Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Tamil Nadu Transport Development Finance Corporation Limited

Madras High Court
Jul 6, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary — Tax Case (Appeal) No. 1029 of 2007 (Decided: July 6, 2007)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal was filed by the Revenue under section 260A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 against an order of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chennai Bench “C” dated January 19, 2007 (I.T.A No. 1726.Mds/2004). The Tribunal had dismissed the Revenue's appeal and confirmed the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)'s order which held that reopening of assessment under section 147 read with section 148 was bad in law.

The assessee is a Government of India undertaking company. The relevant assessment year was 1997-98 (accounting year ended March 31, 1997). A regular assessment under section 143(3) was completed on March 30, 1999 determining income at Rs. 11,40,72,670. Subsequently, it was noticed that interest accrued and receivable by the assessee from M/s. Tamil Nadu State Civil Construction Corporation Limited amounting to Rs. 148.69 lakhs was omitted to be brought to tax. A notice under section 148 was issued on June 24, 2003 and the Assessing Officer completed reassessment by including that interest.

The assessee had filed its 22nd annual report along with the original return of income; that annual report contained a paragraph describing the interest/loan treatment and that a sum of Rs. 148.69 lakhs was not taken to account. The assessee appealed the reopening to the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), who allowed the appeal and held the reopening bad in law. The Revenue appealed to the Tribunal which dismissed the appeal. The Revenue then impugned that Tribunal order by the present appeal raising a substantial question of law.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal was right in law in upholding the order of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and accordingly holding the reopening of the assessment under section 147 read with section 148 as bad in law, even though the facts and circumstances may fall within the exception provided in Explanation 1 to section 147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961?

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue's Arguments

  • The interest of Rs. 148.69 lakhs accrued and receivable from another Government company was omitted to be brought to tax and therefore income had escaped assessment.
  • The mere statement in the annual report about conversion of interest into loan and recognition of interest did not amount to full disclosure of the materials at the time of completing the assessment under section 143(3).
  • The facts of the case would fall within Explanation 1 to section 147 of the Act, justifying reopening under section 148.

Assessee's Arguments (as accepted by lower authorities)

  • The assessee had filed the 22nd annual report along with the original return; the annual report expressly disclosed the interest/loan facts and the amount not taken to account (Rs. 148.69 lakhs).
  • The return filed earlier could be treated as having been filed in response to the notice under section 148.
  • There was no failure to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for assessment during the original assessment proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Elgi Finance Ltd., [2006] 286 ITR 674 Interpreting the proviso to section 147: where an assessment has been made under section 143(3), no action under section 147 shall be taken after expiry of four years from end of relevant assessment year unless income escaped assessment by reason of failure of the assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for assessment (effect of amendments from April 1, 1989). The court applied this principle to hold that because the original assessment had been made under section 143(3) and the information about the interest was available in the annual report filed with the return, reopening after four years was barred by the proviso to section 147.
Commissioner Of Income Tax v. P. Mohanakala, [2007] 291 ITR 278 Where there is a concurrent finding of fact by the authorities below, the High Court should not ordinarily interfere. The court relied on this principle to decline interference with the concurrent factual findings of the Commissioner (Appeals) and the Tribunal that the assessee had not failed to disclose material facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the sequence of events and the material placed before the Assessing Officer at the time of the original assessment. It noted that:

  1. The original assessment under section 143(3) was completed after the Assessing Officer considered all details filed by the assessee, including the 22nd annual report which was filed along with the return of income.
  2. The specific paragraph in the 22nd annual report identified the interest position and stated that Rs. 148.69 lakhs was not taken into account in the accounts — meaning the information regarding the interest was available to the Assessing Officer during the original assessment proceedings.
  3. The proviso to section 147 prescribes a four-year limitation for initiating reassessment where an assessment has been made under section 143(3); beyond that period action can be taken only if income escaped assessment by reason of failure on part of the assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for assessment.
  4. The notice under section 148 was issued on June 24, 2003, which was beyond four years from the end of the relevant assessment year (1997-98). Therefore, the reopening was time-barred unless the Revenue proved a failure by the assessee to disclose material facts.
  5. The Revenue did not demonstrate any such failure: the Tribunal recorded (and the court noted) that the Departmental representative did not controvert that the annual report was filed with the return nor identify any failure by the assessee to disclose material facts necessary for assessment.
  6. The court followed the reasoning in Elgi Finance Ltd. regarding the scope of the proviso to section 147 and applied the principle that the four-year limit operates unless there is a failure of disclosure by the assessee. The court also relied on P. Mohanakala in respect of not disturbing concurrent findings of fact by the authorities below.

