; addresses competence to levy tax on transactions concluded outside the province. The Court cited this to acknowledge Parliament's competence to tax services with extraterritorial aspects, while noting that competence alone does not resolve place-of-provision questions for taxability.
All India Federation of Tax Practitioners v. Union of India, 2007 (7) S.T.R. 625 Characterizes Service Tax as a value-added, destination-based consumption tax; emphasizes that service tax targets consumption and, therefore, place of consumption/provision is relevant to liability. The Court treated this decision as supportive of the proposition that Service Tax is destination-based and used it to sustain the Tribunal’s conclusion that exported services (consumed abroad) fall outside the Service Tax net.
Commissioner of Service Tax, Ahmedabad v. M/s. B.A. Research India Limited, 2010 (18) S.T.R. 439 (Tribunal-Ahmedabad) Tribunal decision recognizing circumstances where testing/certification services provided in India but used by foreign clients were treated as export of services for Service Tax purposes. The Tribunal below relied on factual parity with this decision; the Court noted that the Tribunal followed this case in concluding the respondent's services were exported and not taxable.
KSH International Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Belapur, 2010 (18) S.T.R. 404 (Tribunal-Mumbai) Tribunal decision similarly holding that certain testing/inspection services provided in India but for foreign clients amounted to export of services. The Tribunal applied the reasoning of this decision; the Court accepted that the Tribunal's reliance on these Tribunal precedents was appropriate in the present factual matrix.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the appeal record, the impugned Tribunal order, statutory provisions, relevant notifications and circulars, and the authorities cited by the parties.

The Tribunal's factual finding was that the respondent's contract/privity was with foreign buyers (clients abroad); although tests were conducted and reports prepared in India, the test reports/certificates were forwarded to the foreign clients and delivery of the report to the foreign client was considered an essential and completing part of the service. The Tribunal treated the payment received in India in convertible foreign exchange (not repatriated) as satisfying the condition in the exemption notification.

The Court noted the administrative history: the exemption notification of 9 April 1999 was rescinded on 1 March 2003, the Board issued Circular dated 25 April 2003 clarifying that Service Tax is destination-based and that export of services would remain tax-free, and Notification No. 21/2003 (20 November 2003) later provided an exemption for services where payment is received in India in convertible foreign exchange. The Court observed that the proviso to the exemption notification was not attracted and it was conceded that the respondent had received payment in India in convertible foreign exchange and had not repatriated it.

Legally, the Court accepted the parties’ submissions that the taxable event under the Finance Act is the provision of services (Sections 65(105), 65(106), 66) and that territorial operation (Section 64) makes the taxable event chargeable only if the place of provision is in India. In the absence of a statutory place-of-provision rule, the Court considered administrative clarifications and relevant judicial principles (including that Service Tax is destination-based as stated in All India Federation of Tax Practitioners).

Applying these principles to the facts (foreign clients contracting for tests, reports delivered abroad, payment in convertible foreign exchange received in India and not repatriated), the Court concluded that the Tribunal's determination that the services were exported (i.e., the benefit of the exemption/clarification applied) was legally sustainable. The Court found the Tribunal's view to be consistent with the circulars, the statutory provisions, and applicable precedent and not vitiated by any perverse finding or error apparent on the face of the record.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • The Tribunal's order setting aside the Commissioner’s demand and penalty stands; the demand (and penalty) in relation to the period in question was not sustained by this Court.
  • The Court held that the Tribunal's conclusion — that the services rendered by the respondent were export of services and therefore not taxable in the circumstances — did not raise any substantial question of law requiring interference.
  • The Court declined to decide broader or wider controversies about place-of-provision beyond what was necessary; no new wide-ranging precedent was laid down by this judgment on unresolved place-of-provision controversies.
  • There is no order as to costs.

Show all summary ...

S.C. Dharmadhikari, J.

1. This Appeal under Section 35G of the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with Section 83 of the Finance Act, 1994 is directed against the order passed by the Central Excise Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, Mumbai dated 10th February, 2011 [ 2011 (24) S.T.R. 60 (Tri.-Mum.)]. By the order under Appeal, the Tribunal has set aside the order passed by the Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai, dated 18th July, 2007.

2. The facts necessary to appreciate the argument of Shri P.S. Jetty, learned counsel appearing in support of the Appeal are that the respondent was providing Technical Inspection and Certification Agency Service (for short "TICA") and Technical Testing and Analysis Agency Service (for short "TTAA") at different places in India in respect of goods imported by their customers located abroad. For such services, the respondent received consideration in convertible foreign exchange.

