- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Commr. Of Customs, Trichy v. Chettinad Cement Corporation Ltd.
THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 06.8.2015
CORAM
THE HONBLE MR.JUSTICE V.RAMASUBRAMANIAN
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE T.MATHIVANAN
Civil Miscellaneous Appeal Nos.906, 1118, 1119,
1120, 1146 to 1155, 1306 & 1307 of 2015
CMA No.906 of 2015
The Commissioner of Customs
Trichy
No.1, Williams Road
Trichy 620 001. .. Appellant
1. Chettinad Cement Corporation Ltd.
Rani Seethai Hall Building
603, Anna Salai
Chennai 600 006.
2. Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal
Shastri Bhavan Annexe, First Floor
No.26, Haddows Road
Chennai 600 006. .. Respondents
-----
Appeals under against the Miscellaneous Order No.42230042339 of
2014 dated 18.11.2014 on the file of CESTAT, Chennai.
-----
For Appellant : Mr.G.Rajagopalan
Additional Solicitor General
For Respondent-1 : Mr.Raghavan Ramabadiran
Mr.Muthu Venkataraman
Mrs.Radhika Chandrasekaran
-----
2J U D G M E N T
(Delivered by V.Ramasubramanian,J.)
All these appeals are filed under Section 130-A of the Customs Act,
1962, questioning the correctness of a common order passed by CESTAT, in
a batch of Miscellaneous Applications seeking waiver and stay.
2. Heard Mr.G.Rajagopalan, learned Additional Solicitor General
appearing for the appellant-Department of Customs, Mr.Raghavan
Ramabadiran, Mr.Muthu Venkataraman and Mrs.Radhika Chandrasekaran,
learned counsel appearing for the respondents/assessees.
3. The respondents in these appeals admittedly import coal. They
claim that what they import is steam coal coming under sub heading
2701.1920. However, on the basis of specific intelligence that what was
imported by the respondents was bituminous coal coming under the sub
heading 2701.1200, show cause notices were issued to the respondents.
After the respondents gave replies, the adjudicating authority passed Orders-
in-Original, imposing duty on the basis that what was imported by the
respondents was actually bituminous coal. The respondents filed statutory
appeals before the Commissioner (Appeals). The appeals filed under Section
128 were dismissed by the Commissioner (Appeals) and the respondents
filed further appeals under Section 129. Along with the appeals, the
respondents took out Miscellaneous Applications both for waiver and pre-
3deposit condition and also for stay of recovery.
4. All the Miscellaneous Applications were taken up together by
CESTAT Chennai Bench and an order was passed on 18.11.2014 in
Miscellaneous Order Nos.42230 to 42339 of 2014. By the said order, the
Tribunal referred three issues for the consideration of a Larger Bench and in
the meantime, granted a complete waiver of the pre-deposit condition, till
the disposal of the appeals. Aggrieved by the said common order, the
Department appears to have filed some appeals before the Madurai Bench of
this Court and the rest have been filed before this Court. As a matter of fact,
some of these appeals were originally filed as writ petitions and later got
converted into statutory appeals under Section 130. Therefore, we are now
concerned actually with statutory appeals under Section 130 and none of
these are now writ petitions under Article 226.
5. The grievance of the Commissioner of Customs, who is the
appellant in all these appeals, is two fold, namely (i) that when there was
actually no conflict of opinion between an earlier decision of the Chennai
Bench of the Tribunal and a later decision of the Bangalore Bench of the
Tribunal, there was no occasion for the Tribunal to refer the issues arising for
consideration to a Larger Bench, and (ii) that in any event, the Tribunal was
not right in granting a full waiver of the pre-deposit condition.
46. Assailing the order of the Tribunal, Mr.G.Rajagopalan, learned
Additional Solicitor General contended that when a case arose before the
Chennai Bench of the CESTAT, in the matter of Tamil Nadu Newsprint and
Paper Limited v. Commissioner of Customs, Tuticorin [(2010) 253
ELT 153 (Chennai)], the Tribunal decided the matter on its own merits,
based upon the invoices and declarations made by the appellant therein.
Therefore, the learned Additional Solicitor General contended that there was
no question of law decided by the Chennai Bench in Tamil Nadu
Newsprints and Papers Limited for the Tribunal to take a view that the
Bangalore Bench has taken a contra view in its decision in Coastal Energy
Private Limited v. Commissioner of Customs dated 20.6.2014. It is his
further contention that when issues are decided by the two different Benches
of the same Tribunal on the basis of facts placed before them, there is no
conflict of opinions and consequently, no occasion for the Tribunal to make a
reference to a Larger Bench.
7. We have carefully considered the above submissions.
8. In the light of what is stated from paragraphs 1 to 6, two questions
of law arise for consideration. They are :
(i) Whether an appeal under Section 130A of the Customs Act, 1962 is
maintainable as against a mere reference made by a Bench of the Customs,
Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal to a Larger Bench, of certain
issues, on which, the Tribunal was of the opinion that there were conflicting
5views between two different Benches ? and
(ii) Whether in the facts and circumstances of case, the Tribunal was
justified in granting a total waiver of the pre-deposit condition in favour of
the assessees ?
9. We do not think that we should actually go into the question
whether there was a conflict of opinion between the Chennai Bench in Tamil
Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited and the Bangalore Bench in
Coastal Energy Private Limited.
10. At the threshold, it is doubtful whether the present appeals are
maintainable against an order of reference made by a Bench of a Tribunal,
on the ground that there were conflicting views on the same issue by two
different Benches. Though an order of reference is, in common parlance,
termed as an order, the same cannot be elevated to the status of a decision,
so as to enable one of the parties to file either a statutory appeal or a writ
petition against such a reference.
11. The expression "order" is not defined anywhere in the Customs
Act, 1962. But, the fact that the said expression should be understood to
mean a decision, cannot be denied. The scheme of Customs Act, 1962
contemplates a four tier mechanism for adjudication. At the first tier, an
order of adjudication is passed by the competent authority under Section
Alert