On this basis, the court concluded there was no error in the concurrent findings of the Commissioner (Appeals) and the Tribunal that the reopening was barred by limitation and the assessee had not failed to make necessary disclosures.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The court held that the reopening of the assessment under section 147 read with section 148 was bad in law because the reassessment notice was issued after the four-year period prescribed by the proviso to section 147 and the Revenue did not establish any failure by the assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for assessment. The court recorded that no substantial question of law arises and ordered dismissal of the tax case. No costs were awarded.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The reassessment that sought to bring Rs. 148.69 lakhs of interest to tax is invalidated; the order of the Tribunal and Commissioner (Appeals) in favour of the assessee is affirmed; the Revenue's appeal is dismissed.
  • Broader implication: The court applied established principles concerning the proviso to section 147 (as explained in Elgi Finance Ltd.) and the principle that concurrent findings of fact by lower authorities should not ordinarily be disturbed (as in P. Mohanakala). The opinion does not announce any new legal principle beyond applying these authorities to the facts of the case.
Show all summary ...

Tax Case (Appeal) No. 1029 of 2007

Decided on July 6, 2007

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

P.P.S Janarthana Raja, J.:— This appeal is filed under section 260A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, by the Revenue, against the order of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chennai Bench “C”, Chennai in I.T.A No. 1726.Mds/2004, dated January 19, 2007, raising the following substantial question of law:

“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal was right in law in upholding the order of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and accordingly the reopening of the assessment under section 147 read with section 148 is held as bad in law, even though the facts and circumstances of the case fall within the exception provided in Explanation 1 to section 147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 ?”

2. The facts leading to the above substantial question of law are as under:

The assessee is a company. It is a Government of India undertaking. The relevant assessment year is 1997-98 and the corresponding accounting year ended on March 31, 1997. Regular assessment was completed on March 30, 1999, under section 143(3) of the Income-tax Act (“the Act”) in short), determining the income at Rs. 11,40,72,670. Subsequently, it was noticed that the interest accrued and receivable by the assessee-company from another company, viz., M/s. Tamil Nadu State Civil Construction Corporation Limited amounting to Rs. 148.69 lakhs was omitted to be brought to tax. In view of the same, notice under section 148 of the Act was issued on June 24, 2003. The assessee had sent a reply stating that the return of income filed earlier could be treated as filed in response to the notice under section 148 of the Act. The information regarding interest accrued and receivable from M/s. Tamil Nadu State Civil Construction Corporation Limited was very much available in the 22nd annual report of the assessee-company, which was filed along with the original return of income. The Assessing Officer completed the reassessment under section 143(3) read with section 147 of the Act including the interest accrued and receivable from M/s. Tamil Nadu State Civil Construction Corporation Limited. Aggrieved by the reopening of the assessment, the assessee filed an appeal to the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals). The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) accepted the contention of the assessee and allowed the appeal and held that reopening of the assessment under section 148 is bad in law. Aggrieved, the Revenue filed an appeal to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (“the Tribunal” in short). The Tribunal dismissed the Revenue's appeal and confirmed the order of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals). Hence, the present appeal by the Revenue.

3. Learned standing counsel appearing for the Revenue submitted that the interest accrued and receivable by the assessee-company from another Government-company, viz., M/s. Tamil Nadu State Civil Construction Corporation Limited, amounting to Rs. 148.69 lakhs was omitted to be brought to tax.

4. It is further submitted that the mere statement in the annual report about the conversion of the interest into loan and recognition of interest does not amount to full disclosure of the materials at the time of completing the assessment under section 143(3) of the Income-tax Act. It is also further submitted that the present case would fall within the Explanation 1 to section 147 of the Act. Hence, the Assessing Officer is right in reopening the assessment.

5. Heard counsel. In the original assessment proceedings the Assessing Officer had considered all the details filed by the assessee and only thereafter, completed the assessment under section 143 of the Act. Based on the same details and other documents filed along with the return, the assessment was completed. There is no failure on the part of the assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts. The assessee has filed a copy of the 22nd annual report along with the return of income. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), in his order, held as follows:

“I have carefully considered the above submission and perused the assessment records. The appellant has filed a copy of its 22nd annual report along with the return of income. Paragraph 3.0(a) page 28 of the annual report reads as under:

‘The interest on the term loan granted to Keerapalayam Panchayat Union/TNSCC for construction of a bridge across Vellar River near Sethiathope accounted for in the accounts up to March 31, 1995, on consistent basis was Rs. 224.82 lakhs. The Government under G.O Ms. No. 77, Transport Department, dated April 3, 1996, stated that out of the interest due of Rs. 397 lakhs on the principal up to March 31, 1995, Rs. 100 lakhs should be waived and should treat the balance amount of Rs. 297 lakhs as a fresh loan with effect from April 1, 1995, at 12 per cent simple interest repayable in five annual instalments. Even though Government have directed to treat the interest of Rs. 297 lakhs due as loan since the borrower is a defaulter ab initio as a prudent measure and as per the prudential norms on income recognition issued by the Reserve Bank of India the interest income received will be taken into account on realisation basis. The amount not taken into account is Rs. 72.18 lakhs being the difference in interest provided by the company and Rs. 297 lakhs allowed by the Government and Rs. 76.51 lakhs being interest at 12 per cent on Rs. 297 lakhs for 1995-96 and 1996-97 and penal interest. However, a sum of Rs. 15.39 lakhs being the toll charges received from STUs during the year 1995-96 has also been taken to revenue for 1996-97. As such the TNSCC amount not taken into account is Rs. 148.69 lakhs'.”