3. The Notification No.-S.T. : 1, dated 9th April, 1999, exempted Service Tax on services specified under Section 65(48) of the Finance Act, 1994, provided to any person in respect of which payment was received in convertible foreign exchange. This notification was rescinded vide Notification No. 2/2003-S.T. : 3, dated 1st March, 2003. However, the Central Board of Excise and Customs issued a circular being Circular No. 56/5/2003-S.T. : 3, dated 25th April, 2003, clarifying that the Service Tax is a destination based consumption tax and not applicable on export of services. Export of services would continue to remain tax free even after withdrawal of Notification No. 6/99 : 1, dated 9th April, 1999. It is also clarified that by Notification No. 21/2003-S.T. : 3, dated 20th November, 2003, the department exempted taxable services specified under Section 65(105) of the Finance Act provided to any person in respect of which payment was received in India in convertible foreign exchange. Annexures A, A1 to A3 are the copies of the notifications referred by us hereinabove.

A show cause notice was issued by the Directorate General of Central Excise Intelligence Mumbai Zonal Unit dated 6th January, 2006 alleging that services provided by the respondents were performed in India though test reports thereof were sent outside India. Since the services were performed in India, there was no export of services. The matter was therefore not covered by the clarification given vide Circular dated 25th April, 2003. The respondents before us therefore, were called upon to pay Service Tax amounting to Rs. 82,16,553/for the period 1st July, 2003 to 19th November, 2003. This demand was disputed and that is how the adjudicating authority namely, Commissioner of Service Tax Mumbai heard parties. He passed an order on 18th July, 2007 confirming the demand and imposing penalty. It is this order of the Commissioner/adjudicating authority which was challenged by the respondent in Appeal before the CESTAT, Mumbai, and by the impugned order, the same has been allowed. The demand is thus dropped and equally the penalty. Mr. P.S. Jetly, therefore, submits that this Appeal raises substantial question of law and particularly the one formulated at paragraph No. 4 of the memo of present Appeal. Mr. Jetly submits that the Notification No. 21/2003 may be reinstating the benefit available, yet, we are concerned in this Appeal with the interregnum period i.e. 1st July, 2003 to 19th November, 2003. At that time, there was no exemption and of the nature claimed by the respondent assessee. It is submitted that once the liability had to be discharged, the demand raised by the Commissioner should have been confirmed and not interfered by the Tribunal. Mr. Jetly has invited our attention to the order of the Tribunal and particularly the observations and findings at paragraph No. 7 page 74 of the paper book. Mr. Jetly submits that the circular dated 25th April, 2003 is not applicable to the services rendered by the respondent in the present case. He invited our attention to this circular in some details. Mr. Jetly submits that paragraph No. 3 thereof has no application to the services provided and rendered by the respondent. It is submitted that the conditions have to be fulfilled before the benefit of the circular can be claimed. Mr. Jetly submits that it has been clarified specifically that the Service Tax is destination based consumption tax and it is not applicable on export of services. True, it is that export of services would continue to remain tax free even after withdrawal of Notification No. 6/99, dated 9th April, 1999 but, for service consumed/provided in India in the manufacture of goods which are ultimately exported, no credit of Service Tax paid can be availed or reimbursed during the relevant time as inter-sectoral tax credit between services and goods are not allowed. Mr. Jetly submits that this paragraph of the circular at page 19 has application to the facts and circumstances of the present case. Mr. Jetly therefore submits that the findings of the Tribunal are contrary to this notification and law. In the present case, the exporter is in India. The importer is abroad. The importer has placed orders for certain goods on the exporter in India. The respondent renders services by testing the samples in India. The certification after such testing is in India. The origin of the goods is in India. Hence, Mr. Jetly submits that the respondent is not entitled to the benefit of the exemption notification. Once this clear position emerges and in the backdrop of the services rendered, then, the Tribunal was in error in allowing the Appeal. Therefore, the reframed question of law would arise for determination and consideration as it is a substantial one.

5. Mr. Sridharan, on the other hand, submitted that the issue in question is fully covered by the exemption notification, Apart therefrom, and assuming that exemption notification stood withdrawn for a brief period and thereafter reinstated, the position is that what is not taxable need not be exempted. In other words, the services rendered by the respondent were never taxable at all. Once they were not taxable at all, there is no question of exempting them. In such circumstances, this Appeal does not raise any substantial question of law. The view taken by the Tribunal is in consonance with law. For all these reasons, he submits that the Appeal deserves to be dismissed.

6. Elaborating his submission further, Mr. Sridharan submits that "Section 65(105) of the Finance Act as it stood during the relevant period defined "taxable services" to mean any service provided to and by persons specified under the various sub-clauses of that section. Section 66 of the Finance Act which was the charging section provided that Service Tax was to be levied on the value of taxable services referred to in the various sub-clauses of Section 65(105). Thus, undisputedly, the taxable event of Service Tax is the provisions of services. However Section 64 of the Finance Act provides that the Chapter relating to Service Tax extends to the whole of India except the State of Jammu and Kashmir. Therefore value of services will be taxable under Section 66 of the Finance Act only if the taxable event occurs in India i.e. only if the place of provision of service is in India.

7. Mr. Sridharan further submits that "Services" are intangible in nature and hence the place of provision of services has to be laid down by legislature or by judicial pronouncements. This proposition is supported by the decision of Hon. Supreme Court in the case of The Bengal Immunity Company Limited v. The State of Bihar and Ors. - (1995) 6 STC 446 (SC). Before the enactment of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 there was considerable dispute amongst the States as to situs of sales in cases where sales transactions were partly completed in one State and partly in another. In this context Justice S.R. Das observed as follows while delivering the majority judgment:

The situs of an intangible concept like a sale can only be fixed notionally by the application of artificial rules invented either by judges as part of the judge-made law of the hand, or by some legislative authority.

8. Mr. Sridharan further submits that similar observations were made by Hon. Supreme Court in the case of 20th Century Finance Corporation Limited and Anr. v. State of Maharashtra - (2000) 119 STC 182 (SC) in the majority judgment delivered by Justice V.N. Khare as under:

The situs of sale can only be fixed wither by the appropriate legislature or by Judge made law, and there is no settled principles for determining the situs of sale.

9. Mr. Sridharan submits that there was apprehension in the industry that export of services will become taxable because of the withdrawal of the aforementioned Notification Number:

The Central Government has issued Notification No. 2/2003, dated 1-3-2003 in the current year's Budget rescinding the earlier Notification No. 6/99 -Service Tax, dated 9-4-1999 which exempted taxable services from payment of Service Tax so long as payment for services rendered is received in convertible foreign exchange which is not repatriated outside India. Consequent to the issue of Notification No. 2/2003 cited above, Service Tax would be leviable on all taxable services consumed or rendered in India, irrespective of whether the payment thereof is received in foreign exchange or not.

In this regard various representations have been received by the Board raising apprehension that because of the withdrawal of the Notification No. 6/99, export of service would be affected as it would be costlier in the international markets.

The Board has examined the issue. In this connection I am directed to clarify that the Service Tax is destination based consumption tax and it is not applicable on export of services. Export of services would continue to remain tax free even after withdrawal of Notification No. 6/99

10. Mr. Sridharan further submits that on the same day on which the aforestated circular was issued, the Finance Minister also made a similar clarification in the Lok Sabha with regard to the taxability of export of services. The relevant extract of his speech in the Parliament is as follows:

Some Hon. Members as also some trade representatives have also expressed apprehension that the withdrawal of exemption from Service Tax arising from payments received in convertible foreign exchange could affect our export of services. I want to clarify that a Service Tax is location based. Whatever service is exported abroad whether it be through outsource computer or medical, it will, by law, be outside the proposed code of Service Tax. Therefore, there ought to be no apprehension or worry in this regard.

11. Mr. Sridharan further submits that although there was no provision in the statute which laid down the place of provision of services, there were clear administrative guidelines to the effect that Service Tax will not be applicable if services are consumed outside India. It is submitted that in the absence of any statute or judicial pronouncement to the contrary, such administrative guidelines should be considered to be the applicable legal position in this regard.

12. Mr. Sridharan further submits that the respondent is not contending that the Parliament is not constitutionally empowered to levy Service Tax on a transaction which is completed outside India. The respondent is aware that Hon. Supreme Court had rejected such a contention with respect to sales tax in the case of Popatlal Shah v. The State of Madras - (1953) 4 STC 188 (SC). In that case the Madras State sought to levy sales tax on a transaction in which goods were dispatched from Madras to Calcutta. One of the contentions raised by the assessee was that the legislature was incompetent to levy tax on a sale which was concluded outside the Province. Although the appeal of the assessee was allowed on construction of the language of the Statute, the contention relating to competence of the legislature to tax a transaction which was concluded outside the Province was rejected by the Supreme Court by holding that the entry in the Constitution relating to tax on sale of goods did not suggest that a legislation imposing sales tax could be made only in respect of sales taking place within the boundaries of the Province. It was observed that although a Provincial legislature could not pass a taxation statute which would be binding on any other part of India, it would be quite competent to enact a legislation imposing taxes on transactions concluded outside the Province, provided there was sufficient and a real territorial nexus between such transactions and the taxing province.