6. The above information has been taken as a basis to hold that the income of Rs. 148.69 lakhs has escaped assessment. This information was available with the Assessing Officer in the course of original assessment proceeding. He did not make any addition at the time of completing the original assessment. In fact, in the present case, the assessee had disclosed all the material facts before the Assessing Officer. The Tribunal, in paragraph 5 of its order, held as follows:

“The facts are undisputed. During the course of hearing the learned Departmental representative has not controverted the fact that reopening is after four years and also the reopening of assessment is based on the 22nd annual report which was filed along with the return of income. He only argued that the Assessing Officer could not notice this interest accrued and receivable is on account of escapement of income. On a query from the Bench, the learned Departmental representative could not state any failure on the part of the assessee to disclose any material facts necessary for this assessment. As the proviso to section 147, is very clear that where the assessment is made under section 143(3) of the Act, then no action shall be taken under this section after the expiry of four years from the end of relevant assessment year unless income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment for the relevant assessment year by reason of failure on the part of the assessee to disclose fully and truly all the material facts necessary during the course of original assessment proceedings. The conditions as enumerated in the proviso in the present case are not met with by the Revenue, while issuing notice under section 148 for reopening of assessment under section 147 of the Act. It is a fact that during the course of original assessment proceedings the information regarding interest accrued and receivable by the assessee from another Government company, i.e, M/s. Tamil Nadu State Civil Construction Corporation Limited was very much available in the 22nd annual report, which was filed with the original return of income. In any case it cannot be said that the above income was not added during course of original assessment proceedings due to the failure on the part of the assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for assessment.”

7. Hence the finding by the authorities below is that the Revenue failed to prove that there is a failure on the part of the assessee to disclose any material facts necessary for assessment. Hence they have rightly come to the conclusion that when the assessment is made under section 143(3) of the Act, no action shall be taken under section 147 of the Act after the expiry of four years from the end of the relevant assessment year unless there is a failure on the part of the assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for assessment. This court also considered the scope of the proviso to section 147 of the Act in a number of judgments. In the case of Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Elgi Finance Ltd. reported in [2006] 286 ITR 674, this court considered the scope of the proviso to section 147 of the Act and held as follows (page 678):

“The law relating to the reassessment has undergone a change from April 1, 1989. The change was brought in by the Direct Tax Laws (Amendment) Act, 1987. Two sets of provisions were available under section 147 in clause (a) and clause (b). This distinction has now been taken away by the Amendment Act. Previously, the line of distinction was a limitation period of four years and the limitation period exceeding four years. The Assessing Officer would reopen a back assessment within a period of four years as long as he had reason to believe in consequence of any information, that income has been underassessed or income has escaped assessment. In the case of limitation, providing for a period exceeding four years, there should have been a failure on the part of the assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts leading to the escapement of income. But as a result of the amendment brought with effect from April 1, 1989 the above distinction had been obliterated and the Assessing Officer could reassess the income as long as he had reason to believe that income chargeable had escaped assessment. The new law has inserted a proviso to section 147 in the following words:

‘Provided that where an assessment under sub-section (3) of section 143 or this section has been made for the relevant assessment year, no action shall be taken under this section after the expiry of four years from the end of the relevant assessment year, unless any income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment for such assessment year by reason of the failure on the part of the assessee to make a return under section 139 or in response to a notice issued under sub-section (1) of section 142 or section 148 or to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for his assessment for that assessment year.’

In addition to the time limits provided for under section 149, the law has provided another limitation of four years under the proviso to section 147. As far as the above proviso to section 147 is concerned, the law prescribes a period of four years to initiate reassessment proceedings, unless the income alleged to have escaped assessment was made out as a result of failure on the part of the assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for the assessment.”

8. In the present case, the assessment year is 1997-98 and the Assessing Officer issued notice for reopening under section 148 on June 24, 2003, which is beyond four years after the end of the assessment year. Hence it is clearly barred by limitation under the proviso to section 147 of the Act. Following the above principle, the Tribunal is correct in its conclusion that reopening is bad in law. The concurrent finding given by both the authorities below is based on valid materials and evidence. In the case of Commissioner Of Income Tax v. P. Mohanakala, [2007] 291 ITR 278, the Supreme Court held that whenever there is a concurrent finding by the authorities below, no interference should be called for by the High Court. Under these circumstances, we do not find any error or legal infirmity in the order of the Tribunal so as to warrant interference.

9. In view of the foregoing reasons, no substantial question of law arises for consideration of this court and accordingly, the tax case is dismissed. No costs.