13. Mr. Sridharan further submits that although the Parliament is competent to levy tax on services which are provided to recipients located outside India, in the absence of any legal provision regarding fixation of the place of provision of service and having regard to the Finance Minister's Speech in Parliament and C.B.E. & C. circular, export of services were outside the Service Tax net even during the interregnum period by applying the canon of purposive construction of statutes.

14. Mr. Sridharan therefore submits that the principle that Service Tax is a destination based consumption tax is in conformity with international practice. It has been accepted internationally in order to avoid double taxation. It has also been recognized by the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of All India Federation of Tax Practitioners v. Union of India reported in 2007 (7) S.T.R. 625. Mr. Sridharan therefore submits that the Appeal does not raise any substantial question of law and deserves to be and should be dismissed. Mr. Sridharan submits that in any case, there was no suppression of facts. The respondent was under a bona fide belief that it had exported services and therefore the extended period has been erroneously invoked. The demand has been held to be barred by limitation. For all these reasons, and when the demand is raised on 6th January, 2006 in relation to a liability to pay Service Tax from July to November, 2003 it is ex facie time barred and cannot be sustained. For this reason, as well, the Appeal deserves to be dismissed.

15. We have with the assistance of the learned Counsel appearing for the parties, perused the memo of Appeal and all annexures thereto, including the impugned order. We have also perused the relevant statutory provisions, notifications and decisions brought to our notice.

16. The Tribunal was considering the respondents' challenge to the order of the adjudicating authority confirming the demand and penalty. The argument before the Tribunal on behalf of the respondent was that the respondent is a testing agency. The contract of service was with the overseas purchaser of goods. Thus, the privity of contract of the respondent is with the buyers of the goods who are located or situated outside India. Further, the argument was that this is a contract based tax. The contract is of services. There is no contract in this case with the manufacturer of goods in India. Further, there is no contract and no privity between the respondent and the exporter of the goods who is stated to be based in India. It is in these circumstances that the exemption notification though required to be strictly construed has rightly been construed in favour of the respondent assessee before us.

17. The Tribunal has found that the clients of the respondents are located abroad. The tests reports may have been prepared in India. The tests may have been conducted in India. However, the certificates have been forwarded to the clients of the respondent abroad. It is in such circumstances the Tribunal concluded that the facts in the case of Commissioner of Service Tax, Ahmedabad v. M/s. B.A. Research India Limited which is a Tribunal's decision and reported in 2010 (18) S.T.R. 439 (Tribunal-Ahmedabad) which was followed by the Tribunal's single member in the case of KSH International Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Belapur reported in 2010 (18) S.T.R. 404 (Tribunal-Mumbai) are identical.

18. The respondent before us had exported the services by way of testing and analysis in India and transmitting the test report/analysis report to the foreign clients. The service was complete when the report was delivered to the foreign client. Since the delivery of the report to the foreign client was considered to be an essential part of the service that the demand of Service Tax was set aside.

19. This view of the Tribunal is in accord with the statutory provision and particularly the circular relied upon. In the circular which is relied upon and at page 17 of the paper book, the Government of India in the Ministry of Finance (Department of Revenue) exempted the taxable service specified in sub-section (48) of Section 65 of the Finance Act, 1994 provided to any person in respect of which payment is received in India in convertible foreign exchange, from the whole of the Service Tax leviable thereon under Section 66 of the said Act. The proviso to this exemption notification is not attracted to facts of our case. It is conceded before us that the respondent received payment in India in convertible foreign exchange and that this payment is not repatriated by the respondent from or sent outside India.

20. The definition of the term taxable service is inclusive. It also includes technical testing and analysis [see section 65(106)(zzh)]. by section 65(106), technical testing and analysis has also been defined. In such circumstances, when technical inspection and certification is also a service and goods in question have been inspected or tested, but the services were of the nature noted by us above, the payment was also made in terms aforesaid, then, the benefit of the notification at page 17 of the paper book was available. That was on the footing that the services rendered were exempt from whole of the liability to pay Service Tax.

21. The circular dated 25th April, 2003 (Annexure A2) is issued on the subject of non-levy of Service Tax on export of services. It has referred to earlier circular of 1st March, 2003 and 9th April, 1999. The 9th April, 1999 is a notification of exemption. The April 2003 circular clarifies that Service Tax would be levied on all taxable services consumed or rendered in India, irrespective whether the payment thereof is received in foreign exchange or not. Since representations were received by the Board with regard to the withdrawal of the Notification No. 6 of 1999, exports of service would be affected as it would be costlier in the international market, that the board clarified that service consumed/provided in India in the manufacture of goods which are ultimately exported, no credit of Service Tax paid can be availed or reimbursed till April, 2003 because inter-sectoral tax credit between service and goods are not allowed. Mr. Sridharan has placed reliance on clause (4) of the circular dated 25th April, 2003. That is where it has been clarified that the question of taxability of secondary services which are used by primary service provider for the export of services. Thus been clarified in paragraph No. 4 of its circular. It is in these circumstances that we are of the opinion that the Tribunal has not erred in law in holding that the services provided by the respondent were not taxable. This aspect once becomes more clear if one peruses the Notification No. 21/2003-S.T., dated 20th November, 2003.

22. We are of the opinion that the services rendered in the present case are fully covered by the clarification given and even by the principle laid down in the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India. In this regard, if one refers to the allegations in the show cause cum demand notice, it is apparent that the same refers to the testing charges received by the respondent in convertible foreign currency in respect of services rendered by it in India to its foreign clients. Though the show cause notice refers to the circulars, what is apparent from the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of All India Federation of Tax Practitioners v. Union of India, 2007 (7) S.T.R. 625 that Service Tax is a tax on each activity. When it comes to a Service Tax on professions, the services rendered are of advise and hence, the Hon'ble Supreme Court with regard to the nature of the tax concluded that it is rendered by a Chartered Accountant, for example when he advises his client or audits his account. Similarly, a cost accountant charges his client for advise as well as doing his work of costing. For each transaction or contract, Chartered Accountant/Cost Accountant renders professional based services. However, Mr. Sridharan submits if the taxable event is the provision of services, then, the place where the services have been rendered is of significance. The services will be taxable only if they are provided within India. Mr. Sridharan submits that Service Tax is a destination based consumption tax and therefore, it is not applicable on export of services.

23. In the present case, the Tribunal has found that the assessee like the respondent rendered services, but they were consumed abroad. The clients of the respondents used the services of the respondent in inspection/test analysis of the goods which the clients located abroad intended to import from India. In other words, the clients abroad were desirous of confirming the fact as to whether the goods imported complied with requisite specifications and standards. Thus, client of the respondent located abroad engaged the services of the respondent for inspection and testing the goods. The goods were tested by the respondents in India. The goods were available or their samples were drawn for such testing and analysis in India. However, the report of such tests and analysis was sent abroad. The clients of the respondent were foreign clients, paid the respondent for such services rendered, in foreign convertible currency. It is in that sense that the Tribunal holds that the benefit of the services accrued to the foreign clients outside India. This is termed as 'export of service'. In these circumstances, the Tribunal takes a view that if services were rendered to such foreign clients located abroad, then, the act can be termed as 'export of service'. Such an act does not invite a Service Tax liability. The Tribunal relied upon the circulars issued and prior thereto the view taken by it in the case of KSH International Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner and B.A. Research India Ltd. The case of the present respondent was said to be covered by orders in these two cases. To our mind, once the Hon'ble Supreme Court has taken the view that Service Tax is a value added tax which in turn is destination based consumption tax in the sense that it taxes noncommercial activities and is not a charge on the business, but on the consumer, then, it is leviable only on services provided within the country. It is this finding and conclusion of the Hon'ble Supreme Court which has been applied by the Tribunal in the facts and circumstances of the present case.

24. The view taken by the Tribunal therefore, cannot be said to be perverse or vitiated by an error of law apparent on the face of the record. If the emphasis is on consumption of service then, the order passed by the Tribunal does not raise any substantial question of law.

25. We are of the view that any larger or wider controversy and based on the submissions of Shri Sridharan need not be decided in this case. Suffice it to hold that the view taken by the Tribunal does not raise any substantial question of law. The Appeal is devoid of merits and it is accordingly dismissed. There would be no order as to costs.

"Section 65(105) of the Finance Act